Wednesday, October 28, 2020
Home Fact-Check N Ram competes with Rahul Gandhi in spreading lies about the Rafale deal

N Ram competes with Rahul Gandhi in spreading lies about the Rafale deal

N Ram says standard procedure was not follows in the Rafale deal, but DPP allows diversion in intergovernmental deals.

After publishing a cropped note from the defence ministry to show that the ministry was against the Rafale deal, today The Hindu has come with another story in an attempt to derail the purchase of much-needed fighter jets by Indian Air Force.

In a story titled Government waived anti-corruption clauses in Rafale deal, veteran journalist N Ram alleges that Modi government bypassed standard procedures in inking the Rafale deal. It has come up with another note from the defence ministry, where the Financial Advisor (DS) was opposing the waiver of sovereign/bank guarantee in the deal signed with France. The not also says that in the absence of sovereign/bank guarantee, the French government should be involved in the deal, and the payments should be made to an Escrow account controlled by the French government, from where the payments should be released to the vendors as per terms and conditions.

N Ram writes that Defence Acquisition Council (DAC) chaired by the then Defence Minister, Manohar Parrikar, met in September 2016, and ratified and approved eight changes in the IGA, supply protocols, offset contracts and offset schedules. This goes against the ongoing narrative that defence ministry was kept out of the loop in the deal and everything was handled by PMO. He says that change of these terms is a violation of the Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP), 2013, under which the deal was signed.

The article also says that provisions for anti-corruption penalties and making payments through an escrow account.

But it seems N Ram missed the section in DPP 2013 which is crucial for this deal. The Rafale deal is an Inter-Governmental Agreement (IGA) between the governments of India and France, and the section about the IGA in the DPP has been completely ignored in the Hindu report.

Section 71 of the DPP states that:

There may be occasions when procurements would have to be done from friendly foreign countries which may be necessitated due to geo-strategic advantages that are likely to accrue to our country. Such procurements would not classically follow the Standard Procurement Procedure and the Standard Contract Document but would be based on mutually agreed provisions by the Governments of both the countries. Such procurements will be done based on an Inter Governmental Agreement after clearance from CFA.

Section 71 of DPP 2013

The DPP 2013, which was prepared during the UPA government, clearly states that in case of Inter-Governmental Agreements, Standard Procurement Procedure and Standard Contract Document will not apply and such deals will be done on mutually agreed terms of both the countries. Therefore, the government to government deal of the Rafale jet also involved changes in certain provisions of DPP, which was duly approved by the Defence Acquisition Council, the highest body supervising defence acquisitions in the country.

Section 72 of the DPP 2013 says that when an Inter Government Agreement is signed with a foreign nation, this agreement will safeguard the interests of the Govt of India. This implies that a separate sovereign/bank guarantee may not be required in the case of an IGA.

Section 75 of DPP 2013

Section 75 of the DPP 2013 says that “any deviation from the prescribed procedure will be put up to DAC through DPB for approval”. This means in the interest of a particular deal, the deviation from the standard procedure is possible, provided it approved by the DAC. The Hindu article itself says that the deviations from the standard procedure was duly approved, so this means provisions of DPP 2013 was followed in signing the Rafale deal.

N Ram says that “the DPP stating explicitly that the Standard Contract Document would be the guideline for all acquisitions”, but the fact is that the same DPP allows diversion from Standard Contract Document in case of Inter Governmental Agreements in section 71, which makes the Rafale deal eligible for such diversion.

Now let’s come to the specific note The Hindu has published this time. At the first it must be noted that like the earlier note, this dissent note is also written by someone who was not part of the Indian Negotiation Team (INT) for the Rafale deal. Therefore, the officer may not be aware of the all details about the deals. Second, only the note without what was the response to it means nothing. This is same as N Ram publishing the earlier cropping the vital response of Defence minister.

When negotiations and discussions take place, lots of ideas are exchanged. Many points are raised, many of them are rejected by some, and ultimately a final decision is taken. After a final decision is taken with the consensus of all, the disagreements during the discussion phase cease to matter. Many of such disagreements or doubts may have been resolved or clarified already. Therefore, such dissent notes during the discussion phase of the Rafale deal does not mean that there was some major scam in the deal. It just means that healthy democratic discussion process took place while finalising the deal.

Air Marshal SBP Sinha headed the INT for the Rafale deal, and he has already clarified that the final report was submitted by the team with signature of all the seven members, without any dissent. He has also pointed out that the notes being selectively published are from such persons who were not part of the negotiation team.

Coming to the anti-corruption clause, that is applicable for a direct deal with private companies only, where there are possibilities of bribes and middleman. In Inter Governmental Agreements, such clauses are waived as per the provisions of DPP, and hence there are no illegalities in that as N Ram wants to suggest.

Rafale is not the first Inter Governmental Agreement India has signed, before this such deals were signed with Russia and USA. And similar waivers were granted in those agreements too. The deal for Sukhoi jet that India signed with Russia had also waived the bank guarantee and anti-corruption clause, which was signed by Congress government.

Air Marshal SBP Sinha has further clarified that anti-corruption clause was not there in any of the Inter Governmental Agreements that India had signed earlier, and Rafale is not the first deal to have such an exemption. To claim that such routine exemption for a government to government is nothing by a lie to derail the Rafale deal.

Coming to the allegation that Modi government discarded suggestion for payment to an Escrow account managed by France government and is making payments directly to Dassault, this completely wrong. The Indian government has signed the deal with the French government, and hence the payments are also being made to the French government only. In December last year, the government of India had announced that it was making a payment of 25% of the deal value to the government of France.

According to reports, the French government has set up a treasury account in their national bank to receive proceeds from India, and payments will be released to vendors only after verification of the progress of the deal. There is no direct payment to Dassault or MBDA, and all payments are made to French government-controlled bank account only. This means that the allegations that the government of India is making payments directly to vendors are incorrect. It also shows that the official raising the objection was perhaps not aware of the detail of the deal.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Related Articles

Trending now

“Dawood Ibrahim administrating legal, financial and mental attack on Republic TV, Arnab Goswami may face physical attack”: Former Bureaucrat RV Subramani

RV Subramani speaks on how Arnab Goswami touched the wrong nerve of Dawood Ibrahim and many politicians by reportage on Bollywood drug nexus

TeleMedicine: Technology bridging the doctor-patient gap to strengthen public healthcare system

Telecardiology helps connect cardiologists and patients in remote areas so that they could get timely report leading to proper diagnosis.

Bihar: The shocking story of Jungle Raj hidden in voter turnouts

The shocking story of Jungle Raj in Bihar no one told you.

Munger Police deactivates its Twitter account amidst claims of SP Lipi Singh being suspended over Durga Puja violence

SP Munger had earlier defended police action on devotees during the Durga Visarjan procession, claiming they provoked the force by pelting stones

NIA raids offices of Greater Kashmir and ‘activist’ associated with NGO that called Amarnath Yatra ‘militarised pilgrimage’

The NIA also carried out raids at the offices of another dubious NGO called 'Athroat', a houseboat named 'HB Hilton' in the Dal Lake and on the residence of 'activist' Khurram Parvez.

BJP MLA Krishnanand Rai’s widow writes to Priyanka Gandhi urging her to stop shielding Mukhtar Ansari, accused of killing her husband

Mukhtar Ansari is currently lodged in a jail in Punjab which is governed by Congress party, which has refused to transfer him to UP

Recently Popular

Faridabad: A month after college student Nikita files molestation complaint against Taufeeq, he shoots her dead

As per reports, the accused initially wanted to abduct the victim but killed her when she resisted him.

Nikita Tomar murder: Taufeeq was pressurising her to embrace Islam family alleges

On Monday, 21-year-old Nikita Tomar was shot to death in broad daylight outside the Aggarwal college in Ballabgarh, Faridabad

Chinese state-run channel shows the portrait of Prophet Muhammad, netizens ask if Muslim nations will boycott China

Arslan Hidayat, an Uyghur Rights Activist, took to Twitter shared a video of a Chinese TV series on Twitter in which it was depicted that an Arab ambassador visiting China during the rule of Tang dynasty gifts a portrait of the Prophet Muhammad to the Chinese emperor.

Charlie Hebdo mocks Turkish President Recep Erdogan in its latest cartoons, shows him lifting a skirt of woman wearing ‘hijab’

The front-page caricature of Wednesday's edition of Charlie Hebdo that was released online on Tuesday night depicts Erdogan in a white T-shirt and underpants, drinking a can of beer and lifting up the skirt of a woman wearing a hijab to reveal her naked bottom.

Nikita Tomar murder: Main accused Tauseef belongs to a family of influential Congress politicians from Nuh in Haryana

The prime accused Tauseef's grandfather, uncles and cousin brothers are all infuential Congress politicians from Haryana's Nuh

YouTuber Lakshay Chaudhary levels serious allegations of fraud against Gaurav Wasan of Swad Official whose video on ‘Baba ka Dhaba’ had gone viral

Gaurav Wasan of Swad Official had uploaded a video about the financial difficulties faced by the elderly couple of 'Baba ka Dhaba'.
- Advertisement -

While appealing Muslim counties to counter Islamophobia, Imran Khan says ‘criticism or questioning of Holocaust’ is criminalised in many counties

Pakistan PM confuses between Holocaust denial and Holocaust criticism, says the criticism is criminalised many countries

Republic TV issues statement condemning Mumbai Police summons to their investors in relation to the TRP scam

Republic TV said that crime branch has asked all investors of the channel to produce all financial transactions relating to last five years

Param Bir Singh tortured me with belt, Saffron Terror allegation was Congress conspiracy to paint India as a terrorist state: Pragya Singh Thakur

Pragya Singh Thakur said that Param Bir Singh and Hemant Karkare had tortured her the most when she was in the custody of ATS

Delhi government begins crackdown on Diwali, 11 anti-firecracker squads to be formed to prevent use of crackers other than ‘Green Crackers’

Delhi govt announced that an anti-firecracker campaign will be launched on November 3 ahead of the Diwali festival

“Dawood Ibrahim administrating legal, financial and mental attack on Republic TV, Arnab Goswami may face physical attack”: Former Bureaucrat RV Subramani

RV Subramani speaks on how Arnab Goswami touched the wrong nerve of Dawood Ibrahim and many politicians by reportage on Bollywood drug nexus

Watch: Pro-India accounts disrupt Pakistan’s anti-India online meeting on Zoom, play pro-Hindu and Indian nationalistic songs

Indic social media users caused embarrassment to Pakistani authorities and diplomats after they raided their online event on zoom

Lord Ram’s effigy burnt in Amritsar on Dussehra, case registered after BJYM and VHP members held protests

In a video of the incident, some people were seen burning an effigy of Lord Ram on the occasion of Dussehra

TeleMedicine: Technology bridging the doctor-patient gap to strengthen public healthcare system

Telecardiology helps connect cardiologists and patients in remote areas so that they could get timely report leading to proper diagnosis.

Adivasis and family of Gond tribal leader Komaram Bheem objects to his Muslim look in the upcoming ‘RRR’ movie

Komaram Bheem’s grandson Sone Rao said that the movie RRR depicting Bheem as Muslim is nothing but a 'distortion'

Bihar: The shocking story of Jungle Raj hidden in voter turnouts

The shocking story of Jungle Raj in Bihar no one told you.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
470,365FollowersFollow
19,500SubscribersSubscribe