HomeNews ReportsWhat's in a name: Mumbai's Dadar Metro Station renaming to Chaityabhoomi sparks fierce debate...

What’s in a name: Mumbai’s Dadar Metro Station renaming to Chaityabhoomi sparks fierce debate in Maharashtra; read about the Shivaji vs Ambedkar row and its fallout on the ground

Nilesh Nikam and his 16-year-old son were attacked after the latter shared an allegedly contentious Instagram story with Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj in the background. They were also made to apologise close to an Ambedkar statue. Nikam was taken to hospital after the assault but was declared dead.

A consequential political and ideological trend has been recurring in Maharashtra, where Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj and Dr BR Ambedkar, two historical figures who lived in entirely different eras, have repeatedly become the centre of conflicts, both online and offline, even taking a disturbing turn into physical assaults and even death.

According to reports, a man named Nilesh Nikam was killed on 10th November after his 16-year-old son posted a supposedly controversial Instagram story featuring Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj in the background. The incident took place in Bhalegaon village in Mehkar tehsil of Buldhana district. The teenager apologised and promised not to repeat the alleged mistake.

However, the accused not only forced both him and his father to apologise near a statue of Dr BR Ambedkar but also brutally assaulted them. The attack ultimately claimed the older man’s life. Afterwards, a complaint was registered against 20 perpetrators, and 15 had been arrested.

It is important to note that there is no credible information about the identities of the accused or Ambedkar’s mention in the youngster’s story, but the act of an apology before his statue appears to carry a certain indication.

What’s in a name: The Dadar Metro Station edition

This contest has also extended to official decisions concerning the naming of places after them. The Maharashtra government recently decided to rename Mumbai’s Dadar Metro Station on the Aqua Line (Line 3) as Chaityabhoomi, after the site where Ambedkar was cremated.

The move triggered strong reactions, with one section asserting that people would continue to call it Dadar regardless of what they described as an unnecessary development. Others welcomed the step, while some remained largely indifferent, maintaining that their only concern was convenient travel.

However, the disagreement continued to escalate on social media as Ambedkar supporters fumed over the objection, claiming that this has been a common practice after independence. “What is now Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus, or CSMT, in Mumbai was known as Victoria Terminus (VT) during British rule. Construction of this magnificent station began in 1878, and in 1887 it was named Victoria Terminus after Queen Victoria of Britain,” a person wrote.

“The name remained unchanged for many years after independence. However, in 1996, the Maharashtra government renamed it Chhatrapati Shivaji Terminus (CST). Then, in July 2017, it was renamed Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj Terminus (CSMT),” the user remarked, asking, “Did those opposing the renaming of Chaityabhumi today use the same arguments about history, tradition and the principles of renaming that they are now making?”

The comment mentioned that the demand had been raised by Ambedkarite organisations and followers and subsequently accepted by the government, adding, “How justified is it to honour one great man’s name while objecting to naming a place associated with another great man’s memory?”


However, the statement drew further backlash, with an individual sarcastically suggesting that the country be renamed “Chaityasthan” and the state “Chaityarashtra,” while making it compulsory for every newborn to have “Jai Bhim” prefixed to their name because people could be made to respect Ambedkar through such measures, rather than by reading or learning about him.


A netizen emphasised that the two could not be compared, highlighting that while Ambedkar was great, placing him on the same pedestal as Shivaji Maharaj was going too far.


Another pointed out that Ambedkar was originally Bhimrao “Bhiwa” Sakpal, questioning, “Why not refer to Dadar Metro Station as Sakpal Station? Why be so proud of a borrowed name?”

However, a furious account, Sumedh, declared him “a global leader of social justice, world-renowned economist and only 2nd Indian leader to have a statue at UNESCO (the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation),” alleging, “Shivaji wasn’t even a king of one division of Maharashtra.”


This led to another round of arguments, with a person reminding about purported “global leader” Ambedkar’s defeat in the 1952 elections. However, the Ambedkarite contended that electoral victories are not the only measure of a leader’s success, citing late Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and termed him a statesman.


“Obsidian Hades” countered the remark by outlining that Shivaji Maharaj was both a popular leader and a statesman, placing him above Ambedkar, to which Sumedh replied that he was reportedly “the mansabdar of the 3.5 district. Ambedkar’s Constitution is implemented in the entire Republic of India.”

A similar comment insulted Shivaji Maharaj as a “Shudra who bought the status of ‘Kshatriya’ by paying a bribe and put on the crown. Aurangzeb then placed him among lower-ranking mansabdars. Highly overrated pathetic loser clown.”


The opposition to the station’s renaming angered an Ambedkarite to the extent that he resorted to making deeply offensive slurs against Marathi Buddhists who support Maharashtra Dharma. The sentiment also attracted firm criticism, which characterised Ambedkarites as “frail-minded” and accused them of having such a weak sense of Marathi identity that they “go into a complete breakdown and want to part with their Marathi identity when someone opposes the name change of a railway station,” denouncing them as a stain on Ambedkar’s intellectual legacy.

The growing Ambedkar-Shivaji flashpoint

The controversy over the Dadar Metro Station’s name change has further intensified an already heated debate in Maharashtra. Notably, on the one hand, the two sides are at loggerheads with each other, while on the other, positive posts featuring photographs of Shivaji and Ambedkar have also surfaced.

A post read, “Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj did not merely establish a kingdom but laid the foundation of a just and ideal tradition of governance,” attributing the remark to Ambedkar.

A post stated that the very Manusmriti that was allegedly quoted to oppose Shivaji’s coronation was the same text that Ambedkar publicly burnt on 25th December 1927.


However, beyond these social media uploads, the issue has also been marked by heated exchanges online, with repercussions spilling onto the streets. This was not limited to the recent incident but was also witnessed in 2024, when two policemen were injured, one of them grievously, after a large crowd pelted them with stones during an agitation by Dalits in Amravati, reported Hindustan Times.

The dispute arose after a group of Khanampur Pandhari village residents sat in protest outside the Divisional Commissioner’s office to demand that a welcome arch be built in Ambedkar’s name. However, others wanted the honour to be reserved for Shivaji Maharaj. The tensions prompted a curfew in the area.

Chandrakant Patil, then guardian minister, proposed to name the arch after both of them as a compromise and also committed funds for the construction. The demonstrators, however, demanded a written commitment. Afterwards, over 250 members of the hamlet’s Dalit community rejected Patil’s submission and staged an agitation over their demand. 

Hence, Saurabh Katiyar, the district collector, issued an order which pronounced that the arch would be assigned a name only after a decision was reached in the coming days, rather than immediately. However, the enraged protesters started hurling stones at the cops after ignoring the order. As a result, tear gas and water cannons had to be deployed alongside a mild lathi charge. Police vehicles were vandalised, and two personnel were wounded and brought to a local government hospital.

Conclusion

The recent incidents, whether surrounding the row over the metro station or the targeting of Nilesh Nikam and his minor son, are an offshoot of the same friction, in which one aggressive side appears unwilling to tolerate any challenge to their views and wants complete conformity.

These episodes could take the local political landscape of Maharashtra in new and even uncharted directions, and how they further unfold remains to be seen. One thing, however, is certain. Those responsible for taking a man’s life and thrashing an adolescent must be brought to justice, as some matters rise above politics and concern the fundamental principles of justice, law and order.

Join OpIndia's official WhatsApp channel

  Support Us  

For likes of 'The Wire' who consider 'nationalism' a bad word, there is never paucity of funds. They have a well-oiled international ecosystem that keeps their business running. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Rukma Rathore
Rukma Rathore
Accidental journalist who is still trying to learn the tricks of the trade.

Related Articles

Trending now

- Advertisement -