Sunday, July 5, 2020
Home News Reports Adv Patel who filed the petition with EC clears all doubts about AAP's 21...

Adv Patel who filed the petition with EC clears all doubts about AAP’s 21 MLAs facing disqualification

Also Read

In the latest saga engulfing controversy’s favourite child Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal, AAP in Delhi might see 21 of its MLAs disqualified. The reason is simple: the Delhi Government appointed these 21 MLAs as “parliamentary secretaries” which was not permitted as per law since they were considered to be holding an “office of profit”. This matter has earlier claimed big names such as Jaya Bachchan and even Congress President Sonia Gandhi. While Bachchan lost her Rajya Sabha seat via disqualification, Sonia Gandhi had to resign from all her posts which could have been considered as falling under “office of profit”.

Arvind Kejriwal though tried another method, by passing a bill which had retrospective impact, trying to bless his 21 MLAs with legal sanctity. Unfortunately the bill was rejected by the President of India and ever since a new saga of victim-hood has played out. Kejriwal has cried foul that Modi is behind all the happenings.

The truth however is that all this started with a relatively unknown face: Advocate Prashant Patel. He filed a petition before the President to disqualify the 21 MLAs on 19th June, 2015. Now that the matter has become hot again, Ankit Jain spoke to Advocate Patel to get a clear understanding of the controversy:

Q. The President has just declined to give assent to the Delhi Government’s bill to exclude the post of parliamentary secretary from the office of profit. Why do you think he has done so?

Adv Patel: On 26th December, 2015  I had submitted my reply to Election Commission and a copy to Hon’ble President that the Delhi Government did not observe and follow the mandatory legal and constitutional requirements before introducing and passing this Bill in the Legislative Assembly, hence the impugned Bill cannot and must not be given the shape of a valid law. So Hon’ble Rashtrapati Ji being the defender and upholder of the constitution, must therefore withhold his assent to this Bill. I submitted this after the submission of my Petition seeking disqualification of MLAs holding Office of Profit. Delhi Government tried to present fait accompli to Hon’ble Rashtrapati Ji and brought a bill in Assembly.

Q. Kejriwal has alleged that the President is working on orders of PM Modi and MHA. As per the legal processes, is it fair to make such a conclusion granted that the President has declined NDA’s bills as well?

Adv Patel: Article 102 and 192 read with Section 15 of the NCT Act say that, in the matter of questions as to disqualification of Members, President shall obtain the opinion of Election Commission before taking any decision and decision of President shall be final. The file related to “Office of Profit” doesn’t go to PM, Cabinet or Government.

Q. Kejriwal claims that there are no benefits accruing to these parliamentary secretaries hence it is not an “office of profit”. The official circular says they may use vehicles and space for official purposes. How is this an office of “profit”?

Adv Patel: ‘Profit’ normally connotes any advantages, benefit or useful consequences. Generally, it is interpreted to mean monetary gain but benefits other than monetary gain may also come within its meaning. “Office of profit” is one to which some power to patronage is attached or in which the holder is entitled to exercise the executive functions, or which carries dignity, prestige or honour to the incumbent thereof.

The position of Parliamentary Secretary in Delhi squarely falls in the aforesaid category. MLAs appointed as Parliamentary Secretaries are certainly in a more advantageous or beneficial position in comparison to the other Members. By accepting the position of Parliamentary Secretary which certainly has some position, prestige or patronage attached to it, these legislators have become an inseparable and an integral part of the Executive and the dividing line between Legislature and the Government has been completely obliterated

Advocate Prashant Patel
Advocate Prashant Patel

Q. Why did the Delhi Government frame such a bill in the first place? 

Adv Patel: The appointment of Parliamentary Secretaries was made on 13 March 2015, and the Bill with malafide and malicious intent , was passed on 24 June 2015. It was given retrospective effect by stating that “It shall be deemed to have come into force on the 14th day of February 2015” only because I had filed a petition before the President to disqualify 21 MLAs on 19th June, 2015.

Q. Kejriwal says that many states have such parliamentary secretaries who also get paid and Modi is singling out Delhi. Is it true?

Adv Patel: First of all I want to clear that Delhi is not a state but Union Territory. Delhi comes under Chapter 8 of the Constitution and States Comes under chapter 3 of the Constitution. In Delhi, if You want to make any rule or want pass a Bill, you have take permission first from Central government via LG, which was never taken. In other states they have made parliamentary secretaries after passing the Bills in their Assemblies.

Q. In all the attacks of Kejriwal, he claims Modi is after him, whereas the entire issue started with your petition to EC. Are you in anyway connected to BJP  or Modi?

Adv Patel: I do not belong to any political party and have no political affiliations either. As a vigilant law abiding citizen, I simply want the majesty of the Indian Constitution and the law of the land to prevail.

Q. Some media reports suggest that the 21 MLAs now will be disqualified, but some other reports say that there is still time to go as EC has to hold hearings and take a decision. When will this issue be settled?

Adv Patel: EC is conducting all these proceedings according to directions of the President. EC may give chance to 21 AAP MLAs for Personal hearing. I have also requested to EC in my Rejoinder that the intention of MLAs seems to be malafide and to delay the process. However In the interest of speedy disposal of the matter, the hearing of all MLAs may be completed on a single day itself. The matter is on its final stage and EC may soon give opinion to the President and the President will take a decision and his decision shall be final which can’t be challenged to any court.

Q. Are there any legal remedies available to AAP to solve this issue without getting 21 MLAs disqualified?

Adv Patel: According to the Constitution, there is no legal remedy available to these MLAs, since appointment of 21 MLAs as Parliamentary Secretaries is the worst kind of political corruption.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Trending now

China’s ‘Century of Humiliation’: How period between First Opium War in 1839 and victory of CCP in 1949 shapes China’s view about the world

The Chinese claim to Vladivostok is a stark reminder of the extent to which the 'Century of Humiliation' plays a very crucial role in shaping China's foreign policy.

Tahir Hussain not only planned and instigated the mob, but was also pelting stones and petrol bombs at Hindus: Chargesheet

While Dilbar Negi was dismembered and burnt alive, Ankit Sharma was mutilated, murdered and dumped in a Chand Bagh drain by a Muslim mob spearheaded by AAP leader Tahir Hussain

Uddhav Thackeray approves purchase of expensive new cars for ministers when Maharashtra is struggling to pay salaries to the govt employees

Even as Maharashtra faces acute crisis, the Uddhav Thackeray govt in has given its authorisation for the purchase of 6 new vehicles for its ministers.

Explained: Why is China now eyeing the Russian city of Vladivostok?

The territory of Vladivostok was a part of the Qing Dynasty of China and was handed over to the Russians via the Treaty of Peking in 1860.

Beef ban Haram, Dog Meat ban Halal: Hypocrisy of welcoming ban on dog meat in Nagaland after claiming people have the right to eat...

The Nagaland Cabinet has banned the sale of dog meat in the state following protests by animal rights activists.

Unfortunate that aspersions are being cast on how our brave Armed Forces are treated: Army calls fake news by Congress ‘malicious and unsubstantiated’

Congress party and its ecosystem launched a massive propaganda today claiming that the meeting of PM Modi with injured soldiers at Leh Military Hospital was staged.

Recently Popular

Swara Bhasker starrer web series gets record low ratings, leftist elites claim it is because she opposes BJP, not because it is bad

Swara Bhaskar starrer 'Rasbhari' streaming on Amazon Prime has got record low ratings on IMDb.

Congress leaders and anti-BJP trolls spread fake news that Modi’s visit to Leh military hospital was staged: Here are the facts

The Conference Hall of the Leh Army Hospital has been convereted into a ward for soldiers with minor injuries, that does not mean it is fake

Complaint registered against Hindustan Times reporter Srishti Jaswal for her Hinduphobic tweet against Lord Krishna

Complaint filed against journalist Srishti Jaswal for saing that Lord Krishna was womanizer, fuckboi, and commitment phobic maniac

Suspended Hindustan Times reporter issues apology after Hinduphobic tweet goes viral, says her comment is being taken out of context

Suspended Hindustan Times reporter Shristi Jaiswal has issued an apology after her Hinduphobic tweet went viral on social media.

No, BJP leader Vikas Dubey is not the gangster who killed 8 policemen in Kanpur, read how Congress trolls spread fake news

Several trolls took to social media to share an image of a BJP leader along with Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister to claim that the person was the notorious gangster Vikas Dubey, to allege that he belonged to BJP.

Amidst chants of Allah hu Akbar and ‘Jai Bheem Jai Meem’, Vinod Kashyap was murdered: The Dalit killing fields of North East Delhi

It was the 24th of February 2020 and the atmosphere was tense with anti-CAA protests turning into anti-Hindu Delhi riots

Latest updates and important links about COVID-19 coronavirus

Live statistics and tracking of news related to COVID-19 coronavirus with focus on India.

While Maharashtra govt threatens action against Patanjali for Coronil, state municipal corporations endorse “unani kadha” as a remedy against coronavirus

Several municipal corporations in Maharashtra have started promoting Unani Kadha to bookst immunity against Coronavirus

UK, UAE, EU, and Malaysia start crackdown on Pakistan’s official carrier PIA after report that 30% of Pakistani pilots have fake licenses

Several countries have started disallowing PIA flights after Pakistan aviation minister revealed that 30% of Pakistani pilots had fake licenses

Maharashtra Cyber Police start sending notices on Direct Message to Twitter users for posting ‘offensive’ tweets

The Maharashtra cyber police has aggressively pursued to stamp down opposing voices by dishing out notices on direct message

Guardian falsely claims China built radar tower near Pangong Tso lake in last few weeks: Read details

Satellite images and media reports show that China had built radar station near Pangong Tso lake years ago, not recently as Guardian claims

Journalists with The Wire and The Hindu indulge in brazen Hinduphobia, cast aspersions over Lord Hanuman’s sexual orientation

It appears that the only prerequisite to having gainful employment with the notorious leftist websites such as ‘The Wire’ and 'The Hindu' is to harbour and manifest Hinduphobic views.

ICMR refutes claims of unrealistic goal to release COVAXIN, says it is only cutting red tape, not any necessary clinical process

ICMR issues statement saying its expedited trial for Covaxin will bypass only red tape and files, not clinical tests

China’s ‘Century of Humiliation’: How period between First Opium War in 1839 and victory of CCP in 1949 shapes China’s view about the world

The Chinese claim to Vladivostok is a stark reminder of the extent to which the 'Century of Humiliation' plays a very crucial role in shaping China's foreign policy.

Tahir Hussain not only planned and instigated the mob, but was also pelting stones and petrol bombs at Hindus: Chargesheet

While Dilbar Negi was dismembered and burnt alive, Ankit Sharma was mutilated, murdered and dumped in a Chand Bagh drain by a Muslim mob spearheaded by AAP leader Tahir Hussain

Gujarat: Cops nab one Ismaeel Lashkar for raping a 4-year-old girl in Kutch

19-year-old Ismaeel Lashkar arrested for raping a 4-year-old girl one and half months ago in Gujarat's Kutch district

Connect with us

234,719FansLike
398,230FollowersFollow
269,000SubscribersSubscribe