Tuesday, October 20, 2020
Home Fact-Check 'Activist' Harsh Mander weaves a web of lies to scaremonger about NRC and Foreigners...

‘Activist’ Harsh Mander weaves a web of lies to scaremonger about NRC and Foreigners Tribunals in Assam

People of Assam want to protect the identity of the land, and the process of updating the NRC is an important part of the same.

Today activist Harsh Mander has written an article on Indian Express which is another attempt at scaremongering about the ongoing NRC update process in Assam. The trigger of the article is a recent notification by Home Minister, which had detailed the process to be adopted by the Foreigners Tribunals to deal with appeals that may arise after the final NRC is released. In the order amending the Foreigners Act, the government has now also allowed governments of states and union territories to set up Foreigner Tribunals, which at present can be set up by Union government only.

According to Mander, this simple order has the potential to alter India forever, as he says that an Assam specific act has been extended to entire India. He alleges that this will crush the fundamental rights of millions of vulnerable people in the country. But the fact is, as the home ministry has already clarified, the Foreigners Act applies to the entire nation, not just the state of Assam. Therefore, to allege that union government is extending an Assam specific act to the entire country is completely false.

The government anticipates that after the final National Register of Citizens is published, lots of people will be unhappy with the same. To provide an opportunity to appeal against the decision of NRC authorities, the government has made the provision to appeal at a Foreigners Tribunal. This means even if someone’s name does not appear in the final NRC, it is not the end of road for them, they can appeal at the Foreigners Tribunals, which are special courts set up to deal with citizenship issues. The Home Ministry order only provides direction on how to deal with such appeals. Therefore, there is nothing in the order that will alter India.

Coming to the point of authorising states to set up Tribunals, it is anticipated that a large number of such judicial bodies will be required in the state of Assam post publication of final NRC. To ensure that, the union government has taken this decision so that the Government of Assam can set up Foreigners Tribunal as per requirement in a timely manner. But as the Foreigners Act applies to the whole of India and not just Assam, the order has mentioned governments of states and union territories, as it is not possible to empower only one state to do that. But this does not mean that other states in India will automatically start setting up Foreigners Tribunals where there is no need for such a body. The same has also been clarified by the Ministry of Home Affairs, which says that the order is applicable only to Assam as on date for all practical purposes.

Harsh Mander also repeats many lies about the NRC update process. Entire left-liberal ecosystem opposes it, terming it a BJP conspiracy. They hide the fact that the original NRC was published in 1951, when the Bharatiya Janata Party didn’t even exist. After the massive illegal migration of Bangladeshis to India and specifically Assam, people of after Assam had launched a huge agitation for detection and deportation of illegal immigrants. The agitation was called off after the historic Assam Act signed by the Congress Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi. It was decided that people who came to Assam before 25 March 1971 will be citizens of India. But those who came after that cut off date will be detected and deported, and their names will be deleted from the voter list. To implement this provision of the Assam Act, the NRC was required to be updated.

It was a demand during Assam Agitation, and the demand continued after 1985. So, it entirely false to say that NRC updation is being done at the behest of BJP. Although demand for updating the register was being made since 1985, successive governments kept deferring it due to various reasons, but primarily due to opposition by minority organisations. Finally, in 2013 the Supreme Court of India had directed the central and state government to update the NRC. After that, the work on the same was started, which is done under the supervision of the Supreme Court itself.

Harsh Mander also says that the NRC process reverses the burden of proof, as in most crimes the state has to prove the crime, not the accused. That is a blatant lie as the matter of citizenship is different and it is not dealt with common criminal laws anywhere in the world. The burden of proof of identity always lies with the individual, not the state. If a person ends up in a foreign country without valid identity and travel documents, they will be put in jail or deported to their country of origin. The individuals themselves have to furnish the necessary documents to prove that they entered that country legally, or that they belong to that country, the state will not work on its own to prove the citizenship of the individuals.

In fact, and earlier act related to illegal foreigners in Assam, the IMDT act [Illegal Migrants (Determination by Tribunal) Act], brought by Indira Gandhi government in 1983, had actually reversed this normal burden of proof and said that the complainant has to prove that a person is an illegal immigrant. This had proved to be the biggest hurdle in the deportation of illegal immigrants, and the Supreme Court had struck down this act in 2005 for this reason.

Moreover, section 9 of the Foreigners Act, 1946 clearly states that the burden of proof lies on the person who is suspected of being a foreigner. Therefore, Mander is making a totally false allegation by saying that India’s highest court itself ordered the reversal of burden of proof. The Supreme Court was in fact enforcing what was already in the law, which was made decades before BJP came into existence.

In another blatant lie, Harsh Mander says that people are having to pay huge amounts in lawyers’ fee to deal with the NRC process. That is completely untrue, as lawyers have no role in the entire NRC updation process. Persons have to approach the NRC offices set up for hearing appeals and objections directly, there is no need of any lawyer, and there is no evidence to suggest that people are appointing lawyers for the same. Lawyers are needed in Foreigners Tribunals as they are courts, but certainly not in the NRC process.

Liberals in India would like to keep illegal immigrants, Bangladeshis to Rohingyas, in India. But the fact is, the general public don’t want them. People don’t want to share limited resources, they don’t want farm and forest lands taken over by aliens, and most importantly, they don’t want to become minorities in their own land. The demographic profile of several districts in Assam has already changed drastically, and there is a need to stop that. Of course, liberals will say there is nothing wrong if one religion becomes majority and other goes extinct, but unfortunately for them, most people who vote governments to power do not subscribe to that viewpoint. People of Assam want to protect the identity of the land, and the process of updating the NRC is an important part of the same.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Raju Das
Corporate Dropout, Freelance Translator

Related Articles

Trending now

Twitter first says Leh a part of China, then, they say technical glitch, gets it horribly wrong even after fixing it: Read how

Nitin A Gokhale found that the microblogging platform had not fixed the technical glitch, despite being well aware of the sensitivity around it.

Anti-Trump legal analyst of CNN and The New Yorker contributor suspended after masturbating on Zoom call

Jeffrey Toobin has offered an apology for masturbating on the Zoom video call and said that he thought he had put the video and audio on mute.

ABP News team attacked, stones pelted at crew in RJD held constituency of Arwal

RJD's Ravindra Singh is the sitting MLA from Arwal. ABP's Sumeet Awasthi had shared that a local IYC leader has been threatening to beat up anchor Akhilesh Anand.

Rajdeep Sardesai and India Today secure a gag order against social media user who had said they took 8 crores for Rhea interview

Issuing an order on India Today petition, the Delhi HC has ordered Twitter to suspend the man named Anurag Srivastava, and Google to remove the content from search results.

Jinnah’s ideology: Prof Brij Narain, a strong supporter of Pakistan’s creation, was hacked to death by an Islamist mob in Lahore in 1947

Prof Brij Narain, an enthusiastic exponent of Pakistan, was hacked to death in broad daylight by a Muslim mob even as he kept pleading them to stop ransacking his house in Lahore in the wake of partition .

Recently Popular

After Chinese phones blocking weather data for Arunachal and Ladakh, now Twitter shows Leh as part of China

Security analyst Nitin A Gokhale found that Twitter has labelled Leh in Ladakh as part of People's Republic of China (PRC)

In 2012 ‘out of town’ Salman Khan partied with Parambir Singh in Mumbai on day Bandra cops could not serve him Court summons for...

As reported by Mid-Day in 2012, Salman Khan and Parambir Singh were both found attending a Christmas party hosted by Sunny Dewan and his wife Anu Dewan in Mumbai. This when the Bandra cops claimed Khan was not in town.

During 26/11 Mumbai attack, Param Bir Singh refused to be on ground and take on terrorists, then Mumbai CP Hasan Gafoor had said

Hasan Gafoor, who was the Mumbai Commissioner of Police during the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks, had accused senior police officials, including Param Bir Singh of not taking on the terrorists.

TimesNow joined the Left in condemning Republic TV to hell, now, the Left is gunning for them too

The 'TRP scam' started off when Mumbai Police Commissioner Parambir Singh named Republic TV and hid the fact that the FIR which was filed, based on the Hansa Research Report, named India Today

Rajdeep Sardesai and India Today secure a gag order against social media user who had said they took 8 crores for Rhea interview

Issuing an order on India Today petition, the Delhi HC has ordered Twitter to suspend the man named Anurag Srivastava, and Google to remove the content from search results.

Republic TV’s Arnab Goswami to sue Param Bir Singh for Rs 200 crore after Maha Govt’s admission in Mumbai High court

Maha Govt and Mumbai police distances itself from the allegations meted out at Republic TV by PC Param Bir Singh
- Advertisement -

UK: Conservative party’s Israel body condemns BBC’s attempt to portray convicted Hamas terrorist as a victim, asks to apologise

CFI urges BBC to apologize to victims of 2001 Jerusalem bombing for showing Tamimi as a victim. The US has a 5 million USD bounty on Ahlam Tamimi.

Twitter first says Leh a part of China, then, they say technical glitch, gets it horribly wrong even after fixing it: Read how

Nitin A Gokhale found that the microblogging platform had not fixed the technical glitch, despite being well aware of the sensitivity around it.

Anti-Trump legal analyst of CNN and The New Yorker contributor suspended after masturbating on Zoom call

Jeffrey Toobin has offered an apology for masturbating on the Zoom video call and said that he thought he had put the video and audio on mute.

ABP News team attacked, stones pelted at crew in RJD held constituency of Arwal

RJD's Ravindra Singh is the sitting MLA from Arwal. ABP's Sumeet Awasthi had shared that a local IYC leader has been threatening to beat up anchor Akhilesh Anand.

Hyderabad: Hindu woman confronts boyfriend Syed Mustafa over marriage promises, stabbed to death by him and his brother

24-year-old Hindu woman was brutally stabbed to death by her lover Syed Mustafa and his brother on Saturday night at Rein Bazar neighbourhood of Hyderabad

Days after an Islamist brutally beheaded a teacher, France Govt prepares to expel 231 religious extremists from the country

France is planning to come down hard on religious extremists after an Islamic youth beheaded a teacher recently

Congress, media target Varun Gandhi for unwillingness to speak to a stranger late at night: Here is who the man was and why he...

The Congress party has decided to go after BJP MP Varun Gandhi after a leaked version of his conversation found its way to the media.

India formally invites Australia to join the 2020 Malabar trilateral naval exercise, Australia confirms full participation: Read details

It will be the first time all members of the regional grouping known as the Quad will participate in the Malabar naval exercise

Rajasthan: Two minor girls gang-raped, police shift victims to the hospital in an auto-rickshaw instead of ambulance

Two minors gang-raped by six in Rajasthan. Police conducting raids at various locations in search of accused.

Dance moves by Dr Arup in Silchar, Assam wins Internet, inspires Hrithik Roshan

The Assam doctor's dance video has gone viral on social media, gaining thousands of likes and comments.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
464,966FollowersFollow
18,700SubscribersSubscribe