Friday, July 10, 2020
Home News Reports Read Naidu's scathing rejection of impeachment motion : Allegations not admissible, Parliamentary customs disregarded

Read Naidu’s scathing rejection of impeachment motion : Allegations not admissible, Parliamentary customs disregarded

Also Read

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Vice President Venkaiah Naidu today rejected the impeachment motion against CJI Deepak Mishra tabled by the 64 MPs of seven opposition parties. The VP has stated legal, moral and constitutional reasons as the ground for the rejection of the motion.

The order of rejection which runs 10 pages, lists out the background of the charges and the Vice Presidents base for rejection. At the beginning of the order, the VP acknowledges the relevant sections of the constitution and the relevant laws (The Judges Inquiry Act, 1968) that lays rules for the grounds on which an impeachment motion can be initiated against a sitting judge. He acknowledges that since 64 MPs have signed it, the motion meets the requirement of a minimum of 50 MPs signing the order. He has also added that the same Act also provides for the chairman of the council, after consulting, to either reject or accept the motion.

The VP mentions that he took guidance from a previous Supreme Court order in the case of N Krishna Swami vs Union of India (AIR 1993 SC 1407).

courtesy: Livelaw

The VP mentions that since the case is against the CJI himself he has not consulted him on the matter and has consulted with legal luminaries, constitutional experts, former secretary generals of both houses of Parliament and several jurists. He adds that after going through comments and consultations of all the above, he is of the opinion that the impeachment motion is not fit to be a case for removal of a judge.

The VP added that the article 124(4) explicitly states the ground for impeachment to be ‘proved misbehaviour or incapacity’. He added that the word ‘proved’ places an obligation that the allegations of misbehaviours must be proved before the parliamentary process of removal can be initiated, which is not the case in this motion.

courtesy: Livelaw

Venkaiah Naidu goes ahead to add that the MPs who have presented the motion are unsure of their own case since the page 1 of the motion has phrases like ‘may have been involved’ and ‘he too was likely’ etc and it shows that the MPs are merely stating their suspicion or a conjecture or assumption which cannot be called ‘proved beyond reasonable doubt’. He adds that conversations between the third parties, with dubious credentials, which have been extensively relied upon, cannot themselves constitute any material evidence against the Chief Justice of India.

The VP further adds that it is affirmed by a constitution bench of judges of Supreme Court ( Kamini Jaiswal vs Union of India , 14 Nov, 2017 ) that the CJI is master of roasters and that it is his prerogative alone to constitute benches of judges and there cannot be any direction to the CJI as to who will sit on a bench and who shall take up the matter.

courtesy; Livelaw

The order further mentions that in para 15 of the same Supreme Court order, it is mentioned that the CJI is well within his powers to construct administrative benches too.

Courtesy: Livelaw

Mr Naidu adds further that the five allegations mentioned by the MPs are neither admissable or tenable. He states that the allegations in the motion have a serious tendency of undermining the judiciary and hence it is neither legal nor proper to admit the notice of motion. He states that the provisions in the constitution are to nurture and strengthen the judiciary and there are safeguards to prevent interference in its independence by Legislature and Executive powers.

He adds further that the section 124(4) and the Judges Act both have laid down very stringent conditions necessary for initiation of such proceedings and they are aimed at protecting and safeguarding the independence of the judiciary and keep the judges safe from external pressure.

courtesy: Livelaw

The Vice President further adds that there is virtually no verifiable concrete imputation in the motion and it would be inappropriate and irresponsible to accept statements which have little empirical basis. He asserts that he has examined the relevant provisions in the constitution and also has pursued the annexures provided in the motion, consulted with experts he is certain that the motion is not admissible. He also added that the parliamentary customs and conventions have been disregarded in case of the impeachment notion.

He goes ahead to add that it is prohibited for the members to publicize any notice submitted to the Chairman till it is admitted and circulated to the said members. He condemned the MPs conducting press conferences immediately after submitting the notice and asserted that is against the propriety and decorum of the parliament and also denigrates the institution of the CJI.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Trending now

The Wire accused Yogi Adityanath of being ‘casteist’ for not killing Vikas Dubey hours before the encounter of the gangster

Notorious gangster, Vikas Dubey, who was arrested from Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh was killed in an encounter in the wee hours of the morning on Friday

Vikas Dubey killed in an encounter after he attempts to flee from police custody: Here is what happened

The encounter broke out between Vikas Dubey and the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) after the gangster tried to flee upon reaching Kanpur.

Delhi Riots Chargesheets: Before murdering Ratan Lal, the Islamist mob had held 2 other police constables hostage

The chargesheet filed by Special Investigation Team of Delhi Police in the murder of Ratan Lal and deadly attacks by rioters on IPS Amit Sharma and IPS Anuj Kumar mentions at least 17 accused.

The curious case of ‘Drone Boy’ who has made 600 drones using broken mixer grinders and televisions. A fact-check

While 'drone boy' Prathap NM has claimed to have made 600 drones using e-waste, not a single photo or video of them exist

Criminal Vikas Dubey had tortured his school headmaster to death, exhibited criminal behaviour since childhood: Report

Vikas Dubey had tortured his school headmaster Siddheshwar Pandey to death during his childhood

Used cartridges from the rooftop: What was collected from the scene where Ratan Lal was murdered and what it all means

During the anti-Hindu Delhi riots, the brutal murder of Ratan Lal was one of the first acts of violence that shook the nation from the 24th of February to the 26th of February

Recently Popular

Netizens ask Netflix to cancel comedian Kenny Sebastian’s special show after he hurls obscene abuses

Social media users are demanding that Netflix reconsiders special show of Indian comic Kenny Sebastian after he was allegedly found hurling obscene abuses to people on his Instagram page.

The curious case of ‘Drone Boy’ who has made 600 drones using broken mixer grinders and televisions. A fact-check

While 'drone boy' Prathap NM has claimed to have made 600 drones using e-waste, not a single photo or video of them exist

Jyoti Basu is the mass murderer India forgot

Please don’t feel bad about speaking ill of the Late Jyoti Basu. If there is another world, be certain that there are (at least) 28,000 voices from the other side backing you up.

Only Muslims go to heaven, Ravish Kumar-like non-Muslims can only hope for a mild level of hell: Dr Zakir Naik explains

Naik said that virtues like honesty and charity cannot ensure qualifying marks for heaven or Jannah. Only Muslims can go to heaven and non-Muslims will go to hell by default, he says.

After obscene comments, clip of comedian Kenneth Sebastian calling Sanskrit ‘most useless language ever’ goes viral. Watch video

In the video titled "Journey to the centre of my brain", Sebastian is seen thanking God because 'all the people who spoke Sanskrit are dead'.

From Vikas Dubey has reached Nepal to he may be encountered ‘because he knows dirty secrets’: Read how conspiracy theorists spun yarns

As Vikas Dubey was on the run, the journalists kept themselves busy conjuring up various conspiracy theories.

Congress leader Udit Raj’s organisation makes derogatory comments against Brahmins, compares the community to ‘pigs’

Dalit organsation All India Parisangh run by Congress leader Udit Raj insults Brahmins by comparing with pigs

Nepal: Lawmaker removed from House of Representatives for pro-India stand, blamed China for the new map

Sarita Giri of the Samajwadi Party Nepal has been removed from her position of a member of the House of Representatives.

Nizamuddin Markaz: Delhi Court sets 60 Tablighi Jamaat members from Malaysia free for a ₹7000 fine

60 Malaysian nationals who had attended Nizamuddin Markaz violating visa norms freed by Delhi court on fine of Rs 7000 each

Four policemen injured in the accident, which led to the encounter of Vikas Dubey, brought to the hospital: Watch

The injured policemen have been rushed to Lala Lajpat Rai Hospital in Kanpur, after they suffered some injuries during the encounter of gangster Vikas Dubey.

After notorious gangster Vikas Dubey, another criminal Panna Yadav killed in an encounter after he opened fire

After Vikas Dubey, notorious criminal Panna Yadav gunned down in encounter by Uttar Pradesh police

The Wire accused Yogi Adityanath of being ‘casteist’ for not killing Vikas Dubey hours before the encounter of the gangster

Notorious gangster, Vikas Dubey, who was arrested from Ujjain, Madhya Pradesh was killed in an encounter in the wee hours of the morning on Friday

Nepal irked over reports of KP Oli’s alleged affair with Chinese ambassador, cable operators ban Indian channels

As per reports, the ban is not official and has been brought in by cable operators. Nepal's Nepal’s information minister Yuba Raj Khatiwada, when asked whether the Nepalese government is mulling a ban on Indian channels, had stated that it would be better if Indian media practises self-restraint.

India Today journalist Ashraf Wani peddles fake news claiming Kashmiri woman was killed by Army bullets in Pampore

A lady was caught in the crossfire after some terrorists attacked an Army convoy near a Mosque in Pampore. She was brought to hospital and was discharged soon after first-aid.

Vikas Dubey killed in an encounter after he attempts to flee from police custody: Here is what happened

The encounter broke out between Vikas Dubey and the Uttar Pradesh Special Task Force (STF) after the gangster tried to flee upon reaching Kanpur.

Delhi Riots Chargesheets: Before murdering Ratan Lal, the Islamist mob had held 2 other police constables hostage

The chargesheet filed by Special Investigation Team of Delhi Police in the murder of Ratan Lal and deadly attacks by rioters on IPS Amit Sharma and IPS Anuj Kumar mentions at least 17 accused.

Connect with us

235,293FansLike
402,398FollowersFollow
272,000SubscribersSubscribe