Friday, August 7, 2020
Home Opinions Most 'Marxist thinkers' use Marx without really understanding his academic legacy

Most ‘Marxist thinkers’ use Marx without really understanding his academic legacy

While so-called “Marxian Thinkers” in India talk about our poor social indicators, I believe they also need to view why India ranks better in HDI than compared to Per Capita Income.

The year 2018 has been celebrated as the 200th Year of the birth anniversary of Marx. Marx somehow continues to be the most misunderstood social scientists and thinkers and a major reason behind this is the adulteration of his theory by some of his supporters over the last couple of decades.

I admit that his book Das Capital is one of the finest pieces of work that gives us an interesting and refreshing take on how to analyse factors of production as a comprehensive part of the larger society in which we live in. His work on differentiating labour power from labour is also significant towards our understanding of how labour markets operate. Despite his contribution in terms of giving an alternate view of the society and factors of production within in, his work is generally much more widely cited and read by sociologists than economists.

One of the reasons why economists use selected parts of Marx is because, despite his distinct way of analysis, most of his conclusions were completely wrong. One of the reasons why that occurred is significant theoretical problems in his analysis but despite that, his biggest contribution remains in terms of telling the world that labour is the only human factor of production.

Some of my professors have advocated for the comprehensive view that Marx takes of the society and accept that he is more of a social thinker than an economist. This is why Keynes work which happened around the same time finds a greater emphasis in economic thinking than of Marx. But the focus of this article is not Marx but the great disservice that students of certain universities who advocate for a Marxian way of thinking are doing towards the legacy of Marx.

I wanted to test a hypothesis just for the sake of it (non-academic hypothesis so don’t get into the methodology and everything around it) so I decided to ask 30 students who are ardent supporters of Marx about the contribution he made in Volume 2 of Das Capital. To my surprise, most weren’t even aware that there was a Volume 2 while a couple of people who did try to answer were unable to give any specific answer as they kept talking about “labour” and “workers of the world unite”.

I am not saying that all Marxist thinkers are like that. Some of my best professors have been Marxists and they too are aware of the limitations in Marx’s theoretical analysis but the current breed of students who talk about Marx know zilch about him. Marx unfortunately, has become a figure who is adulterated by these thinkers and as a consequence, he is targeted. His academic legacy is also up for debate. Some might completely debunk his critique of capitalism, while others may find merits in parts of it, however, most of the ‘Marxist thinkers’ of the current lot aren’t even aware of the facts to indulge in reasonable debate.

While his ideology arguably claimed millions of lives, his academic legacy is towards providing us with a strong critique of capitalism so that we can improve upon the system and ensure that in our process of development, social welfare (Health and Education) is of paramount importance. In a big way, we’ve been doing just that as most democracies are welfare states. The problem occurs when those who haven’t even read Marx, stop us from critically evaluating him. For all that Marx gets wrong, he gets one thing right which is the critique of capitalism. The critique offers a roadmap of how to fix the system, not replace it with another one which we now know doesn’t work.

Marx’s biggest improvement towards capitalism is demonstrating the critics of uncontrolled capitalism due to over-concentration of monopoly power (or monopsonic power). This was a timely criticism that had been adequately addressed by most economies by enacting a strong set of laws. There is a definite scope of improvement in anti-monopoly efforts, however, the biggest threat to monopolies has come from innovation and technological progress. Thus, his biggest improvement is towards directing his energies in providing a strong critic of capitalism and provide inputs on what needed some improvement. As far as criticism of Marx’s is concerned, there are volumes written on them. Biggest of them all being that he doesn’t factor in how labour markets are distinct from other markets and he assumes that wages would be suppressed in order to bring down the cost of production. However, as evident, both real and nominal wages actually increased over the last 5 decades pointing out how the wage suppression theory is not completely true. Ironically, China is the only country that has managed to suppressed real wages to reduce the cost of production so the criticism that Marx gave of Capitalism holds true for a Communist nation and not a Capitalist one. Technology too doesn’t find an explicit mention in his understanding of the dynamic nature of society and the economy.

While so-called “Marxian Thinkers” in India talk about our poor social indicators, I believe they also need to view why India ranks better in HDI than compared to Per Capita Income. The reason is that for every 1$ increase in per capita Income, India tends to make a significant improvement in its HDI. This in itself makes the point apparent that India’s model is addressing the critical challenges of social welfare.

Most Marxian thinkers have politicized him to the point that his actual views are immaterial to their political interests. This follows from the fact that Marx advocated for a classless society which can be interpreted as a caste-less society. Given India’s improvement in social indicators along with robust growth and development, the proponents are unable to construct a narrative and have now resorted to “class” based identity politics for their political interests which is in direct conflict with what Marx had envisioned in his work. I’m sure that Marx would have rolled in his grave had he seen how some Indian Politicians use him, without any idea of what he represents.

Karan Bhasin is a political economist by training and has diversified research interests in the field of economics. He tweets @karanbhasin95.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Karan Bhasin
Karan Bhasin is a political economist by training and has diversified research interests in the field of economics. He tweets @karanbhasin95.

Related Articles

Trending now

Muslims chose to stay back in India: An analysis of the mythical, unsubstantiated trope that is used to make Hindus feel guilty

Muslims who stayed back in India after the partition, did not primarily do so out of their innate love for mother India

Soil from ancient Sharda Peeth in PoK was also used in Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan: Read how VHP and some dedicated devotees managed that

This Sharada Peeth is significantly important for Hindus because it is said to be one among the 18 Maha Shakti Peethas.

Assam: Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan celebration by Bajrang Dal attacked by Muslim locals, curfew imposed

The Muslim locals allegedly objected to the Bajrang Dal members chanting slogans and playing music. The arguments soon led to a violent clash.

Ram Janmabhoomi movement: Three sacrifices that can never be forgotten

Five hundred years of struggle went into Ram Janmabhoomi moment. There would be so many heroes that it is impossible to remember them all.

From being bigoted, kids are ‘hope of secularism’. The Wire’s Rohini Singh explains how

The Wire journalist Rohini Singh on Wednesday took to Twitter to share an image wherein she claimed that her child drew a mosque and a temple side by side and wrote an essay on tolerance.

Hindu cricketer Danish Kaneria deletes tweet about Ram Mandir billboard in NYC after Pakistani Islamists flood his TL. Here is what happened

The former Pakistani cricketer had shared an image featuring Ram Mandir's digital image in a giant billboard at New York's Times Square before deleting it.

Recently Popular

Twitter user arrested by Maharashtra police for criticising the Uddhav Thackeray govt on social media

Mumbai Police arrested Twitter user Sunaina Holey for posting against Maharashtra CM and his son, to be presented in court today

Here is why #BabyPenguin is trending on Twitter, and why Aaditya Thackeray is called so by some

Yuva Sena registered complaint against twitter user for calling Aaditya Thackeray "Baby Penguin" and Uddhav Thackeray "Aurangzeb"

While most Bollywood actors and cricketers chose not to welcome Ram Mandir, here are the ones who did not shy away

Only a few actors and sportspersons celebrated Ram Mandir Bhoomi Pujan and shared wishes on social media.

TV actor Sameer Sharma found hanging from the kitchen ceiling, case of accidental death registered

After body of Sameer Sharma was recovered from his house, a case of accidental death has been registered by the Malad police

Muslims chose to stay back in India: An analysis of the mythical, unsubstantiated trope that is used to make Hindus feel guilty

Muslims who stayed back in India after the partition, did not primarily do so out of their innate love for mother India

Maulana from All India Imam Association threatens that ‘believers of justice’ will demolish Ram Mandir and rebuild disputed structure

Maulana Rashidi stated that the Ram Mandir will one day be demolished and a disputed structure will be rebuilt.

Pakistan borrows $1 Billion from its all-weather ally China to repay $1 Billion Saudi Arabia loan to avoid default on international debt obligations

China tightens its grip over Pakistan, gives $1 billion loan to repay Saudi Arabia's $1 billion loan, grants 90% of $6.8 billion railway project

CBI registers case against Rhea Chakraborty, her family and aides in Sushant Singh Rajput death case

CBI files case against Rhea Chakraborty, her father, mother, brother and 2 others in Sushant Singh Rajput's death case

‘As a CM I have no problem with any religion, but as a yogi, I will not go for a Mosque’s ground-breaking ceremony’: Yogi...

When asked whether he will attend ground-breaking ceremony for the mosque at Ayodhya, Yogi Adityanath said that he will not be invited

Complaint filed against Maulana Sajid Rashid for inciting Muslims to demolish Ram Mandir at Ayodhya

President of the All India Imam Association Sajid Rashidi had said that a mosque will be rebuilt after demolishing the Ram Mandir

15th EU-India Summit: Promising an opportunity for India in the post-COVID world

The 15th EU-India Summit was held in the virtual space, which can be called the Covid-19 era normal. Before the pandemic made its presence felt, this Summit was planned to be held in March in Brussels.

Dalit organisation lodges a complaint with MHA seeking an FIR against AIMPLB for intimidating and hurting the faith of Hindu Dalits

AIMPLB had issued a menacing threat yesterday hinting at converting the Ram temple back into a mosque

CBI starts the process of registering a case in Sushant Singh Rajput’s death case, forms SIT for the probe

CBI to probe Sushant Singh Rajput's death after the center issued the letter to CBI on Bihar Police’s request on 5th August

Is being a Hindu acceptable but having faith in Hindutva ‘dangerous’? Quite the contrary

Is being a Hindu acceptable while faith in Hindutva is not? Is it even dangerous? Many Hindus seem wary to be associated with Hindutva

Mumbai faces massive flooding and destruction due to heavy rain, rainfall in one day exceeds the season’s average

Mumbai received 2,319.7 mm rain on Wednesday, which is more than the seasonal average of 2,206.4 mm, causes heavy flooding

Muslims chose to stay back in India: An analysis of the mythical, unsubstantiated trope that is used to make Hindus feel guilty

Muslims who stayed back in India after the partition, did not primarily do so out of their innate love for mother India

Connect with us

239,250FansLike
423,294FollowersFollow
291,000SubscribersSubscribe