Rahul Gandhi’s attacks about Tata factory at Sanand is example of either big lies or nano brains

With the Assembly elections in Gujarat literally just around the corner, it has become a no-holds-barred contest between every political outfit in the state. While I won’t be talking of the ground situation here, I do have some thoughts about a section of Rahul Gandhi’s campaigns – the repeated attacks on the Tata Motors’ manufacturing facility in Sanand in the Ahmedabad district.

The alleged resurgence of Congress’ “perpetual President-in-waiting” off late has been the buzz all around. From his Encylco-Pidi-a to his ability to coin new phrases like Hugplomacy (which by the way sounds hilarious in Hindi), he is the buzz in town, with smart trolls inferring his PR strategy to be akin to that of his Canadian dynastic counterpart.

But on the ground level, nothing seems different at all. Gandhi, is still making vague statements that remind us of his pre-2014 days. But in all this, why he chose to attack Tata Motors has left many bewildered. Perhaps it is to do with the fact that the Parsi community, once a guaranteed Congress votebank has drifted to the BJP? Back in 2014, a Parsi high priest had explicitly asked the community to back Modi.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

Getting back to the campaigning in Gujarat, Rahul has used the Sanand factory to attack Modi multiple times.

On 3 November, he said that Rs 33,000 crore was given to the Nano factory but he hadn’t seen a single one on Gujarat streets for the last 10-15 days. He later said that you can’t see it anywhere in India.

The point is, the Sanand factory does not make cars for Gujarat alone. Two, given that the primary demand for Nanos is for the Taxi industry, it would be pertinent to look at other cities such as Bengaluru where Nanos are aplenty on the city’s roads. If he really hasn’t seen a single Nano on India’s roads, it is a disturbing fact for it could mean he needs medical attention.

Another really important question is, is Gandhi lying about the Rs 33,000 crore? The figure just seems to have cropped up recently in the context of the elections, and is most likely a misinterpretation, just like the 15 lakh drama.

On 25 November, he asked a more troubling question. He asked if the children of residents got employed by the factory. The point is, the factory alone is not the sole source of employment. Add to this the fact that Gujaratis are predominantly business oriented, and what do you get? A thriving ‘local economy‘. If a factory comes up, so do other businesses in the vicinity. From a tea stall to a trucking business to vegetable vendors, everything comes up. Different people do different things for a living.

Further, the highway connecting Sanand to Ahmedabad was also upgraded to a four lane highway, which turn means improved connectivity to the town along with a host of other things including highway-side businesses. Fun fact: Motels run by Patels on highways in the United States are called Potels. Within the factory, there are many jobs, from maintenance to basic clerical jobs to high end ones which require skilled engineers. Is Gandhi asking for unskilled workers to make unsafe cars?

The more troubling aspect of this question is: Is Rahul Gandhi batting for child labour or child exploitation? If that is the case, then sorry, I’d never vote for you.

On 26 November, he made an outrageous claim saying that Rs 33,000 crore had turned to ash because the plant was manufacturing just two Nanos in a month, displaying the failure of Make In India as well. In order to seem intellectual, he backed up his claim by citing a Business Standard report. Unfortunately for Gandhi, many of us also read the same report which mentioned a substantial bit of information to prove him wrong.

The report clearly does mention that around 6,200 Tiagos and 2,300 Tigors are manufactured at the same plant. That’s 8,000 cars a month, at the least. Further, last month Tata announced that one lakh Tiagos had been assembled at Sanand. Yes. 1,00,000. A Hundred Thousand Tiagos. Is this a sign of a useless factory?

Further, Sanand was never part of Make In India, for the Make In India scheme came up only post 2014.

What riles any person is the attack on Make In India – which in no way is a Swadeshi manufacturing scheme – but basically a platform to fuel more Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). Gandhi’s distant relative Tehseen Poonawalla (no relation to Cyrus, Adar or Natasha Poonawalla) mocked the Make In India week in 2016, and that too in a rather disgusting manner. When a stray firework caused a fire at the cultural night, Poonawalla was quick to jump the gun and proclaim that “Modi’s Fake In India” would go up in smoke.

While Rahul Gandhi is certainly not someone to be taken seriously, the itch is that nobody ever questions him. This is my attempt to do the same. Dear Mr Gandhi, do you understand economics, business or anything for that matter?


Share and Support:
Support OpIndia by paying for content

Most read articles recently

Amethi: Here is what Rahul Gandhi did in 10 years and Smriti did in 4 years

Analysis of the development of Amethi: 10 years of Rahul Gandhi vs 4 years of Smriti Irani

If such massive nations like Dubai and Singapore can be built in 20 years then why Amethi can’t be made into a world class constituency, either by Rahul Gandhi or Smriti Irani

Pro-Congress troll Abhishek Mishra arrested for offensive posts which hurt religious sentiments

Abhishek Mishra is was arrested by Delhi Police last night from Madhya Pradesh

Edelman Trust Report 2008 vs 2014 vs 2019: Here is how the Modi govt did vs the Congress govt

In an all-important election year, the Edelman Trust Barometer Global Report signals cheer for the central government led by Prime Minister Narendra Modi
Priyanka Gandhi's entry into politics as UP East incharge seems like a parody of Indian Politics

Priyanka Gandhi’s entry into politics seems like a skit where people dress up as politicians for laughs

For at least 10 years now, journalists, academics and intellectuals have been talking about the supposed charisma, intelligence and political acumen of Priyanka Gandhi

Pallavi Ghosh does a Rahul Gandhi while talking about Uri box office collection and Twitter can’t stop laughing

News18 journalist trolled for wrong box office number in her tweet.

As Priyanka Gandhi Vadra becomes the UP East incharge, here is all you need to know about her colourful history

Congress has appointed Priyanka Gandhi Vadra as the in-charge of Uttar Pradesh East. It appears to be a shrewd move by the party to get its caste equations correct in the state and cut into the Upper Caste vote bank of the BJP

India Today journalist caught ‘directing’ Congress workers to appear excited about Priyanka Gandhi Vadra

India Today journalist later tried to defend herself by saying they were not Congress workers but the 'people of Prayagraj' and she was not feeding them words but was telling them what Rahul Gandhi had to say about it

Pliant Media jubilant on the arrival of a non-achiever dynast in the politics

The media has gone gung ho on the formal entry of Priyanka Vadra into the politics

The art of propaganda: The articles associating Kumbh Mela with unemployment is the latest step in a civilizational war

Business Standard recently published an article associating Kumbh Mela to unemployment

Latest articles

Connect with us

129,003FansLike
105,152FollowersFollow
14,510SubscribersSubscribe

Don't miss these