Monday, September 21, 2020
Home Opinions Indian Judiciary: The Most Undemocratic Institution in India

Indian Judiciary: The Most Undemocratic Institution in India

No major democracy in the world gives so much power to the judges of their country like we do in India. Our judges appoint themselves, regulate their activities and also wield the power to punish those who question them.

Removal of the judges requires a cumbersome impeachment process that involves an investigation followed by 2/3rd majority of votes in both house. As a result not even a single judge of Supreme Court or High Court has been impeached in India.

The accountability of higher judiciary to the people is the least among three major pillars of Indian state. The Supreme Court has every feature of an oligarchy deeply embedded in it.

India’s Judicial Appointment Process 

- Advertisement -

In India , a collegium consisting of chief justice of India and four senior-most judges of Supreme Court screens, scrutinizes and recommends the candidates for appointment to the Supreme Court. The government cannot suggest any names to the collegium. In case of High Courts, screening of candidates for appointment to high courts is done by a collegium of chief justices of respective high courts and four senior most judges on the HC bench. The Supreme court collegium scrutinizes and recommends candidates for appointment to the respective high Court. The same institutions regulate transfer of judges as well.

In addition to this, the deliberations of this collegium are mostly opaque and not fully disclosed to the public. There is high scope for nepotism and elite self-recruitment to top courts in this collegium system. The reason cited for this system is to ensure independence of judges (which is a farce).

Judicial Appointment Process in major democracies like USA and UK

USA and UK are two leading democracies where judicial appointments are far more transparent than India. In USA, the Senate is directly involved in appointing judges. The Senate Judiciary Committee conducts public hearings of potential candidates before confirmation of the candidates.

United Kingdom, (the parliamentary democratic system closest to that of India) appoints Supreme Court judges according to a law passed by the Parliament (Constitutional Reform Act 2005). The judges are appointed through a five member selection commission of which only two members are judges. The other three are members of the Judicial Appointments Commission for England and Wales, the Judicial Appointments Board in Scotland, and the Judicial Appointments Commission in Northern Ireland, members of which are recruited by a transparent process.

Unfortunately, the Indian system of appointing judges has none of these safeguards or scrutiny from people or elected representatives. The government has to simply nod its head for every suggestion sent by Supreme court collegium or send back the recommendations with some reasons. The Indian system of judicial appointments is highly undemocratic.

The Letter Submitted By Mutinying Judges To The Press

It turns out, that the issue raised by Chelameshwar & Co in their letter had something to do with the procedure to appoint Judges to the High Courts and Supreme Court of India. The letter cites a judgement in the R.P Luthra vs Union of India case which says that the Memorandum of Procedure(MOP) for appointment of judges must not be delayed anymore.

MOP is a backdoor document that seeks to end the conflict between legislature and judiciary on the issue of judicial appointments. The previous attempt through NJAC (National Judicial Appointments Commission) , a transparent mechanism was struck down by Supreme Court. From the bench which struck it down, Justice Chelameswar was the lone dissenter, who backed the NJAC. The letter sent to the CJI says :

On 4 July, 2017, a Bench of seven Judges of this Court decided In Re. Hon’ble Shri Justice C.S. Karnan [(2017) 1 SCC 1]. In that decision (referred to in R.P.Luthra), two of us observed that there is a need to revisit the process of appointment of judges and to set up a mechanism for corrective measures other than impeachment. No observation was made by any of the seven learned judges with regard to the memorandum of procedure.

Any issue with regard to the Memorandum of Procedure should be discussed in the Chief Justices Conference and by the full court. Such a matter of grave importance if at all required to be taken on the judicial side should be dealt with by none other than a Constitution bench.

The reason for choosing this case and the timing of this letter raises many questions on the real motive of this mutiny by four senior and ‘respected’ judges of the Supreme Court.

Is the Revolt Politically Motivated?

Justice Chelameshwar’s meeting with the CPI leader D Raja lends credence to the suspicion that this exercise might have a larger political motive. D Raja refused to share the details of what transpired him and the Judge when interviewed by a journalist.

Most of the opposition leaders have piggy backed on the ‘democracy in danger’ statement in their remarks. One can also expect high drama in the upcoming budget session of Parliament. This tweet posted by the Congress party’s official handle gives an indication of things to come in near future.

What does it achieve?

At the end of the day, one must ask, what did this revolt achieve? The rebel judges “came to the public” regarding an issue, which can be resolved only by the President of India, the Government of India, in consultation with the CJI and other Justices. This media circus has only demeaned the post of the CJI. Worse, the letter of the rebel judges, shies away from naming specific cases, thus leaving the field open for innuendo and even more confusion. All this, in the end tarnishes the Indian judiciary itself.

The judicial appointments issue , though important , will now become a victim of political fight inside the Supreme Court and in Parliament. Biggest casualty in the end is the reputation of the Supreme Court of India.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

‘Feminists’ and ‘liberals’ will #BelieveHer until one of their own is accused of sexual assault

At the height of #MeToo movement, most women showed solidarity with the women who were levelling allegations against the men.

Is Govt doing away with MSP? PM Modi fact-checks Rahul Gandhi as he spreads misinformation and panic over agriculture Bills

Prime Minister Modi as well as other ministers took to social media to put out the facts and bust the misinformation being spread regarding MSP

China invades Nepal, constructs eight buildings in Nepalese territory: Reports

With expansionist policies in place, China has continued to invade Nepal inch by inch and constructing buildings on the captured lands.

HW News Network: The digital news outfit facing I-T probe with expenses eleven times the revenue and mysterious source of fund

While the revenue of Theo Connect that owns the HW News was just Rs 54 lakh in the year 2018-19, its expenses were Rs 3.23 crores

Watch: TMC MP Derek O’Brien heckles and attacks Deputy Chairman Harivansh as Rajya Sabha passes agriculture Bills

TMC MP Derek O'Brien on Sunday, entered the well and climbed the dais of the Rajya Sabha Deputy Chairman in an attempt to halt the proceedings of the house.

Customer orders jhatka chicken, BigBasket sends parcel with both jhatka and halal labels, refunds money

BigBasket had earlier come under fire for selling discriminatory 'halal' only products. After severe backlash, BigBasket made 'jhatka' meat available on its website.

Recently Popular

‘He opened his zip and tried to force his c**k inside my vagina,’ actress Payal Ghosh accuses filmmaker Anurag Kashyap of sexual harassment

Actress Payal Ghosh has claimed that she was sexually harassed by filmmaker Anurag Kashyap and called him a hypocrite.

An eyewitness tells media that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party held on the eve of her death: Here are...

An eyewitness has told News Nation that Disha Salian was gang-raped by 4 men in the party which she attended on the eve of her death on June 8.

From ‘she is a small-time actress’ to ‘you are the biggest feminist’, defence pours in for Anurag Kashyap who is accused of sexual assault

Accusing Anurag Kashyap of sexual assault, actress Payal Ghosh stated, "I went to meet him and the next day when he took me to the other room, he opened his zip and tried to force his c**k (penis) inside my vagina by opening my Salwar Kameez.

Fact Check: Is India going under lockdown once again from September 25?

PIB has debunked rumours on social media about the reimposition of lockdown from September 25 in the wake of Coronavirus surge.

Devendra Fadnavis exposes how ABP Majha abruptly ended his interview, shares video of parallel recording he had arranged anticipating foul-play by the channel

Devendra Fadnavis had alleged that his interview was cut short midway while he was explaining centre's help to Maharashtra on GST credit

Customer orders jhatka chicken, BigBasket sends parcel with both jhatka and halal labels, refunds money

BigBasket had earlier come under fire for selling discriminatory 'halal' only products. After severe backlash, BigBasket made 'jhatka' meat available on its website.

‘Feminists’ and ‘liberals’ will #BelieveHer until one of their own is accused of sexual assault

At the height of #MeToo movement, most women showed solidarity with the women who were levelling allegations against the men.

Woman alleges gang-rape at a five-star hotel in Connaught Place in Delhi, one arrested

The woman said that she was lured to the hotel room by the promise of loan at a very low interest rate, where she was assaulted and raped

‘Meaningless to play such a petty trick’, Chinese state media Global Times defends Rajeev Sharma, the journalist caught spying for China

Global Times has come out in support of Rajeev Sharma, who was arrested for passing sensitive information to China.

Watch: Maldives Foreign Minister speaks in Hindi to thank India for $250 million package during Coronavirus pandemic

Maldives Foreign Minister Abdulla Shahid thanked India for financial aid provided to the island nation to fight Coronavirus pandemic

AIMIM Chief Asaduddin Owaisi attends annual conference of Hamas-linked Islamic association, claims RSS was inspired by Nazis

Asaduddin Owaisi accused Bhartiya Janata Party (BJP) and the Modi government of being part of a larger movement known as Hindutva

Sudarshan News refers to programs on ‘Hindu Terror’ and ‘saffron terror’ by NDTV in its affidavit on ‘UPSC Jihad’ submitted at Supreme Court

Sudarshan News said that in programs on 'Hindu Terror', NDTV used Hindu symbols and saints in saffron clothes with Trishuls, Tilak etc

Shiv Sena, NCP dismisses CBDT investigation against Uddhav Thackeray, Aaditya Thackeray, and Supriya Sule, calls it a ‘routine exercise’

EC had asked CBDT to probe allegations of 'fake poll affidavits' against Supriya Sule, Uddhav Thackeray and Aaditya Thackeray

India-China standoff: Indian Army makes a major breakthrough, occupies 6 strategic heights along LAC

To counter India's strategic position, the Chinese regime has deployed 3000 army personnel, near Rechen la and Rezang La heights.

Is Govt doing away with MSP? PM Modi fact-checks Rahul Gandhi as he spreads misinformation and panic over agriculture Bills

Prime Minister Modi as well as other ministers took to social media to put out the facts and bust the misinformation being spread regarding MSP

Union Home Ministry tables FCRA amendment bill at the Lok Sabha, proposes to bring more transparency and accountability in the functioning of NGOs

Home ministry introduces FCRA amendment bill in Lok Sabha, several changes made in regulation of NGOs receiving foreign fund

Connect with us

244,181FansLike
453,989FollowersFollow
16,200SubscribersSubscribe