Wednesday, January 27, 2021
Home Opinions It is time for Sushma Swaraj to end this fiasco, answer questions, or retire...

It is time for Sushma Swaraj to end this fiasco, answer questions, or retire hurt

“The trouble with most of us is that we would rather be ruined by praise than saved by criticism”

                                                            – Norman Vincent Peale

Public service, which our politicians should be in, is ideally based on moral foundations. Which would essentially mean, that the service rendered should be by an individual who believes in justice, has a strong sense of right and wrong, and also, an undying will to ensure that the will and needs of the people are met within reasonable, legal boundaries.

But, as it is rightly said, public service is also somewhat of a contact sport. You fall. You score. You have your moments of glory. You have your moments of shame. You do things right, and sometimes you do things wrong. You have the world cheer you when you deliver that spark of brilliance and pull you down when you fail to deliver. The glory, or the shame, being non-permanent. The public servant, swinging like a pendulum, between being hailed as a messiah, to being brought down as a predator.

Indian politicians, especially the ones from the BJP, are far too familiar with this phenomena. There is a section of elite citizens, including journalists, who seem to find nothing right with the BJP. There is a section of its support base that thinks BJP does no wrong. But a larger, far more substantial base, that tends to toss bouquets and brickbats in equal measure. It is this section that constitutes the real strength of any democracy.

Sushma Swaraj is one such minister who has more often been hailed as a messiah than a predator. She has more often got the bouquets rather than the brickbats. A veteran politician and public servant who has embodied the spirit of service. She has pulled thousands out of terrible situations after she assumed the office of Minister of External Affairs. Her motherly empathy and astute political sense had made her the model minister and a tweet-away-help-desk for Indians stranded abroad.

But just as any contact sport, the Minister was bound to make a mistake. She is human, after all. And a mistake was done.

The Sadia Anas (formerly Tanvi Seth) passport issue and the manner in which it was dealt with, was frankly, a debacle. Many questions were left unanswered when Sushma Swaraj decided to step in and unceremoniously, not only give the woman a passport but also hound the passport officer who asked seemingly valid questions.

We asked why Sadia and her husband go from Noida to Lucknow for a passport when they were required to file same in Ghaziabad. We asked if she and her husband mentioned their marital status in their passport application form. We asked when it was not required by law, why did they provide the nikahnama, especially when the nikahnama had a different name than her legal name. We said if an officer raises a question when there is a difference in names provided, the query does seem valid. We asked whether they got their passports on such short notice without police verification because of the tweet. We asked whether a police verification would be done. After the verification came up empty, we asked if the issued passport would stand cancelled. Questions of national importance. Of security. Of sanctity of the process of providing the one document that authenticates an Indian citizens existence in the system.

And boy, did we get an answer. No sooner had the questions been asked, the rules of address verification itself got changed. The rule that police needs to physically visit the place of residence mentioned to confirm the authenticity of the address provided was scrapped, presumably, by the MEA.

For citizens who demand better from the government they elected, the anger was justified. For supporters who fight for the government so brutally hounded by the left cabal, the disappointment was justified. Under normal circumstances, the sane thing to do would have been for the minister to issue a statement saying the matter will be looked into. That the faith people have in the system, and in the astute minister, won’t be shattered.

Instead, the minister, and I hate to say this, took a leaf out of typical “liberal” playbook, where abuse is highlighted to drown out genuine criticism. It was a tool employed by self-styled liberals and celebrity journalists at least since 2011, and it was painful to see a fiery strong woman adopting the same trick, a good 7 years later. She ‘liked’ a bunch of tweets and asked the people whether they agree with the abuses met out to her. She even ran a Twitter poll. From her official handle. The handle of the External Affairs Minister which is monitored by dignitaries of the world.

Would anyone in their right frame of mind and with a shred of decency condone abuses met out, not just to the minister, but anyone at all? No. On a platform like Twitter, is there any way to understand how many abuses came from real, living, breathing, authentic people and how many were simply troll accounts to create a flutter? No. Is it normal (but unacceptable) for public figures, even unimportant ones like myself to be abused on Twitter? Yes. Do people remember the abuse handed out to our children, the abuses for expressing our cultural opinions, the politicians who issued rape and death threats, the obscene comments, the harassment, the abuse to Smriti Irani, the innumerable abuses to Narendra Modi or Arun Jaitley? Yes.

Was it incumbent upon the minister to ignore the abuses and focus on the questions being asked, in all humility, just like her colleagues Narendra Modi and Arun Jaitley do? Yes.

For a public figure almost using Twitter to run a portion of her Ministry’s responsibility, the use of the platform to highlight abuse and not address genuine questions is rather baffling. Perhaps, it becomes difficult for some individuals to handle criticism when they get so used to praise. Perhaps it became an ego battle. Perhaps it was an instinctive response to harsh words. And god knows, I understand the instinct to lash out when unkind words are spoken. But does this behaviour behove a senior minister? I would humbly, say not.

From where I stand, and perhaps, from where most people stand (unless those people are intellectual vultures looking to score political points), the entire fiasco looks like a smoke screen to ensure tough questions need not be answered. A false flag operation, so public memory, short as it is, forgets the terrible manner in which the Sadia Anas case was handled, and how Vikas Mishra, a passport officer doing his job, was transferred, hounded, and branded a bigot.

Several op-eds were written. The intellectual vultures demonised the ‘right wing’. None from the motley band of buffoons asked the pertinent questions and Vikas Mishra became a distant memory. The abuse was summarily attributed to the BJP support base without any sort of verification and Sushma Swaraj became the new liberal icon for the perfumed elite.

Perhaps Sushma Swaraj fails to realise that she is being used by the people who oppose her, her ideology, and her party, to get back at not only the Prime Minister but also their support base that fights the intellectual vultures on a daily basis. When Sushma Swaraj was abused by the very elites who turn her into an icon today for her Quattrochi speech in the parliament, it was these supporters who fought for her. When the elites criticised her for turning her ministry into a passport-help-desk, it was these supporters who hailed her work. When she was abused for denying visas to Pakistanis, the supporters shielded her. When the journalists maligned her for her prudence in the cases where Indians were held hostage by ISIS, it was these very supporters who rationalised her action and reasoned that what she did was in the interest of national interest.

She was right then.

Perhaps Sushma Swaraj has become so accustomed to praise, that she fails to realise, that the very supporters who fought for her, have the right to question her when she errs, and err she did. Perhaps she forgets, that the vultures, whose wings she seems to ride today, are the ones who maligned her when she did something right, and are hailing her today when she has erred because it serves their agenda of breaking the spirit of her party and its supporters.

Perhaps Sushma Swaraj rather be ruined by praise, than saved by criticism.

Perhaps she doesn’t realise that when she takes to Twitter and in a stunning display of juvenility, declares that a citizen “doesn’t need to wait to get blocked” and follows that with a prompt block, she alienates one voter. Perhaps she doesn’t realise that she is as responsible to that citizen as she is to the ones handing her the victim card today to skirt essential questions being asked.

It is time she realises that this drama has gone on long enough. It is time for her to answer real questions because no public servant can shield themselves from criticism and that it is her duty as a public servant to justify her actions to her voters. It is time she stops compromising the sanctity of her office by getting into petty Twitter quarrels.

If public service is a contact sport, it is time she either dusts herself off, stands up and gets back in the game or retires hurt.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Nupur J Sharma
Editor, OpIndia.com since October 2017

 

Related Articles

Trending now

Post-mortem of protestor killed during tractor rally confirms he died of antemortem injuries, busts left-liberal propaganda of being shot

Left-liberals had tried to blame Delhi Police for the death, spreading the fake news that the protestor was shot dead by Police.

‘Tiranga ka apman, nehi sahega Hindustan’: Angry villages in Rewari issue ultimatum to ‘farmer’ protestors to vacate Highway blockade in 24 hours

The villagers said that due to blockade on the highway, the region remains jammed with vehicles, which have created difficulties for them

Farmer bodies withdraw their support from ‘farmer’ protest, blame Rakesh Tikait for violence on Republic Day

AIKSCC's VM Singh said he does not want to be part of protests led by Rakesh Tikait.

Red Fort attack: Dear ‘liberals’, here is how a little understanding of physics can help you

The underlying message of holding a parallel parade on Republic Day was always clear. They wanted to showcase a parallel power center on the streets, a republic of mob rule.

The mayhem on Republic Day was planned by these ‘farmer leaders’. Here is how they are lying

From Yogendra Yadav to Rakesh Tikait to Darshan Pal: How the 'farmer leaders' egged the 'farmers' to run a riot on Republic Day

Red Fort Insurrection: Deep Sidhu, his Khalistani links, role in violence and how ‘liberals’, who made him a hero, are now using him to...

Opposition leaders who had supported Deep Sidhu saying it is a farmer are now alleging he is linked to BJP

Recently Popular

Protesting mob enters Red Fort, unfurl the Sikh flag, Terrorist outfit SFJ had demanded Khalistani flag to be hoisted: Details

The protestors have hoisted the flag on Red Fort that appears to be the Sikh Flag. Some believe it is the Khalistan Flag.

‘Flag of Khalistan is waving on Red Fort,’ ‘Historic Moment’: All Pakistan Muslim League celebrates “Black Day” for India

The All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) is celebrating the hoisting of the 'Khalistan Flag' at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Here is how Congress and trolls tried to paint a Khalistani accused of spearheading the Red Fort siege as a ‘sanghi’

Deep Sidhu is accused of being responsible for the hoisting of the Sikh flag at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Rajdeep Sardesai lies twice, says ‘farmer’ was killed because the police shot him in the head: Here is the truth

In this way, those who had shared the fake news once would live under the false impression that it was indeed a case of police firing.

Watch: Protestors throw away Tricolour, place Sikh flag on top of flag pole at Red Fort

Disturbing visuals emerge from the tractor rally on Republic Day.

Tractor rally: Rioting mob vandalised Ram Mandir and Kedarnath tableaux from Republic Day parade

Rioting mob on Tuesday not only desecrated the Red Fort and tried to kill the Delhi Police personnel but also vandalised the tableau from the Republic Day parade.
- Advertisement -

 

US-based ‘Human Rights Lawyer’ Arjun Sethi gives a call to oust the Modi government, spreads falsehoods on farmer protests

A chronic PM Modi hater, Arjun Sethi has ceaselessly whined over the Citizenship Amendment Act since its passage in December 2019

‘Not taking the vaccine is a bigger laughing matter’, doctor responds after video of him scolded by wife during live broadcast goes viral

A video of Dr KK Agarwal getting berated by his wife for getting vaccinated alone is doing the rounds on the internet

Watch: Elderly man tries to cross protest site to see doctor, protesting ‘farmers’ issue him life threat

The elderly man said that he was trying to cross the protest site as he had an appointment with a doctor at Panth Hospital

Reflections on Republic Day insurrection: The government’s dilemma, a blast from the past and ghost of Operation Blue Star

Tractor Rally Protesters stormed the national capital and eventually managed to breach the premises of the Red Fort on Republic Day.

Robert Vadra posts distorted map of India on social media, shows PoK and Aksai Chin not part of India

Robert Vadra used a distorted map of India on Twitter and Instagram while demanding probe for Republic Day violence in Delhi

Post-mortem of protestor killed during tractor rally confirms he died of antemortem injuries, busts left-liberal propaganda of being shot

Left-liberals had tried to blame Delhi Police for the death, spreading the fake news that the protestor was shot dead by Police.

Farmer protests: Twitter suspends 550 accounts for inciting violence, abuse, and threats

Delhi Police had claimed that hundreds of Twitter accounts were created to sow confusion about the tractor rally proposed by the 'farmers'.

Congress leader Digvijaya Singh blames Delhi Police for Republic Day violence by ‘farmer’ protestors

While it was already known that barricades will be removed after Republic Day parade is over, Digvijay Singh blamed police barricades for riots

‘You cannot hurt religious sentiments’: SC rejects anticipatory bail pleas of ‘Tandav’ makers

"Freedom of speech was not absolute. You cannot hurt anyone's religious sentiments", Supreme Court of India said to makers of 'Tandav'.

Banned Khalistani outfit SFJ confesses to their hand in Red Fort attack, announces reward for laying siege on Indian Parliament on February 1

Khalistani terror organisation SFJ has announced a reward of $350,000 for those who wave Khalistani flags at the Parliament

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
23,000SubscribersSubscribe