Former UPA Minister Veerappa Moily concedes to framing PM Modi, regrets how some leaders within the Congress stalled the witch hunt: Details

Some recent remarks by Senior Congress leader M Veerappa Moily have triggered a major political storm. In a stunning admission, senior Congress leader M Veerappa Moily said that Prime Minister Narendra Modi would have gone to jail when he was occupying the office of the Chief Minister of Gujarat, but some Congress leaders stalled the investigation against him. The revelation came during Moily’s address at the Bengaluru office of the Congress on the occasion of the release of Sonia Gandhi’s memoir.

Former Karnataka Chief Minister Moily was referring to the period when PM Modi was the Chief Minister of Gujarat and Union Home Minister Amit Shah was the Minister of State for Home Affairs. Without giving out any names, Moily regretfully said that some influential Congress politicians stopped the investigation against Modi. He added that Shah had already been jailed and PM Modi was next in line.

“The court had externed Shah from his home state, and the case was also transferred to another state. The first person to go to jail was Amit Shah. And after that, it was Narendra Modi’s turn. He too would have had to go to jail and be externed from the state,” Moily said.

Moily added that Shah would not have gone on to become as powerful as the Union Home Minister had the investigation against PM Modi continued. Notably, Shah was jailed at the time in the Sohrabuddin Encounter case but was later discharged after the CBI failed to find sufficient grounds to proceed against him.

Furthermore, expressing disappointment over the unnamed Congress politicians’ stalling of the investigation against PM Modi and termed it a “tragedy” for the Congress Party. Moily did not name the Congress leaders who stopped the investigation; however, he clarified that former Manmohan Singh, who was the Prime Minister at the time, was not among them. The senior Congress leader added that the Congress Party is suffering the consequences of the decision.

“This is all a tragedy of our party. Within our own party, the investigation against Modi was stopped. This happened during our own government — not because of Manmohan Singh, but because of other leaders. The result is that today we are suffering,” he said.

It is clear from Moily’s statement that the Congress Party influenced police investigation and legal procedure when it was in power. Moily’s admission that some Congress leaders stopped the investigation against PM Modi proves that the Congress misused its power and position to frame political opponents.

Following Moily’s admission, the BJP strongly hit back at the Congress Party. BJP National Spokesperson and Member of Parliament said that it is evident from Moily’s statement that the Congress Party framed PM Modi and Union Home Minister Amit Shah under false charges which were politically motivated. “It has become clear that the allegations levelled against Modi and Shah were manufactured by Congress and were politically motivated,” Trivedi said.

The statement made by Veerappa Moily relates to Narendra Modi’s tenure as the Gujarat CM, when the CBI was investigating some allegedly fake encounter cases in Gujarat, including the Ishrat Jahan Encounter Case (2004) and Sohrabuddin Encounter Case (2005). Modi-led Gujarat government faced allegations of ordering the allegedly fake encounters

On June 15, 2004, Ishrat Jahan and three men named Javed Sheikh, Amjad Ali Rana and Zeeshan Johar were killed in an encounter near Ahmedabad. The Gujarat Police said that the four were Lashkar-e-Taiba terrorists planning to assassinate Narendra Modi, who was then Gujarat Chief Minister.

Attempts were made to implicate Modi in the case on the allegations that the encounter was carried out on his directions. However, all the accused in the case were discharged by a special CBI court, which held that there was nothing on record to show that Ishrat Jahan and the others killed were not terrorists.

In the Sohrabuddin Encounter Case (2005), Amit Shah was not initially named as an accused. His name in the case was added much later in 2010. He was later discharged without trial after the CBI did not find sufficient grounds to proceed against him.

The details relating to the two encounter cases and Moily’s latest statements about Congress leaders’ intervention in the investigation leave little doubt about how the Congress Party misused power to influence criminal investigations.