Monday, January 18, 2021
Home News Reports 'Will the Supreme Court also give directions on whether to go to war or...

‘Will the Supreme Court also give directions on whether to go to war or negotiate for peace?’: AG while arguing Rafale case

The AG asked the court to exercise restraint in making comments on the Rafale deal

After the Attorney General submitted in the supreme court that the Rafale documents produced in the court by petitioners were stolen from the defence ministry, the hearing in the review petitions on the Rafale deal resumed after lunch today.

In the beginning, the Supreme Court objected to certain statements made by Sanjay Singh against the Supreme Court and refused to hear him. CJI Ranjan Gogoi said that the bench is taking it very seriously and will take serious action against him. The court asked advocate Sanjay Hegde to inform the same to his client Sanjay Singh. The AAP leader is one of the persons who has filed a review petition in the Supreme Court on the Rafale deal.

Referring to Attorney General KK Venugopal telling the court that Rafale documents published by newspapers and used by petitioners were stolen from defence ministry and government is considering action for the same, petitioner Prashant Bhushan said that is an attempt to intimidate the petitioners and to stop them from bringing truth to the Court. He also said that it amounts to contempt of court.

The Attorney General than produced the RTI act and submitted that defence documents are exempted from disclosure under the act. He mentioned that documents published by Hindu are marked as “secret”, and they are not intended to be in the public domain. After the documents were published, huge damage has been done to India’s national security, KK Venugopal added.

Attorney General KK Venugopal also asked whether the Supreme Court will give directions to go to War or negotiate for peace. “Certain issues are outside the purview of judicial review. Do we have to come to the court to justify when we declare war, when we declare peace? Do we have to come and seek permission of the court every time?”, he said.

He then mentioned the need for Rafale jets for the country, but the bench asked him to stick to the review petition.

Disagreeing with the AG, Justice K M Joseph said that even stolen evidence can be looked into by the court as per the Evidence Act. He said that if some corruption has taken place, the government can’t take shelter under the Official Secrets Act. But the Attorney General disagreed and said that the source of documents is important. He asked how the petitioners got the classified documents of the defence ministry.

CJI Ranjan Gogoi asked AG, if an accused is having difficulty proving his innocence, steals a document and produced in court which clearly show that he is innocent, should the judge ignore the document just because it is stolen. To this, Venugopal has to disclose the source of the document.

The CJI Ranjan Gogoi asked AG to produce the authority that says the source of evidence is important. On this, AG produced a 2004 judgement by Supreme Court which had said that illegally obtained evidence cannot be relied upon. Justice Kaul also disagreed with the AG by saying that as documents have come to the court, he can’t say that the court should not look into them. He said that even if the AG is correct, some issues deserve to be heard if they “shock the conscience of the court”.

The Attorney General reiterated that the purchase of the Rafale jets are essential for the nation to survive against the enemies. He said that the issue has a political angle, and CAG has already submitted its report on the deal in Parliament, and the parliament will look into the issue. The AG also requested the court to exercise restraint in the limited are of defence matters, as anything said by the court is used by the opposition to target the government. He also said alleged that opposition is trying to destabilise the government using this case.

Prashant Bhushan rejected the arguments of AG, saying that even in 2G and Coalgate cases court had relied upon such documents. He said during those cases also the government had made similar arguments but those were dismissed by the court.

He also said that he has mentioned that the documents have been published by The Hindu and the Caravan Magazine, so it is wrong to say that he has not disclosed the source of his documents.

CJI Ranjan Gogoi said that if the court accepts the AG’s argument, then it will dismiss, else it will go ahead. To that Prashant Bhushan said that even if the documents are not accepted it won’t make significant difference to the case, as sources have been mentioned in most of the documents submitted by him.

The hearing in the case has been adjourned till 14th March.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Related Articles

Trending now

Pakistan claims India staged Pulwama attack after Mumbai Police leaks chat to embarrass Arnab, Republic hits back: Details

Pakistan has now issued a statement on the nonsensical controversy surrounding the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami

Shiv Sena to contest West Bengal Assembly elections

Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Raut today took to Twitter to announce that the party will contest upcoming elections in West Bengal.

’Guilty until proven innocent?’: Ex-BARC chief’s daughter makes yet another appeal to Maharashtra CM as her father’s health deteriorates

Ex-BARC chief Partho Dasgupta was hospitalised after health deteriorated in judicial custody following his arrest in the TRP case

Enforcement Directorate seeks permission from Rajasthan High Court for custodial interrogation of Robert Vadra in benami property case

ED has sought High Court’s permission to question Robert Vadra and associate Mahesh Nagar in Bikaner land deal case in custody

Fake TRP Scam: Wife of former BARC CEO Partho Dasgupta files complaint with NHRC over torture of her husband in jail

The wife of the former BARC CEO also alleged that someone was paid to beat her husband in jail to falsely implicate Republic TV in TRP case

Troubles mount for ‘comedian’ Munawar Faruqui as UP police seeks his custody

The production warrant has been submitted on January 7 before the Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) court in Indore and the Indore Central Jail, where Munawar Faruqi is serving his judicial custody.

Recently Popular

All you need to know about Jhanvi Kukreja murder case, the teenage girl who was brutally killed at a New Year party in Mumbai

Reports suggest that the injuries incurred by Jhanvi Kukreja were homicidal and not accidental

What the Nidhi-Harvard story reveals about our world: Get off your high horse, you are not that special, anyway

Liberal journalist, Nidhi Razdan, thought she had received an offer from Harvard University to become an Associate Professor of journalism.

Ravish Kumar apologises for spreading fake news about paddy procurement by govt after letter to NDTV by PIB: Here is what he said

After getting caught for peddling fake news about paddy procurement by govt, controversial NDTV news anchor Ravish Kumar has apologized

Condom over Shivling: Netizens slam actress Sayoni Ghosh for desecrating Hindu symbol, expose her dubious ‘account hacked’ claim

Saayoni Ghosh claimed that her account was hacked and she didn't posted the image in 2015, but netizens proved she is lying

British-Pakistani singer Zayn Malik says he loves India and fans can’t keep calm

Recently, Zayn Malik was heard singing Mohammad Rafi's Chaudavi Ka Chand in the track Tightrope.

‘Not a single NPA in the three decades of its existence,’ Adani Group rubbishes Subramanian Swamy’s allegations

On Friday, BJP MP Subramanian Swamy had put out allegations on Twitter against Adani accusing him of non-payment of loans worth Rs 4.5 lakhs, which has allegedly turned into an NPA.

Pakistan claims India staged Pulwama attack after Mumbai Police leaks chat to embarrass Arnab, Republic hits back: Details

Pakistan has now issued a statement on the nonsensical controversy surrounding the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami

Fake letter on Delhi BJP’s letterhead circulated containing derogatory comments and inciting violence against protesting farmers

The fake letter from BJP leader Rajesh Bhatia contains derogatory remarks for farmers and incites BJP workers for violence against farmers

Shiv Sena to contest West Bengal Assembly elections

Shiv Sena leader Sanjay Raut today took to Twitter to announce that the party will contest upcoming elections in West Bengal.

Bihar: Transgenders to be recruited into police either through direct appointment or competitive exam, reservations to be provided

The Bihar Police will now recruit people from the transgender community into its ranks and provide them reservations.

‘Azadi’ slogans raised at Azad Maidan in Mumbai as thousands of Muslim protestors gathered to protest against farm laws

The protestors raised 'Azadi' slogans in support of the farmers at the 'Kissan Alliance Morcha' that was held at the Azad Maidan yesterday

’Guilty until proven innocent?’: Ex-BARC chief’s daughter makes yet another appeal to Maharashtra CM as her father’s health deteriorates

Ex-BARC chief Partho Dasgupta was hospitalised after health deteriorated in judicial custody following his arrest in the TRP case

Enforcement Directorate seeks permission from Rajasthan High Court for custodial interrogation of Robert Vadra in benami property case

ED has sought High Court’s permission to question Robert Vadra and associate Mahesh Nagar in Bikaner land deal case in custody

Police to issue summons to makers of Tandav web series after BJP leader Ram Kadam lodges complaint against its Hinduphobic content

BJP leader Ram Kadam filed a complaint against actor Zeeshan Ayyub and web series Tandav demanding apology for insulting Hindu Gods

Congress admits Mumbai police leaked Arnab Goswami chats: Here are all the wild conspiracy theories they generated

Prithviraj Chavan has admitted that it was the Mumbai Police which leaked the private WhatsApp chats of Arnab Goswami.

Uttar Pradesh police arrest one Mohammed Taslim for sending porn videos to women on WhatsApp

Taslim would steal phone numbers of women from Facebook and Whatsapp groups and then forward porn videos to them.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
22,800SubscribersSubscribe