Turf war between Government and Judiciary witnesses a showdown in Supreme Court

The ongoing turf war between the Government and the Judiciary witnessed a showdown at the Supreme Court when the Center took the Collegium head on for recommending few names to fill up massive vacancies in the High Courts.

The bench was hearing a matter related to the vacancy of judges in High Courts in the Northeastern states after a petition was filed by a man seeking a transfer of his case from the Manipur High Court to Gauhati High High Court. During the hearing, AG Venugopal referred to a resolution where the Collegium recommended that Justice Serto should continue operating from the Gauhati high Court despite being appointed to the Manipur High Court and remarked that it was “very strange”. “That time, only two judges were there in Manipur High Court. It should not have been said that he (Justice Serto) would continue in Gauhati High Court. It was necessary to bring him back to Manipur High Court,” he said. The bench replied, “maybe the Collegium does not want to get him back to Manipur. We do not know.”

“I don’t know, I will have to find out,” said Attorney General KK Venugopal when the Bench inquired how many names recommended by the Collegium were pending with the government to which the bench retorted, “when it comes to the government, you say ‘we will find out'”.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

The Attorney General said, “The Collegium will have to see the broad picture and recommend more names,” before adding, “some high courts have 40 vacancies and recommendation of the Collegium is only for three. And the government is being told that we are tardy in filing up the vacancy”.

The most recent source of conflict between the two pillars of democracy was the recommendation of the Collegium to elevate Justice Joseph to the Supreme Court. According to reports, the Collegium had deferred the decision on reconsidering Justice Joseph’s elevation to the Supreme Court after the government sent it back. Reports had emerged which quoted a source stating that the Collegium was of the view that it will “not send any other names for elevation to the Supreme Court, at least until as long as this Collegium is in place” if the Center did not approve Justice Joseph’s recommendation by the Collegium.

The Center is, however, of the view that Justice Joseph’s elevation would give “seniority and regional representation a go-by.” Justice Joseph features quite low on the seniority list of High Courts Judges and there is already another judge at the Supreme Court who hails from Kerala and is a member of the Christian community. As was decided in Second and Third Judges Cases, these factors contribute towards elevation to the Supreme Court. The Center claims that it duly followed the Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) which was finalized by the Collegium on March 13, 2017. The MoP said in paragraph 5, “In case of elevation of a chief justice of an HC or a judge of the HC as a judge of the Supreme Court, a fair representation shall be given to all HCs. The criterion of ‘seniority’ as an HC judge, subject to merit and integrity, will be followed.”

In a letter to CJI Dipak Misra in April, Justice Kurian Joseph accused the government of abusing its power and sitting on the recommendations of the Collegium for months. “Failure to discharge their duty by sitting over on the recommendations of the Collegium doing nothing, in administrative law, is an abuse of power. More than anything else, it sends a wrong message which is loud and clear to all Judges down the line not to cause any displeasure to the Executive lest they should suffer. Is this not a threat to the independence of the judiciary,” he wrote in his letter.

The primary conflict between the Legislature and the Judiciary arose when the NJAC which was passed by the Parliament and State Assemblies was struck down by the Supreme Court to continue the Judiciary’s monopoly over the appointment of Judges to the Courts. At one point during the showdown, Mr Venugopal remarked jocularly, I think NJAC was a better option to have.” It is still unclear, meanwhile, how the current predicament will be resolved.

Average in every department

Share and Support:
Support OpIndia by paying for content

Most read articles recently

Activist opposing Akshaya Patra’s mid-day meal contract thinks ‘Brahmins obstruct India’s development’

The Akshaya Patra has come under criticism recently for not including onion and garlic in its mid-day meals for school children.

Here is what connects attack on Akshaya Patra, French NGO against Rafale and demonization of Amarnath Yatra

The web of foreign-funded NGOs that demonised the Amarnath Yatra, French NGO that complained against Rafale in France and the demand to remove Akshaya Patra from midday meals contract

Mumbai Police teaches a lesson in humility to ‘special’ Sonam Kapoor

Actor Dulquer Salman clarified that he and Sonam were sitting inside a car that was rigged to a truck and hence were not breaking traffic rules.

All you need to know about Congress’ Chhattisgarh CM elect: Bhupesh Baghel, who was once jailed in sex CD case

Congress leader and Chhattisgarh CM elect Bhupesh Baghel is currently out on bail in sleaze video case

Zee News issues defamation notice of Rs 1000 crore to Congress leader Navjot Singh Singh

Sidhu had allegedly threatened the Zee News when he had said “nani yaad dila denge” after Zee News had shown a video ‘Pakistan Zindabad’ slogans were raised at an election rally

Uttar Pradesh: Eight cattle smugglers arrested in Bahraich with arms and ammunition

The smugglers even tried to trample the police personnel with their vehicle.

Church of South India Archbishop Dyvasirvadam arrested in church fund scam, reports Times of India

According to the report, archbishop Dyvasirvadam was allegedly involved in misappropriation of church fund for over a decade

Rafale: SC examined the pricing details closely, ‘did not rely’ on CAG report as claimed by Rahul Gandhi

Rahul Gandhi has claimed that the Supreme Court verdict on Rafale was based only on the CAG report, while it is not true

#GoBackSonia trends on Twitter ahead of Sonia Gandhi’s Tamil Nadu visit to inaugurate Karunanidhi’s statue

Twitter is abuzz with #GoBackSonia trend as Sonia Gandhi is going to Chennai to inaugurate the statute of DMK founder Karunanidhi.

Rafale: They wanted to pull Modi down to their level

The Congress and its ecosystem is strong and well oiled.

Latest articles

Connect with us

125,730FansLike
98,118FollowersFollow
6,327SubscribersSubscribe

Don't miss these