Home News Reports Yogendra Yadav Sting - What does it say about the media?

Yogendra Yadav Sting – What does it say about the media?

Recently it was uncovered that an AAP worker, secretly recorded a conversation with Chandra Suta Dogra, a journalist and used it to malign/expose Yogendra Yadav. This news has been reported as either a bad intra-party squabble, or the breach of the journalist’s trust by an AAP worker by taping their conversation. While these are both valid points, this piece by SP Singh, a senior journalist, on the issue raises some very pertinent questions of the ethics in journalism.

First a backdrop of what happened. Yogendra Yadav, met a bunch of journalists at the house of a local AAP leader in Chandigarh on 15 August 2014 over breakfast. Dogra then claims that, Yadav spoke about politics in “the backdrop of the AAP’s performance in the Lok Sabha elections, and the party’s decision not to contest the (then forthcoming) Haryana assembly polls”. She continues saying She continued, “Since this was not a formal press conference, we were told not to attribute the information to Yadav in our writings, but we could use it in other ways.”

Dogra, who was then employed with The Hindu, then published this story, in which she quoted “sources” to make the following assertions:

The State executive committee also gave a unanimous opinion in favour of contesting. The Hindu has learnt that when the matter went to the 22-member National Executive Committee of the AAP, 15 of the 17 members who voted did so in favour of contesting. Mr. Kejriwal and five others who are close to him did not vote

- Ad - - article resumes -

On the very day this article got published, Dogra was called by a Bibhav Kumar (now serving as PS to Arvind Kejriwal). Bibhav told her that the information she had published was false, to which Dogra told him that this was told to her by Yogendra Yadav. This conversation was recorded by Bibhav and was recently spread to malign/expose Yogendra Yadav.

This of course is Dogra’s version. Senior journalist SP Singh, who wrote the earlier mentioned piece differs with her. Singh claims that he was present at the same meeting with Yogendra Yadav on 15th August. Using colourful language, Singh clearly states that whatever information Dogra claims was given by Yogendra Yadav, was in fact never given by him. He states “if Yadav did indeed give out the juicy tidbits mentioned in Ms Dogra’s story, that plate did not make it to the breakfast table where we were seated. Intriguingly, there was only one table.”

Once this recording leaked out, Yogendra Yadav made an online post re-iterating that he had never given such information to Dogra. He also refers to mail testimonies from two other journalists present in that breakfast meeting. who are on record saying that the sensitive information about Haryana disclosed in the article was never discussed at the breakfast meeting. Lastly, he questions Dogra saying “Why did she report on a breakfast conversation that was clearly understood to be not for reporting? Why did she reveal her sources to an interested party?”

To this, Dogra replied by saying “Considering that nine people were present at the breakfast meeting, there was no element of confidentiality. Since he was the chief spokesperson of AAP, one assumed that the party was aware of the breakfast meeting

This entire episode points out quite a few things:

1. Dogra had no qualms about giving up her source to an interested party, even though it meant endangering the source (Yogendra Yadav in this case). Non-Disclosure of “Sources” is considered to be the hallmark of standard reporting, but Dogra failed on this test

2. When questioned by Yadav as to why she did so, Dogra non-nonchalantly says “nine people were present at the breakfast meeting, there was no element of confidentiality”. This is hypocrisy. SP Singh rightly points out that if indeed there was no element of confidentiality, why didn’t she reveal Yadav’s name in the story itself? Why reveal it only when prodded by an AAP worker?

3. SP Singh who attended the meeting, and Yogendra Yadav, are in agreement on one issue: The information reported by Dogra was never discussed by Yogendra Yadav. The question then arises, did Dogra make up this information? Or does she have some other source who she is protecting?

In all this, some things are clear. Journalists have become less trustworthy than they used to be. A journalist can reveal sources, at the same time claim that a source isn’t confidential, and can even cook up some details if need be. To end, we tend to agree with what Saikat Datta, Editor on National Security at Hindustan Times, and Sachin Kalbag, Editor of Mid-Day had to say on this issue

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.

Big Story

While the date of the recording is not clear, it can be inferred from above conversation that it took place sometime in July.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

Army veteran Surendra Poonia receives threats from Pakistan, files online complaint with cyber crime portal

Major Poonia shared screenshots of the threats he has been receiving as well as screenshot of message which said how an unknown number had threatened to character assassinate him and malign him.

Barkha Dutt’s strange coincidences with a Kashmiri who wished death upon PM Modi and Amit Shah

Idrees ul Haq, with whom Barkha Dutt had a series of ‘coincidences’ is a known separatist sympathiser
Google search shows images of Pakistan PM Imran Khan on search of Bhikari

Old controversy resurfaces: Google throws up images of Pakistan PM Imran Khan when searched for “Bhikari”

This controversy is, however, not new. In December 2018, a resolution had been submitted in Punjab Assembly, Pakistan to summon Google CEO and question him as to why Imran Khan's images show up when one searches for the word 'Bhikari'.

Deplorable ‘journalists’ further Pakistan propaganda and undermine India: Why should their patriotism not be questioned

Indian 'journalists' and 'intellectuals' have taken up the mantle of peddling the Pakistan narrative on Kashmir it appears.
Shah Faesal was reportedly planning to approach ICJ over India’s decision to abrogate Article 370

IAS-turned-politician Shah Faesal was travelling to file case against India in the ICJ over Kashmir issue: Report

Shah Faesal was nabbed at the New Delhi International Airport on August 14 when he was trying to leave the country, reportedly, to Turkey

Purported email screenshots of Kavita Krishnan’s team show them discussing use of retired judges and ex-military officers for Kashmir propaganda

Purported screenshots of internal emails of urban naxals are being circulated on social media

Here is why Shobhaa De could be first in a long list to be exposed by Pakistan

India’s stand on abrogation of Article 370 and 35A and dilution of Jammu and Kashmir from a state to a Union Territory has dropped the baby of pretence.

After the abrogation of Article 370, Pakistan Minister expresses angst over Rahul Gandhi not winning 2019 elections

After abrogation of Article 370 by the Modi government, Congress and Pakistan seem to have found an ideological soulmate in each other
PM Modi's debut on Man vs Wild becomes most viewed show worldwide with 3.6 billion impressions, leaving Super Bowl behind

PM Modi’s debut on Man vs Wild becomes most trending show worldwide with 3.6 billion impressions, leaving Super Bowl behind

The appearance of PM Modi on Discovery’s ‘Man vs Wild’ show with survivalist and adventurer Bear Grylls has garnered 3.6 billion impressions and counting.
Shehla Rashid bats for Armed insurgency in Kashmir

Career-protester-turned-politician Shehla Rashid downplays terrorism in Kashmir, calls legitimate action by India ‘state terrorism’ instead

According to Shehla Rashid, India has been inflicting atrocities on Kashmiris since 1953
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post