Thursday, October 22, 2020
Home Opinions One of the 100 Lies of Kejriwal: The Truth about the High Court ruling...

One of the 100 Lies of Kejriwal: The Truth about the High Court ruling on ACB

As Delhi Govt. Completed 100 days in power, to mark the special occasion, Aam Aadmi Party held a public ‘cabinet’ meet at Connaught Place on 25th May, to highlight their achievements. What they chose to highlight instead was their apparent victory over the Centre citing that day’s Delhi HC order,  allegedly ‘striking down’ a MHA notification regarding  Delhi ACB.

Now most of the Media too proceeded to report same of how HC had quashed MHA notification regarding Delhi’s ACB (Anti Corruption Bureau) having limited jurisdiction over the Delhi Police which falls under the Central MHA.  (Read here)

My inquisition began after Kejriwal claimed that the MHA Notification has been struck down by a judgment of Delhi HC. Since Kejriwal does not really enjoy the reputation of being honest with facts, it prompted me to study the judgment he bragged about.

Facts about the Judgement itself

The judgment relates to a regular bail application filed under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The matter is titled as Anil Kumar Vs. Govt of NCT of Delhi and registered as Bail Application No. 878/2015.

The fact which needs to be underscored at the outset is that the court was proceeding under a criminal jurisdiction and not under the Constitutional or Writ jurisdiction. Therefore, the constitutionality of the Notification could not have been decided while exercising merely criminal jurisdiction.

Therefore, the only issue which the court was seized of was whether the applicant was entitled to the relief of bail or not. No other issue was under the consideration of the court. Hence, it goes without saying that the legality / constitutionality of the MHA Notification was far from being under the consideration of the court.

In Paragraph 34 of the judgment, the court made it explicitly restricted its findings and conclusions only to the extent of that case, i.e. the bail application under consideration.

 

  Union of India was not a party to said proceeding. Union of India was therefore not heard. Therefore, the legality / constitutionality of the MHA Notification could not have been decided without hearing the Union of India which is the issuing authority. The court was mindful of the said position. Therefore the following observations made by the court assume significance and debunk the claims of Kejriwal and coterie that MHA Notification has been struck down- This is an important constitutional issue which has bearing on executive authority of Union and the said issue cannot be finally determined without hearing Union and examining its stand  

 

Thus without slightest of doubt it is clear that the court did not decide the constitutionality / legality of the MHA Notification and the findings of the court do not go beyond the said particular bail application.

Hence the judgment has no bearing whatsoever on the Constitutionality / legality of the Notification.

Another important aspect of the matter is that the Notification which was discussed was the one issued on 23/07/2014 as can be seen from Paragraph 16 of the judgment.

The latest Notification of 21/05/2015 was not considered by the court. Only a fleeting, cursory reference is made to it in Paragraph 66 of the judgment.

My Conclusion

Two cardinal principles of law also make it abundantly clear that the judgment does not affect the MHA Notification. The first principle is known as Audi AlteramPartemwhich means that no party can be condemned unheard and no decision which materially affects the right of a party can be given without affording opportunity of hearing to it. Since Union was never heard in the said case, the court was not empowered to strike down the MHA Notification. The court was also mindful of the constraints and rightfully refrained. The second principle is that the court cannot travel beyond the scope of the case and cannot grant any such relief which is not claimed by any party. In the case in hand, the only relief claimed by the applicant was that of bail and the only contrary demand of the Govt of NCT of Delhi was to refuse bail. Therefore, the court had no other issue to decide and certainly not the issue of the constitutionality of MHA notification.

Thus the latest MHA Notification which is the bone of contention nowadays was not considered in with any seriousness in the said judgment. This further falsifies Kejriwal’s claim that the Notification has been struck down.

Therefore after a thorough reading of the judgment and with the understanding of law at my command, I say it without doubt that the claim made by Kejriwal is completely spurious and false.

The legal position as it stands today is that the MHA Notifications of 2014 as well as 2015 hold their ground. They have not been struck down by any court.

Despite this clear position, Kejriwal as usual twisted the facts and went on to peddle falsehood. It did not come as any surprise to see the main stream media readily lapped those claims up and painted a totally false picture that MHA Notification has been struck down. Some overzealous media houses even portrayed it as a huge victory of Delhi Govt over the Center which is far from truth.

That Kejriwal will twist the facts and make false claims is not at all surprising. Politicians do that quite often and a politician like Kejriwal has built his political career on such oblique practices. But really dismaying is the inability of media to comprehend the legal niceties. This brings out their desperation to stay ahead in the rat race by being the “quickest” or “fastest” in “Breaking” a news. While doing that all the basic journalistic principles of verifying the news, testing its authenticity, seeking expert opinion if the news is technical in nature (such as legal news, as is the case here) are thrown to the winds.
The real news and truth bear the brunt ultimately.

– by @BhateKetan. ILS alumnus. Lawyer. ( In co-operation with @RpG_89 )

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

Punjab’s new Agriculture Laws are hogwash meant to fool gullible farmers, violates the constitution: Read how

The Essential Commodities Act passed by the Punjab govt contravenes the constitution, adds opacity and infringes on the centre

How do Customs officials remove gold concealed in the rectum of smugglers? Things you never thought you’d want to know

Customs officials convince the smugglers to eject the gold from their rectum, or extract with the help of doctors

21 October 1943: Netaji Subhash had formed the Azad Hind Government, India’s ‘declaration of independence’

On October 21, 1943, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose announced the formation of the 'Arzi Hukumat-e-Azad Hind' or the provincial government of free India in Singapore and had declared war on the British Empire.

No, going to Dubai to buy the new iPhone 12 Pro is not cheaper than buying in India. Here is how

Dhruv Rathee criticised the 'Indian Tax System' by claiming that travelling to Dubai for buying an iPhone 12 Pro is cheaper than getting it from India.

Is somebody paying the “experts” to spread spurious narratives on Atmanirbhar Bharat?

A more self-reliant India, with a bigger industrial base, with lesser trade deficits was the need of the hour. Who could object?

Rahul Gandhi to help PFI member and Kerala-based ‘journalist’ Siddique Kappan who is accused of attempting to instigate violence in UP

The Congress leader met a delegation at Malappuram, Kerala on Monday and promised them to look into the issue of the arrest of 'journalist' Siddique Kappan.

Recently Popular

UK: 37-year-old paedophile named Rehan Baig jailed for raping chickens to death while his wife filmed it

Rhan Baig's wife had also joined him in the videos and at one point he alternated between having sex with his wife and the chickens.

‘Comedian’ Agrima Joshua, who calls herself ‘feminist’, passes offensive sexual comments against woman due to political differences

Agrima Joshua had earlier found herself in a controversy after insulting the Shivaji Maharaj memorial during a performance.

Caught on camera: NCP’s Nawab Malik ‘predicts’ Arnab will commit suicide as he will be ‘trapped’ in TRP case

Maharashtra minister Nawab Malik insists that though the BARC letter clears Republic TV's name, the police investigation 'will find evidence' against Arnab.

Pakistan in ‘civil war’ mode after Sindh Police and Army clash after police chief was kidnapped. Read details

A civil war is brewing in Pakistan after deadly clashes broke out between Sindh police and Pakistani army over the illegal detention of Sindh police chief.

Remember Sheena Bora case? Param Bir Singh was the IG of Konkan range, the site where her body was dumped

Param Bir Singh knew that Sheena Bora was missing. He had asked Rahul Mukerjea to file a 'missing persons' report. Sheena, however, was never reported as 'missing'.

Paris: Two Muslim women stabbed under Eiffel Tower by white women shouting “dirty Arabs”

Two Muslim women were stabbed repeatedly under the Eiffel Tower on Sunday night by two white women who called them "dirty Arabs".
- Advertisement -

Another contempt case? Prashant Bhushan targets CJI Bobde again, links his home visit during holidays with Madhya Pradesh MLA disqualification case

CJI is eligible for state arranged transport during visits to states, but Prashant Bhushan alleged CJI Bobde of taking favors from MP govt

Shahabuddin was a powerful ‘pawn’ under Lalu-led government in Bihar: Read how he dominated Siwan during the jungle raj

Shahabuddin was fearless because of the backing he got from Lalu Yadav, and in return, he made sure Lalu got votes in the elections

Maharashtra: Uddhav Thackeray government blocks CBI from investigating cases in the state, withdraws general consent

The Maharashtra government on Wednesday passed an order withdrawing its consent for the CBI to probe cases in the state

Punjab’s new Agriculture Laws are hogwash meant to fool gullible farmers, violates the constitution: Read how

The Essential Commodities Act passed by the Punjab govt contravenes the constitution, adds opacity and infringes on the centre

Paris: Two Muslim women stabbed under Eiffel Tower by white women shouting “dirty Arabs”

Two Muslim women were stabbed repeatedly under the Eiffel Tower on Sunday night by two white women who called them "dirty Arabs".

How do Customs officials remove gold concealed in the rectum of smugglers? Things you never thought you’d want to know

Customs officials convince the smugglers to eject the gold from their rectum, or extract with the help of doctors

Fake news peddler Prashant Kanojia granted bail by Allahabad High Court

Kanojia was also arrested last year for postin derogatory tweets aimed at spreading hatred.

Youth Congress chief spreads misinformation about Modi govt’s Bihar package, distorts statement of BJP chief JP Nadda

Youth Congress chief uses only a part of speech of JP Nadda to spread misinformation about Modi govt’s Bihar package

21 October 1943: Netaji Subhash had formed the Azad Hind Government, India’s ‘declaration of independence’

On October 21, 1943, Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose announced the formation of the 'Arzi Hukumat-e-Azad Hind' or the provincial government of free India in Singapore and had declared war on the British Empire.

China fines dairy company for ‘incorrect’ map of its territory in an advertisement, the company issues apology

China penalised Bright Dairy and Food for not showing 'complete and correct territory' of the country, which is a violation of laws

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
465,750FollowersFollow
18,800SubscribersSubscribe