Tuesday, October 20, 2020
Home Opinions Anantkumar Hegde's comments on constitutional amendments - a media manufactured controversy

Anantkumar Hegde’s comments on constitutional amendments – a media manufactured controversy

The debate on the inclusion of the word ‘secular’ in the preamble has been raging in recent times due to the controversy surrounding the BJP MP Anantkumar Hegde. The minister said that “we (BJP) are here to change the constitution.” He did not say what exactly the change is going to be. The media and anti-BJP elements ganged up to twist his words on the topic of secularism and created huge brouhaha. To end the ruckus in the parliament, he tendered an apology in the house.

This episode raises an important logical question. Did the people and the governments which have amended the constitution in the past, have no allegiance to the constitution? Were they traitors? The first government to amend the constitution was led by Jawaharlal Nehru himself. Per the same logic, was he against the constitution? The 42nd amendment, which made sweeping changes to the constitution was passed under Indira Gandhi’s tenure. Was she then also a traitor?

In The Hindu, an article on this episode appeared on 2nd January, expressing deep concern over ‘threat to the secular character of the constitution’. The author, an advocate in the Madras High court wrote :

There was a point of time, perhaps, when we might have taken the idea of a secular, pluralistic India, tolerant of all sects and religions, as a position set in stone. But, incidents, especially since the early 1990s, have radically altered both reality and our imagination. That certain groups, including many within the political party presently in power at the Center and in many States, actively believe in a different kind of India is today intensely palpable.

Of course, some fundamental values of the constitution have to be preserved. Democracy, multi party democracy, federalism, secularism (in its true sense) and free speech must not be threatened by any government. But that doesn’t mean the favorite parts of the pseudo secular liberal elite class should never be touched. It doesn’t mean that a political party disliked by the same class, should be banned from amending the constitution as per what they think fit and in accordance with the mandate they have received.

There are many loopholes in the current constitution. Its vagueness on appointment of judges has given disproportionate power to judiciary. Lack of definition of the word ‘minority‘ has led to misuse of article 29 and article 30 of the constitution. Hindus who are in minority in 8 states are unable to get the benefits meant for minorities. Rampant conversion of gullible poor is also a matter of great concern.

Lokanath Mishra in his speech in the constituent assembly on (6 December 1948) argued against the freedom of propagation of religion and questioned the brand of secularism that was being written in the constitution. He said :

Sir, it has been repeated to our ears that ours is a secular State. I accepted this secularism in the sense that our State shall remain unconcerned with religion, and I thought that the secular State of partitioned India was the maximum of generosity of a Hindu dominated territory for its non-Hindu population [..]

Do we really believe that religion can be divorced from life, or is it our belief that in the midst of many religions we cannot decide which one to accept? If religion is beyond the ken of our State, let us clearly say so and delete all reference to rights relating to religion. If we find it necessary, let us be brave enough and say what it should be. [..]

But this unjust generosity of tabooing religion and yet making propagation of religion a fundamental right is some what uncanny and dangerous. Justice demands that the ancient faith and culture of the land should be given a fair deal, if not restored to its legitimate place after a thousand years of suppression.

As far as the freedom of future generations to amend the constitution is concerned, Jawaharalal Nehru himself has conceded that the constitution can be changed by the country from time to time in his address to the constituent assembly. Pt Jawaharlal Nehru in his constituent assembly speech on 8th November 1948 :

I should like this House when it considers the various controversies – there are bound to be controversies and there should be controversies because we are a living and vital nation, and it is right that people should think differently and it is also right that, thinking differently when they come to decisions, they should act unitedly in furtherance of those decisions.  […]

Vast number of minds and eyes look in this direction. We have to remember them. Hundreds of millions of our own people look to us and hundreds of millions of others also look to us; and remember this, that while we want this Constitution to be as solid and as permanent a structure as we can make it, nevertheless there is no permanence in Constitutions.  […]

It is right that House elected so – under this Constitution of course it will have the right to do any thing – should have an easy opportunity to make such changes as it wants to. But in any event, we should not make a Constitution such as some other great countries have, which are so rigid that they do not and cannot be adapted easily to changing conditions. Today especially, when the world is in turmoil and we are passing through a very swift period of transition, what we may do today may not be wholly applicable tomorrow. Therefore, while we make a Constitution which is sound and as basic as we can, it should also be flexible and for a period we should be in a position to change it with relative facility.

The basic structure and boundaries of power to amend of the Parliament is well defined by the Supreme court in various cases over the years. If any amendment is found to be against the spirit of the Constitution or principles of justice, the courts have the authority to strike them down as they did under the tyrannical rule of Indira Gandhi.

So what is this fuss all about? No constitution is perfect. And the document can be corrected and updated as per needs of the time and the mandate that the government of the has received. The Modi Government got a thumping majority for a reason. For the promises they made and in tune with the aspirations of a young nation. Why then is it to inconceivable that they should attempt to change the Constitution in accordance with those aspirations. For the Constitution is meant to reflect the will of the people, not the other way around.

[Transcripts of Constituent Assembly debates can be accessed on the Parliament website here]

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

Rajdeep Sardesai and India Today secure a gag order against social media user who had said they took 8 crores for Rhea interview

Issuing an order on India Today petition, the Delhi HC has ordered Twitter to suspend the man named Anurag Srivastava, and Google to remove the content from search results.

Jinnah’s ideology: Prof Brij Narain, a strong supporter of Pakistan’s creation, was hacked to death by an Islamist mob in Lahore in 1947

Prof Brij Narain, an enthusiastic exponent of Pakistan, was hacked to death in broad daylight by a Muslim mob even as he kept pleading them to stop ransacking his house in Lahore in the wake of partition .

India-China standoff: Indian army captures PLA soldier, probing espionage angle

The army stated that the PLA personnel will be handed over to the Chinese officials at Chushul-Moldo meeting point, following the completion of formalities.

If Congress comes back to power, it will be impossible to utter a word against them

This time, they will have a third and most potent weapon: technology and dominance in the digital space.

‘Uddhav Thackeray has formed a special team to bring down Republic TV, Arnab has to be locked up’: Explosive sting reveals MVA govt plot

"The strategy is to lock him (Arnab Goswami) behind bars. Nobody can save his channel from being banned," the Congress leader said.

Recently Popular

After Chinese phones blocking weather data for Arunachal and Ladakh, now Twitter shows Leh as part of China

Security analyst Nitin A Gokhale found that Twitter has labelled Leh in Ladakh as part of People's Republic of China (PRC)

In 2012 ‘out of town’ Salman Khan partied with Parambir Singh in Mumbai on day Bandra cops could not serve him Court summons for...

As reported by Mid-Day in 2012, Salman Khan and Parambir Singh were both found attending a Christmas party hosted by Sunny Dewan and his wife Anu Dewan in Mumbai. This when the Bandra cops claimed Khan was not in town.

During 26/11 Mumbai attack, Param Bir Singh refused to be on ground and take on terrorists, then Mumbai CP Hasan Gafoor had said

Hasan Gafoor, who was the Mumbai Commissioner of Police during the 26/11 Mumbai terror attacks, had accused senior police officials, including Param Bir Singh of not taking on the terrorists.

Pro-congress journalists and trolls target Amitabh Bachchan’s son-in-law Nikhil Nanda when another Nikhil Nanda criticised Rahul Gandhi

Nikhil Nanda, the MD of JHS Svendgaard Laboratories Limited, had exposed Rahul Gandhi for criticising India's handling of COVID-19 crisis

Shashi Tharoor wears Mani Shankar Aiyar’s hat, denigrates India and praises Pakistan at Lahore Literature Festival, claims Modi govt targeting Muslims

Shashi Tharoor denigrated India and praised Pakistan during a discussion at the Lahore Literature Festival.

Odisha lawyer Mehendi Reza gives rape threats to Kangana Ranaut on Navratri post, claims Facebook ID was ‘hacked’

Actress Kangana Ranaut receives rape threat on her post wishing people for Navratri.
- Advertisement -

Days after an Islamist brutally beheaded a teacher, France Govt prepares to expel 231 religious extremists from the country

France is planning to come down hard on religious extremists after an Islamic youth beheaded a teacher recently

Congress, media target Varun Gandhi for unwillingness to speak to a stranger late at night: Here is who the man was and why he...

The Congress party has decided to go after BJP MP Varun Gandhi after a leaked version of his conversation found its way to the media.

India formally invites Australia to join the 2020 Malabar trilateral naval exercise, Australia confirms full participation: Read details

It will be the first time all members of the regional grouping known as the Quad will participate in the Malabar naval exercise

Rajasthan: Two minor girls gang-raped, police shift victims to the hospital in an auto-rickshaw instead of ambulance

Two minors gang-raped by six in Rajasthan. Police conducting raids at various locations in search of accused.

Dance moves by Dr Arup in Silchar, Assam wins Internet, inspires Hrithik Roshan

The Assam doctor's dance video has gone viral on social media, gaining thousands of likes and comments.

Family of girl murdered in terror attack condemns BBC for providing platform to terrorist Ahlam Tamimi, painting her as a victim: Read details

Ahlam Tamimi was convicted and sentenced for 16 years her role in a pizza parlour bombing in Jerusalem in 2001 before her imprisonment was cut short in a prisoner-exchange deal with Hamas

Republic TV’s Arnab Goswami to sue Param Bir Singh for Rs 200 crore after Maha Govt’s admission in Mumbai High court

Maha Govt and Mumbai police distances itself from the allegations meted out at Republic TV by PC Param Bir Singh

Frustrated with “rants” of Shashi Tharoor, MP Nishikant Dubey requests Lok Sabha speaker to put him in a committee where there is no Tharoor

Congress leader Shashi Tharoor yesterday ranted against Republic TV and Times Now, issuing 'moral sermons' to the corporates who financed the aforementioned news channels

Rajdeep Sardesai and India Today secure a gag order against social media user who had said they took 8 crores for Rhea interview

Issuing an order on India Today petition, the Delhi HC has ordered Twitter to suspend the man named Anurag Srivastava, and Google to remove the content from search results.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
464,943FollowersFollow
18,700SubscribersSubscribe