Saturday, June 6, 2020
Home News Reports "Why, How, and When" of the successful #MarchForIndia

“Why, How, and When” of the successful #MarchForIndia

Also Read

Vivek Agnihotri
- Vivek Agnihotri is a filmmaker, writer and motivational speaker. He tweets at @vivekagnihotri

November 5, 7.30 AM

It was a chilly morning in Mumbai when I got a call from Madhur Bhandarkar. He asked me if I would like to join an impromptu get together of some eminent award winning artists in Delhi to discuss the misguided propaganda of ‘intolerance’. I felt I must listen to their point of view.

November 6, 10.30 AM

I read a tweet in which Anupam Kher gave a call to all like-minded artists for a march to Rashtrapati Bhavan. Anupam’s idea was to highlight that a lot of artists believe India is tolerant. I questioned myself: Where do I stand? What does my inner being feel?

I believe that India, despite being a polytheist society, has always welcomed, tolerated and accepted monotheist religions. We are one of those rare democracies where Communism, Marxism, Naxalism, Maoism and extreme religious parties are welcomed in mainstream politics. With the plethora of religious beliefs, spiritual practices, rituals, customs, political ideologies, social hierarchies, traditions and 100s of cultural and linguistic divides, India has survived.

It has survived invasions, loots, massacres, genocides, emergency, corruption, forced vesicostomy, oppression, exploitation, social evils, abject poverty and unemployment. With such inhuman living conditions on one side and unlimited wealth on the other, we have survived.  The culture which has nurtured tolerance for years, decades and centuries can’t become intolerant in just 1 year. There was no clear evidence, visible or suggested by the ‘intelligentsia’ that this balance was disrupted by the Modi’s government in 15 months.

I took the next flight to Delhi.

Delhi, 8.00 PM

When I met Anupam with 50 other prominent artists on the eve of the march, a general feeling was that few hundred people would gather. Hence, there were no arrangement, no plans and no organization. Soon we got messages from Bharat Ratna Lata Mangeshkar, Padma Vibhushan Birju Maharaj, Padma Vibhushan Sonal Mansingh, Mahakavi Gopaldas Neeraj, Dagar bros. National award winner Mohanlal, Rajan & Sajan Mishra, Maharashtra Ratna Shri Paunddhare and almost 500 more jewels of India. Apart from that there was a huge support from the social media. People trended #MarchForIndia and #IndiaIsTolerant. We were not alone. As they say, Karvaan banta gaya….

November 7, 8 AM

When we got up in the morning, we read on twitter and FB that this march was taking place in 23 cities in India and a few cities in US and Canada. I also started spreading my messages through #MarchForIndia which soon became the number 1 trending topic worldwide.

10.30 AM

When we reached the venue, all we could see was people. There was no dais, no security and no place to move. Everything was organic. In no time 500 award winning artists from various parts of the country joined in.

11AM

Encouraged with the response, Anupam, me and several others requested PM on twitter to meet us. We had an idea that it won’t be possible as he was in Kashmir.

12 noon

Some people came to me and complained that some media people were unnecessarily intimidating them and when they refused to answer they were called Modi’s Bhakts/Gunde. I reminded them that ‘it’s their job and they are paid for it’. I even saw few media reporters fighting with each other on unethical journalism practiced by their channels. But we were not there to solve competing media’s intolerance with each other.

12.30 PM

There were screams of ‘VandeMatram’ all around. I have never been in the midst of so many patriots. I won’t put any number on the supporters, but the SHO Walia of India Gate told me on record that this was the largest mobilization of a voluntary crowd since the Anna Movement.

2PM

By the time we came out of the Rashtrapati Bhavan, Anupam received a message from PM Modi asking us to meet at 6.30PM.

March For India

6.30PM

While waiting in a small hall in 7RCR, I could feel meticulous professionalism and humility all around. We weren’t sure if PM would make it on time as he was travelling back from Kashmir and it was also the eve of Bihar election results. 6.30 sharp he arrived in spotless white kurta payjama and his trademark jacket. He listened to us, one by one, with absolute concentration and then he spoke with wit, humor, concerns, anecdotes and hope. I have never heard a better half hour speech on tolerance. Some highlights:

  • He told us about his belief that cultural space shouldn’t be ‘rajya aashrit’ (Government dependent) as it takes away the voice of reason but it should be ‘rajya puraskarit’ (Awarded by the state). And without ‘fearless cultural evolution’ we would be a robotic society.
  • He clarified that he never received any request from any ‘kalakar’ to meet him. “One day I saw on TV that Shri Munnawar Rana was saying that ‘if PM invites us, we’ll go and tell him about our concerns’ so I immediately called my secretary and asked him to invite Shri Rana at his convenience but till date no one has come’. As a PM, he can’t go beyond this.  Home Minister Rajnath Singh has publicly extended invitation, twice, but no one has responded.
  • On Kalburgi and Dadri, he said that no one has met the Governors of respective states and lodged their concerns in order to be channeled to him as he can’t interfere in State’s issues. He had asked the Karnataka Govt. to send him all the files on Kalburgi murder but they have not sent them as yet.
  • He illustrated an example of administrative intolerance. During the last days of AB Vajpayee’s government, it was decided to make 6 AIIMS. The then health minister Sushma Swaraj named the Patna AIIMS Jaiprakash Narayan Institue and similarly other 5 were also named on non-Congressi national leaders. Vajpayee’s government lost and Congress came in power. UPA passed a bill in the parliament and ‘banned’ these names to be used for any Government project. That was the level of intolerance, he cited.
  • He was concerned about ‘political concern vs national interest’. He cited that 54 Heads of African countries were in India for the Indo-African summit. “So many heads of state don’t even attend a state funeral’ he said sarcastically.  “1/3rd of the world’s population, its concerns and aspirations were represented yet in our media and public discourse this event was absent’.  He said emphatically ‘If there is a loss to the country due to my mistake, please criticize me which you must… punish me… but just to oppose me or any other political rival, one shouldn’t forget national interest’.
  • He quoted how Galileo was killed for opposing a belief but in India, when Charvak, an atheist, challenged Vedas with logic and rejected the idea of reincarnation he was given the title of ‘Rishi’. Indian thought isn’t about tolerance, its’s about acceptance. He reminded that the societies, which championed the cause of human rights, are the ones who initiated two world wars whereas India has been the most peace generating country, in global context. He said ‘I have absolute faith that ‘tapasya’ of thousands of years can’t be destroyed by you and me’.
  • I proposed to him that he should talk to people from ‘cultural sphere’ including those who don’t agree with him. I told him that I’d want to hold such interaction in Mumbai as in Delhi ‘culture can’t be without politics’. Amidst laughter, he instantly agreed. I said we would organize it whenever he has time to which he said ‘…then it will never happen… you tell me the time and I’ll adjust’.

This wasn’t a one-way speech. This was informal, interactive chat filled with humor, ideas and positivity. And of course, there was chai along with chaas, dhokla, idlis and veg kathi rolls which were literally forced down on us by the Prime Minister himself.

My takeaway from the meeting was that he has immense faith in Indian youth. In him I found a man who is eager to talk to everyone and is ready to solve problems. I hope that disappointed artistes will accept his invitation and make him aware of their concerns. Maybe, he can help.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Vivek Agnihotri
- Vivek Agnihotri is a filmmaker, writer and motivational speaker. He tweets at @vivekagnihotri

Trending now

This is not the first time Arvind Kejriwal has said he doesn’t watch Rahul Kanwal’s shows, here is an incident from 2014

Arvind Kejrowal rejects the claim of India Today journalist Rahul Kanwal that he watched his program on Delhi hospitals

A tale of 2 contradictory orders: How Arvind Kejriwal govt made the Coronavirus fight impossible for doctors at Ganga Ram Hospital

Reportedly, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital would test 150-170 Coronavirus samples and conduct 30-40 surgeries per day, prior to the government order.

Celebrities have commercialised dissent in India, they say ‘BlackLivesMatter’ while endorsing racist fairness creams: Kangana Ranaut

Kangana Ranaut slams celebrities for speaking on 'Black Lives Matter' while staying silent on incidents like Palghar lynching

No, Jyotiraditya Scindia has not ‘removed BJP’ from his Twitter bio: Here is the truth

Media claimed that Jyotiraditya Scindia, the former Congress leader who is now with the BJP, had removed his association with the BJP from his Twitter bio.

How AltNews ‘fact-checked’ the pregnant elephant story to shield Muslim suspects, quietly changed copy but continued to peddle agenda

AltNews tried to 'fact-check' the brutal incident that resulted in the death of an elephant in Kerala with the aim to shield the Muslim suspects

US filmmaker says former Pakistan minister Rehman Malik raped her, former PM Yousaf Raza Gilani manhandled her: Watch

Cynthia D. Ritchie said that sexual assault against her by Senator Rehman Malik had happened occurred at Interior Minister's residence in 2011

Recently Popular

Times of India journalist Samina Shaikh tries to shame Hindus over the killing of pregnant elephant in Kerala

In Hinduism, Lord Ganesha has the head of an elephant and elephants are also considered holy.

Himachal Pradesh: After Kerala pregnant elephant death case, video of a pregnant cow injured due to cracker explosion in mouth surfaces online

In the video shared online, it can be seen that the mouth of the pregnant cow has been injured very badly with a lot of blood oozing out of her mouth

“Your mother was Hindu, how can we trust you?” Read shocking revelations by the niece of Nawazuddin Siddiqui

Nawazuddin Siddiqui and his family refused to believe the niece's allegations stating that they cannot trust the daughter of a Hindu.

Woman ‘protestor’ poops on an overturned police car in middle of riots in America. Watch the video (or maybe not)

A woman was seen defecating on a damaged police car in USA, an act video recorded and photographed by onlookers

After trying to rope in 2nd, 3rd-year MBBS students to manage Coronavirus patients, Maharashtra govt to punish medical interns if they get coronavirus

Medical interns in Maharashtra will be liable to repeat the internship for the quarantine period if they are infected with Coronavirus

GoAir fires trainee officer Asif Khan after screenshots of his Hinduphobic comment went viral on social media

GoAir has terminated the employment of one Asif Khan after his anti-Hindu offensive comments on social media went viral.

Defence Ministry advises media to refrain from any speculative and unsubstantiated reporting on India-China border situation

Defence ministry said that any speculative reporting about India-China border situation would not be helpful

Gujarat: Ahead of Rajya Sabha polls, Congress moves its MLAs to resorts

The Election Commission (EC) has now finalised the polling of four Rajya Sabha seats in Gujarat on June 19.

This is not the first time Arvind Kejriwal has said he doesn’t watch Rahul Kanwal’s shows, here is an incident from 2014

Arvind Kejrowal rejects the claim of India Today journalist Rahul Kanwal that he watched his program on Delhi hospitals

Congress leader Archana Dalmia passes off an old image from 2017 as recent one, deletes it after being caught

Archana Dalmia claimed that the woman had died by the railway tracks of the MP's Damoh and she was spotted by people in the state

Coronavirus: Mild and asymptomatic cases do not need hospitalization, says Delhi Health department

Citing union health ministry guidelines, Delhi govt said that Coronavirus patients with mild and no symptoms do not need hospitalization

Every Sikh wants Khalistan, says Akal Takht Jathedar Giani Harpreet Singh on 36th anniversary of Operation Bluestar

The controversial remarks came from the Akal Takht chief on the occasion of 36th anniversary of the Operation Blue Star

A tale of 2 contradictory orders: How Arvind Kejriwal govt made the Coronavirus fight impossible for doctors at Ganga Ram Hospital

Reportedly, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital would test 150-170 Coronavirus samples and conduct 30-40 surgeries per day, prior to the government order.

Communist Party is ‘both a court and police station’: Kerala women’s panel chief MC Josephine courts controversy

State Women’s Commission chairperson MC Josephine kicked up a controversy after she claimed that her party Communist Party of India (Marxist) was both a court and a police station

Celebrities have commercialised dissent in India, they say ‘BlackLivesMatter’ while endorsing racist fairness creams: Kangana Ranaut

Kangana Ranaut slams celebrities for speaking on 'Black Lives Matter' while staying silent on incidents like Palghar lynching

Pakistan: 8-year-old maid Zohra Shah beaten to death after she accidentally let two parrots escape from cage

When the parrots flew away, a miffed Siddiqui and his wife Umm Kulsoom beat the victim 8-year-old Zohra Shahblack and blue, killing her

Connect with us

229,766FansLike
364,229FollowersFollow
246,000SubscribersSubscribe