Home Government and Policy I-T dept disputes claim of Travel Khana over angel tax recovery, says only unexplained cash receipts penalised

I-T dept disputes claim of Travel Khana over angel tax recovery, says only unexplained cash receipts penalised

The company did not provide records of funds received, despite repeated reminders, hence the department was unfortunately left with no choice

Yesterday, a shocking news had emerged that the bank account of a start-up was emptied by the Income Tax department due to the recovery of angel tax. It was reported that four bank accounts of Travel Khana was frozen, and around ₹33 lakh was withdrawn from the accounts towards due of angel tax. Travel Khana is a start-up company that delivers food for passengers of Indian Railways. The Angel Tax has raised lots of concern for start-up businesses, and the action on Travel Khana was seen as an example of Tax Terrorism.

But now the Central Board of Direct Taxes (CBDT) has issued a clarification saying that no Angel Tax was recovered from the bank accounts of the company. In a statement issued last night issued by CBDT spokesperson Surabhi Ahluwalia, CBDT says that tax was recovered from Travel Khana on account of unexplained cash credits and not on the premium of shares, as has been alleged.

The statement says that during the assessment of the company, the assessing officer had requested for confirmation of the persons from whom deposits had been received. Wherever confirmations were submitted, the same were accepted by the assessing officer. But for some cash deposits no confirmation about the depositors was received from the company, therefore proper show-cause notice was issued in such cases. CBDT says that due to the failure of Travel Khana in furnishing detail of depositors, a demand of around ₹2.22 crore was raised by the department.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

The statement clarifies that action against the company was taken under section 68 of the Income Tax department, not under section 56(2)(viib). The section 68 deals with unexplained cash credits, while the section 56(2)(viib) deals with premiums received on shares issued.

The CBDT also says that the company did not obtain a stay against the demand raised by the I-T department. Had they obtained a stay, recovery proceedings would not have been undertaken by the department, it says.

Due to the concerns about the Angel Tax among the start-ups, the government had issued an instruction prohibiting coercive measures for enforcing recovery of outstanding demand in Angel Tax cases. But CBDT says that Travel Khan is not eligible for this relaxation as the tax demand was for unexplained cash credit, not Angel Tax. Moreover, the company did not submit any certificate from DIPP indicating its status as start-up, which mandatory to obtain the relaxations. Had the company or its directors had furnished such a certificate, the situation would not have arisen.

The statement says that “the benefit of doubt should and must be given to our entrepreneurs. However when after repeated reminders, records of funds received are not provided, the department is unfortunately left with no choice.”

The full statement of CBDT can be seen below:

CBDT

Press Release – 08.02.2019

CBDT clarification

New Delhi: It has come to the notice of CBDT, through some media reports that Rs 36 lakh have been recovered from a start-up, namely, Travel Khana as part of recovery of outstanding demand on account of Angel Tax. It has been alleged that this was in violation of the CBDT instructions dt 24th December, 2018 pertaining to recovery of dues in Angel Tax cases.

On ascertaining the facts it is seen that the additions in the case were made u/s 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 on account of unexplained cash credits and not u/s 56(2)(viib) on account of premium on shares, as has been alleged.

During the assessment proceedings, the assessing officer requested for confirmation of the persons from whom deposits had been received. Wherever confirmations were submitted, the same were accepted by the assessing officer and no addition was made. However, where no confirmations were furnished by the assessee, the assessing officer made the addition after issuing proper show-cause notice and obtaining reply in the matter. Thus, the addition was made only when the taxpayer failed to substantiate the source of the deposit resulting in demand of Rs. 2.22 crore approximately.

The assessee did not obtain any stay in respect of the demand raised. Had the stay been obtained, recovery proceedings would not have been instituted by the department. Since there was no stay against recovery and the demand had become due, the department recovered Rs. 36 lakh after attaching the bank accounts of the assesse. Thereafter, all the bank accounts were released.

It may also be noted that neither the assessee nor its Director submitted any certificate from DIPP to indicate its status of being a startup, either during the assessment proceedings or thereafter, which is a mandatory requirement as per extant instructions in the matter. Had such a certificate been furnished, this situation would not have arisen.

Thus, it is clear that the case of Travel Khana is not covered by the instruction issued by CBDT dated 24th December, 2018  prohibiting coercive measures for enforcing recovery of outstanding demand in Angel Tax cases as the addition was made under section 68 of the IT Act and not under section 56(2)(viib). Therefore, the action of the assessing officer of enforcing recovery of demand is not in violation of CBDT’s instructions.

The benefit of doubt should and must be given to our entrepreneurs. However when after repeated reminders, records of funds received are not provided, the department is unfortunately left with no choice. Our agencies also have a duty to prevent and expose suspected evasion.

 

Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans:
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Most read articles recently

Sri Lanka attacks

Sri Lankan millionaire’s family was an ISIS cell: Suicide bombers shatter shameless excuses peddled by ‘liberals’ to justify Islamic terrorism

All over the world, the terrorist attacks by radical Islamists is immediately served with long and extensive excuses about how social ills, discrimination, poverty, hardships, and atrocities lead to terrorism.

Meet the Photoshop artist whose work Akshay Kumar showed to Prime Minister Modi

While mostly people have been appreciative of his artwork, suspended bureaucrat Ashish Joshi has threatened him with police complaint about his cleverly Photoshopped image
If you believe Google trends, this election is a runaway win for Modi

If you believe Google trends, this election is a runaway win for Modi

It’s fairly clear: Congress hasn’t managed to get its message out.  If you ask Google Trends, this election is over. The writing is on the wall. PM Narendra Modi is all set to win

Propagandist Dhruv Rathee mocks Manohar Parrikar’s death to score political brownie points

Earlier, too, Rathee was caught speaking the same language as that of Pulwama attack terrorist by mocking 'cow urine drinkers'
The Quint lies, twists and tortures CVoter data to make it say that the Modi wave is over. Here is what the data actually says

The Quint lies, twists and tortures CVoter data to make it say that the Modi wave is over. Here is what the data actually says

Leftist portal The Quint published an article headlined "Modi wave over? Why pollsters are scaling down projections for BJP" based on CVoter data, where the data itself was twisted, selectively quoted and misrepresented

Coward, gutless, visionless, losers: ‘Neutral’ media has a meltdown after Priyanka Gandhi Vadra is not fielded as Congress candidate against PM Modi

The media first put its eggs in the Rahul Gandhi basket, and when that appeared to have holes big enough to fit chickens, they decided to pin their hopes on Priyanka Gandhi Vadra.

Two AAP MLAs lunged towards Kejriwal and one punched him such that his glasses fell off, claims Kapil Mishra

AAP MLAs reportedly beat up Kejriwal so much that he has injured his knees and could not walk properly

Mamata Banerjee sends kurtas and sweets for him says PM Modi in a freewheeling chat with filmstar Akshay Kumar

Prime Minister Modi's informal interaction with film star Akshay Kumar leads to a meltdown of 'journalists'

Netizens play Jagga Jasoos as Arvind Kejriwal resurfaces days after rumours of him beaten up by AAP MLAs went viral

From 'scratch marks' on nose to 'new frame of glasses', Twitterati had a field day on Kejriwal's first public appearance after a long time

After getting Bangladeshi actors to campaign, Mamata’s TMC caught running ads in Bangladesh appealing for votes

Mamata's TMC is running as many as 13 ads on Facebook, appealing people to vote for TMC in the ongoing elections

Latest articles

Connect with us

157,493FansLike
130,619FollowersFollow
55,033SubscribersSubscribe

Don't miss these

Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans: