Thursday, November 26, 2020
Home Editor's picks When Bollywood starts asking ‘Kaun Jaat Ho?’

When Bollywood starts asking ‘Kaun Jaat Ho?’

Neeraj Ghaywan, Director of Masaan, recently came out with job vacancies where he asked only people from certain castes to apply. A young filmmaker responds to this development.

Let me start by unequivocally stating that Neeraj Ghaywan is a great Director; having won awards (notice the plural form) at Cannes for his very first feature film is a reason enough to admire his craft. He is an exciting talent we have in our country. I had read the screenplay of Masaan (sourced it from a friend who is a writer) before going to the theatre, and LOVED every bit of the finished film.

It is important to state these facts before voicing my disagreement with his hiring policy; which really is a very very small subset of who he is – a director we can all be proud of and a craftsman I aspire to be!

I, on the other hand, am a small filmmaker whose films have been to many (if 15 qualifies as many) film festivals across the globe. The current film is just about complete and it is being screened at Chicago South Asian Film Festival. The stark difference in our ‘achievements’ aside, I do hope that I have the right (both legal and moral) to respectfully disagree with your ‘hiring DBA candidates only’ policy.

Mr. Ghaywan put out an ad on social media for hiring assistant writers and assistant directors from DBA background (Dalit, Bahujan & Adivasi) only. His post went viral and attracted all kinds of commentary – hailing him as some social reformer to accusing him of indulging in publicity stunt. Many accused him of bringing in caste where none exist. He has since then spoken to The Wire and responded to the criticism here. I am quoting from the article:

“Speaking to The Wire, Ghaywan says he had anticipated that social media would respond in this way but is still amused at how ‘unprepared and uncomfortable’ the Hindi film industry is to discuss the caste realities of the country.”

When Mr. Ghaywan talks about industry’s comfort or preparedness to discuss caste realities, there are two aspects to it. The industry’s comfort in its output i.e. the movies, and the comfort in working behind the scenes. Let us first talk about the output.

On the evils of casteism, a recent film Article 15 has grossed over ₹ 90 crores. The Hindi film industry has been making films around caste since like forever. As young kids, we were bombarded with films on Doordarshan with ‘Thakur’ as villains, who were zamindaars, dacoits, gali ka gunda, or some other characters having villainous shades. For years I grew up watching villains share my identity; ‘Thakur’ being the quintessential villain, imagine what it does to an impressionable mind!

SRK era might have made surnames out of fashion now, and the movies in the new millenium have been mostly about romance and aspirations, but the young generation even today is still growing up witnessing a Sushant Singh Rajput suddenly made to be feel ashamed and drop his surname from his Twitter account. Essentially, Bollywood is not really that ‘uncomfortable’ or blind to caste realities.

In fact, my first recollection of a ‘hero’ with my surname was Rajkumar in Tiranga (Major Suryadev Pratap Singh). I had to wait for that long! I don’t think there were even any supporting Thakur characters either in Bollywood movies, who would normalise the blow (like the Good Samaritan Rahim Chacha of Sholay). All you need to do is scan through the badly made films of the 80s or the films of Sunil Dutt to know the way issue of caste has been treated – directly or indirectly – on screens.

But Mr. Ghaywan belongs to a different world altogether. For him, perhaps even Sunil Dutt was blind to caste realities, and in Tiranga, he would have wanted Major Suryadev Pratap Singh to hire some DBA warriors who would take out the ‘fuse’ of the missiles. But wait a minute, that will be a ‘savarna’ character taking credit for hard work done by DBA people. Only Mr. Ghaywan can write the screenplay of a caste-sensitive Tiranga.

Jokes aside, credit where due. Mr. Ghaywan does raise the issue of caste in Masaan. But let him be honest and answer it himself – does he really think that the storyline of Masaan is as radical as the policies he wants the industry to adopt?

In the Wire interview, Mr. Ghaywan has criticised Article 15 as a ‘DBA story told through a savarna lens’. But he, in Masaan, also tells story of a Brahmin girl, running parallel to the story of a Dalit boy, not as a contrast but as a support plotline (where both are disadvantaged). The story is primarily about the aspirations of a poor boy who happens to be a Dalit. The only place his caste becomes a conflict is in his love story, which is introduced and resolved in two scenes on either side of the interval. I am sure the ‘activist’ Ghaywan will find this Director Ghaywan lacking courage to tell the real story!

What a creative person puts in his art is inspired from realities, but what he professes when donning the hat of an activist is often at odd with the same realities. Which one of these two is playing to the galleries, I leave that upon the readers to decide.

Now let us go behind the scenes, where things become even more interesting and complex. Mr. Ghaywan says the following about the film industry:

“I have thought a lot about how I can work towards diversifying this industry. I did not just wake up one day and decide to call for DBA artists and writers to work with. I have, as a matter of policy, ensured that women comprise at least 50% of my crew, right from Masaan, my first film.”

Not many years back, we were told quite the opposite; that Hindi film industry is diverse and ‘secular’. This is a personally attested fact; the industry – not as organised as a typical industry is – hires us on merit and doesn’t bother with our surnames or regional origins. Nobody in my 12 years (15th Dec 2007 and counting) really bothered me about it. However, just because it didn’t happen to me, I will not claim it doesn’t happen to anyone.

I would have really appreciated if Mr. Ghaywan told us how and when he started feeling that the film industry was discriminatory or exploitative towards people from certain castes? Given the fact that he has mostly worked with stalwarts and fellow ‘activists’ like Anurag Kashyap, what do we conclude about the way Kashyaps work?

And how did Mr. Ghaywan conclude that the industry was not diversified enough? There are 16000 registered members of IMPPA. Many of them use names that can hardly give you a clue about what caste they belong to. Sometimes you can not even guess the religion. Did someone call up all of them to ask ‘kaun jaat ho?’ and then found out that bulk of them were Savarnas? When did Bollywood become prejudiced and casteist to attract affirmative action?

I don’t know if someone checked names of IMPPA members, but I did check some names. On the IMDB website, your film Masaan has 223 total credits listed, of which only 46 are female, whereas you told The Wire that 50% of your crew were women. Where are those 65 missing women I wonder!

The Wire interview then veers off to trolls (I am surely going to be added to the list now), Vivek Agnihotri, and the privilege of ‘savarna’ castes.

Unlike you maestro, I am only privileged enough to speak for myself.

My family of 8 (father and uncle) migrated out of Bihar because of Lalu politics of bhura baal saaf karo (politics of finishing off the ‘upper castes’). From 1991 to 1994, the family lived in an area called Balkum, which is outside Thane city, the affordable neighborhood of Mumbai. We could not afford even the affordable. The locality had community toilets and water. Then we lived for another 16 years in a cramped 2 BHK flat of Navi Mumbai with, fortunately, in-house toilet and running water.

I am glad to report that the family of 8 is now family of 10; of my 6 siblings, 2 are doctors (one Maharastra Gold Medalist), 2 engineers (one from IIT) and one India U-19 cricketer. We were privileged, yes, but only in the knowledge that education and hard work alone changes the destiny. However, thanks to all activism that you’ve brought to Bollywood – which is a softer and ‘intellectual’ form of the ‘activism’ from which we had to run away from 90s Bihar – now it seems that I should not, even for a while, think that I’ve accomplished anything due to hard work and perseverance. I should just feel a sense of guilt, and move away.

Your interview continues…

“While shooting the film in Varanasi, I was surrounded by pandits (Brahmins). They were all in love with me, offering unwavering support all through. I had this constant fear that if they find out my caste, will they still support me? The fear was so strong that I did not have the courage to mention it even to my closest friends within the industry.”

I also have a constant fear that if ‘they’ (activist liberal brigade of Versova) find out who I am I will be denied all opportunities and shunned as a RW troll. So taking a leaf out of your book, I too not have the courage to write this in my own name and won’t mention this article to my closest friends in the industry. Maybe one day I will put my name, after two Cannes awards come my may.

Post-Script: On parting, we in Bihar always say ‘jaane anjaane mein koi galti ho gayi ho to chhota bhai samajh ke maaf kar dijiyega’ (if unknowingly I have erred, please forgive me as you’d forgive your younger brother). Keep working, and keep hiring, Mr. Ghaywan.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Related Articles

Trending now

After allowing Israelis to visit without visa, UAE stops issuing visas to citizens of 13 countries including Pakistan and Turkey

The decision of UAE to stop issuing visas to citizens of 13 countries is reported to have been taken due to security decisions.

Forgotten daughter of Uttarakhand: Before Nirbhaya, girl working in Delhi was kidnapped, raped and brutally murdered in Haryana

In February 2012, a 19-year-old girl from Delhi was abducted, gang-raped, brutalised and abandoned to die at a mustard field in Haryana

Law against ‘Love Jihad’ does not violate anyone’s fundamental rights: Smashing the ‘liberal’ arguments with truth

The readers must know that this is not a law against interfaith marriage or any marriage to begin with. Interfaith marriages are and will continue to be allowed in India.

Ex-Bollywood actress Zaira Wasim, who quit showbiz for Allah, asks fans to remove her pics

Zaira Wasim had earlier asked her fans to stop praising her as it is dangerous for her 'Iman'.

While Imran Khan continues his rants against Emmanuel Macron, Pakistan govt expects debt relief of around $300 million from France

Pakistani PM Imran Khan and Pakistan citizens have been dissing about France after Emmanuel Macron criticised radical Islam

When Sonia Gandhi trusted Ahmed Patel for conveying to PV Narasimha Rao’s family that his funeral will not be held in Delhi

Sanjaya Baru had said Ahmed Patel approached him to let PV Narasimha Rao's son know about Sonia Gandhi's message.

Recently Popular

Hyderabad elections: Owaisi makes ‘beef biriyani’ sly on BJP leaders, Raja Singh offers him pork biriyani

As an insult to BJP leaders, Owaisi had stated that they should have some biriyani at a particular hotel in Hyderabad that is famous for beef dishes.

Anvay Naik suicide case for which Arnab Goswami was arrested: Letters exchanged, the closure report, and unanswered questions

On 4th of Nov, the country watched as Arnab Goswami was dragged out of his house by over 20 armed policemen for a closed 2018 suicide case

Fraud fact-checker accuses TrueIndology of lying, when caught, wants an HD-quality photo from 1904

Pratik Sinha's lies were exposed in an OpIndia report. After his shoddy 'fact-checking' was called out, he has now resorted to name calling and shifting goalposts.

Uttar Pradesh: Golu and Guddu kill driver Mushtaq with an axe for harassing their sister, surrender to police

The brothers, Golu and Guddu, reportedly reached the police station with a blood-stained axe and confessed to killing Mushtaq.

Habitual offender Rehana Fathima given last warning by Kerala High Court after violating bail condition in ‘Gomatha’ cookery video

In the cookery video titled Gomatha Ularthu, Fathima kept referring to the meat as Gomatha. The High Court let her go giving her last opportunity to 'improve'.

Fraud fact-checking: AltNews co-founder Pratik Sinha spreads fake news while attempting to ‘fact-check’ old picture of a Hindu Sadhu

AltNews's Pratik Sinha posted fake information about an old image of a Hindu Sadhu in Kashmir in his hurry to call TrueIndology as a fraud.
- Advertisement -

After allowing Israelis to visit without visa, UAE stops issuing visas to citizens of 13 countries including Pakistan and Turkey

The decision of UAE to stop issuing visas to citizens of 13 countries is reported to have been taken due to security decisions.

Algerian-born Muslim cleric Abdul Nacer Benbrika stripped of his citizenship by Australia after convicted of terrorism

Benbrika was convicted of directing a terrorist group, and possessing material associated with planning of a terrorist attack in Australia

Fact-check: No, the government has not issued Rs.1,30,000 to the citizens towards Covid-19 funding

Fake message circulated claims that govt of India has issued Rs.1,30,000 to every citizen above the age of 18 as Covid-19 funding

Fact Check: Did Arfa Khanum Sherwani eat the goat she was petting in the photographs she posted?

Arfa Khanum Sherwani took social media by storm after she posted photographs of herself with a beautiful white goat.

Indian Navy inducts two American Predator drones on the lease, can be deployed on India-China border for surveillance

The Predator drones has been leased from a private company for one year, India plans to purchase 18 such drones from USA

Reservations for SC Christians: How it could affect the prospects of Dalit Hindus

There have been several calls for the inclusion of Dalit Christians in the reservation system meant for SC/St and OBC communities.

Forgotten daughter of Uttarakhand: Before Nirbhaya, girl working in Delhi was kidnapped, raped and brutally murdered in Haryana

In February 2012, a 19-year-old girl from Delhi was abducted, gang-raped, brutalised and abandoned to die at a mustard field in Haryana

UP: Woman given triple talaq for not bringing Rs 20 lakh and a car in dowry

The woman from Rampur has alleged that her husband and in-laws have been harassing her for not bringing Rs 20 lakhs and a car.

China comes to defend Pakistan after PM Modi accused the latter of harbouring terrorists

After PM Modi's remarks against Pakistan, China praised Pakistan for making positive contribution toward counter-terrorism cause

Cyclone Nivar is fast approaching Tamil Nadu, Puducherry and parts of Andhra: All you need to know

Cyclone Nivar is expected to his coastal states in next few hours, currently travelling at 11 KMPH, it may cause severe damage to houses, roads, crops, electricity and communications lines.

Connect with us