Tuesday, August 11, 2020
Home Law Ayodhya case Day 2: Nirmohi Akhara asks for more time to present evidences, bench...

Ayodhya case Day 2: Nirmohi Akhara asks for more time to present evidences, bench asks to resubmit arguments after better preparation

The Nirmohi Akhara had on day 1 strongly pitched for claiming the ownership for the entire disputed 2.77-acre plot, stating that Muslims had not been allowed to enter the place since 1934.

The Supreme court today resumed the hearing for the Ram Mandir-Babri Masjid land dispute case on the second day. A Constitution Bench comprises Chief Justice of India Ranjan Gogoi, Justices SA Bobde, DY Chandrachud, Ashok Bhushan and Abdul Nazeer. The 5-judges bench resumed hearing the arguments presented by senior advocate Sushil Jain, appearing for Nirmohi Akhara, one of the parties in the case.

The Ram Mandir case has been taken up for a day to day hearing after the efforts to arrive at an amicable settlement through mediation failed.

The Nirmohi Akhara had on day 1 strongly pitched for claiming the ownership of the entire disputed 2.77-acre plot stating that Muslims had not been allowed to enter the place since 1934.

Senior Advocate S Jain continues the arguments on behalf of Nirmohi Akhara:

The argument commenced today with Sushil Jain advancing his argument based on the point of limitation. He based his argument on Article 47, 142 read with Section 23 of the Limitation Act 1908 saying the suit filed by Nirmohi Akhara was “well within the prescribed time limit”:

  • He began by saying the suit is covered by Article 47 of Limitation Act 1908. The property was under attachment of Magistrate under Sec.145 CrPC.
  • The limitation period starts running only after final order under Sec.145. Since the interim order of Magistrate was pending, cause of action didn’t arise.
  • The suit sought restoration of “shebait” rights for management of temple (‘Shebait’ is the custodian of the temple) ‘Shebait’ rights include management and proprietary rights. When dispossession happened in 1950, Shebait rights got affected, argued Jain.
  • To get over the bar of limitation, Jain argues that prayer for the restoration of ‘shebait rights’ will be covered under-recovery of possession. The limitation period for recovery of possession is 12 years. The dispossession happened in 1950. The suit was filed in 1959. So suit filed well within limitation said, Jain.
- Advertisement -

Jain representing the Nirmohi Akhara reiterated that at this point they were petitioning for the possession of the inner courtyard and the Ramjanma Bhoomi. “Our claims of ownership stem from our possession. We had been in possession for the longest time. Obstruction to worship and prayer is what forced Nirmohi Akhara to file the civil suits,” Jain said in the court today.

CJI asks Nirmohi Akhara to be consistent in presenting citations and submissions:

The hearing resumed after lunch. CJI asks Jain to make submissions regarding the documentary evidence supporting the claims of Nirmohi Akhara and asks him to provide the bench and the lawyers of the other petitioners with the documents being referred to during arguments.

When Jain said that he would refer to two judgments, senior advocate Rajeev Dhavan, appearing for one of the Muslim parties, interjected and said that he should be given copies “of the SCR” too.

Agreeing with Dhavan on this point the CJI asked Jain to be consistent in what he was referring to and should provide copies of each citation/ documents to the other parties and the bench. The CJI then directed Jain to refer only to those documents, which have been provided by him to all the parties and people present in the court and not just to the bench.

Nirmohi Akhara argues on the difference between ‘shebaitship’ and ‘trusteeship’:

The Nirmohi Akhara also argued that there was a difference between a shebait and a trustee of a temple.

The advocate said that a ‘shebait’ is an “agent of the idol of a temple”. “The shebait enjoys some sort of rights to the property, which are akin to proprietary rights. It is not just a post but proprietary rights are blended with it. That, my lords, is shebaitship,” he added.

The advocate relies on Article 142 to present his arguments, “The Nirmohi Akhara’s right of management, and not just its right of possession, has also been curtailed by the disputed structure”.

In response to this argument, Justice Chandrachud said a shebait could be entitled to conducting worship in the temple without being in its possession. He asserted that if Jain’s reference to Article 142 was to be admitted, it would also mean that Nirmohi Akhara would only have 12 years from the time of dispossession.

Justice Chandrachud said, “(Article) 142 speaks of possession of the immovable property but does not talk about its management. So possession of property and management of worship (rituals) are two different things.”

Nirmohi Akhara draws CJI’ flak for failing to produce records:

The Supreme Court demanded that Jain present either oral or documentary evidence that Nirmohi Akhara was in possession of the Ram Janmabhoomi. CJI Gogoi said, “Do you have oral or documentary proof, revenue records, of possession of Ramjanmabhoomi before its attachment?”

However, Jain replied that records had been lost in a dacoity in 1982. The bench then added, “For the next two hours, we want to see the documentary and oral evidence only. If not, we will proceed to the next case.”

Bench gives more time to Nirmohi Akhara to present evidence:

The Constitution Bench said that the counsel for the Nirmohi Akhara, who has been presenting his arguments since the hearings began on Tuesday was underprepared and failed to present satisfactory evidence to back their claims in the case.

The 5 judge bench giving some time to the Nirmohi Akhara to prepare itself and resubmit arguments after better preparations, decided to take up suit no 5, submissions of deity Ram Lalla.

Counsel for deity Ram Lalla begins argument:

Senior advocate K Parasaran for the deity Ram Lalla started advancing submissions in the Ayodhya case.

In view of his age and seniority, the CJI asked K Parasaran to sit and argue. Parasaran declining the offer said, “Tradition constrains me to defy my age” and offers to argue standing. He began his submission by saying.

  • Devotees believe that the spirit of Sri Ram is present in the place and this unshakeable faith, evidences that the ‘Asthan’ is the birthplace of Lord Ram.
  • At least in three places in Valmiki Ramayana, it is mentioned that Sri Ram was born in Ayodhya, said Parasaran.

Justice Bobde, in response, asked, “Has such a question regarding the place of birth of a prophet or god arisen before any court before? Whether issues like the birth of Jesus Christ at Bethlehem have been questioned and dealt with by any court in the world?”

Parasaran said he would check and revert to the court.

This marked an end to the second day of the day to day hearing in the Ram Mandir-Babri Masjid land dispute case.

The daily hearings were prescribed by the Constitutional bench on August 2 after taking note of the ‘failed mediation’ by a three-member panel led by former Supreme Court judge FMI Kalifulla. The mediators also comprised spiritual guru Sri Sri Ravishankar and senior advocate and renowned mediator Sriram Panchu.

The panel had said in its report that Hindu and Muslim parties had not been able to find a solution to the vexatious dispute.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Related Articles

Trending now

Gujarat: Loudspeaker permission granted by Bhuj Magistrate to Shiv Mandir after it was denied on grounds that coronavirus transmits to sound waves

Bhuj Magistrate has denied permission to use loudspeaker for the holy month of Shravan at a Shiv Mandir on ground that loudspeakers disperse the virus and will spread coronavirus.

The curious case of a ‘Hindi Supremacist’ Twitter account, its Islamist origins and links to widely followed Islamist accounts on the platform

Twitter user Shubham Tripathi which has been trying to fan communal tensions by making regionalist comments is probably run by an Islamist.

Ashok Gehlot reportedly offers to resign from the post of Rajasthan CM after Sachin Pilot’s return to Congress: Reports

Sachin Pilot had recently returned to Congress after meeting with former Congress President Rahul Gandhi

PTI spreads another fake news, misquotes PM Modi on coronavirus cases in India

Prime Minister Modi said that the percentage of active cases of coronavirus cases in India has come down and the recovery rate has come up.

NCP leader Ajit Pawar’s son Parth Pawar draws flak for welcoming the Ram Mandir and demanding CBI inquiry into the alleged suicide of actor...

The Maharashtra Minority Development minister, Nawab Malik dismissed Parth Pawar’s statements, saying the deputy chief minister’s son is young and inexperienced and that there’s no difference of opinions among the Maha Vikas Aghadi alliance members

Karnataka: Outrage across the state as raped minor commits suicide, family demands capital punishment for accused Basheer

The accused Basheer accosted the girl when she was going to a temple to pray for her ailing mother and molested and raped her

Recently Popular

Pakistan: Maulvi rapes child reading Quran in mosque in Sindh province, caught on CCTV

Muslim Cleric in Sindh province in Pakistan on the run after video of hem raping a child inside a mosque emerges, case registered

Who really is Binod? Read how one Youtube comment triggered a bizarre meme fest

The name 'Binod', which has now become the talk of the town and trending on Twitter, originated from a YouTube channel 'Slayy Point'

Reports claim Sushant Singh Rajput’s former manager Disha Salian’s post-mortem report says she was found nude after her death, Mumbai police deny the reports

According to the post-mortem report of Disha Salian, her body was found nude, which was not revealed by the police so far

Rhea Chakraborty leaks WhatsApp conversation to accuse that Sushant Singh Rajput considered his sister Priyanka as ‘pure evil’

Rhea Chakraborty tries to prove that Sushant Singh Rajput did not like his family, releases chat messages with him

Sushant Singh Rajput’s brother-in-law gives a befitting reply to toxic journalism of Shekhar Gupta’s portal

Sushant Singh Rajput's brother-in-law Vishal Kirti on Sunday slammed Shekhar Gupta and his portal for toxic journalism.

DU Professor Apoorvanand mastermind behind the Delhi riots conspiracy, says Delhi riots accused Gulfisha

DU Professor Apoorvanand had already warned the students that riots would ensue and asked them to be prepared with stones, bottles, acid, knives and dry chilli powder

Linkedin employee Sourav Paul vows to murder Brahmins, claims it is easier to kill instead of opposing them

LinkedIn Employee Sourav Paul was unapologetic about his vitriol and abused a person when his hatred towards Rama was pointed out.

Rhea Chakraborty called mysterious ‘AU’ 44 times, calls made before and after Sushant Singh Rajput’s death: Reports

Call records of Rhea Chakraborty show that she was in touch with someone whose contact number was stored in her phone with the initials 'AU'

Maharashtra CM’s son involved in Sushant Singh Rajput death case, says Bihar govt’s lawyer: Here are the full details

SC heard Rhea Chakraborty’s plea for the second time in connection with Sushant Singh Rajput death case today

Here is what Sachin Pilot said when an agitated Rajdeep Sardesai insinuated that his rebellion was sponsored by BJP

Sachin Pilot issued a sharp rejoinder after Rajdeep Sardesai suggested that the rebelling Congress MLAs were doing it at the behest of the BJP

Nobody in the family saw his body hanging, don’t trust Mumbai police: Father of Sushant Singh Rajput argues in SC

The Supreme Court has reserved the order in the death case of late actor Sushant Singh Rajput after hearing submissions made by the father

Meerut Police initiates action against a social media user for threatening activist and writer Nidhi Bahuguna

Nidhi Bahuguna was threatened by a social media user for recounting her ancestors’ ordeal in Muslim majority Pakistan

‘With the strength of your experience, our country will win this battle,’ PM Modi holds meeting with CM of ten states with maximum Covid-19...

PM Modi held meeting with Chief Ministers of ten states that contribute to 80% of Covid-19 cases on Tuesday.

The curious case of a ‘Hindi Supremacist’ Twitter account, its Islamist origins and links to widely followed Islamist accounts on the platform

Twitter user Shubham Tripathi which has been trying to fan communal tensions by making regionalist comments is probably run by an Islamist.

‘Where do you want me to move on? I am in abyss,’ Rajdeep Sardesai trolled on social media after Asaduddin Owaisi’s Bhoomi Pujan meltdown

After a clip of his interview with AIMIM supremo Asaduddin Owaisi went viral on social media, Rajdeep Sardesai was trolled.

Uttar Pradesh: Sultanpur police arrest one Sajid who threatened to exterminate Hindus and bomb temples

Following a complaint by a Twitter user, the National Crime Investigation Bureau of Uttar Pradesh took cognisance of the matter and directed the Sultanpur police to take necessary action in this regard.

Connect with us