Home Blog Page 7263

Mainstream media has been spreading communally sensitive fake news for quite some time

0

Recently, the editor of Postcard news Mahesh Hegde was arrested for spreading fake news about an attack on a Jain monk by Muslims. This has suddenly created awareness about fake news that is being spread by the media.

Fake news is dangerous for society as it can lead to violence and create false impressions and nobody in their right mind can support the phenomenon. However, the menace of communally sensitive fake news is not new. The mainstream media is routinely involved in peddling such news. So far they have not been arrested the way Mahesh Hegde has been.

Raped for consuming beef? Pallavi Ghosh’s inflammatory and false tweet

Pallavi Ghosh of CNN News network had shared false reports of a rape committed because of consuming beef. This news was busted by Uttar Pradesh police.


Instead of arresting the journalist for fanning communal tensions, UP police said that her Tweets were fictional and they could not verify the same. The same kind of treatment could have been given to the Postcard News founder who had shared false news of a Jain monk who had been attacked by a particular community. In fact, the brazenness of the mainstream media is such, that Pallavi Ghosh has still not deleted the high sensitive, and blatantly false tweet even after being corrected by the police.

Sagarika Ghose forced to delete her Tweet 

Sagarika Ghose was also forced to delete her Tweets that were aimed at fanning communal discord. As mentioned in an older article on OpIndia: She didn’t give any reference to any incident or data to back her sensational claims, which incite communal passions. [..] It should be noted that the Indian laws have provisions for punishing speech that can create enmities between communities or disturb law and order, especially if the speech is not based on facts. Sagarika’s tweet was deemed as a provocation that could have led people to take law into their own hands.

Hate speech by Sagarika Ghose
The controversial tweet, now deleted by Sagarika.

Dubious ‘Data Journalism’ claiming 86% killed in cow related violence are Muslim

Another classic example of fake news was the claim that “86% killed in cow-related violence since 2010 are Muslim, 97% attacks after Modi govt came to power”. This piece of news was carried in almost all major media houses in India. The links to the same are below :

These reports are based on a piece of data journalism by a portal called IndiaSpend. An article that busted this myth was published on OpIndia. The writer clearly called this analysis a lynching of data because the analysis was not done based on police records or crime data. It was done after analysing news reports in media! The three major loopholes in the IndiaSpend study pointed out by the author are :

To summarize, we see:

  1. No attempt to define the source (“English media”) that has been studied.
  2. No attempt to explain why the subclass (“English media”) that has been studied is representative of the whole class (“media”).
  3. No justification provided as to why media reports are to be preferred to government records.

Such a blatantly communal news peddled across English media without any stringent analysis went without punishment under a government headed by a ‘fascist party’ like BJP. One must question as to why such fake news went unpunished. The same myth has been countered by an another OpIndia article exposing the piece of fake news.

Hindustan Times’ infamous ‘Hate Tracker’

Similarly, Hindustan Times “Hate Tracker” (content has been taken down by HT) which peddled biased views of all hate crimes in the country is another example of biased news with communal implications. The OpIndia article countering this propaganda had highlighted as to how crimes against Dalits and Muslims had been given more weight, thereby promoting the propaganda that violence against these groups had increased under the BJP government at the centre. Not many socially conscious intellectuals called out Hindustan Time’s propaganda using biased data.

Gujarat has only 2.33% of India’s Dalit population but ranks fourth on atrocities?

Another interview in The Wire which wrongly claimed that violence against Dalits in Gujarat was high in spite of their low population in the state is also an example of how media peddled lies to sow seeds of hatred in the country. The article claimed: “Gujarat has only 2.33% of India’s Dalit population but ranks fourth on atrocities against the community.”

The OpIndia article countering this false data using the information published by NCRB (National Crime Records Bureau) revealed that Gujarat was not among the top 10 state in terms of violence against Dalits. The Wire was not held accountable for its biased reporting which ostensibly has the intention of furthering social divisions in Gujarat and elsewhere.

The Wire’s interview that falsely dragged RSS on Naga accord sparks violence?

While above examples have the ability to widen social divisions and create violence, another interview by The Wire led to actual violence in Assam. The interview’s title was: ‘Revealed: RSS Draft Plan for Nagaland Accord’. Further, the report carried the following extract: Jagdamba Mall, a known face of the RSS in the Northeast, who has also been instrumental in BJP’s electoral inroads into the region, said the Accord is his “personal effort” coming from his “study of the Naga issue for over 45 years”.

The suggestions of Jagadamba Mal on resolving Naga issue were blown out of proportion by The Wire according to him. Jagamba Mal also clarified to Indian Express that he was not associated with RSS.

“I had indeed drawn up a list of suggestions for a proposed solution to the Naga issue, which included a one-time grant of Rs 500 crore for 10 districts including Dima Hasao of Assam, and formation of a development authority to ensure proper utilisation of that amount over a given period of time. But then that was entirely my personal opinion and has nothing to do with the government or the RSS. It is also a fact that I had shared this idea with a journalist who totally misinterpreted it, leading to such serious problems including the death of two innocent persons,” Mal told The Indian Express over the telephone.

In spite of spreading false news which allegedly led to violence, the portal was allowed to go scot-free by the Assam government.

Arundhati Roy’s false claims on anti-Muslim violence forced her to apologise

Arundhati Roy, the icon of liberals has also been involved in spreading communally sensitive fake news. She had claimed that Babri Masjid was demolished in the year 2002. In addition to that, she had distorted facts about crimes against Muslims in an article published on Outlook and was forced to publish an apology. The standards that were applied for the founder of PostCard news are not applicable to the liberal icon Arundati Roy.

An international columnist tries to stoke violence with fake news in Kasganj

CJ Werleman a US columnist tried to stoke violence with a video claiming that people were barging into the house of Muslims in Kasganj. However, the UP police were quick to bust the myth on Twitter. Werleman deleted his original tweet. Indian media tried to spin news with a secular angle while reporting the events from Kasganj.

When NDTV reinvented the identity of a Cow 

In response to a circular by the central government, some members of Kerala Congress slaughtered a calf and shot a video of it. NDTV which had some hidden agenda in reporting the matter called the cow as a buffalo and then changed it to an Ox. A detailed report of the same can be found here .

Jadhav and Doklam – Media has jeopardised national security as well

In addition to communally sensitive news, half baked reports jeopardising national security have been peddled by top journalists with impunity. Theories about Kulbhushan Jadhav and Doklam are published based on unnamed sources and flimsy logic without any fear of government action. The government is also not keen on acting upon these journalists.

After the Mahesh Hegde/Postcard episode, we can probably hope that fake news spread with an intent of creating communal discord or jeopardizing national security will be dealt with seriously. In addition to that star journalists who have spread the fake news in the past should also be brought to book based on the evidence that is already available in the public domain.

Sagarika Ghose slammed for peddling Congress leader’s ‘spin’ on Lalu’s imprisonment

0

Controversial journalist Sagarika Ghose who had once spread falsehoods to whip up communal sentiments, routinely sees herself questioned on social media, with regards to her ‘unique viewpoints’.

Today was one such day when Sagarika while quoting a TOI blog claimed that oppressive jail sentences were meted out to fodder scam convict Lalu Prasad Yadav and that they were a violation of his fundamental human rights. She further questioned whether Lalu was being victimised for his anti-BJP stance:


The article she quoted was incidentally co-written by senior Congress leader Abhishek Manu Singhvi. There he sought to drive home the point that Lalu could well have been provided with a “concurrent” jail sentence in place of the “consecutive” one which has seen him getting sentenced to 14 years in jail by a CBI court in Ranchi. This verdict saw the judge giving two seven-year jail sentences to Lalu which will be served consecutively.

Without much extrapolation, the article in its concluding lines claimed that Lalu’s human and fundamental rights were egregiously violated, which was picked up by Sagarika in her tweet. By going a step further she also floated a conspiracy theory in her tweet by subtly questioning whether the BJP was behind such a sentencing.

People were less than amused by Sagarika’s tweet thereby making their objection clear:


One user calmly pointed out the obvious typo in her tweet while questioning her intentions:


This incident raises the question whether a narrative has already started getting built with regards to a possible rehabilitation of Lalu ahead of the 2019 Lok Sabha elections so that votes could be canvassed with regards to the “inhuman treatment” meted out to him?

Missing Hindu girl traced to Bangladesh by Police

0

A missing Hindu girl from Karimganj, Assam has been traced to Dhaka, Bangladesh by the Police. Mausumi Das (21) was a student of Rabindra Sadan Girls’ College had been missing since March 12. The girl, who was assumed to have been kidnapped, has stated that she travelled to Bangladesh with one Bangladeshi citizen Badsah of her own free will. She has since then converted to Islam after marriage and is now known as Fatima. She has apparently refused to return to India.

The Police officials while addressing the media have said, “The investigating officer along with a team had started an inquiry in Silchar where the expo was organised and as per information their next destination was Agartala. Also, there was an involvement of a Bangladeshi citizen so we made a lookout circular through the Bureau of immigration where all the routes of exit were on alert.” They added, “We were also in touch with the Indian High Commissioner in Dhaka seeking support from the country.”

Since then, a video has supposedly emerged where the girl appears to be saying that she travelled to Bangladesh of her own free will. She was quoted as saying, “I have come to Bangladesh on my own terms and no one has kidnapped me. I have run away from India and want to stay here with my husband.” She added, “Bangladesh is a nice country and I do not want to return back India. I am not a kid that I would be lured. This is totally my decision.”

The girl’s family had initially filed a missing report with the Police after she had gone missing. She has admitted to travelling to Bangladesh without a valid passport.

ED attaches the properties of Bihar topper scam kingpin Bachcha Rai

0

The Enforcement Directorate has attached properties worth Rs 4.5 crores belonging to Bachcha Rai alias Amit Kumar, the main accused behind the infamous Bihar topper scam. The attached properties also include assets belonging to family members of Rai.


Rai was accused of taking large sums of money to make school kids top board exams through illicit means. The issue came to highlight in 2016 when several media reports revealed that the toppers of the Bihar board exams could not even answer basic questions about the number of subjects and curriculum for the examinations they topped in.

[youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqXCrvtPd7k]

Bachcha Rai was the principal cum secretary of the Vishnu Rai college in Vaishali. The Arts and Science stream toppers of his college, Ruby Rai and Saurav Sreshtha, had failed to answer the simplest of questions regarding their subjects on television. Bachcha’s own daughter Shalini had topped the Bihar Board Science stream exam in 2015.

Following police complaints, the scam of making students board exam toppers after taking money came to highlight. Bachcha Rai had surrendered to police in June 2016 after absconding for several days. Former Bihar Board of Secondary Education chief Lalkeshwar Singh, his politician wife Usha Singh and principals of four different colleges were also arrested for involvement in the scam. Supreme Court had denied interim bail to Bachcha Rai.

According to reports, the ED has attached a total of 29 plots located in Hajipur, Mahua and Bhagwanpur area. Ed has also attached 10 bank accounts belonging to Bachcha and his family members and a flat in Patna.

We need interns!

We need interns!

First thing first – it doesn’t mean we are looking for free work. It will be a paid association. You will be paid stipend that matches industry standards. It will be a three-month association, to begin with, and could be renewed further or changed into a regular job based on your and OpIndia’s performance. 

What is the job description?

Your job can be threefold :

  1. Writing news reports – around 4-5 every day. Articles that are curated from largely reliable sources/publications, and are generally of the nature that the mainstream media will not highlight or report about. This needs to be done after fact-checking.
  2. Keeping an eye on mainstream media and media talking heads, which and who are known to twist facts.
  3. Assist in research when it comes to our investigative pieces or fact-checking articles.

Location?

If you are in Kolkata or Bangalore, you can choose to come to our office premises, or you can work from home using internet-based technologies. Essentially, your current city of residence is not a problem.

Who can apply?

You are fresh out of college, or on a break between jobs, or looking for a job, or a freelancer working from home, or maybe a student who can somehow manage to be online and work during the day (and sometimes in the late evenings too).

Who cannot apply?

A typical virtue signalling left-liberal wannabe. Or if you believe that NDTV is a non-partisan media house.

Essential qualifications?

Should have proper knowledge and command of English. Should be a news junkie. Should not be digitally illiterate or clumsy – should be aware of WordPress publishing, should be able to undertake basic image and rich-text editing, and generally, know how the internet works. Your stream of studies doesn’t matter, but you should have logical and analytical abilities and research skills. You should be available online virtually all the time (but we won’t make you work all the time). 

Bonus qualifications?

Should have some articles on politics or current affairs published, even personal blogs count. If some articles were contributed to OpIndia (or MyVoice), that’d surely be a bonus qualification. Being active on social media is a desired and bonus qualification too.

How to apply?

Send an email to [email protected] with “Application for internship” (please use this and this exact phrase only) as the subject line with one sample work of writing attached and details about yourself. You can choose a sample news report that you believe a mainstream media house won’t normally publish or highlight.

Last date of application

Send it in by 11:59:59 PM on 7th April 2018.

Will I get a response?

Yes, you will be responded to, regardless of whether you are selected or not. The response might not be immediate, so please be patient. Everyone will get a response latest by 10th April 2018 end of the day.

Senior Congress leader dubs his party’s Lingayat card a ‘political stunt’

0

Senior Congress leader Jaffer Sharief has dubbed the Congress Lingayat card a ‘political stunt’ and stated that no one could ‘fool them’ by trying to divide them. He also stated that the move which saw the Congress government in Karnataka recommend a minority tag for the Lingayat community will not succeed at polls.


The Congress leader also complimented the contribution to society made by the Lingayat community and the organizational framework the community has established for itself through its network of Muths and spiritual leaders. He reiterated that no one could divide them with such a move.

Sudhanshu Trivedi, the spokesperson of the Bharatiya Janata Party, accused the Congress party of trying to retain power by sowing seeds of division in the country.


Earlier, the Veershaiva Mahasabha had rejected the minority tag recommended by the Karnataka government and dubbed the decision a ‘height of injustice’. The minority tag is believed to have been recommended by the Congress government to cut into the Lingayat vote-base of the BJP.

Shashi Tharoor drags BJP into college fee hike, Uttarakhand CM accuses him of spreading falsehood

0

Shashi Tharoor, Congress MP, had alleged that private medical colleges in Uttarakhand had implemented a 300% fee hike taking the fee from Rs. 7 lakh per year to Rs. 26.6 lakh per year. Then he tried to drag the newly elected BJP government into it by alleging that there were no student loans under BJP which would make an MBBS course for a student from the middle class costlier than what they can afford.


The Chief Minister of Uttarakhand, Trivendra S Rawat, then replied to Tharoor and accused the Congress leader of spreading falsehood through his tweet. He clarified that his government had ordered the private colleges to roll back the fee hike.


The Chief Minister also stated that his government was committed to the welfare of the students and not let any private college overcharge them.


This isn’t the first time Shashi Tharoor has been caught on the wrong foot. Recently, he made a twitter faux pass while wishing people on the occasion of Mahavir Jayanti. He had also wrongly attributed a cartoon to RK Laxman. Aside from Social Media blunders, he had also recently, along with the leftist propaganda website ‘The Wire’ got the rural electrification scenario completely wrong.  

This tweet by Shashi Tharoor appears to be consistent with the Congress party president’s accusations of the BJP being a ‘suit-boot ki sarkar’. However, on this occasion, Tharoor’s attempt was quickly rebutted by the Chief Minister of Uttarakhand.

Kerala cardinal accused of shady land deals now wants importance to be given to ‘god’s laws’

0

Cardinal George Alencherry who now a days is in deep trouble for allegedly being part of shady land deals, has in his Good Friday address asserted that importance needs to be given to god’s laws. In the message he also expressed his displeasure over the Syro-Malabar Catholic Church moving to court against him.

He claimed that citizens should live by the country’s laws but also need to give due importance to the ‘rule of god’. He also claimed that it was a wrong notion to measure god’s justice with the nation’s justice.

Other reports, incidentally claimed that the cardinal asserted that the “legal system shouldn’t interfere with the canon’s laws”. It quoted him as saying that, “its the duty of the citizen to obey the rule of law existing in the country, but more importance should be given to the divine law”.

He then supposedly pointed the fingers to unknown individuals within the church to claim that they wanted to control the church via court orders. He thus insinuated that these individuals hadn’t understood the Bible’s words properly.

The Cardinal delivered this controversial speech from the Kokkamangalam St Thomas Church in Cherthala, Kerala.

Following the controversy which erupted due to the speech, the church spokesperson resorted to damage control by claiming that the cardinal’s comments were distorted by the media.

Coming to the shady land deals, the cardinal has been accused of favouring a middleman who sold Church land worth 27 crores for a price of 13 crores. In spite of selling below its market value, the Church had received only 9.3 crores. In his defence, the Cardinal had claimed that the balance had remained unpaid due to demonetisation. In total, reports have speculated that the church has lost about 93 crores.

The Cardinal has now been booked under sections 120B, 406, 415 and 420 of the IPC following a Kerala High Court directive. These sections pertain to crimes like cheating, dishonesty, criminal breach of trust and criminal conspiracy.

Besides the police, the cardinal has also had to deal with opposition from within the church with Kerala priests vociferously demanding his removal for shady land deals.

The cardinal had incidentally tried to use the defence of “Canon’s laws” while arguing his case before the Kerala High Court by claiming that only the Pope could punish him under Canon law. The High Court promptly retorted that the Pope had no jurisdiction in India.

CBI to initiate probe against ICICI Bank CEO Chanda Kochhar’s husband

0

The Central Bureau of Investigations has initiated a preliminary inquiry (PE) against Deepak Kochhar, the husband of ICICI Bank CEO Chanda Kochhar for his alleged involvement in the quid pro quo loan provided to Videocon Ltd.

According to reports, a CBI official, under the condition of anonymity, stated that Deepak Kochhar and Venugopal Dhoot, promoter of Videocon group and unknown others have been named as suspects in the PE. Chanda Kochhar is not a suspect in the current PE.

The issue first came to light when it was reported that In December 2008, Venugopal Dhoot of Videocon Ltd set up a joint venture (JV) with Deepak Kochhar, Chanda Kochhar’s husband. In an investigative report by the Indian Express, it was brought to light that Venugopal Dhoot, after setting up a JV with Deepak Kochhar, issued the company a 64 crore loan through one of his fully owned entities and then proceeded to transfer the ownership of the JV to a trust headed by Deepak Kochhar. The transfer of ownership was done at just Rs 9 lakhs.

The report further revealed that the ownership transfer happened just six months after the Videocon group was issued a 3,250 crore loan from ICICI Bank Ltd. Almost 86% (2,810 crores) of that loan remains unpaid and it was declared an NPA in 2017.

The ICICI Bank in a press release has denied any quid pro quo or conflict of interest in case of the loan Videocon Group and the bank holds faith in its MD and CEO Chanda Kochhar and the alleged irregularities are only an attempt to malign the image of the bank.

In another press statement, the Chairman of the ICICI Bank MK Sharma revealed that Chanda Kochhar was, in fact, part of the panel that approved the 3,250 crore loan to Videocon but there was no conflict of interest involved.

In December 2008, Deepak Kochhar and Venugopal Dhoot had set up NuPower Renewables Pvt Ltd. Dhoot (through family members) held 50% while Deepak and his relatives held 50% of it. In2009, Dhoot resigned as director of NuPower and transferred his shares to Kochhar for 2.5 lakhs. In March 2010, NuPower received a 64 Crores loan from Supreme Energies (owned 99.9% by Dhoot). Supreme Energy then, through a series of transfer of shares became the owner of 94.99% owner NuPower while the rest of the shares remained with Deepak Kochhar. Dhoot then transferred all his holdings in Supreme Energy to his associate MC Punglia who eventually transferred them to Pinnacle Energy, a trust where Kochhar was the Managing Trustee. The cost of the total transaction was just 9 lakhs.

The transactions are now under scanner as it raises several questions of conflict of interest on the part of ICICI Bank and the Videocon conglomerate. The other shareholders in NuPower were Deepak Kochhar’s father and Chanda Kochhar’s brother’s wife.

This is how Ola can revolutionize news industry, but maybe they will surrender

0

Last evening, Ola cabs – an app based ‘cabs on hire’ service provider – announced that they are getting into news gathering, especially hyperlocal news. They are calling this initiative ONN – Ola News Network.

In a promotional video that they have created for this initiative, it appears that not only there could be a digital TV channel of sorts – to be played either on the user device or the devices they have in their ‘prime’ cabs – but also there could be ‘information on demand’, especially local information.

Had it been posted tomorrow, perhaps it would have been a April Fool’s prank, as they have done earlier, for the idea could sound a bit outlandish. But since it was posted two days prior to the April 1, I’m assuming in good faith that they mean it! But more than that, there are another reasons why I think could prove to be a serious business.

In the video, common users are seen asking the app about traffic condition somewhere in their town, or price of ‘bhindi’ in the local market, and other such information. Following which an Ola reporter – who are presumably the drivers of the cabs or autos – goes to the location and provides them with the sought information, sometimes by live streaming video from the location.

Essentially, from a location-based ‘cabs on hire’, they are now morphing into a location-based ‘reporters on hire’.

And it’s pretty exciting.

Earlier today on Twitter, I put out a non-serious tweet that Ola got inspiration for this idea due to a tweet of mine that I had posted back in January 2016. I was joking, but the truth is that I had pitched a similar idea to Network18 back in 2015 itself, which was about ‘reporters on hire’. And that’s why I think it is a serious business, and I’m very keenly interested to see how ‘Ola News Network’ unfolds.

Following Reliance’s acquisition of Network18, things had become a little slow, especially in the digital publishing division where I worked, and hardly any new initiatives were being taken up. The company was figuring out top management issues and other integration issues post the acquisition, and thus I could only get appreciation for my ideas, not any budget or team to work with.

While the motive of writing this article is partly to blow my own trumpet a little and claim that I had thought of this idea more than 3 years ago, I, in no way mean to suggest I’ve any copyright over it or Ola doesn’t deserve credit for it. I’m sure maybe someone else was also thinking of a similar idea way before me. In the end, execution matters more than ideas.

The main motive of writing this article however is to explain why I thought something like ‘reporters on hire’ made sense and why I was pitching for the idea.

Firstly, it makes sense economically. Journalism won’t survive unless news gathering costs are somehow met; and news gathering is a costly affair. The traditional model of journalism tries to subsidize this activity through advertisements where the reader doesn’t pay for the entire operational cost.

The traditional model worked in print format because news had a virtual monopoly on publishing – you can hardly consume anything else than news, on a daily printed paper – and thus they could command the advertising rates on publishing platform, which would eventually meet their revenue targets and sustain the business.

The same model also worked in electronic format, because the production cost of competing products – general entertainment TV serials for example – was usually higher than news gathering costs, hence the advertising rates on electronic platform too were good. The business sustained.

Apart from favorable advertising rates, television and print both are highly regulated sectors especially when it came to news, so life was a bit easy for news media organizations.

However, this traditional model of subsidizing news gathering through advertising is struggling in the digital domain because there is all kind of competition on the digital platform. A chat application, a meme generator, content websites requiring no on-ground reporters, and of course, the social networking websites – all of these are competing against the news organizations on the digital platform.

In fact, news was a late entrant in the digital domain, and thus it had to adapt to already set standards – low advertising rates, a belief that information and knowledge should be free on internet (thus resistance to paying for information), and an unregulated jungle.

In such a scenario, the news industry needs to find new ways to make people pay, as advertising money is not enough. As of now, subscriptions are the only model most news organizations are trying when they get on to the digital format.

But how about putting your reporters on hire?

Let people hire the reporters for their information needs, and make payment for that because it’s a customized service. It can meet a part of the news gathering costs. Every reporter is not busy 24×7 and thus ‘idle resources’ could be utilized.

Say, I need to relocate to Indore from Kolkata. On a real estate website one particular flat interests me, but I don’t know about the locality. I try to contact a local reporter in Indore who gives me a customized report about the locality and other relevant information about moving in that area. A reporter can even provide a live video streaming for information (the way it is seen in Ola’s promotional video), say for an area where I just want to stay for a holiday.

That was my thought and proposal. I guessed that it will be met with internal resistance in a news organization, for it’s a sacrilegious to suggest that journalists should be hired for petty personal information requirements of common men. After all, journalism is such a great and respectable job that is about saving the world.

However, my ideas couldn’t even get to the resistance stage due to issues I mentioned earlier.

Ola won’t have any such resistance fortunately because drivers are under no such illusion that they are saving the world – while they actually save a lot of lives by driving responsibly – or that any job is petty.

However, I presume that Ola will not be charging for their ‘reporters on hire’ from the very first day. The initial avatar of Ola News Network could be hyperlocal news content destination – accessible for free – to start with and a part of the costs sustained through advertising – say the ‘reporters’ wearing some branded shirts. But if they don’t move to ‘reporters on hire’ model soon where common people pay for information gathering, I would be surprised.

And that model, where a reporter is directly interacting with the common person, can prove to be revolutionary.

Because what ‘reporters on hire’ essentially does, is not to lower the standard or stature of a reporter, but it does away with the middleman called ‘editor’.

Most user-based and transaction dependent technologies are actually about removing the middlemen, and it could be revolutionary for the news industry if the middleman called editor is removed.

It obviously paints a very scary picture too – of anarchy, fake news, etc. but these issues can be taken care of with some checks and balances in the systems and processes. Overall, I think more good than bad will come out of it. Primarily because free flow of information regarding current events is far more valuable.

An editor’s role has been corrupted by the traditional media over decades. Instead of becoming a person who goes for sanity-check and fact-check, the editor is mostly busy coloring an information from ideological and political perspectives and suppressing facts. We have seen how editors at one website told their own reporter not to talk about an attack on her (the reporter) for sake of ideological objectives.

So current news is not about what is happening on ground, but what a few editors want you to believe is happening on ground. You need the control.

Therefore, I believe that this ‘reporters on hire’ was badly needed so that information reaches a common man without the corruption of an editor.

Take this for example: you just read a news in The Indian Express that a person in Vadnagar in Gujarat was assaulted because he just uttered ‘ya allah’. You think Express is spinning news and truth is something else that assault for a couple of words. So you go to your Ola app, search for Vadnagar, see the reporters/drivers around that area, contact them to get you a first hand report, make the payment on the Ola app, and make your findings public shaming The Indian Express.

Pretty cool, isn’t it?

I don’t really know if Ola has this in mind, but as I said earlier, I would be surprised and shocked if they are not moving in this direction eventually.

And that’s where Ola will face its biggest resistance from. The way Ola and Uber revolutionized and changed the cabs industry, they can do the same to the news industry. The existing players won’t just watch idly their citadel being breached.

I foresee that soon Times Group or someone will raise an objection as to why Ola should be allowed to get into news gathering. They will talk regulations, journalistic standards, etc. and try to stop it or throw spanners using their clout.

My fear, however, is that Ola too might yield to the pressure and start hiring editors – the same politically and ideologically colored ones – to buy peace with the old news mafia. And that will be pretty sad.

For now, let’s see how this story unfolds. (update: yes, it can unfold as prank too, as was mentioned earlier, but let me emphasize. I so well wish someone does it!)

And if Uber is reading it, you can contact me 😉