Saturday, January 16, 2021
Home Media Former Supreme Court judge accuses media of running fake news over Alok Verma case

Former Supreme Court judge accuses media of running fake news over Alok Verma case

According to media reports, justice Patnaik said the decision to remove was very hasty, but the fact is SC had ordered to take a decision withing a week

Adding more fuel to already heated debate on former CBI director Alok Verma, on 12th January several media houses published reports claiming that Justice Patnaik had told them that there was no evidence against Verma regarding corruption. The Supreme Court had asked justice A K Patnaik to supervise the CVC (Central Vigilance Commission) investigation against Alok Verma. According to the reports, the retired judge of Supreme Court said that there was no evidence of corruption against Verma and the decision of the selection committee to remove Verma from his post was “very, very hasty”.

Although all the media houses are claimed that have talked to Justice Patnaik, surprisingly, the quotes they got are exactly same. According to NDTV, their reporter Sunil talked to the retired judge. India Today also said that they have talked to the Justice Patnaik. Indian Express also published a similar report. On its website, CNN18 credited Indian Express for the report, but on their TV report, they said that they talked to Justice Patnaik and it was an exclusive story. The Telegraph also made a similar claim like many other media houses saying that justice Patnaik talked to them. According to the reports, Justice Patnaik also said that “none of the findings in the CVC report are mine”.

After these reports came out, retired Supreme Court judge Justice Markandey Katju decided to a little probe, and talked to Justice Patnaik on phone. He published some detail of the conversation in an article published at The Week. According to him, Justice Patnaik told him that no journalist sought an appointment with him to discuss the matter. He also said that only one lady journalist from The Indian Express had telephoned him, and they spoke for less than a minute. Thus, going the version of Justice Katju, several media houses ran a story copied from Indian Express claiming to be their original stories. On the basis of a single conversation, several media houses ran elaborate stories, each claiming they had spoken to Justice Patnaik.

Reacting on the statement attributed to Justice Patnaik that the decision to transfer Alok Verma was “hasty”, Justice Katju pointed out that Supreme Court had given only one week for the committee to take a call on Verma, therefore the three-member selection committee had to arrive at a decision soon. The SC order was given on January 8th, so the committee had time till January 14th only.

Before this, the media also ran stories saying that the Committee should have heard Verma before taking the decision. Along with prime minister Narendra Modi, justice A K Sikri gave the decisive verdict in favour of transferring Verma. Media had reported that Verma was ‘sacked’, and it was a punishment, but the fact is that he was merely transferred to a different post with equal rank. Justice Katju explains that an opportunity to hear needed to be provided only when someone is dismissed, the same is not needed when someone is transferred or even suspended. Moreover, CVC had already heard Verma, who had also submitted his response to the CVC report to the Supreme Court. Therefore, there was no need for the committee to hear him. Justice Katju had also spoken to Justice Sikri earlier, and he had given these reasons for not hearing Verma and transferring him.

Media could have talked to Justice Sikri before declaring the decision to be wrong, and they apparently ran a story claiming to have talked to Justice Patnaik without talking to him. Criticising such behaviour of media, justice Katju said that it amounts to ‘fake news’. He said that media is the true enemy of people, which largely believes in creating sensations and providing masala to the public. There is no surprise that the people do not hold most of the media and journalists in high regard, he added.

The comment of Patnaik that the findings of the CVC report are not his is a matter of fact that the media tried to spin. Supreme Court had not appointed justice Patnaik to investigate Verma, he was only asked to supervise CVC’s probe on Verma. His role was to ensure that the CVC probe was fair, and Verma got adequate opportunity to present his side. Therefore, it is factually correct that it is a CVC report, not a report by justice Patnaik.

It is important to be noted that the decision to transfer Alok Verma was taken on the basis of CVC report, and two Supreme Court judges had found that there are some serious allegations against him which need to be probed. Before Justice Sikri decided that Verma should be removed from the post CBI Director to ensure a fair probe, CJI Ranjan Gogoi had said that some allegations against Verma are serious, while commenting on the CVC report which was submitted to the court in a sealed cover. CJI Gogoi had said that on some charges, the CVC report is very complimentary for Verma, on some, not so complimentary, on some, it is not at all complimentary, and on others, further investigation is required.

Now ignoring the ruling of the two sitting Supreme Court judges, including the CJI, media is trying to build a narrative that allegations against Verma are based only the statements of CBI special director Rakesh Asthana, and Alok Verma is actually innocent. By making such claims, they are actually questioning the judgements of CJI Gogoi and Justice Sikri.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Related Articles

Trending now

‘Physically and mentally tortured’ former BARC CEO, arrested by Mumbai Police, admitted to hospital, daughter requests PM Modi to save his life

Pratyusha Dasgupta, the daughter of former BARC CEO Partho Dasgupta, has appealed to PM Modi to save her father's life.

All you need to know about Navdeep Bains, minister who resigned from Trudeau govt: Corruption, Khalistan, immigration scam and lobbying for China

Navdeep Bains is considered to be one of the aggressive Khalistan sympathizers within the Canada government.

Mumbai Police accused of tearing Lord Shri Ram’s posters in Malwani and arresting 3 VHP workers for filming the act: What we know

The VHP have alleged that Mumbai Police personnel in Malwani had removed and tore the posters of Ram Mandir Nidhi Sankalan Abhiyan

HDFC Bank removes video hailing Pastor Praveen as ‘Neighbourhood Hero’ after his arrest for making hate speech against Hindus: Details

In August 2020, HDFC Bank had posted a video on its YouTube channel in which it hailed Pastor Praveen as a 'Neighbourhood Hero'.

After a global outcry, WhatsApp issues clarification, delays enforcement of updated privacy policy: Read full details

The WhatsApp privacy policy update invited backlash after the app said it reserved the right to share some user data with Facebook.

Ravish Kumar apologises for spreading fake news about paddy procurement by govt after letter to NDTV by PIB: Here is what he said

After getting caught for peddling fake news about paddy procurement by govt, controversial NDTV news anchor Ravish Kumar has apologized

Recently Popular

Nidhi Razdan was scammed into believing she got an offer from the real Harvard University to become a professor of journalism: Details

Nidhi Razdan, formerly with NDTV, has revealed that she was the victim of a phishing attack and Harvard never came calling.

The Nidhi Razdan Harvard fiasco: A user had sounded off the alarms as early as September 2020

Nidhi Razdan revealed on Friday that she fell victim to a phishing scam and confirmed that she was never offered a job by Harvard.

All you need to know about Jhanvi Kukreja murder case, the teenage girl who was brutally killed at a New Year party in Mumbai

Reports suggest that the injuries incurred by Jhanvi Kukreja were homicidal and not accidental

Ravish Kumar apologises for spreading fake news about paddy procurement by govt after letter to NDTV by PIB: Here is what he said

After getting caught for peddling fake news about paddy procurement by govt, controversial NDTV news anchor Ravish Kumar has apologized

Nidhi Razdan got ‘scammed’ into believing that she got a job from Harvard University: Here is what does not make sense in her story

While Nidhi Razdan says that the Harvard job she was offered was fake, last year she had said she is teaching in Harvard

CNN’s ‘Ted Cruz-Dorito’ clarification is fake, but here is a real ‘crowbar-ProBar’ correction issued post spreading fake news

It was claimed that Ted Cruz was seen wearing a pin of QAnon symbol that was later discovered to be a Dorito snack chip stuck to his suit

Jhanvi Kukreja murder case: Autopsy reveals no sexual assault, accused sent to judicial custody

The Khar police have failed to find eye witness testimonies or any concrete evidence in connection to the Jhanvi Kukreja murder case.

‘Physically and mentally tortured’ former BARC CEO, arrested by Mumbai Police, admitted to hospital, daughter requests PM Modi to save his life

Pratyusha Dasgupta, the daughter of former BARC CEO Partho Dasgupta, has appealed to PM Modi to save her father's life.

When Lalu Prasad’s daughter, Misa Bharti, also pretended to deliver a lecture at Harvard University

Harvard University had junked the fake claims about being invited as a speaker by the university made by Misa Bharti

Uttar Pradesh Police arrest one Mehboob from Karnataka for allegedly kidnaping a Hindu girl and trying to convert her to Islam

Mehboob had allegedly befriended the Hindu girl on social media and lured her by promising a job.

Kashmiri-origin appointee in Joe Biden’s White House team has links to Islamist org, CIA Director pick has concerns about ‘Hindu majoritarianism’: Details

Joe Biden has appointed Sameera Fazili of Kashmiri origin as the Deputy Director of the National Economic Council.

All you need to know about Navdeep Bains, minister who resigned from Trudeau govt: Corruption, Khalistan, immigration scam and lobbying for China

Navdeep Bains is considered to be one of the aggressive Khalistan sympathizers within the Canada government.

‘Dawai bhi, Kadaai bhi’ is the new mantra, says PM Modi while flagging off world’s largest vaccination program against Covid-19

India will inoculate 30 crore people against Covid-19 in the largest ever vaccination program that started on 16th January

BHU to induct degree course on Hindu Studies with Ancient scriptures, Vedas, Puranas and more: Exclusive details

Bharat Adhyayan Kendra of BHU has come up with a structured two-year course on Hindu Studies, scriptures and traditions

Watch: Sanitation worker Manish Kumar becomes the first person to receive Coronavirus vaccine at AIIMS Delhi

PM Modi on Saturday flagged off India's Coronavirus vaccine drive, the biggest immunisation exercise in the world

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
22,700SubscribersSubscribe