Thursday, June 24, 2021
Home Variety Culture and History Right to worship: The good, the bad, and the ugly aspects of the ‘debate’

Right to worship: The good, the bad, and the ugly aspects of the ‘debate’

Of late, the media and the activists in India have found a new muse – right to worship. It refers to the right of women to enter some Hindu temples in India.

An overwhelming majority of Hindu temples don’t restrict entry of women, however the activists have focused on two Hindu temples – Sabarimala in Kerala and Shani Shingnapur in Maharashtra (the latter actually allows entry to women, but the inner sanctum is kept out of bound, as is the case of Haji Ali dargah in Mumbai, which no activists are planning to “storm”).

We will not get into the details or merits of both the cases in detail in this article; however this entire activism needs to be analyzed from different angles.

The Good:

The good thing is that the Hindu community is debating, even though there have been attempts to silence or caricature dissenting voices (read this article about a panelist’s experience when he went to NDTV for a debate) by the so-called liberals.

We can’t deny that women get a raw deal in most walks of life, but this shouldn’t prejudice one’s thinking about the respective temples, which have their own reasons for having some rules that appear discriminatory and misogynist. In fact, the Shani Shingnapur temple recently appointed a woman – a first in five centuries – to head the temple trust. They wouldn’t have done that if they were misogynists.

The outrage by many well meaning people (discounting the “adarsh liberals” types) appears more of an emotional outburst arising out of the belief – which is totally justified – that women are treated unfairly in our society.

And as it happens in most emotional debates, the finer points are being lost e.g. the Sabarimala temple doesn’t deny entry because it considers menstruating women “impure”, but because of local tradition that treats the deity as a “bachelor”.

The good thing would be that Hindus debate and possibly discard this belief that menstruation makes a woman impure. This belief is not unique to Hinduism e.g. verse no 2.222 of Quran also hints at impurity arising out of menstruation. However, Hinduism has a tradition of revisiting beliefs and modifying them in accordance with times. A debate on this won’t hurt. Shastrarth is good, and that’s how different schools of thoughts have come into being in the Hindu religion.

The Bad:

The bad aspect is the attempted hijacking of these movements and debates by the “adarsh liberals”. It is clear that they don’t want reform or debate, but confrontation. Today, a set of activists tried to “storm” the Shani Shingnapur temple. Local residents, which included women, tried to stop them, but the mainstream media clubbed these residents as “right wing” activists.

A situation is being created to send a message as if the Hindu temples or the Hindu society is the most regressive one, and reforms can happen only through aggressive confrontation. This if far from truth.

Remember how Pankaja Munde, the daughter of BJP leader late Gopinath Munde lit the funeral pyre of her father – a tradition that has always been followed by a male relative of the deceased in Hindu families. It was no less a reformist move. It didn’t need any confrontation. Yes, it was easy for Pankaja as she comes from a political family, but that sent a signal.

We are not trying to say that confrontation is never needed, but did these activists even try the non-confrontational approach before deciding to “storm” the temple? Is it really a “right to worship” they are fighting for? Did they try to understand the local customs?

The Ugly:

The legal and “logical” ramifications of this activism are almost absurd. R Jagannathan, Editorial Director of Swarajya magazine, has already written how the legal interventions in matters like Sabarimala is making them look like Don Quixote, who sought glory in fighting imaginary enemies like windmills.

On the logic side, it’s terrible. It almost insults logic. Most of these activists are coming up with two counter arguments:

  1. It’s discriminatory.
  2. Where do the scriptures say so?

The first – it’s discriminatory – often is a result of not understanding the issue and conflating the temple rules with other beliefs such as menstruating women being impure. Many temples in India have strange rules due to local customs e.g. only wines are offered as prasad in Bhairav Mandir of Ujjain – that doesn’t make wine an acceptable religious beverage among Hindus!

The second logic – where do the scriptures say so – is insidious. This is akin to treating Hinduism like Semitic religions that have holy books, which are the source of everything that is allowed or forbidden. That’s not how Hinduism works – it is an amalgamation of various traditions and beliefs in different parts of the country.

Funnily the same set of people attack the “right wing” saying some Hindus can even eat beef, and every Hindu is not required to follow the same set of beliefs, but now they want every temple to follow the same rules!

Summing it up, these issues should trigger a healthy debate in the Hindu community about generic gender bias present in the culture, but let not ill conceived arguments and “movements” deny the local communities the right of self-determination.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Rahul Roushanhttp://www.rahulroushan.com
A well known expert on nothing. Opinions totally personal. RTs, sometimes even my own tweets, not endorsement. #Sarcasm. As unbiased as any popular journalist.

Related Articles

Trending now

From cover up to conspiracy to murder: Some unanswered questions about Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee’s death in Kashmir

Dr Syama Prasad Mookerjee had died mysteriously days after he was arrested in Jammu and Kashmir for entering the state without permission

Former IFS officer Lakshmi M Puri sends legal notice to Congress supporter Saket Gokhale for misleading allegations against her

Alleged activist and Congress mouthpiece Saket Gokhale made baseless allegations against Lakshmi M Puri, wife of Hardeep Singh Puri

Ever Given: Ship that blocked Suez Canal has since been held by Canal authorities, they wanted 916 million dollars

After demanding 916 USD initially, the canal authorities had later lowered the demand amount to 550 million. A final settlement is expected to be reached soon.

Trinamool MP Mimi Chakraborty duped by fake IAS officer’s fake vaccination drive, one arrested

Mimi Chakraborty was reportedly duped by a man who claimed to be an IAS officer and requested the TMC MP to be chief guest at a COVID-19 vaccination drive organised by him.

Telangana: Woman working at Christian priest’s home dies in police custody, officer suspended

Mariyamma, who used to work as a domestic help at local priest Father Balaswamy's house in Govindapuram village, breathed her last on June 18 after cops allegedly assaulted her.

Kanpur: Hindu families put “for sale” signs outside their houses after being forced to convert to Islam, SP MLA accused of shielding the goons

10 Hindu families in Rail Patri colony in Kanpur live under constant fear as they have been threatened either to covert to Islam or leave the area.

Recently Popular

‘Is your father a mali or chowkidar? I will cancel your license, H*r*m*zade’: Maneka Gandhi threatens vets in viral audios

The Indian Veterinary Association in a letter have condemned the unruly behavior and unparliamentary language used by Maneka Gandhi against animal doctors.

After being slammed by Bombay HC for lack of evidence, Mumbai police names Arnab Goswami as an accused in second TRP chargesheet

Republic TV had submitted before Bombay HC that Mumbai Police have deliberately not named Arnab Goswami in charge sheet to keep the investigation open

Former IFS officer Lakshmi M Puri sends legal notice to Congress supporter Saket Gokhale for misleading allegations against her

Alleged activist and Congress mouthpiece Saket Gokhale made baseless allegations against Lakshmi M Puri, wife of Hardeep Singh Puri

Uttar Pradesh: One Dilshad caught breaking idols in Hindu temple in Kannauj, accomplice Umar says they were instructed to do so

Kannauj Police superintend Dr Arvind Kumar informed that a case will be filed under NSA against the main accused and others.

Kerala CPM expels Christian member who questioned conversion of his wife and son to Islam

He had alleged that Nazeera, a Panchayat member, and her husband Younus, an employee of Calicut University were the masterminds behind the alleged forced religious conversion.
- Advertisement -

 

Connect with us

255,564FansLike
555,569FollowersFollow
24,400SubscribersSubscribe