Tuesday, July 14, 2020
Home Law If Court desires respect for law, it must make law respectable by reiterating that...

If Court desires respect for law, it must make law respectable by reiterating that nobody is above it

Also Read

For legal fraternity past few days have been very disturbing at least for common advocates and litigants. It seems that the noble conception of “Equality” which forms the basis of legal system and rule of law in the country is dying its own death in India. Those who have access to the high echelons of power in Delhi can overnight innovate an altogether de novo mean to stall the Police investigation which no ordinary citizens of this country even think of.

The arrest of few so-called Human Rights activists after unearth of some evidence that they were conspiring and feeding Maoists for the assassination of Indian PM, in past few days unleashed a sequence of events which ended up in the Supreme Court. The Hon’ble Apex Court passed an ex-parte interim order of conversion of their transit remand into house arrest. Instead of being taken into immediate police custody and furthering investigation in this highly sensitive case, special treatment has been given to the urban Naxal cadres by an exception to the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code and normal criminal jurisprudence of Police investigation.

Imagine, if the arrests were of simple ordinary citizens or of persons from troubled areas or from minority communities under the same charges what would be the response of the Supreme Court if the Writ Petition of similar nature has been filed. It is now a well-settled principle after several pronouncements of Hon’ble Supreme Court itself that if there is an alternate remedy available, writ jurisdiction should not be invoked, which in this case is a bail application at the disposal of Magistrate’s Court. Here the case was not of illegal police detention but of simple police transit remand in pursuance of the investigation in the light of certain unearthed evidence after ‘Bhima-Koregaon’ Violence.

The Supreme Court in Sakiri Vasu v. State of U.P., (2008) 2 SCC, in Para 27 itself dealt with this principle of alternative remedy and refrained High Court for entertaining Writ in such cases and withhold the power of Magistrate.

As per Cr.PC, it is a normal routine for Police to investigate a crime and take remand of suspects. It is perhaps unimaginable for any ordinary citizen or even their advocates that the Apex court would come to their rescue in the manner they have in this case, with the ‘dissent is the safety valve of democracy’ argument. The way things furthered in Delhi is in complete derogation to the attributes of The Goddess Iustitia (lady justice) which carries a blindfold, a balance, and a sword as a symbol of justice which is free from differentiation of the status of the parties before it.

Thousands of people in India are arrested every day for several crimes and the provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code deals with them as per the “Law of Arrest”. Interpretation of Supreme Court itself suggests that Arrest forms the part of Investigation. It is an essential component of the Investigation that if facts and circumstances warrant the accused can be taken into custody and rigorously interrogated. Moreover, it is the Judicial Magistrate who decides the extent of Police remand and such custody. If accused wants to be free after Police remand they can apply for a bail before the Magistrate’s Court or Sessions Court.

The Supreme Court in Babubhai v. State of Gujarat, (2010) 12 SCC 254;held in Para 38 that “Unless an extraordinary case of gross abuse of power is made out by those in charge of the investigation, the court should be quite loathe to interfere with the investigation, a field of activity reserved for the police and the executive…”So, the Interim Order of the Court is completely unwarranted, as also there was no any chance of irreparable injury to the Petitioners.

For ordinary citizens, the Hon’ble Apex Court has multiple times decided that higher/appellate Court should not interfere at the very nascent stage of Police investigation and criminal jurisdiction of Lower Courts. Intermeddling with the investigation which is sole dominion of the investigative agencies ought not to be done in a routine and casual manner. Courts are entrusted with the duty of inquiry, not an investigation. Inquiry can only be commenced rationally at the end of the investigation. Freedom of investigative agencies and Magistrate Court is a must for the revelation of truth.

A presumption that the Police and Magistrate’s Court are not doing its duty, without any cogent evidence is bad in law & against judicial morality. Let the authorities do its duty for which it has been entrusted and only if in pursuance of that they commit any illegality then Higher Courts should step in.

What makes the case of urban cadres of Maoist revolutionary different is this presumption by the Apex Court that they are being victimized for their views and hence the Courts should step in with such an exceptional extraordinary route to stall the investigation. The question rather they should ask is what is the fear if they have not committed any illegality? Or, is it Hon’ble Supreme Court has itself lost its faith in the Police and the lower judiciary like of these urban cadres? What was the urgency behind this usurpation of the power of Magistrate Court by the Apex Court of the Country?

The Supreme Court itself in Director, Central Bureau of Investigation v. Niyamavedi, (1995) 3 SCC 601; has held in Para 4 that “…Ordinarily, the Court should refrain from interfering at a premature stage of the investigation as that may derail the investigation and demoralise the investigation. Of late, the tendency to interfere in the investigation is on the increase and courts should be wary of its possible consequences. We say no more.”

The Hon’ble Apex Court has recently in Dineshbhai Chandubhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, (2018) 3 SCC 104; relying on Swapan Kumar Guha ((1982) 1 SCC 561)case held in Para 31 that “…once the court finds that the FIR does disclose prima facie commission of any cognizable offence, it should stay its hand and allow the investigating machinery to step in to initiate the probe to unearth the crime in accordance with the procedure prescribed in the Code.”

Para 397 of Kartar Singh v. State of Punjab, (1994) 3 SCC 569; judgment observed that it is a legitimate right of the police to arrest a suspect on receiving some credible information or material. The interrogation and investigation should be in true sense purposeful to make the investigation effective.

Now what the Hon’ble Supreme Court seems to be doing in this case, is nothing but subverting the entire legal procedure for a group of influential people using its extraordinary power who perhaps can afford a battery of influential lawyers. What is the message of Apex Court to the Lower Judiciary and people of this country? Is it not differential treatment, privileged procedure and a separate set of rules?

If we take judiciary as an extended organ of State within Article 12 of the Constitution, this decision of the Court itself is Ultra-Vires the Constitution as being violative of Article 14 creating an unreasonable classification between two different groups of people, liberal intellectuals and ordinary citizens and privileging one over the other in the Judicial process.

How many people in this country get this privilege of arguing directly before the Apex Court. One must ask if the Hon’ble Court will open its doors for a common man at 2 AM as it did for Yakub Menon or whether the court will protect the “civil liberties” of thousands of undertrials still locked up in jails as it protected in this case. One must ask whether the court will strike off the entire legal provision of arrests from the Criminal Procedure Code itself to bring the parity among all accused of criminal offences and if not, then what is so sacrosanct about Sudha Bhardhwaj or Varvara Rao that they cannot be even interrogated in Police custody. Whether the Hon’ble Court has considered the fact that this delay of not taking them in custody will directly help them to manipulate with the evidence and will dent the entire investigation?

Nobody knows where this liberal romanticism will take us to, but we should keep this in mind that the history of our country is an eye-witness that we have lost not one but two Prime Ministers who have been brutally assassinated. This is an issue concerning the security of our Prime Minister; he is not an individual but an institution.

People in this country usually avoid commenting upon the wisdom of My Lords, but this differential treatment and especially to those who are accused of plotting against the integrity of the country is unpalatable. It seems that protection of freedom to speech is at the radical extreme for those who want to shekel the system of democracy itself. Times will come and go, regimes will change, eras will pass but the credibility of the institution of the judiciary must be sustained, it is the oxygen of a functional democracy amidst the suffocating pressures of suppression.

If the Court desires the respect for law, it must first make the law respectable with an eternal mantra that nobody is above the law; otherwise, an important pillar of our democratic Constitutional setup fears a serious crisis of credibility if it continues with this differential treatment compromising the sanctity of the Institution.

(This article has been written by Ayush Anand, a practising advocate at Supreme Court and Shubham Tiwari, a law student at NALSAR, Hyderabad)

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Trending now

AMU girl complains about being threatened and hounded since CAA was passed, told she will be made to wear “brass hijab”

Calling her a "Sanghi", the fellow AMU students had attacked her for calling out sexualisation of women in the varsity

Islamists issue rape threats to a social media user for asking Muslims to recite Azaan at lower volume

Apart from Fardeen Modal, Ashi's Azaan tweet miffed other Muslims, who also abused the Hindu girl on Twitter

Secret meetings, plan of action and riots: How Safoora Zargar and others are intertwined in the murder of Ratan Lal during Delhi riots

Name of Jamia Millia Islamia student Safoora Zargar appears multiple times in Ratan Lal murder chargesheet

Google head Sundar Pichai, who studied at IIT Kharagpur, is all set to bring a digital revolution worth Rs 75,000 crore in India: Read...

Google, headed by Sundar Pichai, pitches in to help bring about a digital revolution in India

A tribute to Tapan Ghosh: The firebrand leader who helped Muslim women marry their Hindu lovers and secure a happy ending to their love...

Hindutva Icon of West Bengal, Tapan Ghosh, passed away on Sunday, days after he was diagnosed with the Wuhan Coronavirus.

Sharad Pawar, Mamata Banerjee, Jagan and Himanta Biswa: How Congress ignored key regional leaders and eventually lost those states

Choosing loyalists over popularity and calibre has cost Congress dearly. Losing key regional leaders has decimated the party to ruins in many states.

Recently Popular

The curious case of ‘Drone Boy’ who has made 600 drones using broken mixer grinders and televisions. A fact-check

While 'drone boy' Prathap NM has claimed to have made 600 drones using e-waste, not a single photo or video of them exist

‘Drone boy’ Prathap NM makes a statement after OpIndia fact-check: Here is why his explanation makes little sense

'Drone boy' Prathap NM says he won't show his drones due to intellectual property issues, but will show certificates from unregistered events

Sachin Pilot reaches Delhi with 25 MLAs amid speculations of Rajasthan government collapse, Gehlot holds late night meetings

Ashok Gehlot claimed that the State government was stable and would continue to remain so despite all efforts to the contrary

Pakistanis are shocked that Turkish actress does not cover herself head-to-toe in real life like her role in TV show Ertugrul, slams for wearing...

Pakistani Islamists troll Turkish actress Esra Bilgiç for her modern clothing, not traditional dress like her historical role in a TV show

Stand-up comedian apologises for insulting memorial to Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj in Arabian sea after MNS workers vandalised studio

The stand-up 'comedian' Agrima Joshua had made scornfully derisive remarks in her video against the Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj memorial that is going to be erected in the Arabian Sea

Aakar Patel abuses Amitabh Bachchan and Sachin Tendulkar – reasons go beyond hatred for Modi

The 'Woke' secular-liberal camp of current times is defined by its elitist arrogance and crass snobbery. 'Human rights activist' Aakar Patel is one such specimen.

Here are the six significant statements by the court today while denying bail to Tahir Hussain, accused in the Delhi anti-Hindu riots

Tahir Hussain had sought bail saying there was no cogent evidence to link him to Ankit Sharma's murder

Nepal PM says Shri Ram was Nepali and India has created ‘fake Ayodhya’, admits scholars will not believe his ‘new fact’

Nepalese Prime Minister KP Sharma Oli claimed that India falsely says Shri Ram was born in Ayodhya, India.

Amidst rising demand to boycott Chinese products, Bollywood actor Karthik Aryan drops multi-crore endorsement deal with Oppo

Karthik Aryan has become the first Bollywood actor to drop a multi-crore deal with a Chinese brand.

AMU girl complains about being threatened and hounded since CAA was passed, told she will be made to wear “brass hijab”

Calling her a "Sanghi", the fellow AMU students had attacked her for calling out sexualisation of women in the varsity

The death of BJP MLA Debendra Nath Roy shows that no opposition political leader is safe in West Bengal

BJP MLA in West Bengal, Debendra Nath Roy, was found hanging in public on Monday.

Why ‘liberal’ hate against Amitabh Bachchan for getting admitted to a hospital after testing positive for Coronavirus makes no sense at all

A bevy of perverse liberals took to Twitter to denounce Amitabh Bachchan after he got Coronavirus, claiming it to be a "privilege of rich" and accusing him of needlessly occupying a hospital bed

London: Indian diaspora, PoK activists and Iranian diaspora protest outside the Chinese embassy over ‘expansionist policies’

Demonstrators were heard singing the Indian National Anthem 'Jan Gan Maan' and the Indian National song, 'Vande Mataram' at the protest site.

AIB co-founder Rohan Joshi, who wanted entire Pawar family dead, deactivates his Twitter account

AIB co-founder Rohan Joshi has deactivated his account after screenshots of his abusive tweets against politicians went viral .

Gehlot’s last ‘resort’? Congress moves MLAs to Jaipur hotel, Pilot claims Rajasthan govt has lost majority

Reports claimed that 107 MLAs, including some independents, were present at the CM's residence. Congress has moved its MLAs to a resort in Jaipur.

In touch with ISIS recruiters since 2015: NIA arrests 2 Islamic State terrorists in Pune planning to carry out terror attacks in India

The duo arrested by the NIA were involved in promoting and propagating ISIS and their activities in India

Connect with us

235,877FansLike
406,231FollowersFollow
274,000SubscribersSubscribe