Home Blog Page 3730

J&K terror financing: Modi govt may soon ban all Hurriyat Conference factions. Read details

The Modi government may soon ban all factions of the Kashmiri separatist organisation Hurriyat Conference as an “unlawful organisation” under Unlawful Activities Prevention Act (UAPA) for their leaders’ involvement in terror financing in Jammu and Kashmir, according to a report in Times of India.

According to the report in TOI, sources in the intelligence agencies said that the Modi government might decide to ban all factions of the Hurriyat Conference including the faction that was led by now dead Syed Ali Shah Geelani. The government plans to ban these factions under Section 3(1) of the UAPA.

Earlier, the Jammu and Kashmir government along with NIA had submitted input to the Home Ministry about the Hurriyat Conference financing terror in the state. The Home Minister had then sought additional information from NIA and the state govt. The sources informed TOI that the additional data that was sought has now been submitted to the MHA and therefore, the decision to ban the factions may come soon.

An officer, speaking to Times of India said that even though several leaders of the Hurriyat have been in jail in the past couple of years and agencies have cracked down on terror financing, a ban on Hurriyat would help curb terrorism further. He said it would help the agencies curb the community level fund collection that is carried on by the Hurriyat conference. Thereafter, that money is given to subversive elements in Kashmir under the instructions of Pakistan’s ISI. The officer further said that with a UAPA ban, the government would be able to crack down not only on terror financing but also on the routes of financing used by Hurriyat. One of the major routes through which money for terrorism is raised in the sale of medical seats in Pakistan’s colleges from its quota and then channeling that money to fund terrorism in Kashmir.

The ban would also mean that Hurriyat would have to dismantle all its offices and infrastructure and the calls to Bandh and protest would automatically be considered illegal.

Once the government decides to ban the Hurriyat Conference, the government would announce the decision in the official gazette. Thereafter, the decision would have to be approved by the committee that has been formed under UAPA to ratify such decisions.

Busting the Hindu Vs Sikh narrative: How Hindus saved and helped Sikh Gurus, provided weapons training and donated for Gurudwaras

Many Sikhs today continuously try to draw differences between Hinduism and Sikhism. They describe Sikhism as a huge advance over Hinduism. Due to this increasing Hinduphobia among this particular section of the Sikh community, a false narrative is peddled that the Hindus in India were only saved from Islamic invader Aurangzeb’s atrocities and barbarism because the Sikh Guru paid the highest sacrifice for members of ‘other’ religious community and did us Hindus a favour.

On February 9th, 2021, Harsimrat Kaur Badal, an Akali Dal leader stated angrily in the Lok Sabha: “It was our Guru Tegh Bahadur who got beheaded to save your Tilak and Juneau.” When a BJP MP asserted that the Gurus belonged to Hindus as well, Harsimrat Kaur vehemently denied the notion, emphasising that the Gurus only belonged to Sikhs.

A similar narrative was spread during the ‘farmers’ protest, which eventually led Prime Minister Narendra Modi to announce the withdrawal of all three agricultural laws that were passed for the benefit of the farmers.

Yograj Singh, the father of ex-cricketer Yuvraj Singh, had while addressing the farmers last year, proudly reiterated the sentiments with similar rue. “Inki aurate take-take ke bhaw bikti thi” (their women were sold for two cents). When their women and daughters were abducted by people like Ahmed Shah Durrani and sold off for a paltry sum, it was we Sikhs who saved them, Singh had said.

Due to this discord between the Hindus and Sikhs, the latter probably needs to revisit history. In this article, we revisit how Mirza Raja Jai Singh I and his son Ram Singh protected Guru Tegh Bahadur from opponents within his own Sikh community.

This is the second article of OpIndia’s Hindu-Sikh history series. In the first, we discussed how Guru Nanak’s sons deviated from his father’s path and created the ‘Udasi Panth.’ In addition, the Hindu king had bequeathed his palace to the Connaught Palace Gurdwara in Delhi.

The fact is that until Guru Arjan Dev, the fifth Sikh Nanak (Guru), had the leadership in his hands, Sikhism was never regarded as a separate faith from Hinduism. Till then, Sikhism was not treated as a distinct religion but just a separate sect. Under the leadership of the first five Gurus, Sikhism emphasized universal selflessness and brotherhood. Till then, the Sikhs had not taken up arms. It was the atrocities and barbarism of the Islamic invaders, which had compelled the Sikhs to take up arms. In fact, it was under the leadership of the sixth Sikh guru, Guru Arjan’s son Hargobind that the Sikh community became militarized.

When Guru Arjan Dev was summoned to Lahore by the Mughal Emperor Jahangir, the fifth Sikh Guru possibly suspected that he might never return. Thus before leaving for Lahore, he appointed his son Hargobind as his spiritual successor on May 25, 1606. The 11-year-old became the sixth Sikh Guru.

The execution of Guru Arjan Dev by the Mughal emperor Jahangir in 1606 went on to become a watershed moment for the fledgling Sikh community. As Guru Hargobind took up the Akal Takht or the Eternal Throne after his coronation by ‘Baba Buddha’ he made military training important for his followers, as he remembered his father’s supreme sacrifice.

From that day onwards, Guru Hargobind started carrying two swords. The swords symbolised the philosophy of Miri-Piri. The first sword, Miri, represented temporal power, while the second sword, Piri, represented spiritual prowess. Guru Hargobind redefined the Guru’s persona from that of a spiritual leader to that of a warrior by completely changing the attire.

In addition, he established an army known as the Sant Sipahi, or Saint Soldiers. Soldiers trained in an akhara built in front of the Akal Takht, and combat exercises became a regular feature of the Guru’s camp. As part of their tributes, the Guru instructed his devotees to offer him arms and horses rather than money.

Guru Hargobind transformed the nature of devotional singing, which had been an important aspect of Sikhism since Guru Nanak. His court was dominated by Var or epic combat songs. The execution of Guru Arjan Dev was exemplified as a symbol of sacrifice for the truth. Sikh devotees were instructed to follow the example of Guru Arjan Dev. Guru Hargobind told them it was un-Sikh to endure injustice.

So, it would be ridiculous to assert that Sikhs acquired weapons for the sake of Hindus. The truth is that after Guru Arjan’s execution, the Sikhs took up arms to defend themselves against the Mughal atrocities.

Hindus formed an essential part of the Sikh army, were tasked with protecting the Gurus

Do you know that the Rajputs not only trained the Sikhs in fighting and made them a warrior community but also protected Guru Hargobind? It was only with the support of the Rajputs that the Sikhs formed such a fierce army that humbled the mighty Mughal forces on various occasions.

Moreover, Guru Nanak had also visited the Hindu pilgrimages of Kolayat and Pushkar, which were under the Rajputs. He got along well with the Rajputs of Manaswal (Doad). In fact, during his stay at Kartarpur, only a Rajput family would offer him food.

History has it that while Guru Hargobind was imprisoned by the Mughals in the Gwalior Fort, he met a number of Rajput monarchs, and when he was released, he recruited numerous Rajputs into his army.

Rajput warriors named Rai Sigra and Rai Jaita were instrumental in teaching Guru Hargobind and his troops how to use weapons. In the battle of Gurusar, the Rajput army had aided Guru Hargobind. In fact, when Mughal ruler Jahangir was compelled to release Guru Hargobind from the Gwalior Fort, he was accompanied by 52 Hindu princes who from that moment forth always remained loyal to him.

Likewise, Bajar Singh, a descendant of Rao Mandan Singh Rathore, trained Guru Gobind Singh in the intricacies of warfare, as well as in unarmed combat, equestrianism, armed combat, musketry, archery and foot tactics.

One might not be familiar with the name Alam Singh Chauhan Nachna. He was the son of Bhai Durgu, a Rajput of Sialkot who had headed Guru Gobind Singh’s army. Guru Gobind Singh regarded him as his most trusted confidant. He earned the epithet Nachna (dancer) because of his uncommon agility. On one occasion, when Guru Gobind Singh was suddenly attacked, Alam Singh Chauhan Nachna showed exceptional valour and rescued him with the army.

It is believed that Alam Singh Chauhan Nachna went on to play an extremely vital role in almost all the battles fought around Anandpur. As Guru Gobind Singh himself testifies in his Bachitra Natak, when the Khanzada, the son of Dilawar Khan the Subahdar of Lahore, tried to storm Anandpur at night, it was Alam Singh’s vigilance which alerted the Sikhs and forced the Khanzada to retire without completing his assault. Alam Singh sacrificed his life fighting for the Guru’s son Ajit Singh.

Some Sikhs aided the Mughals against their own Gurus

While Hindus always supported the Sikh Gurus, obeyed their orders and helped them, there were some Sikhs who had sided with the Mughals against their own people. One such was Ram Rai, the seventh Guru Har Rai’s eldest son, who had joined the Mughal tyrant Aurangzeb. Compelled by his desire to become a Nanak (guru), Ram Rai incited the Mughals and got Guru Tegh Bahadur arrested. At such a time too it was a Hindu ruler who stepped in to aide Guru Tegh Bahadur, the ninth Nanak, who was the leader of Sikhs from 1665 until his beheading in 1675.

History has it that Ram Rai was sent to Aurangzeb by his father Har Rai as a messenger, but his intentions altered. He formed the ‘Ramraiya’ sect, which was not recognised by the Sikhs. Ram Rai fell from grace when he performed miracles in Aurangzeb’s court and deliberately misinterpreted lines from the Adi Granth to please the Mughal emperor. Asked why Guru Nanak had criticised Islam in the verse Mitti Musalman Ki, Ram Rai satisfied the assembled people in Aurangzeb’s court by saying that the line had been copied incorrectly and that the actual writing was correctly Mitti Beimaan Ki and not Musalman ki. Pleased by Ram Rai, Aurungzeb gave him a jagir of four villages in the Doon area as a reward.

Though Ram Rai managed to please Aurangzeb, Guru Har Rai forbade all Sikhs from ever associating with Ram Rai. Displeased with his elder son Ram Rai, Guru Har Rai declared that his younger son Har Krishan the next Sikh Guru before he passed away in 1661.

Ram Singh got Guru Tegh Bahadur, 9th guru of the Sikhs, released from the captivity of Aurangzeb

Later, Aurangzeb arrested Guru Tegh Bahadur and brought him to Delhi. Aurangzeb issued the orders of Guru’s execution. It is said, Raja Ram Singh of Jaipur, the elder son of Mirza Raja Jai Singh I, pleaded for mercy and was able to convince the Mughal emperor who rescinded the order. He undertook full responsibility for Guru’s conduct to secure his release.

Guru Tegh Bahadur was later beheaded in 1675 on the commands of Aurangzeb for taking up the cause of Kashmiri Pandits and refusing to convert to Islam. Gurudwara Sis Ganj in Delhi is the place where he was beheaded and Gurudwara Rakab Ganj in Delhi is where he was cremated.

It is also recorded in history how Tegh Bahadur gained full backing from Raja Jai Singh against his opponents in his quest to become the 9th Guru.

The history of ‘Gurdwara Bangla Sahib’ in Delhi

Gurudwara Bangla Sahib, one of the most prominent Sikh gurdwaras, was originally Jaisinghpura Palace, a haveli of the Jaipur kings. It was originally a bungalow owned by Raja Jai Singh. It was in 1664 that Sawai Raja Jai Singh of Amber (Jaipur) hosted Guru Hari Krishan. The guru stayed there for about 8-10 months at a time of cholera and chickenpox epidemics.

Raja Jai Singh, who had also supervised the construction of nine Sikh shrines in Delhi in the same year, during the reign of Mughal Emperor, Shah Alam II, later donated the haveli (bungalow), where Sikh General Sardar Baghel Singh first built a small shrine in 1783. After Independence, the place saw rapid changes. The small shrine eventually went on to become the famous Gurudwara Bangla Sahib.

This is the second article of Hindu-Sikh history, you can read the first article here.

‘Don’t like it, don’t read it’: Delhi HC refuses to ban book by Salman Khurshid comparing Hindutva to ISIS, puts onus on govt

On Thursday (November 25), the Delhi High Court rejected a petition, seeking a ban on the newly released book titled, ‘Sunrise Over Ayodhya: Nationhood in Our Times’ by Congress leader Salman Khurshid.

The petition was filed by one Vineet Jindal through advocate Raj Kishore Chaudhary. He contended that the contents of the book could spark communal tension in the country. Chaudhary had emphasised how the house of author Salman Khurshid was attacked for drawing parallels between Hindutva and Islamist outfits such as ISIS and Boko Haram. “Even the author’s home in Nainital has been damaged… Though there have not been any significant incidents yet but it is likely to happen,” he added.

Advocate Raj Kishore Chaudhary pointed out that Article 19 of the Indian Constitution (Right to Freedom of Speech and Expression) was not absolute. “I am asking for this part to be removed. Communal riots start like this. At least notice should be issued,” he said while emphasising that reasonable restrictions have been placed on Article 19 of the Constitution. Chaudhary highlighted that Salman Khurshid had a large influence on society, owing to his status as a former MP and former Law Minister of India.

Delhi High Court asks people to not read by Salman Khurshid if they did not want to

While hearing the petition, the Delhi High Court stated that restrictions on the publication, circulation, sale and purchase of the contentious book can only be imposed by the government. A Bench led by Justice Yashwant Verma directed that people had the option to not read the book, authored by Salman Khurshid. It observed, “If you don’t agree with the author, don’t read it. Please tell people the book is badly authored, read something better…What can we do if people are feeling this? If they didn’t like the passage they can skip the chapter. They could have shut their eyes if they are feeling hurt.”

Salman Khurshid compared Hindutva to Islamic terror groups ISIS, Boko Haram in his book

In his book ‘Sunrise over Ayodhya’, Congress leader Salman Khurshid had compared ‘Hindutva’ to Islamic terror organisations like ISIS (Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) and Boko Haram. ISIS, one of the most dreaded Islamic terror groups has been responsible for terror attacks across the world in recent years. He made the comment in a chapter called ‘The Saffron Sky’ in the book.

In the chapter, Khurshid had said that in the current form, Hindutva is a political force and was cornering the ancient Hindu religion. Khurshid said that this politicising of Hinduism is akin to the Islamic terror groups ISIS and Boko Haram. Referring to the Ram Janmabhoomi movement as ‘Ayodhya saga’, Khurshid claimed that the Supreme Court judgement in favour of Ram Lalla Virajman was like one faith trumping the methods of another.

“Sanatan dharma and classical Hinduism known to sages and saints were being pushed aside by a robust version of Hindutva, by all standards a political version similar to the jihadist Islam of groups like ISIS and Boko Haram of recent years,” he said in his book.

Discussion on Conversion Jihad amounts to Islamophobia? NBDSA orders NewsNation to take down their show discussing the menace: Details

On November 6th, News Broadcasting and Digital Standards Authority (NBDSA) received a complaint regarding the ‘Conversion Jihad’ show aired by News Nation TV. On the 15th of November, NBDSA passed an inexplicable order where it urged the broadcaster to ensure that their anchor was “impartial”. The NBDSA directed the channel to take remedial action and even train their anchors in the appropriate “manner” to conduct the program.

Further, the NBDSA directed that all videos of the program should be taken down from all platforms within 7 days. If the videos were still up, the channel is supposed to inform the NBDSA in 7 days in writing. It is pertinent to note that News Nation TV had issued an unconditional apology for the show “Conversion Jihad” that they had broadcasted on their channel.

The NBDSA Chairperson Justice (retired) AK Sikri, observed that whenever any news story is telecast by the broadcaster, the Code of Ethics and Broadcasting Standards, Principles of Self-Regulations, Fundamental Principles and Specific Guidelines Covering Reportage relating to Impartiality, Neutrality and Fairness as also the Specific Guidelines Covering Reportage- Guideline No 9 relating to Racial & Religious Harmony, must be adhered to.

The NBDSA further took umbrage to certain statements made during the show by the anchor Deepak Chaurasia.

Some of the statements that NBDSA took offence to were:

  1. “Memchand zinda hai Jamaat sharminda hai”
  2. “500- Hindu kaise banaye Muslim?”
  3. “Kya Mewat Pakistan ban gaya?”

Retired Justice AK Sikri said that such statements violated the guidelines, principles and guidelines.

On YouTube, the video by NewsNation is now “private” and has been taken off air for common public.

YouTube video made private by NewsNation TV

What was the complaint against News Nation TV and their show ‘Conversion Jihad’

An NGO called CJP (Citizens for Justice and Peace) had lodged a complaint with NBSDA taking umbrage to the “Conversion Jihad” show by News Nation TV, anchored by Deepak Chaurasia. The complaint said that the anchor called one Maulana Syed Ul Qadri a ‘factory of lies’ and made him apologise on behalf of the entire Muslim community.

The complaint had also said that there was an “attempt” to promote “Islamophobic” ideas during the show saying that there is an attempt to promote anti-religious and anti-national activities by the Jamaat and that some clips on Twitter, that received thousands of likes and retweets promoted hate against the Muslim community. The NGO claimed that such programs must not be aired as they may hurt the “composite and diverse” culture of India and that it may lead to violence.

News Nation TV had in turn said that the channel or the anchor cannot be held responsible for statements made by the guests in the program, but, had tendered an unconditional apology if the statements had hurt anyone.

The NBDSA had ordered for the show to be deleted upholding the notion that any harsh reality being discussed in the media amounts to “Islamophobia”.

Is Conversion Jihad a figment of the imagination and a product of Islamophobia?

Conversion Jihad is a reality that the mainstream media, the organisations that govern the media and the political class, on the whole, wants to push under the rug. There are hundreds of cases where Hindu women were forcefully converted to Islam either by deceit or force. There are other cases where Hindu women were even brutally murdered and/or raped when they found out the real identity of the perpetrator and refused to convert to Islam. For example, there was a recent case in Surat when a Muslim man pretended to be a Hindu man. Thereafter, he abducted and raped Hindu women. Hundreds of such cases where Muslim men have pretended to be Hindu just to entrap Hindu women have been recorded.

Not just individual cases, which run in the thousands, but there have also been entire conversion rackets which have been unearthed by the security agencies.

The Anti-Terrorist Squad (ATS) of Uttar Pradesh police investigating religious conversion scam by Islamic scholar Maulana Kaleem Siddiqui and others have claimed to have detected the flow of foreign funds worth Rs 150 crore for the racket. While the investigation is underway, the above fund detected so far was invested in the illegal religious conversion activities in India. The fund mainly originated from Gulf countries Bahrain, Britain, Turkey and others.

The ATS has partially disclosed foreign funding in a charge sheet submitted before the court of the chief judicial magistrate of Lucknow against Rameshwar Kawade, Kausal Alam, Bhupriyo Bando alias Arslan and Faraz Shah of Maharashtra. They are among 10 accused arrested by ATS for carrying illegal conversion to Islam in Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra, Karnataka and other parts of the country. ATS alleged accused were working in a syndicate for a systematic conversion to alter the demographic structure and to create communal ill-will.      

According to a report, the fund was sent to Kaleem SiddiquiMaulana Umar Gautam and Salahuddin Zainuddin Sheikh. All three were arrested by ATS during the course of the investigation. Now the ATS is investigating background of organizations that provided funds to them.

Three organizations namely Islamic Dawah Centre, Fatima Charitable Trust and Al Hasan Educational & Welfare Foundation being run by Umar Gautam were used as fronts to receive foreign funds. In the last five years, Umar Gautam is accused to have received Rs 57 crore as foreign funds, out of which 60 per cent was used to run the conversion racket. Most of the fund was transferred by Britain based Britain-based Al Falah Trust. ATS said Kawade’s wife Maihasan Ali who is an Egyptian is a key foreign link of Umar Gautam.

In a 1860 page chargesheet filed by the Vadodara police recently, the police said that the key accused converted “100 to 200 Hindu girls to Islam and married them off” using the money, according to a charge-sheet filed by the police in a Gujarat court. CNN News 18 reported that, “The Vadodara police on Tuesday submitted the charge-sheet in the case wherein the managing trustee of a charitable trust and his aides had acquired foreign funds and illegally diverted them to covert people to Islam, build mosques and to provide legal help to anti-CAA protesters and rioters held in Delhi after the 2020 communal riots in the national capital”.

With such rampant forceful conversion of Hindu women to Islam, it is inexplicable why the NBDSA would consider a discussion on facts as “Islamophobia” just to maintain a modicum of political correctness.

Several Muslim women not issued admit card for Bengal police recruitment exam because of their Hijab-clad photos, HC steps in: Details

The Calcutta High Court has stepped in after Muslim women moved the court for being denied admit cards for the Bengal police recruitment exams. According to reports, over 1,000 Muslim women were not issued admit cards because they had affixed images of themselves wearing a Hijab. Calcutta High Court has stayed the recruitment process of the West Bengal Police Recruitment Board after a group of Muslim women filed a petition alleging their application forms for the recruitment of constables were rejected because of wearing Hijab (headscarf) in the photograph.

The Calcutta HC has had made the result of the recruitment process subject to its order. The matter has now been listed for hearing on the 6th of January 2022.

Excerpt from Court order (Order credit: LiveLaw)

“The petitioners question the rejection of their candidature for having applied with their respective photographs with headgear (hijab) as part of their religious practice when the face in the photograph is clear for necessary identification,” Justice Arindam Mukherjee noted.

The court then made the results for these candidates subject to its order, saying that an important point comes up for deliberation in this writ petition.

Background of the case and why the application forms of the Muslim women were rejected in the West Bengal police recruitment exam

The West Bengal Police Recruitment Board (WBPRB) had conducted a preliminary examination to recruit constables in the State police force on September 26th. The Board had issued admit cards on the 6th of September. According to the petitioners, close to 1000 Muslim women had not received their admit cards for the exams because they had suffixed hijab-clad pictures of themselves in the application forms.

The application forms were rejected on the basis of rules for the exams that states that the face of the candidates must not be covered in any manner in their applications forms.

Excerpt from Court order (Order credit: LiveLaw)

The petitioners, knowing this rule fully well, submitted pictures with hijab on. When rejected, they petitioned the court that the rejection and the rule itself infringes upon their right to practice their religion.

Mumbai court dismisses closure report by police, asks police to probe complaint accusing Sanjay Raut of harassment, torture, abuse

A city magistrate court has ordered the Vakola police station to continue investigating the stalking case filed by Marathi film writer and psychologist Dr Swapna Patker against Shiv Sena Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut in 2013.

According to an order made available on Wednesday, November 24, the court also dismissed the closure report the Mumbai police had submitted in the case stating that they could not find the unknown culprits. The chief metropolitan magistrate S B Bhajipale had rejected the ‘A-summary’ report of the police on November 18 and detailed order in the matter was made available now, reports Mid-Day.

An ‘A-summary’ report is a document used by the police to close an investigation, in which they believe that despite the existence of an offence, there is insufficient evidence against the accused.

Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate SB Bhajiale said in his order that the complainant had herself submitted names of suspected people, but the investigating officer did not bother to probe them. He added that the investigating officer had miserably failed to notice that the complainant was attacked on May 16, 2013, before the alleged incident on June 29, 2013.

The court stated that it is a well-established notion that an FIR is not a repository of information. It observed that the complainant’s (Dr Swapna Patker) statement was collected separately by a vigilant Inquiry Officer and its veracity was verified. However, the current Inquiry Officer has done nothing of the sort, said the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. He added that a further inquiry can be conducted based on the woman’s complaint in this case.

It may be noted that the Marathi film writer and psychologist Dr Swapna Patker had said in her protest petition against the Mumbai police’s closure report that the latter had not probed her husband, with whom she had strained relations, or the ‘political person’ Sanjay Raut.

Swapna Patker accuses Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut of 8 years of harassment, character assassination and abuse

She said that she had told the police that Raut was stalking her and following her and had removed the CDR from her phone, allowing them to track her whereabouts. She had further added that she had informed the officers in the Vakola police station that the Shiv Sena MP was providing perks to her husband to harass her, but that neither her husband nor the politician were ever investigated.

Notably, Patkar has been alleging that Sanjay Raut, co-editor of Shiv Sena mouthpiece ‘Saamana’, has been using his political clout and hold on the system for the last 8 years to not only assault her but to also harrass family and relatives.

In June this year, Patker was taken to Bandra Police station by police without any written summons, her advocate Abha Singh has said. Singh also alleged that she was not provided with an FIR copy before cops took her to the police station.

She had in April 2021, written a letter to Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in which she alleged that she is being harassed, tortured and abused by Shiv Sena MP and Editor of Saamana, Sanjay Raut, since the past eight years.

In her letter to the PM, Swapna alleged that her complaints were ignored by the police, Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray, ex-Home Minister Anil Deshmukh and other officials of Maharashtra as the perpetrator has a stronghold in the political party. 

Dr Swapna informed OpIndia that she used to write columns for Shiv Sena’s mouthpiece publication Saamna from 2009-2014 and also took care of some of Sanjay Raut’s Rajya Sabha work. However, when she decided to get back to her profession from her passion, Dr Swapna alleged that Sanjay Raut was not happy with her decision and started to heckle, harass and torture her. 

As 12 Meghalaya Congress leaders join TMC, Mallikarjun Kharge’s wishy-washy statement points towards party’s surrender to Mamata

The Congress party has been plunged into deep trouble in Meghalaya as 12 out of their 17 MLAs dumped them to join the Trinamool Congress Party (TMC) on Wednesday. The 12 also include former Meghalaya CM Dr Mukul Sangma. A formal announcement is said to be scheduled for Thursday. With 12 jumping ships, Congress will now be left with only 5 MLAs in Meghalaya.

LoP in Rajya Sabha for Congress and senior leader of the party, Mallikarjun Kharge, issued a wishy-washy statement explaining the steps the party plans to take after their leaders were abandoning them and joining TMC in Meghalaya.

“This is happening like a conspiracy. People of our party, especially our party pres, Rahul Gandhi & others in the high command are looking into it. They will make a decision”, said Kharge.

This seems like a mundane wishy-washy answer that Congress generally spouts when it has a larger or at least, a hidden agenda at play. Kharge essentially shifted the responsibility and said that the party would do “something” but gave no specific details of how the party actually views this development. These sort of statements essentially create the illusion that the person concerned is giving people some explanation but there is no tangible answer that has actually been given.

What Kharge said after this was far more telling than this statement itself.

Mallikarjun Kharge said that even though he senses a “conspiracy” in Congress leaders joining TMC, the party will still ally with TMC to defeat BJP regardless of the alleged difference in ideology.

“We will fight the issue of farm laws. We have also prepared a list of 15-16 issues on which we can come to an agreement & we will fight at the Parliament in unity”, he said.

Continuing his statement, Kharge said, “Org fights have always taken place,no use commenting now. Important to fight together in the arena of Parliament as Rahul Gandhi, in a core committee meeting of floor leaders, had said that parties may have different ideologies but our common goal is to fight BJP”.

These statements by Kharge points to how Congress seems to have completely surrendered to TMC and Mamata Banerjee.

First, Kharge alleged that this was a conspiracy. Now, since Congress leaders in Meghalaya joined TMC, one would presume that he was insinuating that there is a conspiracy by TMC to dismantle the Congress party in Meghalaya.

However, right after he alleges there was a conspiracy and says that “Rahul Gandhi will take a decision”, he goes on to say that Rahul Gandhi has already taken the decision to ally with TMC in the parliament and elsewhere to defeat BJP. This would therefore mean that the “conspiracy” statement was just a preface to give the impression that Congress was taking umbrage to their leaders joining TMC, but in tangible terms, they had no problem with the development since they had already surrendered to TMC.

It is pertinent to note that Congress perhaps knows that it is a spent force and is now trying to strengthen regional parties to defeat the BJP, a feat they are sorely incapable of. The shift of Congress leaders to TMC seems to be a part of that attempt pointing to the fact that Congress has decided to annihilate itself regionally to form a working alliance to defeat the BJP wherever it might be possible.

Seven-time national deaf chess champion Malika Handa rebukes Punjab govt for not providing her govt job despite repeated appeals: Details

Malika Handa, the specially-abled chess player from Jalandhar has made a desperate appeal to the Punjab government after it failed to provide her with a government job and financial support despite repeated reminders. Malika Handa has won several medals in national and international events, including a prestigious gold at World Deaf Chess Championship and a silver medal at the Asian Championship in Chess.

Out of the ten years that she has been playing the sport, she has spent seven urging the state administration to provide her with a job. 

On Wednesday, November 24, the seven-time national deaf chess champion posted a short video clip on her Twitter handle. Handa, who was visibly upset, displayed the several medals and trophies she had earned for the country and asked why the Punjab government was treating her so unfairly.

“I am very feeling sad Two Month gone No one invited me or talked regarding Cash award or Job from Punjab Govt I still waiting waiting Why why I m graduate,Intenational deaf Gold medal, 6 Medals world, Asian. Why why Punjab doing this??????,” the chess star wrote.

Malika breaks down outside the office of Director Sports Punjab on facing refusal

After completing her graduation, Handa had in September approached the Director, Sports Punjab, in Chandigarh, for a job and a financial reward. However, after receiving a cold response from the state government, she broke down outside the office. She had then taken to Twitter to express her agony in sign language. Her video had gone viral almost instantly, garnering her a lot of emotional support.

Malika’s father Suresh Handa had then stated: “Malika is very upset today. My son Atul Handa and I had accompanied her to the office of Director Sports, but she almost got a refusal. My daughter has been playing the game for the past 8-10 years and has been bringing medals for the country and the state just with a hope that these would fetch her job offer just like other Olympians and para-athletes.”

He said, “For the past two-three years, she has been told that she must complete her graduation to get a good government job. With high hopes she approached the Director of Sports today, she got the reply that there was no policy yet in the state to offer jobs to hearing-impaired athletes. This is the fag end of the tenure of the present government. If they have not made a policy till now, they will be able to make it even in the next three months. My daughter has lost all hopes and it is really difficult to convince her at this stage,” Suresh Handa added.

Meanwhile, Director Sports Kharbanda had justified the state government’s callousness by saying that the Punjab government has a policy for able-bodied players and para-athletes (arms and legs handicap) but none of the other 21 types of disabilities which includes blindness, hearing disorders or mental retardation.

Malika Handa appeals for a coach and a government job

In August, Malika Handa had urged the Punjab government to provide her with a coach and a government job. Tagging Punjab Sports Minister Rana Gurmit S Sodhi and Union Minster Anurag Thakur, Handa, asked why was the state administration ignoring her. “I m sitting at home why why Im getting depressed day by day No one sees my hard work,” she wrote. 

Renu Handa, the player’s mother had told ANI later that despite being a seven-time national champion, her daughter had received no recognition from the state government. “My daughter is the first Indian woman to win a gold medal in the International Deaf and Dumb Chess Championship. She also received a national award from President last year. She has received no appreciation from government despite being a seven-time national champion”, said Renu Handa. 

Bombay HC reduces death penalty of convicts in 2013 Shakti Mills rape case to life imprisonment: Here is what it said

0

The Bombay High Court Thursday, converted the death penalty given to three convicts in the 2013 Shakti Mills rape case to life imprisonment stating that the constitutional court cannot award punishment based on public opinion. Justices SS Jadhav and Prithviraj Chavan pronounced the order.

“The Shakti Mill gang-rape case has shocked the conscience of society. A rape victim suffers not just physically but mentally as well. It is a violation of human rights. But only public outcry cannot be taken into account. A death sentence is only an exception. Judgment should not be guided by public outcry. Death puts an end to the concept of repentance… It cannot be said the accused deserved the only death penalty. They deserved religious imprisonment for life to repent for the offence committed by them. Not to assimilate into society. There is no scope of reformation,” said the Bombay HC bench.

The accused will now be sentenced to spend the rest of their lives behind the prison, with no chance of parole or furlough, ensuring that they never interact with society. The offenders were sentenced to solitary confinement for the rest of their lives. “The accused will be unable to assimilate with society,” the bench stated.

In March 2014, three men were sentenced to death by a sessions court in the city. This was for the first time, repeat rape convicts were given capital punishment under new laws enacted in 2013.

The court held that the photojournalists’ case cannot be considered their second offence as both cases were tried simultaneously. And therefore conviction under 376(E) would not sustain.

2013 Mumbai Shakti Mills rape case

On August 22, 2013, a 22-year-old photojournalist and her male colleague went to Mumbai’s abandoned Shakti Mills for a photoshoot. There, five men accosted the duo. They tied the man and took turns to rape the woman. Aakash Jadhav, a juvenile, was one of the accused in the case.

As he was a minor at the time of the crime, he was sent to a remand home for reformation and was released a few years later. Aakash started his own criminal gang once he was released from the correctional facility.

The Mumbai Police had cracked the case within 24 hours and arrested all the accused within a week. Emboldened by the swift action, a 19-year-old telephone operator approached the police a month later to complain of gang rape by five men, at the same location on July 13, 2013. Qasim Shaikh, Salim Ansari and Vijay Jadhav were named and identified by both victims in rape trials that were heard simultaneously.

Opposition’s crocodile tears on fuel prices are just that: Crocodile tears. Here is a detailed analysis

That the Wuhan virus (and Covid-19 caused by it) has impacted the global economy severely, is no longer a hidden truth. Its aftermath tolling effects are out in the open and are being witnessed across geographies. The economic crisis that entailed the lockdowns due to the pandemic has sent commodity prices at all times high globally. 

One commodity that is the backbone of all human activity is petroleum and the rise in its prices came as almost the final knockout punch on the common man. It is true, however, that the soaring fuel prices is a global phenomenon and not limited to India. It is also true that the Covid-19 alone hasn’t buoyed the fuel prices.

A year and a half ago, when the crude oil global price hit a low of $19 per barrel, the OPEC (Organisation of Petroleum Exporting Countries) decided to cut oil production to boost the prices up. It’s simple demand and supply matrix. Owing to OPEC’s production cut decision and ease in Coronavirus related travel restrictions, the entire world is now facing a supply deficit as well as spurred demand which manifested, as OPEC desired, in October 2021, as Brent crude oil reached a 3 year high of over $85 a barrel. OPEC and its allies led by Russia has decided to gradually withdraw the supply cut only from 2022,  eradicating any hope of immediate relief from inflation in fuel cost worldwide. 

Unfortunately, however, each time the fuel prices rallied in India, Opposition led by Congress (INC) decried and held the Narendra Modi government responsible for it while deliberately choosing not to objectively access the dynamics that play a vital role in deciding petroleum products pricing, all the while seething over hefty VAT/ sales tax, which accounted for 41.67% of final petrol price, that Opposition ruled states too enjoyed levying over Petrol and Diesel.

When Opposition’s entire mourning over inflating petrol prices emanates from its compulsion to target the Modi government for factually no fault of its, it becomes necessary, before we plunge into the details of the hypocrisy of Congress-led opposition, to contemplate and unravel the mechanics of what goes behind the scheme of fuel pricing. 

The pricing of domestic petroleum products such as Petrol and Diesel consists of essentially 3 components (the fourth component is the commission paid to dealers, but it is so small compared to the other three components that it is not material) I) base price II) Excise duty levied by Central Govt and III) VAT/ Sales tax levied by State Governments.

The base price is essentially the cost of production that Indian refineries incur and is proportional to global crude prices. The higher the global crude oil price gets, the higher will the base price be. The Centre excise taxation amounted roughly only 30% while VAT or sales tax levied by State governments amounts more than 40%. It is to be noted that the central government had only a 30% stake while 70% of it (30% base price+ State’s 40% VAT) was beyond its control.

The state governments, including non-BJP/ Opposition-ruled states, levied a whopping 10% more than the Centre/ Modi government. It is worthwhile to note that while Central excise duties are fixed, the VAT levied by States are ad-valorem. What this means is that taxes levied by States go up with the price buildup of fuel and so does States’ share in overall fuel price. Modi government on various occasions has accepted that rallying fuel price is a burden on the common man and appealed for a joint call of both Centre and States on tax cuts. If the Opposition was even one bit serious and concerned about the perils of the general populace due to the rise Modi government on various occasions has accepted that rallying fuel price is a burden on the common man and appealed for a joint call of both Centre and States on tax cuts.

If the Opposition was even one bit serious and concerned about the perils of the general populace due to the rise in fuel prices, it would have immediately reduced the tax that states ruled by them levied on petroleum. The opposition instead chose to engage in mere mudslinging on Modi Government. 

However, given the sensible and decisive leader that Prime Minister Narendra Modi is, on 3 November, a day ahead of Diwali, he decided to slash the Central levies on petrol by ₹5 a litre and on diesel by ₹10 a litre, in an attempt to unilaterally provide a major relief to Indian people. All BJP ruled States and UTs immediately emulated the Centre by bringing substantial reductions in petrol and diesel by up to ₹13.5 and ₹20 per litre, respectively. Almost 10 days have passed and there has been no petrol tax cut in 9 non-BJP or Opposition-ruled states. These states are Andhra Pradesh, Chattisgarh, New Delhi, Jharkhand, Kerala, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu, Telangana and West Bengal. 

The saga of the Opposition’s hypocrisy doesn’t end here. Soon after fuel prices in all BJP-ruled States and UTs fell down below ₹90/₹100, Opposition leaders expressed their inability to cut VAT on fuel in states ruled by them due to the GST dues and compensation that they claim the Modi government hasn’t cleared to States ruled by them. Some Opposition leaders even accused the Modi government of using fuel prices as a political tool. Mamta Banerjee, TMC Leader and Bengal CM claimed ₹45000 crores in GST compensation. Sharad Pawar used the same line too. 

It is no secret that Congress and its allies in the opposition have the clinical habit of lying upfront when it suits them politically. But should their convenient lies become an inconvenience for the common people? The truth is there is no connection between GST compensation and States’ ability to cut VAT on fuel. If that was indeed the case, how could BJP ruled States and UTs lower their VAT?

The Central government has always been prompt in releasing GST compensation to States. During the pandemic, it has gone several steps beyond this. Realising that the pandemic was having a short-term impact on GST and Compensation cess collections, the Centre, in order to ensure that States don’t suffer, set up a back-to-back borrowing system so that States were compensated adequately and on time. For the 2020-21 GST compensation, the Centre committed to compensating for the entire ₹ 2.35 lakh crore of losses that the States bore during the pandemic in the GST council.

It is to be noted that in the GST council meet when States were given two options on how they would like to be compensated, all the States opted for the same option wherein the Rs 1.1 lakh crore loss attributable to GST implementation would be compensated that year itself and the balance would be compensated by extending the GST compensation cess over the five years it was meant to be in effect. Out of which, ₹1.1 lakh crore has already been compensated, and the GST Council has agreed to extend the GST Compensation Cess past 2022 (when it was originally meant to be removed).

Moreover, in order to provide State Governments with the fiscal flexibility to ensure a strong economic recovery from the pandemic in their regions, the Centre front-loaded its releases of compensation in 2021-22. In just 3 trenches, the Central government released the entire year’s compensation amount of ₹1.59 lakh crore to States within the first 7 months of the financial year itself. Therefore, to argue that there is still some pending GST compensation that is due is a factually incorrect argument as it was agreed by the GST Council that the pending amount would be due only after the completion of the first five years of GST, which is not over yet.

The opposition led by Congress has time and again used the common man as a pawn and their perils as merely an opportunity to settle political goals. It is a tragedy that the opposition used a global tragedy as a political instrument to frame the Modi government. Now that the ball is in their court, the Opposition is still to practice what they’ve been preaching to Modi.

The MVA government in Maharashtra has slashed excise duty on imported liquor by 50% but hasn’t cut VAT on petrol and diesel products. The Opposition’s priorities are clear. In Maharashtra, the rich can now have their scotch cheaper whereas the common man, the poor, continue to suffer and bear the brunt of high fuel prices. It won’t be an exaggeration to say that they weep crocodile tears for the poor and disadvantaged, but are basically happy with things as they are. It is our duty and obligation to expose the Opposition‘s deceiving lies, propaganda and treachery tirelessly.