Home News Reports From Dadri to Haryana to Manipur, how stories about crimes against Dalits and Minorities have panned out

From Dadri to Haryana to Manipur, how stories about crimes against Dalits and Minorities have panned out

In the run-up to the Bihar elections, media reported many atrocities and crimes taking place all over India, and most of such stories which were heavily highlighted by media related to crimes against minorities and dalits. As the dust settled though, much like the unfolding of the “church attacks” bogey, many of these stories revealed some alternate versions which question the premise of rising intolerance and communal violence

1. Dalit family stripped by police.

A facebook page named as “DALIT Parivar – The Rising Shudra – dedicated to Dr. Bhim Rao Ambedkar” posted a video claiming that a Dalit family in UP was stripped by police. This was first picked up by a site called Daily Sikh Updates, (who later deleted the story) and later by news sites like The Hindu and DNA . The video in fact was inconclusive and could not prove that the family had been forced to strip. DNA did mention this in their piece, but only as a byline. India Today however carried a story that the family had stripped on its own accord, as a sign of protest. A ground report from Caravan also supported this theory and also revealed that Sunil Gautam, a member of the family was commonly found doing such antics. Eventually SP Noida also clarified that the family was not stripped by the cops but it was done by themselves. We had covered this in our “Media lies” post for October.

- Ad - - article resumes -

2. Dadri Mob lynching of Akhlaq over beef

We are all too familiar with this news, which was a sort of inflection point for the entire “intolerance” debate. We were told that a lynch mob, on the basis that a Muslim had eaten beef, attacked him and beat him to death. Today a story has emerged from Dadri, with an eyewitness saying beef may not have been the reason. He says the murder was orchestrated by a handful of people and not a mob. He says the main motive was some personal enmity. He asks why Akhlaq’s son Danish, who had suffered injuries and was the prime witness, hasn’t been approached by the cops even though he is out of hospital now. He asks why the piece of cow hide was so far away from “beef eater” Akhlaq’s house. While this may not be enough to conclusively prove anything, these are pertinent questions which raise doubts about the original narrative.

3. Khap orders rape of Dalit sisters

Amnesty International, the human rights group, hosted a petition to help 2 dalit sisters in UP, who were apparently ordered to be raped by a Khap Panchayat. According to a news report, one of the sisters also moved court. But after the story gained much international traction thanks to Amnesty, some issues began coming up. BBC visited the said village and the villagers said there was no such order passed. The local police also said that their investigations revealed that there was no such order passed. The village council also denied such allegations. When asked, Amnesty spokesperson Gopika Bashi said:

“We have not been on the ground, we have not visited the village, We still believe that whatever has occurred, regardless of allegations being thrown back and forth that it’s very important that the family is safe and the girls are safe.”

Apparently Amnesty’s petition, which went viral all over the world, was based solely on the application made by one of the sisters to the court. In such cases it is hard to say which version is the truth, but fact remains that it wasn’t a clear cut case as it was made out to be by Amnesty.

4. Man killed for ‘stealing’ calf in Manipur

This story said that the headmaster of a school, Md Hasmad Ali was beaten to death after he was seen with a calf that was missing from the shed of one of the villagers. This lynching story was picked up even by NY times to further their anti-India propaganda. Even though the media had made up its mind, Ali’s elder son said something different:

It’s a cold blooded murder because of some land dispute. The murderers shift the blame on another community and take advantage of the (sensitive) functioning of the society.

The son further blamed his father’s death on a personal land dispute with his neighbour and also distant relative, Mohammad Amu, and Amu’s brother. The family said that Amu tried to mask his personal enmity by using communal overtones to shift the blame elsewhere even as he was settling scores with his enemy. Also, the “Meeteis” have been characterised as Hindus, by national media, who killed a Muslim. But a member of the Meetei ethnic group staunchly opposes  being homogeneously identified with being Hindu or Hinduism. In his detailed account of the incident, he mentions how no-one in the village bought the cow story and that Ali, the deceased, was a well to do, respectable citizen who would never need to steal a calf.

5. Dalit children burnt alive by Upper castes in revenge killing

News channels went into overdrive discussing this revenge murder of dalit children by upper caste Rajputs. TV debates were centred around growing intolerance and rising incidents of violence. An angle was dug which said this murder was a revenge for the children’s family being involved in some murder, a year back. But a few days later, as investigations went ahead, initial theories were trashed. Forensic experts who investigated the crime scene concluded that the “origin and source of fire was from inside the room and not from outside”. They found a half-burnt kerosene oil plastic bottle under the partially burnt bed and a burnt matchstick lying on a slab next to the window of the room. The report also apparently mentioned that there were “no traces of outside entry” into the premises. There are many other inconsistencies between the forensic report and the version which was publicized. Again, too early to say either ways but premature outrage won the battle.

6.  90-yr-old Dalit man burnt alive for trying to enter temple in UP

The story claimed that an old Dalit man was killed because he tried to enter a temple in Uttar Pradesh. Embedded image permalinkThis was subsequently picked up by various media outlets. But other media houses reported that the Dalit man was in fact killed by a drunkard. They reported that the Dalit man was going to the temple, when he was asked for money by a drunkard. When he refused, the drunkard hit him with an axe, and later burnt his body. This was also confirmed by the District Magistrate. Indian Express also confirmed the money angle and further reported that the deceased was in fact coming out of a temple and that too a temple built by members of the SC community. So the bogey raised by Hindustan Times was proved to be totally untrue. We had covered this in our “Media lies” post for October.

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Big Story

The anchor of Suvarna news, Jayaprakash Shetty has now asked for the arrest of scientist Ranganathan for claiming Mysore Pak belonged to Tamil Nadu in a sarcastic Tweet

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

Rakesh Jhunjhunwala slams notions of economic crisis gripping the country

“I don’t want Pappu to be my Prime Minister”: Investor Rakesh Jhunjhunwala says PM Modi has performed very well

In an explosive interview, Rakesh Jhunjhunwala pulled no punches in rubbishing the doomsayers casting aspersions on Modi government

Prashant Kishor’s team starts reaching out to media and influencers with ‘paid content’ offers ahead of West Bengal assembly elections

Darjeeling Chronicle has exposed how Prashant Kishor led IPAC is reaching out to 'influencers' and digital portals to carry out paid campaigning for TMC and Mamata Banerjee ahead of 2021 West Bengal state elections

‘Kashmir free from shackles of Pakistan sponsored terrorism’: Pakistani org representing Pashtuns refuses to support Imran Khan’s Kashmir protest, backs India

Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement (PTM), the principal body representing Pashtuns in Pakistan, has rejected Prime Minister Imran Khan’s recent call to all people in which he urged them to come out and support Pakistan’s narrative on Kashmir. 
Image Source: twitter

Malala Yousafzai spreads fake news, claims girl from Kashmir missed her exams on August 12 which was an Eid holiday

According to Malala, one of the three girls from Kashmir missed her exams on August 12. However, August 12 is a notified holiday declared across the country by Government of India on the occasion of Bakr Id or Eid ul-Adha.
Sharad pawar invents a new excuse to shift the blame of the defeat in the Lok Sabha polls

Pakistan hospitable, BJP govt spreading lies about Pakistan for political gains: NCP supremo Sharad Pawar at minority event

NCP chief Sharad Pawar expressed his admiration for terror state Pakistan stating that the people of Pakistan are "very hospitable" while blaming BJP govt for spreading lies about Pakistan for political gains
Stopped for traffic rules violation, Delhi girl threatens suicide

Watch: Stopped by traffic cops, Delhi girl threatens with suicide, helmet attack and then her mother

The girl was reportedly stopped for the broken license plate on her two-wheeler. When the traffic police demanded to see the scooter's documents, she stated that she had no papers.

West Bengal: Majidur Rahman fakes Hindu identity to develop relationship with Hindu girl, later rapes and murders her

Married Majibur developed relation with Jaba pretending to be Hindu Pintu. rapes and murders her when pressed for marriage

Suvarna news anchor wants scientist arrested for his sarcastic Tweet about ‘Mysore Pak’, claims his act was ‘seditious’

The anchor of Suvarna news, Jayaprakash Shetty has now asked for the arrest of scientist Ranganathan for claiming Mysore Pak belonged to Tamil Nadu in a sarcastic Tweet

Kannada media spreads fake news, accuses Nirmala Sitaraman of ‘giving’ Mysorepak to Tamil Nadu

No one had expected that a huge controversy would erupt over the issue of Mysore Pak, which originated in Mysuru during the rule of Wodeyar dynasty.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

182,775FansLike
180,136FollowersFollow
97,390SubscribersSubscribe
Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post