Maneka Gandhi’s idea of controlling trolling on internet is quixotic

It is too much of a coincidence. Mid May 2016, Co-Founder and Executive Co-Chairperson of the tainted NDTV, Prannoy Roy asked a question to Arun Jaitley, asking whether ‘disgusting toxic trolls’ could be controlled. Around the same time, NDTV journalist Sunetra Choudhury cooked up a quote claiming it was said by Maneka Gandhi:

The statement which was never made

It seems the statement which was never said then, has eventually been said by Maneka Gandhi. The Women and Child Development minister has come up with a plan which would put most hare-brained schemes to shame:

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

And if media sources are to be believed, this is also in the works:

Yes Maneka Gandhi wants to take it upon herself and her ministry to clean the internet of “trolls and abusers”. Now this is not a clear cut bad idea from the word go. But, it does exhibit a poor understanding of how things work online.

There is no denying that a section of people use social media to post abusive messages, issue threats, engage in defamation, indulge in targetted harassment, and even cyber-stalking of women. But the problem here is clubbing “trolls” with these offenders, by simple calling them “abusers”.

Trolling is a very vague term. A user saying “Lol loser” can be called a troll, so also a person who calls out bunkum of another user (often a “celebrity”) can also be a troll. A troll can also be someone who cracks jokes on some celebrity online, possibly by tagging that person. Yes, most of our stand-up comics can be called trolls and even the comics from older generation like Johnny Lever and Raju Srivastava would also fit in this definition of trolls, for spoofing so many celebrities (although their medium is different and there is no way of “tagging” the target).

Will this be considered as “trolling” by Maneka Gandhi and will the concerned accounts face any action? A troll tweet

“RealHistoryPic” is a popular troll account on Twitter. It has targetted many celebrities humorously in the past. In the above image, the target of “trolling” is a woman. Further, the Delhi CM and AAP Supremo Arvind Kejriwal has Re-tweeted the above tweet. So are the Troll Account and the Delhi CM indulging in trolling a woman? Is this “being mean“?

Is this the kind of “trolling” which will be targeted by Maneka Gandhi? In her tweet she makes it clear that she is only here to serve women being trolled, by virtue of being the WCD Minister. So if a female celebrity, puts up something wrong or some other reader objects to what is posted, and decides to voice his opinion freely, is he a troll? Is a Central Government ministry actually so jobless to go behind such people? Well, that is the fear that has been created online. Many are already likening this move to a back-door entry to the draconian Section 66A which as wielded by UPA. 

Even the “abusers” category can be argued upon. Ideally abusive language should not be used on a public forum, online or offline, but can it be covered under “freedom of expression”? Wasn’t it just a few weeks ago when we were arguing that abuses in Udta Punjab should not be censored? Or a year ago when the AIB roast was attacked for being, among other things, abusive? Is Maneka Gandhi going to tutor mature adults on how they should speak on social media? Is this the mandate of a WCD Minister? Or is this some cultural regimentation? 

And why is the WCD Minister trying to re-invent the wheel? Social media already has enough inbuilt tools to deal with “trolls” as described above, or the abusive lot. On Twitter for example, at first you can “Mute” an account, hiding all its activity from you. Next you can “Block” the account, denying that person access to your account. You can go one step ahead and even “Report” the user to Twitter for being “abusive or harmful”. These 3 steps are good enough to take care of the above cases.

Where Maneka Gandhi needs to focus instead is real crimes happening on social media. A threat to a person in real life counts as a crime. Logically this should extend to social media as well. But here the system fails. Social media platforms like Twitter and Facebook have no mechanisms to take action against people who threaten with a crime. Sure they could suspend the account, but they can do nothing to ensure a crime doesn’t take place. Obviously, they are not expected to do so and here the law enforcement agencies step in. Unfortunately, the local police station also may not be of much help. Cops are often misogynistic, and to add to this, technologically illiterate. Explaining and convincing them about a threat on social media to a woman could be a herculean task.

THIS is exactly where WCD Ministry should step in. Credible threats of violence, especially against women, need to be addressed as soon as possible. Any ministry is well within its rights to act against a crime or the possibility of occurrence of a crime. A very simple thing which the ministry can do is educate and empower the local police stations on this issue. Have a system to monitor these cases. As soon as a woman feels threatened online, she should be able to take up the matter with the WCD, which can judge whether the complaint is reasonable, and then get on to work to coordinate with police and trace the criminal. 

This of course needs real work to be done on the ground, unlike a cozy meeting with Twitter honchos in an AC cabin. 

Fortunately, Maneka Gandhi seems to have begun to realise the errors of her ideas. There has been some back-tracking and this has been made clear via some tweets from her account. She claims that the internet will not be “patrolled” but only complains received from women via emails will be taken up. The key words used are “abusive behaviour”, “harassment” and “hateful conduct”. But then she also claims that “all trolling” and usage of “abusive language” is wrong, ending with a sermon that we should not be mean on social media. One hopes this article criticising her is not considered “mean” and we aren’t booked for “trolling”


Share This Post and Support:
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Most read articles recently

Actor R Madhavan offers support to PM Modi to urge voters to cast votes in elections, gets trolled by ‘liberals’

Because of their sheer bitterness for Modi, these cynics are in no mood to spare anyone who comes out in support of Modi
Malala has maintained a conspicuous silence over atrocities on Hindu girls in her country

Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala’s silence on abduction and forceful conversion of two Hindu girls is deafening

Malala, who often preaches the world about feminist adventures and jumps in to display her intellect over human rights issues especially against women across the world seems to have not found her voice to condemn the bigotry of Pakistanis as she could face severe backlash within her own country.

NC Lok Sabha candidate Akbar Lone begins a rally with ‘Pakistan Zindabad’, says will abuse anyone who abuses Pakistan

Akbar Lone, NC Lok Sabha candidate for Baramulla, said that the country across is a Muslim country and abusing Pakistan would mean he is abusing himself
Tejaswi Surya attacked for Ayudha Puja

Congress IT cell attacks BJP’s Bangalore South candidate for performing Ayudha Puje as per Hindu rituals

Ayudha Puje is one of the widely celebrated festivals in India which falls during the Navratri
Owner of AAP propaganda blog agitated when Sushma Swaraj stands up for two underage Hindu girls

AAP propaganda site owner gets angry after India expresses concerns over atrocities against Hindus in Pakistan

Sushma Swaraj's move to seek details of the Incident had agitated quite a few people in Pakistan, including their Information and Broadcasting minister Ch Fawad Hussain, who saw it as an intervention in Pakistan's internal matters.

Where is the money? Rahul Gandhi’s promise is going to cost a whopping Rs 3.60 lakh crore a year, 13% of union budget

Minimum Income Guarantee Scheme of Congress party ensures monthly income of Rs 12,000 for 20% of India's population

Rahul Gandhi’s Minimum Income Guarantee could kill all other subsidies and be the mother of all scams

Remember, India’s worst-case scenario is also the Dynasty’s best case scenario.

Facebook arbitrarily suspends account of activist Anshul Saxena, fails to restore account despite no wrongdoing

The social media giant, Facebook, has allegedly resorted to arbitrarily suspending the account of social media user Anshul Saxena

After ‘Modi removed your name from voter list’, AAP allegedly calls up people pretending to be radio channel

'Who will you vote for?' People speculate if Aam Aadmi Party call centre is up to new trick again

Amethi: Resentment grows against the party and the Nehru-Gandhi family, locals say they do not want to empower Muslims in this region

They do not want to empower Muslims because if we become strong, we could also become MP: Locals in Amethi show resentment towards Congress

Latest articles

Connect with us

149,301FansLike
120,841FollowersFollow
31,565SubscribersSubscribe

Don't miss these


Share This Post and Support: