In a shocking incident, a youth named Shoaib Pasha (23) was stabbed by his friend Nabi on Sunday night in Mavalli near Kalasipalyam, Bengaluru, as he refused to hug him citing bad breath.
Shoaib’s brother, Shahid (21) who rushed to rescue his brother after receiving a call from him was also stabbed by Nabi.
The two brothers, Shoaib and Shahid, residents of Wilson Garden, were treated at a private hospital and are reportedly out of danger.
The two friends, Shoaib Pasha and Nabi chanced upon each other on LBF Road in the Mavalli area. On encountering his friend, when Nabi tried to hug Shoaib, he was pushed away. Shoaib Shoved Nabi citing his bad breath, which angered the latter.
Nabi started abusing Shoaib which led to a fight between the two. As the confrontation escalated, Nabi took out at a knife and stabbed Shoaib in the stomach.
Before fleeing, Nabi also stabbed Shoaib’s brother Shahid, who rushed to the spot to rescue his brother after learning about the incident. According to reports, Bengaluru police had arrested Nabi, a resident of Siddapura and filed a case against him under Section 307 (attempt to murder) of the Indian Penal Code. Nabi was produced before a local court which remanded him in judicial custody.
This is not the first incident when such a trivial issue have invited drastic responses. Mangru Pahan (30), belonging to a tribal community from Jharkhand was stabbed to death, on the night of June 21, just because he had asked three men not to smoke ganja outside his house. According to reports, the three accused identified as Mohammad Sajid alias Chottu, Azam Ansari alias Babu and Ramzan Ansari alias Chutri had been arrested and had confessed before the police that the stabbing took place following an argument with Pahan.
In order to instigate communal tensions, some unknown miscreants distributed fake pamphlets in Shahpur Kalan village falling under Sadar Thana area, Ballabgarh, Faridabad, Haryana asking for a ban on temple entry for Dalits, as per reports.
These pamphlets were found lying on the streets of Shahpur Kalan village barring the Dalits from entering the temples.
It spoke of a meeting which was scheduled to be organised on July 7 in the premises of the Mohanram temple. The meeting, it read, would be convened to discuss barring Dalits from entering temples and the procedure to purify the temples which had been frequented by Dalits until now. It specified names of 14 people who would convene the Panchayat (meeting).
On Monday, after people found their names mentioned on the pamphlet, they approached the police of the Sadar Thana and filed a written complaint against unknown miscreants who, with an intent to spread communal discord, had distributed such fake pamphlets. The local people, however, have also mentioned that these pamphlets were spread by mischief mongers since there is no such caste-divide in the village. A local resident even mentioned how there is no restriction on Dalits to enter the temple.
Another local resident also mentioned how there are no caste issues in the village. He said everyone lives in harmony in the village. “We live peacefully in harmony and we do not face any discrimination from anyone,” said Lal Charan, a resident of the village.
Devdutt Sharma, a resident said that some mischief mongers indulged in this for local sarpanch elections. “We have always lived in harmony,” he said. He also accused other people of Brahmin community of planting such fake pamphlets for destroying the harmony.
The police, in turn, registered a case against unknown miscreants. The preliminary investigation by the police has established that such pamphlets were put up to create an atmosphere that could lead to discord between the communities.
As the cycle rickshaw took me through the bylanes of Chandni Chowk, I wondered if the reports of communal tension in Hauz Qazi after the Durga Mandir was desecrated, were being overhyped. The bylanes were bustling with activity. There were shops which were conducting their business as if nothing had happened and people were going about their lives just as they would on any other day. The only thing that perhaps gave an inkling that something had happened here a few days ago, was the presence of CRPF and Rapid Action Force personnel.
I asked my rickshaw-wala what had happened here. Tight-lipped at first, he only said that there some was a fight between Mohammedans and Hindus. I asked him what the fight was about. “I don’t know”, he said, “The rumours are many. From how Hindus killed a Muslim man to the other way around”.
The cycle rickshaw took us as far as the barricades would allow. Thereafter, we were on foot. My source told me that I would have to walk about a kilometre before I could find that narrow lane that is called ‘Gali Durga Mandir Wali’. I was dropped at the mouth of a place that was ironically called ‘Laal Kuan’. When I started walking towards “Gali Durga Mandir Wali’, the atmosphere changed. I could feel eyes piercing through my back. The lanes were full of groups of Muslim men standing around and talking in hushed tones, the tension was palpable.
What the Muslims said
The Muslims have a version of things that are in stark contrast to the Hindus of the area. The Muslims blame a “Hindu Halwai” for tensions flaring up. In their version, the Muslim mob did not desecrate the temple at all and the fight, which started from an argument over parking was aggravated because this Halwai, who was a part of that fight, wanted to fan tensions.
The Muslim of the area claims that the Hindus had desecrated the Durga Mandir themselves just to victimise the Muslims, who are in majority in the Chandni Chowk area. They also believe that there was no tension between the Hindus and Muslims at all. This incident was simply a concocted situation. They claimed that no stones were pelted but it was the Hindus who had simply displayed the stones in front of the Mandir to give the impression that stone pelting had indeed happened.
When one walks a little further, one reaches a second barricade, behind which, the Hindus of the area were seen protesting. Right outside the Durga Mandir Wali Gali, under a makeshift chaupal, the elders discussed their future course of action.
What the Hindus say
Inside the lane where the attack happened and the Durga Mandir was desecrated, the Hindu residents, who are confined mostly to that lane, rubbish what the Muslims are saying. They point to a CCTV camera and say that there is enough video evidence of the stone pelting and the attack on the temple itself.
One of them held up the charred remains of a burnt curtain and showed us the murtis of the Gods which lay in ruins. Along with the outrage of their place of worship being desecrated. came a stunning allegation. The residents alleged that the Police had tried to suppress the news of the Durga Mandir desecration by bringing in new idols to replace the ones broken.
Idols that the police allegedly got to replace broken ones
The residents also claimed that the Muslim mob had not only broken the idols of the Durga Mandir but also urinated in the Durga Mandir. They say that a mob of several hundred men had congregated at the mouth of the lane, and if they had not pulled the shutter down, the Hindus of the area would have surely been killed.
The stone pelting even happened from atop buildings that surrounded the lane and the residents allege that they not only pelted stones but were armed with swords for the attack. The residents say that the tension did not die down that night itself. In fact, even after that, the mob was circling the lane and was ready to attack several times, but it was the Hindus who also armed themselves with bats and whatever else they could find to ensure that they could warn the mob away.
The police, they say, wanted the Hindus to keep quiet and not react. A resident from the area tells me that this is not the first time that the lane, where Hindus live, have been attacked. A few months ago, she says, some Muslim men chased some boys in a bid to get violent. The residents claim that even when this happened, Muslim mob had allegedly pelted stones.
While several people claim that historically, the Hindus and Muslims of Chandni Chowk have co-existed peacefully, several others say that the incidents of animosity have increased. The reason, they say, is because earlier, Hindus were more in number in the area, and now, their numbers have dwindled. One resident also claims that their aim is to take control of the lone lane where Hindus reside.
The night of the attack
On the night of the attack, with the police station being only minutes away, the residents say that the PCR van took over an hour to get there. The apathy, according to the residents is such that even when some journalists got to the lane to report, they were told by other residents of Chandni Chowk that the lane is inhabited by drunkards and that no tension really escalated there.
The residents, for now, are not even being allowed to travel to Laal Kuan, which an area at a walking distance from the Hindu lane. The Muslims residents of the area had alleged that Hindus had taken out a bike rally in from of the nearby Masjid and chanted ‘Jai Shree Ram’ to provoke, the Hindus deny these allegations categorically. There are in fact several news reports that indicate that Whatsapp forwards alleging exactly the same was circulated to gather Muslim mobs.
The Hindus say that Arvind Kejriwal has not met them and only Dr Harshvardhan has (till the time this correspondent was on the field). They say that if this was Muslims who were being beaten, he would have met them.
A communal tinderbox and a 17-year-old missing Hindu boy
While I spoke to the residents of the lane, outside, in a sudden bout, slogans of ‘Allah Hu Akbar’ and ‘Jai Shree Ram’ could be heard. As we rushed out, two policemen had managed to pacify the situation temporarily.
The ‘argument’ was about a young 17-year-old Hindu boy who has been missing since the day tensions broke out. When I stepped out, the mother was sitting in one corner, with the copy of the FIR clutched in her fist. A vacant expression engulfed her even as a fight between the Hindus and Muslims was about to break out yet again.
When I approached her, I took a while to convince her that I will ensure that her story is told. “Humari baat koi nahi bata raha”, she said. Mona then told me that her young son, all of 17 was missing since the day the tension began. She says, the Muslim mob kidnapped him and dragged him away without a trace. It has been three days, and till the time this correspondent was on the ground, the boy had not been recovered.
FIR filed by Keshav’s parents
Mona’s FIR says that after the Muslim mob vandalised the Durga Mandir and beat up Hindus in the lane, they entered her house and started misbehaving with her son. He was, according to the FIR, resting when the Muslim mob entered the house and abducted her son. Keshav Saxena, the young boy, is nowhere to be found and the parents of the minor, Mona and Devendra are caught in a web of anger and distress.
As the chants of Allah Hu Akbar subsided and tempers were calmed down momentarily, the father of the minor who has been abducted couldn’t hold his angst in any longer.
“****, I will kill myself. My son is gone, I will die today and so will my wife”, he wailed. Someone from the crowd asked him, what would happen to his son if he and his wife die. Another resident, who was standing in front of Devendra said, “What can we do. If we are Hindu, this is what will happen to us”. The angst was so palpable, that it could be cut with a knife.
“Nobody will suppress us”, said another. “If you die, we will also die with and we will take these people with us”.
The mother suddenly got up and the vacant eyes turned into one breathing fire. “Someone tell me where my son is. He has not eaten or slept. I have filed an FIR too. Who should I go to or talk to? They desecrated the temple and kidnapped my son”.
The father chimes in again, “Give us 4 of those who entered our gali that night, and I will get the truth out of them”.
When the mother started talking to the two police officers who were present there, one of the policemen said, “Your son is alright”.
The mother, distressed, said “How do you know he is ok? Do you have him? Do you know where he is?” To that, the policeman said if they knew, they would have recovered the boy already. Nobody really understood why the policeman said he was ok, or what investigation has been conducted thus far.
The Hindus were not happy with the police. On the other hand, when the Muslims were approached earlier, they held placards hailing the Delhi police.
Hindus: A troubled minority
The moment the correspondent was spotted, the Muslim crowd help up placards saying that Muslims want peace and tranquillity. However, it was the same crowd that was later chanting Allah Hu Akbar in a face-off with the Hindus.
While talking to the Hindus of the areas, narrating their plight, they asserted repeatedly that in the area, most of the shops belonged to Muslims and just a few to Hindus. The Hindus assert repeatedly that the Muslims want the Hindus to leave the area and want to ensure that the tiny lane is also occupied by Muslims. The Muslims are now economically boycotting the Halwai who was involved in the parking lot fight.
Snapshot of a WhatsApp forward from a Muslim interviewee
The mute apathetic media
While the tension simmers, when this correspondent was there on the ground and the parents of the missing boy were wailing, a correspondent from a television channel was also on the ground. Interestingly, while the parents screamed about their child who has been abducted, the reporter from the channel simply walked off, proving the parents’ allegation that their plight has been largely ignored by the media.
The media often lives in their ivory towers reporting from their cosy air-conditioned studios. The class difference perhaps stops them from truly sensing the gravity of the situation or even bother about the tears of a mother wailing for her missing son. The father spoke in a tongue that would make several television anchors uncomfortable. It would take a massive climb-down from the ivory tower to cut through the angst and get to the truth of what he wanted to say, what he meant, what he felt.
Perhaps this is why the Hindus feel abandoned. Perhaps why they said that it is the “pedestrian” VHP and Bajrang Dal folks who came the next day to stand with them toe to toe. Perhaps this is why the ivory tower journalists feel comfortable just taking to Twitter and alleging that this brewing situation was nothing but a “minor scuffle”. A minor scuffle where the Hindus say this Halwai was beaten up and the womenfolk of his house were also misbehaved with.
Amit Shah, the Home Minister has now reportedly pulled up the Delhi police. After the meeting, just a few minutes ago, Delhi Police Commissioner Amulya Patnaik has said that the situation is normal in Hauz Qazi. He has reiterated that 4 people have been arrested. However, there seems to be not a word that is being said about the missing 17-year-old Keshav.
The experience has left me numb, angry, despondent, and I perhaps run out of adjectives. The very people reeling with the loss of their son, are today being maligned. The very mob that desecrated a temple is being hailed as people who wish to settle the ‘matter’ amicably. The 17-year-old boy’s disappearance has been shamelessly hushed up by the media. A section of the media has decided that Hindus can never be victims, and Muslims would always want to “settle things peacefully”. The truth often gets lost in hushed tears and screams that don’t reach the high towers of television studios.
UPDATE: The Hindu boy who had gone missing from Hauz Qazi has returned. He says that was assaulted by Muslim youths when they got to know he was a Hindu. Read details here.
On Tuesday, a 35-year-old man was arrested by the Delhi police for killing his two wives as he got tired of their frequent fights.
Reportedly, the accused identified as Jamshed Alam, hailing from Bihar, allegedly killed his wives Ismat Parveen (34) and Jabeena (45) by strangulating them. After committing the crime he had fled to his native village in Araria in Bihar with his 13-year-old son and was later arrested when he returned to Delhi on a tip-off.
During interrogation, he allegedly revealed that he had married Ismat about 20 years ago and had also been living with Jabeena for the last 10 years. The three had come to Delhi from the village about three years ago and he started working as a labourer.
Frustrated with the low income, Alam’s wives often had fights with each other. Alam had even sought a divorce from his wives last year, but they did not agree to it. Zabeena had also accused Alam of not being able to give her a child. Finally, fed up of these fights, Alam decided to kill his wives to live ‘peacefully’.
Initially, Alam had planned to use one of his wives to kill the other and then kill her too. He devised a plan with Zabeena to kill his first wife Parveen. On June 26, Alam and his wives had dinner together and soon a fight started. Alam strangled Parveen with a chunni and then caught Zabeena unawares and throttled her as well before fleeing the house.
According to the police officials, the PCR received a call on June 27 from neighbours about a bad smell emanating from the house. A team led by DCP (southeast) Chinmoy Biswal reached the spot and broke open the locked door. “The team found two bodies. A special team comprising ACP Gursewak Singh Dhillon and others was formed to investigate the case,” said Devesh Shrivastava, joint commissioner, southern range.
The abduction and rape of a minor girl on Monday have led to violent protests in the city of Jaipur. Angry residents have vandalised vehicles and pelted stones at the police. Around 160 vehicles have been torched. Rioters have been demanding swift action against the perpetrator. The incident has taken a communal angle and heavy forces have been deployed.
According to the police, the 7-year-old girl was picked up from near her home in Shastri Nagar area by an unidentified person on a motorcycle at around 7:30 pm. He claimed to be a friend of the girl’s father. He took her to an isolated place and raped her. She was then dropped back at her home, following which the girl narrated her ordeal to her parents. She was immediately rushed to the hospital and is currently undergoing treatment at the JK Lone hospital. The police were also informed.
The accused has been identified and the police have registered a case under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act. They are still trying to nab the accused who had fled from the spot after dropping the girl.
Reportedly, shortly after the girl was found, locals started protesting while demanding for justice. The protest took a violent turn on Tuesday after rumours of a communal angle spread. Vehicles in the vicinity of the hospital were vandalised. A mob had also gathered around the police station and pelted stones at the police.
Local police and special forces have been quickly deployed to avoid any further escalation. In order to stop the spreading of rumours, the government had to shut down internet services in 13 police districts.
The Police Commissioner Anand Shrivastav has said that the girl is safe and is being treated by experienced doctors. He had also said that strict action would be taken against anyone who spreads rumours about the incident.
Talking about the protesters he said, “Some people had gathered in the area to protest. When the police tried to disperse the crowd, they started pelting stones. Some vehicles were damaged and a few police officers were also injured. We have registered a case and arrested 16 people”.
Meanwhile, the Rajasthan government has given a compensation of Rs 5 lakh to the family of the minor girl on Tuesday. District collector Jagroop Singh Yadav said, “the compensation was sanctioned from the chief minister’s relief fund”.
In May the horrific gang rape of two Dalit women in Alwar had rocked the state of Rajasthan. In another incident, a few days ago a minor girl was gang-raped for nearly two years by her own four cousins as they were jealous of her for excelling in studies. A teacher also participated in the crime against the girl.
As the Durga Temple vandalism incident that took place in Delhi’s Chandi Chowk area on the night of June 30 enters its third day, the Delhi police have nabbed four persons so far associated with the case.
Delhi Police Commissioner Amulya Patnaik after meeting Home Minister Amit Shah over #ChandniChowk incident: I have briefed him about the situation here. Things are now normal in the Hauz Qazi area. 4 people have been arrested pic.twitter.com/pBD0uLIfj7
Two of the arrested youths have been identified as Mohammad Zubair and Mohammad Anus, while another one is a minor. While these three were arrested yesterday, a fourth person was arrested today but has not been identified yet.
One of the two arrested has a past criminal record and was earlier also arrested in snatching and Arms Act cases. The investigation into the case has revealed that the persons apprehended were protesting along with locals on Sunday. Police apprehended them from their homes on Tuesday.
A Delhi Police official confirmed the arrests but declined to divulge further details. Delhi Police Commissioner Amulya Patnaik met union Home Minister Amit Shah to brief him about the situation in Chandi Chowk after the incident. Patnaik was summoned by Shah today morning. According to reports, the Home Minister reprimanded the Police Commissioner over the incident of temple vandalism.
Sources: Delhi Police Commissioner Amulya Patnaik was summoned by Home Minister Amit Shah. He was reprimanded by HM Shah over #ChandniChowk incident. A clash had broken out between 2 groups over parking and a temple was vandalised on June 30, in Hauz Qazi area pic.twitter.com/pbZ1nbyqkT
On Tuesday evening, in the presence of Delhi police, people from the two communities (Hindu and Muslim) held discussions on ways to defuse the tension which persisted in the area over the incident of temple vandalism.
Aarti and puja once again commenced in the Durga Mata Mandir on Wednesday.
The Durga Mata Mandir in Lal Kuan in Chandni Chowk area in Delhi was vandalised on the night of June 30, 2019, by a mob of 300-400 people. According to videos posted on social media by locals, at around 12 am, the Durga Mandir was attacked, the idols present inside the shrine were desecrated by 300-400 people belonging to the Muslim community. Along with the temple, the houses belonging to Hindus in the neighbourhood were also targeted by the mob, the locals alleged.
According to police sources, this was triggered by a skirmish caused by an argument over parking. When the argument over parking in the area became intense, some people started pelting stones. Later in the night a mob entered the temple and vandalised it. The police have confirmed that Muslim youths in the area attacked the temple.
The next day in a video shared by Pradip Bhandari, CEO of Jan Ki Baat, one witness had stated that few intoxicated Muslim men had gathered under their house. As people around the temple stopped them, they brought in more than 300-400 men to attack. He further alleged that Imran Hussain (AAP MLA) came and supported the Muslim mob but no one came in their support.
While Congress leader and Delhi municipal councillor Yasmin Kidwai had chosen to overlook the crimes allegedly committed by a Muslim mob and attempted to whitewash the desecration of a temple in Hauz Kazi, Chandni Chowk in Old Delhi by stating that there was no attack on the temple, Union Minister and Chandni Chowk MP Dr Harshvardhan who visited the site yesterday condemned the incident and directed the Delhi police to take stringent actions against the miscreants who desecrated the Durga temple.
He had taken to Twitter to express his agony and anger over the incident and had assured that the miscreants would not be spared. After the Union Minister’s stern directions the Delhi police had assured, yesterday, that the perpetrators would be caught in the next few hours.
However, what is surprising is that, though the tension prevailing over the temple vandalisation moves into its third day, the Delhi Chief Minister, Arvind Kejriwal is yet to come out and make any statement. He has until now, maintained a stoic silence over the Chandni Chowk temple desecrating incident.
Sonia Gandhi’s fearmongering by opposing corporatisation of railways production units by terming it as privatisation on the floor of the House seems to be stemming from their own legacy of scams during the UPA era.
Remember Coalgate and 2G spectrum scam and the then Union Minister Kapil Sibal’s infamous ‘zero loss theory’ on 2G spectrum allocation? The coal allocation scam cost the exchequer an approximate amount of Rs 1.08 lakh crore, while the 2G ‘zero loss’ spectrum scam was pegged at Rs 1.76 lakh crore. On 24 September 2014, the Supreme Court of India decided to cancel 214 out of 218 coal blocks allocated since 1993. The Supreme Court in 2012 declared the allotment of the spectrum “unconstitutional and arbitrary”.
Sonia Gandhi’s fears that only ‘few industrialists’ will benefit for the corporatisation appears to be based on the above two scams considering it was her own government which pushed for disinvestment and privatisation.
To refresh her memory, former Union Finance Minister P. Chidambaram, who is currently being probed for his alleged involvement in bribery and money laundering during his 2004-05 budget speech had said, “Disinvestment and privatization are useful economic tools. We will selectively employ these tools, consistent with the declared policy. As a first step, I propose to establish a Board for Reconstruction of Public Sector Enterprises (BRPSE). The Board will advise the Government on the measures to be taken to restructure PSEs, including cases where disinvestment or closure or sale is justified.”
Sonia Gandhi’s concerns that the corporatisation will lead to loss of employment didn’t come in the way during the UPA tenure it seems.
Also, although it is true that the railway ministry has proposed corporatisation of some railway units, it is absolutely misleading to say that it is done with the objective of privatisation.
In the 100-day plan prepared by the ministry after the formation of the new government, a proposal to set up a new government-owned public sector unit named Indian Railway Rolling Stock Company Ltd (IRRSCL) has been included. The ministry aims to hive off its locomotive and rolling stock production units and their associated workshops into this new entity.
The aim of this is to bring in increased efficiency in production in the units. The IRRSCL is proposed to drive the technology partnership and modernisation initiatives of the seven production units under the Ministry of Railways. Each production unit under a CEO will operate as an individual profit centre.
The ministry is planning to only corporatize its production units in a separate entity, and it does not mean privatisation. Therefore, Sonia Gandhi was presenting distorted facts in Parliament by saying that the government is planning to privatise the production units. Even after corporatisation, the production facilities will remain a government entity named IRRSCL, and they will not be handed over to some industrialist like she is alleging.
Sri Lanka won a match when it meant nothing for them in the World Cup. Had they won the previous game and then won this it would have been an opportunity for them to reach the semis. West Indies, as usual, performed below par to their calibre.
After winning the toss, West Indies decided to bowl first. The Lankan batters looked positive from the start, and the openers batted for 15 overs without losing a wicket. The pair added 93 runs for the first wicket before Karunaratne edged to the keeper. In the space of 9 runs, Sri Lanka lost their second opener, Kusal Perera got run out for a well made 64 runs. Avishka Fernando, the third time in a row played a significant knock for his team, this time he scored his maiden ODI hundred. He made assure that Sri Lanka crossed the 300 runs mark for the first time in this World Cup. The lower order also provided full support to Fernando to reach a match-winning total of 338 in 50 overs.
Chasing 339, West Indies had a poor start as they lost two wickets for 22 runs. Gayle was not at his best, scored 35 runs but took 48 balls for it, very unusual innings for him. Nicholas Pooran, who scored his maiden ODI hundred, has got little help from the middle order until Allen smashed a quick fire 51 off just 32 balls. With 30 runs needed to win in 18 balls, Sri Lankan captain asked Angelo Matthews to bowl, who has not bowled a single ball in international cricket in past 7 months, produced the wicket off the very first ball. That ended the hope for West Indies. Malinga was again the pick of the bowlers for Lanka who took three wickets in the match.
STATS
Pooran and Fernando scored their maiden ODI Hundred.
Malinga, who took three wickets in the match, has now 54 wickets in World Cup and far behind only McGrath (71), Murali (68) and Akram (55).
Social media is not everything, but it is definitely something. And if reactions on social media are anything to go by, I do not remember a time in recent history when BJP supporters were so hurt as they are now. And why not?
The act of temple vandalism in Chandni Chowk has broken the hearts of BJP supporters. The images of the vandalized temple and the broken idols have gone viral on social media and in the hearts of the people.
But our ancestors did not live in a democracy. They did not have a voice but we do. And this is not what BJP supporters voted for.
Not surprisingly, the “liberal” crowd did not particularly care about what happened in Chandni Chowk. See how the HuffingtonPost tries to play down the incident itself as some kind of conspiracy theory.
Despicable headline by Huffington Post
And the PTI reported that the idols were “defaced slightly.”
PTI downplaying the temple desecration
What a way to use journalism as some kind of performance art to blur out the seriousness of the situation. Liberals, however, would never hold back from using the strongest possible slurs, including references to Nazism and Communist North Korea, when referring to any incident, real or imagined, when it suits their narrative.
Of course, these things hurt, but only so much. BJP supporters have long learned to take such reactions from liberals in their stride, dismissing them with bitter humour. The otherwise outspoken CM of Delhi is silent on this, but so what? There is no joke bigger than him anyway.
The real hurt among BJP supporters over this incident goes much deeper and for very different reasons. Because this is not what they voted for when they gave 303 MPs in the Lok Sabha, a solid majority two times in succession.
When BJP supporters voted in overwhelming numbers, it was not for a party but for a cause. A cause that they felt was bigger than themselves. What happened in 2019 was quite spectacular: Hindus coming together and sinking their caste differences to achieve a grand reconciliation that would pave the way for a grand Hindu revival. A rebirth of the Indian consciousness, a reclaiming of the soul of India.
This Hindu revivalism was much reviled in liberal outlets, both in India and abroad. The peaceful Hindu was hit with every slur possible: Nazi, Taliban, ISIS everything. The peaceful Hindu brushed off these insults and waited patiently to have their say when the EVMs would be opened.
And then to see a repeat of our worst civilizational memories play out before our eyes in the heart of Delhi…
BJP supporters are broken, disappointed and distressed. Their voices are hoarse. Their energy is spent. They are uncertain of what lies ahead.
All they need is for the powers that be to look them in the eye and tell them that they are still with the cause.
Nearly 261 priests of the Syro-Malabar Church gathered on Tuesday to express their resentment against the reinstatement of Cardinal George Alencherry as head of the Ernakulam-Angamaly Archdiocese, who is accused of involvement in dubious land deals.
According to the reports, priests of the Syro-Malabar Church organised a protest meet in Ernakulam on Tuesday against the removal of the two Auxiliary Bishops Sebastian Adayanthrath and Jose Puthenveettil. The two priests were asked to move out of the Archbishop’s House after George Alencherry assumed office following his reinstatement on Thursday.
The priests have also protested against the return of controversial George Alencherry who is accused of causing a loss of 90 crores to the Syro-Malabar church following a controversial land dealing involving criminal conspiracy, breach of trust and misappropriation of money executed by the Cardinal in 2016.
As accusations began to mount on Cardinal Alencherry, he was stripped of all administrative powers as the head of the Ernakulam archdiocese by the Vatican. However, he continued to remain the Cardinal and head of the Church but did not have any role in the governance of the Archdiocese of Ernakulam.
However, a new communique by the Archdiocese Media Commission has said that the administrative responsibility of the archdiocese will now be handled by Cardinal Alencherry, leading to severe protest within the Syro-Malabar church.
The communique also said that Bishop Jacob Manathodath, whose term as Apostolic Administrator has ended, will continue to head the Palakkad diocese. Earlier, he was appointed as Apostolic Administrator in June after Cardinal Alencherry was removed from the post.
Reportedly, the priests have now decided to protest against the order and said that they would not cooperate with Cardinal Alencherry and his office. “How can we cooperate with those who failed to discharge their duties honestly?” they asked.
The priests have also passed a resolution taking strong exception to the decision of the Vatican to reinstate Cardinal Alencherry as the head of the archdiocese. They also questioned why the Cardinal had taken charge by entering the Archbishop’s House in the night
Cardinal George Alencherry, the head of Syro-Malabar Catholic Church had found himself in big trouble after the Kerala High Court directed the police to file a criminal complaint against him and three others, namely, two priests Joshy Puthuva, Sebastian Vadakkumpadan and Saju Varghese Kunnel, a real estate broker involved in the land deals, alleging their involvement in a dubious land dealing.
This case pertains to the Cardinal allegedly favouring a middleman who sold Church land worth 27 crores for a price of 13 crores. In spite of selling below its market value, the Church had received only 9.3 crores.
