Sunday, February 28, 2021
Home News Reports Beyond outrage - What's the Tribune Aadhaar hack and consequent FIR is all about

Beyond outrage – What’s the Tribune Aadhaar hack and consequent FIR is all about

On 4th Jan, The Tribune published a story titled “Rs 500, 10 minutes, and you have access to billion Aadhaar details”. The story claimed that you can “purchase” a “service” being offered by anonymous sellers over WhatsApp that provides unrestricted access to all details of every Aadhaar number generated in India so far.

This is how it worked: the journalist anonymously contacted an Aadhaar agent who installed a software on her computer using “Team Viewer”, a remote desktop software. The journalist also received an username and password on her mail. And bingo, she had access to “all Aadhaar details”.

If true, this is a very serious security flaw. This should be brought to the authorities notice as soon as possible to fix the lapses before the data ends up in wrong hands. Also, the report suggests that the journalist was able to access the Aadhaar data using credentials generated specifically for her. Now this is pretty embarrassing.

Sensitive data should always be protected using multiple layers of security and not just a user id and password. This is a standard practice in banks where apart from the credentials, an employee has to punch his fingerprint to log in into the core banking system. What this means is, even if you get an SBI employee’s credentials and get access to SBI’s intranet, you still can’t log into the system unless you are an employee of SBI authorized to use the system you are trying to log into.

Systems that deal with sensitive data are always authenticated through multiple layers to ensure no foul play. To think that something like Aadhaar data, where security is being questioned day in and day out, will leave the security perimeter for the agents to just an user id and password. This is some serious lackadaisical approach from the authorities towards privacy & data security.

However, some of the claims of the news report is questionable. For example, the report then claims that, using this security vulnerability, one can get a SIM on someone else’s name or withdraw money from someone else’s account. Both these require biometrics and as per UIDAI claims, biometrics data was not breached, though it agrees that some details (non biometric) may have been exposed, which is a security flaw nonetheless.

UIDAI press note on the said security breach

UIDAI maintains that this is a case of “misuse” of the grievance redressal search facility provided to some designated personnels. Subsequently, on 4th Jan, UIDAI registered an FIR with cyber cell, Delhi Police in this matter, under Aadhaar act [pdf] 36 and 37 and other IPC sections which names Unknowns, Anil Kumar & Sunil Kumar (the people who installed the app on the journalist’s machine and gave her access privileges), Rachana Khaira (the journalist who installed the “app” and allegedly accessed UIDAI details) and Tribune newspaper. As law bound, UIDAI has disclosed all the details of the case that is known to it in the FIR. The FIR names everyone in the chain of events leading to commission of the crime.

Section 36 and 37 of the Aadhaar act

Everyone, who thinks this is an attack on press freedom, here are few submissions.

  • Some quarters in the press maintain that the people are actually whistleblowers who exposed the vulnerabilities in the system. However, Sunil Kumar and Anil Kumar (assumed names I believe) are not whistleblowers. They are authorised agents by UIADI, who have misused their access privileges to allow access to a 3rd party for exchange of money. This is not whistleblowing, this is rather monetising the known vulnerability of the system to their own benefit, without bringing it to authorities notice. Even if we consider them whistleblowers, there could be others like them (referred to as the ‘Unknowns’ in the FIR, I will presume) doing the same, whose actions need to be investigated to find out and address any misuse of data.
  • A reading of above mentioned sections of Aadhaar act clearly establishes that a crime has been committed. UIDAI neither has investigating nor prosecution power. The natural course of action demands an investigation for which FIR is the first step in the process. For the investigating agency to conduct a free and fair investigation, it is imperative for them to know the full details of the case. Hence, the FIR had to name all of them. Whether everyone is actually charged or not will be decided by the investigating team while filing chargesheet. However, a proper enquiry demands the journalist and her team to be questioned to understand the modus operandi and chain of events. Do the journalist fraternity expect UIDAI to partially report the crime so that a fellow journalist is not named? Won’t that jeopardise the investigation? As UIDAI rightly points out, if someone is named in the FIR, it doesn’t necessarily mean he is guilty or is being targeted. That will be decided only after police investigations are over.
  • At times, to unearth scams or expose vulnerabilities, occasionally law has to be bypassed. Sting operations where journalist try to offer bribe to govt officials are an example. Though bribing a govt official is a crime under PCA, this is done in larger public interest to expose the malaise. However, who gets to decide whether the wrong you committed to bring out the “bigger wrong” is actually in public interest? The honourable Supreme Court in Rajat Prasad vs C.B.I case makes it clear that, a crime does not stand obliterated or extinguished merely because its commission is claimed to be in public interest. It will depend on the facts and circumstance of the case. So, let the court decide on the public interest part.

SC judgement on Sting operation and criminality

While we all want the Aadhaar system to be foolproof, we also need people to be punished for misusing their privileges and violating Aadhaar act. So, before making a hue and cry about journalistic freedom being trampled, please go through the merits of the case and understand the intention of filing the FIR. Union Minister for Information Technology Ravi Shankar Prasad and UIDAI too have clarified that the FIR is not about prosecuting the journalist or the newspaper but to seek their assistance in nabbing real culprits.

We all want a foolproof resilient system and at the same time we also want the culprits to be brought to the book. One would expect the newspaper to cooperate with the authorities to nab the culprits and tighten the loose screws. That will be some public service, a cause you dedicate yourself to.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

Congress ‘remembers’ Kamala Nehru on her ‘birth anniversary’ which is actually her death anniversary: The legacy of gaffes continues

However, after many pointed out, Congress quietly deleted the tweet and posted another one with correct information that today was Kamala Nehru's death anniversary.

Naushad, who was caught spitting while cooking tandoori rotis in viral wedding video, to be booked under NSA

Earlier this month, a video of Naushad who appears to be spitting on the tandoori rotis before putting them inside the tandoor for cooking, while at a wedding function, had gone viral.

Delhi Police arrests 2 men who were plotting to assassinate Kashmiri activist Sushil Pandit against payment

Sukhvinder Singh and Lakhan said they were paid Rs 10 lakh each by one Prince to kill Kashmiri activist Sushil Pandit

Hindu Mahasabha asks Rahul Gandhi to change Congress’ name to ‘Godsevadi Congress’ after Godse follower joined party: Read why

Hindu Mahasabha has advised Congress leader Rahul Gandhi to change the name of the Congress party to Godsevadi Congress.

As desperate Pakistan welcomes the Indo-Pak ceasefire with much fanfare, India takes it with a caution

The latest ceasefire agreement between India and Pakistan comes nearly 17 years after such an agreement was first signed

Encryption vs Compliance: The new IT Act guidelines put messaging services like WhatsApp in a tight situation

To comply with the new IT Act guidelines, services like WhatsApp will have to break its famous end-to-end encryption

Recently Popular

Did Aamir Khan’s daughter Ira Khan elope with her Hindu servant? Here is the truth

The image that is being used to claim that Iran Khan has 'eloped with her Hindu servant' was originally shared by Nupur Shikare, her fitness trainer. The two were posing on the occasion of Diwali.

US President Joe Biden casually drops the N-word during Munich Security Conference, accused of racism on social media

The N-word is considered as one of the hateful words that were first uttered in the 17th century. Its origin can be traced back to the Spanish word 'negro', which is often used by white supremacists to deliberately offend the African-American community.

Father of Richa Bharti, the girl who had refused to distribute Quran to secure bail, shot dead in native Bihar village: Read details

The father of the daring Bihar girl Richa Bharti has been shot down by assailants in her native village of Nalanda district in Bihar.

“A contest between my ball and your ball”: Netizens in splits after comments of Harsha Bhogle go viral

Harsha Bhohgle said that a cricket contest should be between bat and ball, not between bat and bat or ball and ball

Spokesperson of Samajwadi Party resigns after workers abuse his wife for sharing anti-Akhilesh Facebook post: Details

Anil Yadav of Samajwadi Party has resigned from the party after his wife, Pankhuri Pathak, was abused by SP workers.

Father of 6, Mehtab Rana, abducts minor by shrouding her in Burqa, had abducted the girl twice in 2018, role of in-laws, family suspected

Kidnapping of a 17-year-old girl in Agra, where accused made her wear a 'burqa', has sent shockwaves and resulted in outrage
- Advertisement -

 

Connect with us

253,132FansLike
520,759FollowersFollow
23,800SubscribersSubscribe