‘You should know what restraint in language means’: SC raps “seasoned politician” Sanjay Raut for his anti-judiciary remarks; refers to Nikhil Wagle’s tweets as worse than “unparliamentary”

On 17th November (Tuesday), the Supreme Court pulled up Shiv Sena (Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray) Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Raut over his inflammatory remarks targeting the judiciary. The Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) filed a criminal contempt plea against Raut and alleged journalist Nikhil Wagle for their offensive comments against Chief Justice Surya Kant and the judiciary. A bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi was hearing the matter.

Justice Kumar stated, “You have expressed an apology. But in a matter of this magnitude, an apology must come from the heart and not the mind. Mr Sanjay Raut, you are a seasoned politician. We have been hearing your speeches from advocate days. You are a seasoned parliamentarian, and you yourself were in the press. You should know what restraint in language means.”

The SCBA President, Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, argued that Raut had apologised for his statements but continued to attack the judiciary on social media. He referenced a post by Raut which claimed the BJP has taken control of India’s Election Commission, central investigation agencies, judiciary, and democracy.

Rai highlighted a picture that Raut had shared of the Albanian Supreme Court, which was set on fire by the demonstrators, adding that it carried a hidden message intended for the Indian Supreme Court. He called Raut a “habitual offender” and noted that his affidavit did not include these later tweets.

Wagle was represented by Indira Jaising, who maintained that he had removed the offensive social media post and issued an unconditional apology to the Supreme Court and Chief Justice of India. She asked that he should be relieved from the contempt proceedings, contending that he had complied with the court’s prior directive to stay present virtually.

However, Senior Advocate Rahul Kaushik pointed out Wagle’s language against the CJI and submitted that he should also be ordered to appear in person during the next hearing. “It leaves a very bad taste in our mouth to even repeat it. Unparliamentary is also too less to describe this,” Justice Kumar conveyed.

He also emphasised that the journalists are the fourth pillar of democracy and hence entail accountability. He mentioned, “On a personal note, after becoming a lawyer, I saw my father’s passport, in which it was written that the profession was journalist. It is the fourth estate. You know, the court has come to your rescue many a time.”

Jaising had claimed that Delhi’s air pollution might prevent her client from attending in person, suggesting, “Your Lordships were also not able to stop the pollution,” to which Justice Kumar replied, “Again you are blaming us.” The bench has scheduled a follow-up hearing for 8th December and ordered the two to appear in person and submit affidavits explaining their tweets.

Background of the matter

The controversy erupted last month after the CJI rejected the request by a delegation of members of the opposition for a personal meeting, informing that a petition could be used to bring the case before the court. Afterwards, Wagle attacked CJI Kant and wrote, “F*ck you,” on social media. However, he soon issued an unconditional apology, asserting his outburst was an emotional reaction that does not reflect how he usually expresses himself.

Raut similarly alleged that several judges attended dinners hosted by chief ministers and political events arranged by the BJP. He made accusations against the CJI and others based on purported photos of judges playing badminton with politicians in London.

He even called for an Albania-like situation in India, where violent anti-government protests wreaked havoc. He threatened, “The people of Albania have burned down the Supreme Court. The people were enraged because the Supreme Court was helping corrupt prime ministers. The protesting public has also attacked the parliament and government offices, as well as the ministers’ homes. All countries should learn a lesson from these events. Especially India.”

Raut and Wagle received show-cause notices from the Supreme Court on 16th October. Attorney General R Venkataramani gave his nod to start criminal contempt proceedings under Section 15(1)(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 after the SCBA presented its petition, a day earlier.