Friday, October 23, 2020
Home Fact-Check Media Fact-Check India Today sting on JNU violence: Here is how Rahul Kanwal passed off a...

India Today sting on JNU violence: Here is how Rahul Kanwal passed off a JNUSU activist as an ABVP member

Tweets of grandstanding where Rahul Kanwal alleges that his channel did their job without "fear or favour" does not hold water and to tarnish the image of Delhi police based on a shoddy investigation ridden with lies does not bode well for the channel or Rahul Kanwal either.

India Today channel on the 10th of January 2020 aired a sting operation that they called a stupendous work of investigative journalism. The sting operation by India Today was to do with the JNU violence that had erupted in the campus on the intervening days and nights of 3rd, 4th and 5th of January. In the sting operation, India Today claimed to unmask 2 ABVP activists who had supposedly indulged in retaliatory violence on the 5th in the Sabarmati hostel after they said that the Leftists had attacked the Periyar hostel. It now appears that India Today tried to pass off a JNUSU activist as an ABVP member simply to further a narrative.

The sting operation was aired by India Today right after the Delhi police had held a press conference and implicated several Left students, including the JNUSU president Aishe Ghosh as suspects in the JNU violence.

Read: JNU violence: Delhi police names nine suspects and 4 Left organisations, suspects include JNUSU Pres Aishe Ghosh

During the airing of the sting operation, ABVP had come out to issue a statement saying that Akshat Awasthi, the man being identified as an ABVP activist is not associated with ABVP in any manner. To this, Rahul Kanwal had claimed that he has proof of Akshat attending an ABVP rally. Though this was a flimsy reason to associate someone with a political outfit since thousands of unrelated and unconnected people might turn up for a political event, Kanwal stuck to his guns.

After the sting operation was aired, Rahul Kanwal took to Twitter to publish the “proof” of Akshat Awasthi attending an “ABVP rally”.

It is here that Rahul Kanwal and India Today’s “sting operation” started unravelling.

Read: ABVP statement on IndiaToday JNU sting: Smear campaign to deviate from Delhi Police finding, man on camera not ABVP

Rahul Kanwal claimed that though Akshat Awasthi has now changed his stance and said that he is in no way associated with the ABVP, there is a photo of him at an ABVP rally holding the Indian flag. The picture he offered as proof is as follows.

Picture shared by Rahul Kanwal as proof of Akshat Awasthi attending an “ABVP rally”

According to Rahul Kanwal, the man in the picture holding the Indian flag is Akshat Awasthi and this is an ABVP rally.

First, to ensure that we have the right information, we tried to search other publications that had used with the very picture and the picture credits thereof. This was done to ascertain whether this was an ABVP rally and what the rally was about.

Manorama article

The picture used by Manorama says that the picture is from the 11th of November 2019 when the police stopped JNU students who were staging a protest over the hostel fee-hike issue. The picture was taken by Kamal Singh of PTI.

To confirm it is indeed the same picture, we tried to spot Akshat in both.

The picture tweeted by Rahul Kanwal, PTI picture of 11th November protests

We had now established that the rally Rahul Kanwal was calling an ‘ABVP rally’ was held on 11th November 2019 in protest against the JNU hostel fee-hike issue.

We found a corresponding article on India Today itself about the 11th November protest which Rahul Kanwal and India Today have now claimed was an ABVP rally.

India Today article from 12th November

The India Today article, in its first paragraph, said, “Shouting slogans and raising banners, thousands of Jawaharlal Nehru University (JNU) students clashed with police on Monday as their protest over steep fee hike escalated. The students of the varsity, which has seen several such agitations in the recent years, were protesting outside the All India Council of Technical Education (AICTE) premises, the venue for the varsity’s third convocation, which was addressed by Vice President M Venkaiah Naidu”.

We had now established that the protest on 11th November was one outside the AICTE, the venue for JNU’s third convocation, which was addressed by Vice President Venkataiah Naidu. In fact, during this protest, HRD Minister Ramesh Pokhriyal ‘Nishank’ was also stranded for over six hours at the venue of the varsity’s convocation.

The India Today article in the question itself spoke about who organised the protest and the other parties that were supporting the protest.

India Today article

The India Today article mentions that the 11th November protests were organised by JNUSU. The current President of JNUSU is Aishe Ghosh, who has been named by the Dehli police as a suspect in the JNU violence and is from Leftist organisation SFI.

This protest was in turn supported by parties like BAPSA (Birsa Ambedkar Phule Students’ Association), Kshatra RJD (the student wing of RJD, Lalu’s party) and Congress’ NSUI.

The chants in the protest were ‘Humein Chahiye Azadi”.

Further, the India Today article says, that the situation, of the minister being stuck in the AICTE premises, was only brought under control after the HRD minister spoke to the JNUSU president (Aishe Ghosh).

India Today article

The India Today article itself does not mention ABVP even once.

Here is a video report by the India Today about the JNUSU protest outside AICTE on 11th November 2019.

Interestingly, there is no mention of ABVP even in the video report.

The fact that this was not a protest by ABVP or an “ABVP rally” as claimed by Rahul Kanwal is further proved by the fact that even the second page of the Jansatta article shared by Rahul Kanwal mentions Aishe Ghosh and JNUSU, but not ABVP.

Jansatta article

OpIndia also acquired the JNUSU pamphlet of the 11th November protest.

Pamphlet of JNUSU protest on 11th November 2019

Thus, by every account, the “proof” shared by Rahul Kanwal does not hold. The protest march, which is being claimed as an “ABVP rally” by Rahul Kanwal of India Today was clearly a protest by JNUSU, dominated by the Left and supported by other Left organisations including the Congress’ student wing NSUI. Thus, it is only reasonable to assume that Akshat Awasthi was a JNUSU activist at the very least and not an ABVP member.

This begs several important questions that Rahul Kanwal and India Today must answer:

1. If India Today’s had only this to prove that Akshat Awasthi was an ABVP member, how was this sting operation allowed to air?

2. Even after the Delhi police had categorically named the initial suspects, India Today aired this clearly erroneous sting operation and went on to question the credibility of the Delhi police. Will India Today now apologise?

3. What was the motive behind India Today deliberately trying to pass off what looks like a Left student activist as an ABVP member who was involved in the JNU violence?

4. Who is this first-year student who seems to have clearly lied on camera when he said that he had organised the violence in Sabarmati hostel and called several ABVP activists?

5. Is there an ulterior motive of muddying the water as far as the JNU violence investigation is concerned in order to shield Left parties?

Read: Rahul Kanwal of India Today bullies a BHU student during debate, refuses to let him speak

The questions only grow stronger after this one shocking aspect that came to light. While the excess of graphics in India Today hid the timestamp, on Aaj Tak, in the second segment of Akshat Awasthi speaking, a strange timestamp is revealed.

Screengrab from the video uploaded by Aaj Tak

The timestamp that is on the second segment of the video showing Akshat Awasthi shockingly has the date stamped as 22nd October 2019. The violence in JNU happened on 5th January 2020.

In this segment, Akshat Awasthi was making generic statements about how ABVP activists got the idea of masking their face, Interestingly, there were no details specific to the 5th January violence were revealed by Akshat Awasthi in this segment.

The specific details of the attack on Sabarmati hostel and Periyar hostel were only revealed in the first segment of the India Today sting on JNU violence where Akshat is wearing a blue blazer and sitting supposedly in the canteen.

Read: Traitors of JNU, Nothing will be forgotten: Naxal-style poster seeking revenge on non-left professors and alumni put up inside JNU

While this could possibly be a technical glitch, with the credibility of India Today being extremely low with respect to this sting operation, there are certain questions that the channel and Rahul Kanwal must answer:

1. Was this segment indeed recorded in October?

2. If this segment was recorded in October, was there some sort of conspiracy by the investigators of India Today to implicate ABVP falsely and that plan was postponed till yesterday?

3. If this was a technical glitch, why was a disclaimer not added either in India Today or Aaj Tak?

There are several questions that India Today must answer about its JNU sting operation and explain why they tried to pass off what looks like a Left student as an ABVP student even after Delhi police made those revelations implicating the Left for JNU violence.

Tweets of grandstanding where Rahul Kanwal alleges that his channel did their job without “fear or favour” does not hold water as far as the India Today sting on JNU violence is concerned and to tarnish the image of Delhi police based on a shoddy investigation ridden with lies does not bode well for the channel or Rahul Kanwal either.

Update: OpIndia reached out to India Today journalist Rahul Kanwal to get a comment on this fact-check. Rahul Kanwal said, “We do not speak to other publications so I won’t be able to comment”. 

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Nupur J Sharma
Editor, OpIndia.com since October 2017

Related Articles

Trending now

US Senate Committee on Judiciary approves subpoenas for Jack Dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg asking them to testify over allegations of censorship

The senate approved the subpoenas in a 12-0 vote after both Facebook and Twitter censored a New York Post report on Joe Biden

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

CM Yogi distributes relief amount of Rs 113.21 crore among the flood-affected farmers in Uttar Pradesh

CM Yogi distributed the relief amount to the flood-affected farmers in 19 districts of the state by online transaction.

‘Mughal Prince Tucy’ lashes out on AIMIM’s Asaduddin Owaisi, calls him ‘Bewakoof, and Gadha’

Prince Tucy said that when the people of Hyderabad are dealing with horrific floods, MP Asaduddin Owaisi is busy doing poll campaign in Bihar.

Recently Popular

France: Charlie Hebdo cartoons projected on government building to express solidarity with deceased teacher who was beheaded by Islamic terrorist

Days after the barbaric beheading of teacher Samuel Paty on the streets of Paris by a terrorist for showing the cartoons of Prophet Mohammad to his students, support continues to pour in for the deceased teacher.

Eros Now apologises for publishing vulgar Hinduphobic content on Navratri

After netizens outraged over vulgar posts on Navratri, Eros Now issued an apology.

Lucknow: Jama Mazar caretaker ‘Kale Baba’ caught running sex racket, video goes viral

The caretaker has allegedly confessed to police that he was sexually exploiting women and engaging them in illicit activities in the name of curing infertility and other ailments.

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

Complaints filed against Eros Now and Arré for vulgar social media posts related to Navratri

Both Eros Now and Arre had published social media posts linking Navratri festival with sex and vulgarity

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav
- Advertisement -

Last presidential debate: Biden wants to ‘transition’ from oil and gas, Trump hits him hard with jobs and business loss

"That’s maybe the biggest statement in terms of business. What he is saying is he is going to destroy the oil industry," Trump said.

Canada condemns China’s treatment of Uyghur Muslims and other ethnic minorities. Read details

the Subcommittee on International Human Rights of the Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development heard testimonies of academics, civil society and victims of Chinese atrocities for 12-long hours and over 2 days.

Argentinian artist accuses Disha Patani of passing off his artwork as her brother’s: Read details

In fact, the anime artwork shared by Disha Patani claiming to be her brother's artwork was first shared by Argentinian artist 'Inhoso' in July this year.

Raza Academy threatens to move court against Maharashtra govt if Eid-e-Milad procession is not allowed

Eid-e-Milad is celebrated to commemorate the birthday of Prophet Muhammad and it falls on 29th October this year.

US Senate Committee on Judiciary approves subpoenas for Jack Dorsey and Mark Zuckerberg asking them to testify over allegations of censorship

The senate approved the subpoenas in a 12-0 vote after both Facebook and Twitter censored a New York Post report on Joe Biden

Complaints filed against Eros Now and Arré for vulgar social media posts related to Navratri

Both Eros Now and Arre had published social media posts linking Navratri festival with sex and vulgarity

Chhattisgarh police file FIR against video journalist who had reported on farmer protests based on an allegedly edited video

Video journalist Manish Soni had reported about the plight of farmers whose paddy crops were ruined due to anti-encroachment drive

Reducing Navratri to ‘mating dance’, comparing Holi with terrorism— how the Indian media has turned Hinduphobic

After Eros Now posted series of vulgar messages associated with Navratri, far-left site Arre posted a Hinduphobic tweet on Durga puja

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
466,002FollowersFollow
18,800SubscribersSubscribe