Thursday, June 13, 2024
HomeOpinionsIf 'propaganda' is a symphony, Ram Guha is Beethoven

If ‘propaganda’ is a symphony, Ram Guha is Beethoven

Propagandists in India are prone to tawdry and tacky methods. There is very often no elegance in their methods. No poetry. No finesse. They lie clumsily, their hypocrisy, as bright as day, for all men to behold. The kind of propagandists who use photoshop to morph images and don’t dress their lies up just enough so they don’t get caught. Not Ramchandra Guha. Watching him propagate is like watching poetry in motion. The lies rolling off his tongue like airy butter cookies melting in one’s mouth, his hypocrisy, misrepresentations and half-truths, blending so effortlessly to falsely present a mirage of truth. His nonchalant brazenness that has almost become a part of his charm, only amplified by those Harry Potteresque glasses, albeit rimless, that give him the natural air of nerdy, intellectual superiority.

How can someone not believe a man with his salt pepper, dishevelled, quintessentially “intellectual” look? And therein lies the beauty of his con. Look so immaculately tousled, that every bit of lie and hypocrisy is taken at face value. And lord knows, Ram Guha is a treasure trove of hypocrisy and lies.

Recently, a video surfaced where a citizen was seen visibly angry with a shabby propagandist called Rajdeep Sardesai. The techie questioned Sardesai on his anti-India, anti-Modi slant. Of course, if Sardesai was as good at the art of propaganda as Ram, he would have never been publicly confronted, but that’s for another time. News later surfaced that this unwashed citizen who had dared to question the court jester was ‘detained’ by Bangalore police because let’s face it, how dare the villager assume to have the same levels of Freedom of Expression as the perfumed elite.

Some rejoiced. Some questioned. Among the ones who questioned, was TV Mohandas Pai, who is the Chairman of Manipal Global Education. He was a former director of Infosys.

He dared to speak up.

Ram Guha proceeded to do what he does best. Obfuscate by confusing his readers to an extent that his half-truth starts to appear as the whole truth.

A seasoned propagandist like Ram Guha did two things here. Firstly, addressed Pai by his first name. Mohan. Thereby establishing the obligation that comes with a supposed acquaintance. Secondly, before calling Pai a liar, he slipped in an underhand compliment: “A man of your stature”. Put together, these two tools can work wonders, Establish a personal connect thereby convincing the adversary that he is a friend and doesn’t detest him for his differing ideology (he does) and remind him of his “stature” so he backs off owing either because of the fear of ostracisation or the realisation that the “perfumed elite” aren’t supposed to fight for the unwashed masses, but lofty ideals that may (or may not, most probably won’t) help the unwashed masses.

Owing to his “natural charm” and “stature”, none of the intellectuals and fellow (far less poised) propagandists would dare point out that he was obfuscating facts to justify the harassment of a citizen.

Nobody would remind him that there lies a world of difference between ‘detention’ and ‘arrest’. Police can ‘detain’ someone on mere suspicion without charging him of any crime whereas, when an arrest is made, a person is charged with a crime, seeks bail, and appears in court to prove his innocence. A citizen is held on ‘reasonable suspicion’ for questioning. Now, while detention is legimite in law, nobody bothered to ask why a citizen was detained on “reasonable suspicion” simply for being angry at a public personality and using words to express the same without being abusive, threatening or menacing.

TV Mohandas Pai said the citizen was being ‘detained’. Ram Guha refuted Pai and called him a liar by saying that he had not been ‘arrested’. Both were right. But Ram made Pai look like a bald-faced liar. This example of blatant propaganda was like Beethoven’s fifth symphony. Effortless.

Ramchandra Guha has picked a side and he is sticking to it. People, facts, figures, truth, logic are mere tools. To be used, twisted, abused, as and when it suits the side he has picked.

In the run-up to this brazen lie, Guha indulged in another form of trickery. As any propagandist, he tried his best to maintain the charade of neutrality by praising a fellow intellectual who doesn’t belong to his ideological leaning. Arun Shourie. The ‘right-wing’ intellectual who is credible, in Guha’s eyes.

Just as before, he starts with appealing to the ‘stature’ of the individual he wants to use to aide his propaganda. This time, Shourie. And then progresses to his real agenda. Using Shourie to malign Modi and Shah.

This argument would hold if Guha always held Shourie in high regard. But that is not the case and that is again something a seasoned propagandist like Guha would never reveal.

As pointed out by TrueIndology, this wasn’t the case when Shourie wasn’t serving Guha’s propaganda by speaking out against Modi and Shah. Some excerpts from his essay “The use and Abuse of Gandhi” from his book “An Anthropologist Among the Marxists.”

He had called Shourie a “pamphleteer masquerading as Historian”

via @TrueIndology

He had almost compared Shourie’s nationalism to that of white supremacists.

via @TrueIndology

He had called Shourie a “bilious polemicist and baiter of the minorities”

via @TrueIndology

He had also called Shourie ‘woefully ill-informed’ because Shourie had dared to disagree with Congress and its supporters.

via @TrueIndology

Propaganda is information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote a political cause or point of view. It is said that only the mob and the elite can be attracted by the momentum of totalitarianism itself, the masses have to be won by propaganda (Hannah Arendt). The ecosystem of the left, that Ram Guha belongs to is a totalitarianist system. It is dictatorial and demands complete submission and subservience to the “cause” it espouses. And for the left, it is extremely easy to have the elite and criminals favour them by their sheer momentum. Look how quickly abusive, criminal and downright stupid people are turned into overnight stars. But to get us, us unwashed masses on their side, it takes a well-oiled propaganda machinery. To subvert the truth. Further the lies. Obfuscate facts. Give people the carrot of being a part of the ‘elite squad’ and the stick of being labelled and called all sorts of heinous names. The subtle fear of being harassed if one doesn’t conform. It is propaganda and propaganda alone that can get the unwashed masses drawn to their totalitarian system.

Ramchandra Guha is a maestro and this propaganda is his symphony.

Ayodhra Ram Mandir special coverage by OpIndia

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Nupur J Sharma
Nupur J Sharma
Editor-in-Chief, OpIndia.

Related Articles

Trending now

Jaipur, Rajasthan: Local Hindus cite harassment, pressure from Muslims to vacate the area, posters urging Hindus not to sell their homes to non-Hindus put...

It has been said by the local Hindus that the local Muslims are continuously harassing them through various tactics and even pressuring them to sell their houses to Muslims. Frustrated due to the perpetual harassment several Hindu families are reportedly migrating from the area.

Day 1 of BJP govt in Odisha: All 4 Dwars of Jagannath Temple opened, State Secretariat allows journalists after 4 years

Majhi, who was sworn in as Odisha's Chief Minister on June 12, in his first Cabinet meeting approved a proposal to re-open all four Dwars of Shree Jagannath Temple in Puri early on Thursday morning, as promised by the BJP during election campaign.

Recently Popular

- Advertisement -