Giacomo Filibeck, an Italian socialist leader, has triggered a controversy in India by raising the ‘Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhor’ slogan coined by the Congress leader Rahul Gandhi against the elected Modi government, at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad on 14th November. As is the tradition with global leftist-socialist coterie, when Indians questioned Giacomo Filibeck about what locus standi he had to meddle in India’s political affairs, the Italian leader and his party played the ‘personal attacks’ victim card.
PES backs Giacomo Filibeck and extends unflinching support for Rahul Gandhi and Congress
On 16th November, the Party of European Socialists (PES) issued a statement in defence of its Secretary General Giacomo Filibeck. The PES claimed that ever since Filibeck extended support to Rahul Gandhi and his ‘Vote Chori’ campaign, he has faced “a wave of personal attacks” on social media from “Bharatiya Janata Party trolls”.
Filibeck said, “The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) trolls who have targeted me since my speech in Hyderabad will not intimidate me into silence. I stand by what I said. I grew up knowing India as the world’s largest democracy. I have deep respect for the generations of Indians who have defended its democratic institutions. That is why it is so painful to see people turn up to vote and find their names missing. One person, one vote. That is the principle I defended in Hyderabad, and I will continue to stand with those fighting to ensure every eligible voter can cast their ballot.”
Communicating like an appointed PR manager of Rahul Gandhi, the PES statement endorsed the Congress leader’s farcical message about “love in politics and the courage to defend democracy.”

The PES statement also amplified the conspiratorial narrative woven by the Opposition and its media allies to cast aspersions on the integrity of the Election Commission of India, Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, and the transparency of the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise.
“In the eastern Indian state of Bihar, around 6.5 million names were omitted from the draft electoral roll. India’s Supreme Court directed the Election Commission to publish those names and the reasons for their exclusion. Reuters has reported that voters in Bihar and West Bengal who found their names missing were unable to cast their ballots. The Indian Express also reported that two election commissioners repeatedly raised concerns about decisions and procedures within the Commission,” the PES claimed.
“Rahul Gandhi and the Indian National Congress argue that the revision has been used to favour the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP),” it added.
PES amplifies Opposition’s propaganda to lend credence to the ‘Vote Chori’ bogey
The Italian socialist political party, PES, highlighted the SIR in Bihar and West Bengal, and the dubious Indian Express report, to cast aspersions on the transparency of electoral processes in India.
However, beyond the alarmist rhetoric, there is nothing conspiratorial about the SIR outcomes and the IE report about two Election Commissioners expressing dissent internally.
In September 2025, the Election Commission of India released the final voter list for the upcoming Bihar Assembly elections, marking the completion of a Special Intensive Revision (SIR) conducted after more than two decades.
Bihar had 7.89 crore voters before the exercise, but the August draft showed a dip to 7.24 crore after 65 lakh deletions. In Patna alone, the final roll now counts 48.15 lakh voters, up by 1.63 lakh from the draft. Between August 1 and September 1, over 16.5 lakh people applied for fresh registration, while applications from September are still being processed. Voters can continue to apply until 10 days before nominations close, with names added via a supplementary list.
Soon after, the Muslim-appeasing political parties, including Rahul Gandhi’s Congress, alleged that the SIR essentially disenfranchised Muslims and other groups historically opposed to the BJP.
The Supreme Court indeed directed the ECI to publish those names and the reasons for their exclusion; however, this direction was about procedural transparency and not a finding of illegality or bias. The top court has upheld the ECI’s authority to conduct such revisions of electoral rolls.
The Italian political party ignores the scale of India’s population and the documented menace of inflated rolls when it portrays the 6.5 million omission figure as self-evidently sinister.
Independent analyses, even by entities known to be anti-BJP and anti-Modi government, say that there was no evidence of deliberate mass disenfranchisement of Muslims or any specific religious group.
The ECI has also maintained that the electoral rolls do not capture the religion of any elector.
In West Bengal, in the 20 Assembly seats that recorded the highest voter deletions, TMC won 13, BJP won 6, and one seat was won by Congress. If the SIR or voter deletions were systematically designed to damage the TMC and benefit the BJP, then how did TMC dominate the highest-deletion constituencies? Clearly, data debunks ‘ECI did partisan engineering’ claims.
The PES, much like Rahul Gandhi and the Congress party, has failed to furnish any evidence that confirms that the SIR was used as a weapon by the ECI at the BJP’s behest to manipulate electoral rolls in the BJP’s favour.
Interestingly, this is the second major incident wherein a foreign politician has cast doubts about the SIR process in India. In October this year, several US politicians amplified the Opposition’s claim that the ECI has disenfranchised 130 million Indian voters.
Contrary to the insinuation that somehow 130 million or 13 crore voter names have been arbitrarily struck down from voter rolls, in a politically motivated mass disenfranchisement manoeuvre by the Election Commission of India, these are exclusions from the draft electoral rolls, not permanent final deletions.
The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls across the country in recent months was conducted after a monumental gap of nearly 24 years. The SIR was not an illegal mass disenfranchisement action but a constitutionally aligned house-to-house enumeration exercise to update and clean electoral rolls.
The latest SIR was conducted across 30 states and Union Territories, scrutinising about 95.4 crore voters. Nearly 13.39 crore voter names were left out of the draft electoral rolls. These voter names were not singled out based on their religion, caste, gender or political leanings. These voter name deletions fall mainly under the ASDD, which means Absent, Shifted, Dead, and Duplicate voters.
Of the 13 crore names removed from the draft electoral rolls, 6.30 crore were Permanently Shifted, 3 crores Absent or not traceable, 2.80 crore Dead, 1.02 crore Duplicate and 0.26 crore under other categories.
As per the stated rules, there is a claims-and-objections window after the draft is published. After processing claims, objections, and any related appeals, the final rolls are published; only then are the voters’ name exclusions for that revision finalised.
Though there was an attempt by the Opposition to allege malice over the Supreme Court’s remark that it has not approved any fresh changes to Form 6, the apex court recently clarified that it has not disapproved of it either.
Pertinently, the ECI has maintained that Form 6 has not been altered or replaced. It pointed out that a new declaration mapping the parents of a prospective voter in the previous SIR was introduced as a separate eligibility verification requirement, and it wasn’t a modification of Form 6.
Earlier, the ECI had pointed out that the decision to introduce this new declaration was taken unanimously by the Chief Election Commissioner and both Election Commissioners Vivek Joshi and Sukhbir Singh Sandhu. It has maintained that prescribing additional information for eligibility verification falls within its residual powers.
This interpretation was backed by the Supreme Court’s order dated 27th May 2026 in the Bihar SIR. The top court had recognised the ECI’s authority to prescribe documentation for verifying voter eligibility.
The PES cited The Indian Express report to suggest that there were internal disagreements between the three election commissioners, which somehow automatically indicates wrongdoing.
It must be recalled that in late September 2026, The Indian Express published a dubious ‘investigative’ report casting aspersions on the integrity of Chief Election Commissioner (CEC) Gyanesh Kumar. This series of ‘investigative reports’, however, was, in reality, a well-timed hit job against CEC Gyanesh Kumar.
The Indian Express claimed that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had recorded objections at least 14 times over 10 months on issues concerning the Special Intensive Revision, Form 6, electoral-roll software, voter additions and deletions and other administrative decisions. The newspaper presented these findings as proof of an unprecedented rupture within the Election Commission.
Highlighting the internal objections, the IE report wove an alarmist narrative that powers were being centralised in Delhi, that statutory Electoral Registration Officers were being bypassed, that software was overriding field-level decisions and that the Election Commission was facing an unprecedented institutional breakdown.
The Election Commission issued an elaborate clarification stating that internal objections do not mean an institutional coup.
In fact, the internal discussions and dissenting note exchanges by the CEC and the other two Election Commissioners, Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi, indicate that the Commission’s top officials freely and strongly express their opinions and disagreements about various issues pertaining to the electoral process and take decisions after thorough consensus, contrary to the framing that CEC Gyanesh Kumar alone holds the reins of the Election Commission.
The Indian Express was widely used by the CJP leaders and INDI bloc politicians as some sort of ‘proof of “hijacking of India’s democracy” just because they lost elections in some states and the public rejected them for the third time in Lok Sabha elections.
OpIndia reported earlier that neither the claims by The Indian Express report around the Form 6 modifications issue nor the claims about alleged “centralisation” of electoral roll databases are backed by enough evidence to support the ‘Delhi has taken over the voter database’ accusations.
Neither the SIR outcomes nor the exchange of dissenting notes by the Election Commissioners internally prove that any of the ECI’s decisions under Gyanesh Kumar, though taken unanimously post internal opposition, benefitted the BJP in any manner.
There is no evidence that the ECI or CEC Gyanesh Kumar was acting in a dictatorial fashion to manipulate electoral rolls, and by extension electoral outcomes in favour of the BJP.
The Election Commission is a constitutional body under Article 324, and its key functions are superintendence, direction, and control of elections, including preparation and revision of electoral rolls.
SIR is not a new and unique instrument that CEC Gyanesh Kumar has introduced to manipulate electoral rolls in favour of a political party. SIR is a long-overdue intensive voter roll cleanup. The last major SIR drive was conducted more than 20 years ago. Not weeding out dead, shifted, duplicate, and other ineligible voter names from electoral rolls would essentially have meant that the ECI was not serious about transparency in the electoral process.
Merely because opposition parties and leaders lost elections in some states after SIR does not mean that Gyanesh Kumar personally oversaw the manipulation of electoral rolls to ensure a BJP victory.
However, foreign parties and their leaders endorsing the Opposition’s electoral narrative is itself evidence of the fact that Rahul Gandhi, who has a track record of seeking foreign interference in India’s internal affairs, is now soliciting endorsement from ideologically aligned foreign leaders.
This is a selective internationalisation of domestic issues and a portrayal of India’s institutions as captured and helpless tools in the hands of the ruling dispensation.
Rahul Gandhi essentially reframed a domestic administrative and constitutional process as somehow an international human rights or democracy crisis, inviting foreign parties and leaders to take sides in India’s electoral machinery.
If democracy was actually strangled by the Modi government, as Rahul Gandhi suggested while speaking about the denial of visa permits to some of the foreign attendees, even his newly imported Italian cheerleader, Giacomo Filibeck, would not have made it to India.
It is, however, amusing that the same ECI, SIR, and CEC become clean when Congress wins Kerala, Himachal Pradesh, Telangana, and the anti-BJP TVK wins Tamil Nadu elections. Basically, ‘Vote Chori’ happens only where the Opposition parties lose.
If the ECI was actually manipulating electoral rolls in the BJP’s favour, why did it not ensure at least ten seats for the BJP in Tamil Nadu, if not securing a number significant enough to make the BJP a kingmaker?
Not to forget, many Congress leaders themselves have praised the SIR exercise.
In October 2026, Karnataka Public Works Minister Satish Jarkiholi publicly endorsed the SIR exercise that was conducted in Karnataka. The minister said that the exercise was done right in the state. Jarkiholi defended the electoral revision in Karnataka even as his party has been calling for the cancellation of the SIR exercise undertaken by the Election Commission across various states.
Senior Kerala Congress leader Ramesh Chennithala has also praised the SIR, saying that it helped remove fake voters from the electoral rolls.
#WATCH | Thiruvananthapuram | Congress leader Ramesh Chennithala says, "We had given a positive agenda to the people of Keralam. The five guarantees announced to the people of Keralam by Rahul Gandhi also helped us. SIR was helpful in Kerala because earlier, CPM used to provide bogus votes."
— ANI (@ANI) May 4, 2026
Keralam Congress leaders Mathew Kuzhalnadan and Shashi Tharoor boasted that the SIR exercise helped the UDF win the Assembly elections, as thousands of bogus voters were removed from the electoral rolls.
“Of course, the SIR process also removed a lot of fake voters, which, in some constituencies at least, were managed by the CPI(M). So that also helped us,” Kuzhalnadan said as his party won 99 of the 140 seats in Keralam.
“…in Kerala, I suspect the Congress benefited from the deletions because the CPIM was long a past master of double, triple, quadruple enrollment… That used to happen. So they were eliminated by the SIR…” Tharoor said in May this year.
What did Giacomo Filibeck say at the Bharat Summit in Hyderabad, and who is he?
On Saturday, 14th November, Giacomo Filibeck, the Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists, sparked a major political row by raising the Congress party’s slogan, “Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod” (Vote Thief, Leave Your Seat), while addressing the Bharat Summit 2026 in Hyderabad. The program is organised by the Congress government of Telangana.
Speaking before a gathering of international delegates, Filibeck’s decision to chant a domestic Indian political attack line immediately raised eyebrows about foreign interference in India’s internal affairs. Echoing the Congress’ lies, Giacomo Filibeck further claimed, “The Congress Party built the democratic foundation of modern India. Today, it is fighting to protect them. And progressives everywhere stand with you.”
When Giacomo Filibeck recited Congress’s ‘Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhor’ slogan, Rahul Gandhi was seen laughing and applauding. Gandhi’s gesture triggered a fierce backlash from the BJP, which said the Congress was giving a foreign political representative a platform to intervene in India’s internal affairs.
After praising Gandhi’s campaign for “one person, one vote,” he delivered the line the hall had been waiting for: “Vote Chor Gaddi Chhod.” He translated it himself: “Vote thief, leave your seat.”
He went further. “Democracy is under attack in India, and we need to defend it. And the best way to defend it is to stand by Rahul Gandhi and the Indian Congress Party.”
Filibeck’s gimmick, however, was sharply criticised by Italian legislator Deborah Bergamini, a senior Forza Italia leader and ally of Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni. She said it is “inappropriate to lecture on democracy a nation that enables 970 million citizens to vote”.

Born in 1978, Giacomo Filibeck is a European socialist political leader, currently serving as the Executive Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists (PES) since October 2022.
Filibeck was the Deputy Secretary General of the PES, in charge of international policy. At the 2019 European elections, Filibeck was joint Campaign Manager for PES common candidate Frans Timmermans.
Filibeck was President of the European Youth Forum and President of the Young European Socialists (YES) from 2002 to 2009. He joined the international department of Partito Democratico in Italy in 2010, where he oversaw policy relating to the Middle East, the Mediterranean and Africa.
“In 2013, Filibeck became the chair of Partito Democratico’s foreign policy forum. Between 2014 and 2015, he served as director of the international relations office of the Italian Ministry of Agriculture. Giacomo Filibeck is currently the Secretary General of the Party of European Socialists. He holds a bachelor’s degree in Political Science, and a Master’s degree from INSEAD,” PES’s website states.

Interestingly, in April 2018, Giacomo Filibeck was detained by the border police after he arrived at Mactan-Cebu International Airport and was deported the same day. He was there to attend the party congress of Akbayan, PES’s sister party in the Philippines and a fellow member of the Progressive Alliance.
Subsequently, Filibeck was given a notice informing him of a blacklisting order from the authorities in the Philippines. The authorities cited illegal political activities as the reason for the action against the Italian socialist leader.
Then Justice Secretary Menardo Guevarra said that foreign nationals were not allowed to partake in partisan political activities in the country.
Bharat Summit and its anti-Bharat agenda
Organised in Hyderabad on 14th November, with over 1,000 delegates from 70 countries, the Bharat Summit is officially pitched as an intellectual forum to discuss a “new global order,” “electoral integrity,” “cooperative federalism,” and the fight against the “politics of hatred, division and authoritarianism.”
However, the Bharat Summit is closely tied to the Progressive Alliance (PA), a global network of Left and socialist parties founded in Leipzig, Germany, in 2013 after breaking away from the Socialist International.
The Progressive Alliance’s stated mission is to share campaign strategies, coordinate international action, and organise against alleged “right-wing populism” and “dangerous authoritarianism.” By embedding itself in an international coalition built to counter nationalist governments, the Congress appears to be using a global stage to recast India’s elected government as a global “threat” that foreign parties must unite against.
The event was attended by notorious Islamo-leftists masquerading as progressive intellectuals. These included Salil Shetty, Kancha Ilaiah Shepherd, Professor Sujatha Surepally, Sir Iqbal Sacranie, Anies Baswedan, DU professor Apoorvanand, Guillaume Long, Patrick Gaspard, Giacomo Filibeck, Jayati Ghosh, and Nurul Izzah Anwar.
OpIndia has earlier reported that the Progressive Alliance follows regime-change enthusiast George Soros’ ideology, who has openly expressed his dislike of PM Modi. Furthermore, the Indian members of this global ecosystem, such as Neha Bora and Prashant Bhushan, have already stated that the recent opposition protests are aimed at bringing down the democratically elected Modi government, echoing the violent examples witnessed in Bangladesh and Nepal.
Telangana BJP files complaint with FRRO against Giacomo Filibeck
Amid the outrage over a foreign politician meddling in India’s internal political affairs at the invitation of the Leader of Opposition in the Parliament (LoP) Rahul Gandhi, the Telangana BJP president N Ramchander Rao has demanded criminal proceedings against Filibeck and the Congress government for inviting a foreign national to “make remarks against India and interfere in its internal political affairs”.
The Telangana BJP has submitted a formal complaint to the Foreigners Regional Registration Office (FRRO) in Shamshabad. The BJP delegation also met the DGP to lodge a formal complaint. The complaint seeks a probe into Giacomo Filibeck’s statements and possible violations of immigration laws and visa conditions by foreign participants at the Bharat Summit.
‘భారత్ సమ్మిట్’ ముసుగులో ‘యాంటీ భారత్ సమ్మిట్’.. విదేశీ నేత జియాకోమో ఫిలిబెక్తో పాటు రాహుల్ గాంధీ, నిర్వాహక సంస్థలపై క్రిమినల్ కేసులు పెట్టాలి https://t.co/eKUvE5g3la
— N Ramchander Rao (@N_RamchanderRao) November 16, 2026
“An ‘anti-India summit’ masquerading as an ‘India summit’.. Criminal cases should be filed against Rahul Gandhi and the organizing bodies, along with foreign leader Giacomo Filibeck,” the BJP leader said.


