Thursday, October 22, 2020
Home Opinions Gurmehar Kaur is by no means a 'Free Speech Warrior'

Gurmehar Kaur is by no means a ‘Free Speech Warrior’

TIME Magazine thinks of Gurmehar Kaur, the celebrity student, as a “free speech warrior” and such an idea could not be further from the truth.

It is indeed true that she faced a situation which I would wish on no one. But the fact of the matter is that abuse is a surety if you are a public personality in twitter. The fact that she had to go through that is definitely unfortunate and condemnable, but it is not out of the ordinary. 

More importantly, she is not in any way a crusader for free speech. She can claim that she is a free speech advocate, but she is not.

She has been threatening young boys for making harmless memes – which she deemed to be defamatory in nature. I do not dispute her right to legal recourse. However, claiming that she is in any way a paragon of free speech is more than disputable.  

On 6th October, leftist student leader Shehla Rashid tweeted this, to which Ms. Kaur, the TIME magazine’s free speech crusader replied “Always”:

Not just that, she also retweeted that tweet: 

This incident imitates something that has been quite a phenomenon in the global left:

The artificial distinction that they have sought to create between “free speech” and “hate speech” in an effort to shut down any speech that they dislike.

Much like another favourite buzzword of the left – “Islamaphobia” – the distinctions that exist between “hate speech” and free speech are unclear. Moreover, while there are limitations to free speech, the United States Supreme Court (the bastion of free speech in the world), has consistently upheld the citizens right to free speech which includes hate speech.

This is because what constitutes “hate speech”, is a matter of subjective and thus arbitrary opinions. Can then, an advocate of free speech accept this classification? After all, what is accepted now could have been considered hateful some time ago, and vice versa.

Ms Kaur is, in my view, actually a status quoist to our current legal regime. If she supports the distinction between hate speech and free speech, she is endorsing Section 295 A of the IPC – the provision that criminalises blasphemy, since Blasphemy is obviously hateful speech against a religion or religious figure.

I am more than inclined to take this exercise further. If she thinks that hate speech is not free speech, then the slogans that were raised at JNU – were they not hateful to the patriotic citizens of India? Thus, is it or is it not free speech?

I digress.

Considering all this, is Ms. Kaur an advocate of free speech? In my mind, she is not. She may not have retreated into a cocoon when faced with opposition to her views, and I applaud her for that. But the fact that she is more than happy to silence others is worrying. To think that Ms. Kaur, with her hypocritical stand on free speech is a next generation leader is extremely concerning for me.

She maybe an advocate of free speech for some, but for me – as a person of the same generation, she is a representative of the rapid raise in progress and fame one can have, if one has the right family background and right ideological background (pun unintended). Her appearances in TV, her book deal and her selection as a next gen leader displays to me, at the least, the influence her ideological compatriots exercise in the national and international media and otherwise.

I have, for TIME magazine alternative suggestions to Ms. Kaur, who they can hail as “free speech warriors”:

Ms. Shreya Singhal, who filed the Public Interest Litigation that struck down Section 66A of the IT Act, 2000 which had severely limited our freedom of speech in the internet.  Or the 17 years old boy in West Bengal whose harmless Facebook post led to Islamist mobs rampaging in West Bengal and so many others.

Even this article can be considered as being hate speech against Ms. Kaur. After all, it has all the necessary ingredients. If we were to stand for civil liberties in any manner, we have to imbibe Evelyn Beatrice Hall’s words: “I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it”. (He was illustrating Voltaire’s ideas)

Editor’s note: The author has earlier written two articles on his blog: “On Free Speech” and “An Examination of two scenarios” and a third one for Swarajya Magazine: “The Rights and wrongs of free speech” . It is advised that the articles be read for a clearer picture on the Freedom of Expression. You can also follow him on Twitter at @Ananth_Krishna_.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Ananth Krishna
Law Student at NUALS, Kochi. Bharathiya, Sanatana Dharmi, മലയാളി.

Related Articles

Trending now

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

CM Yogi distributes relief amount of Rs 113.21 crore among the flood-affected farmers in Uttar Pradesh

CM Yogi distributed the relief amount to the flood-affected farmers in 19 districts of the state by online transaction.

‘Mughal Prince Tucy’ lashes out on AIMIM’s Asaduddin Owaisi, calls him ‘Bewakoof, and Gadha’

Prince Tucy said that when the people of Hyderabad are dealing with horrific floods, MP Asaduddin Owaisi is busy doing poll campaign in Bihar.

Is Modi govt giving Coronavirus vaccines for ‘free’ only to Bihar? No, that’s not how it works

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Thursday while releasing the BJP manifesto in Bihar for upcoming elections said that the BJP promises free coronavirus vaccines in Bihar, whenever the vaccine is made available.

Recently Popular

UK: 37-year-old paedophile named Rehan Baig jailed for raping chickens to death while his wife filmed it

Rhan Baig's wife had also joined him in the videos and at one point he alternated between having sex with his wife and the chickens.

Eros Now apologises for publishing vulgar Hinduphobic content on Navratri

After netizens outraged over vulgar posts on Navratri, Eros Now issued an apology.

France: Charlie Hebdo cartoons projected on government building to express solidarity with deceased teacher who was beheaded by Islamic terrorist

Days after the barbaric beheading of teacher Samuel Paty on the streets of Paris by a terrorist for showing the cartoons of Prophet Mohammad to his students, support continues to pour in for the deceased teacher.

Remember Sheena Bora case? Param Bir Singh was the IG of Konkan range, the site where her body was dumped

Param Bir Singh knew that Sheena Bora was missing. He had asked Rahul Mukerjea to file a 'missing persons' report. Sheena, however, was never reported as 'missing'.

‘Comedian’ Agrima Joshua, who calls herself ‘feminist’, passes offensive sexual comments against woman due to political differences

Agrima Joshua had earlier found herself in a controversy after insulting the Shivaji Maharaj memorial during a performance.

Paris: Two Muslim women stabbed under Eiffel Tower by white women shouting “dirty Arabs”

Two Muslim women were stabbed repeatedly under the Eiffel Tower on Sunday night by two white women who called them "dirty Arabs".
- Advertisement -

Complaints filed against Eros Now and Arré for vulgar social media posts related to Navratri

Both Eros Now and Arre had published social media posts linking Navratri festival with sex and vulgarity

Chhattisgarh police file FIR against video journalist who had reported on farmer protests based on an allegedly edited video

Video journalist Manish Soni had reported about the plight of farmers whose paddy crops were ruined due to anti-encroachment drive

Reducing Navratri to ‘mating dance’, comparing Holi with terrorism— how the Indian media has turned Hinduphobic

After Eros Now posted series of vulgar messages associated with Navratri, far-left site Arre posted a Hinduphobic tweet on Durga puja

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

Mumbai Police threatens Republic TV executive editor with imprisonment for refusing to reveal source of Hansa report in TRP scam

Republic TV Executive Editor warned by Mumabi Police that he will be booked under IPC sections 174 and 179 if does not give source of Hansa report

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

UP: Police find conversion of over 200 people to Buddhism fake, people were asked to sign conversion papers disguised as govt scheme

After reports of 236 Valmiki community members converting to Buddhisim, police find no evidence of conversion in Karehra village

Lucknow: Jama Mazar caretaker ‘Kale Baba’ caught running sex racket, video goes viral

The caretaker has allegedly confessed to police that he was sexually exploiting women and engaging them in illicit activities in the name of curing infertility and other ailments.

Meghalaya: Khasi student body puts up racist posters saying “All Meghalaya Bengalis are Bangladeshis”

The banners put up by Khasi Students Union read, ''All Meghalaya Bengalis are Bangladeshis'' and "Khasiland for Khasis; Foreigners Go Away".

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
466,035FollowersFollow
18,800SubscribersSubscribe