Wednesday, January 27, 2021
Home Law Adultery should be a crime in armed forces: Centre tells SC

Adultery should be a crime in armed forces: Centre tells SC

In its application, the Centre has contended that decriminalising adultery might cause instability as military personnel are separated from their families for long durations.

The Centre has sought clarification from the Apex Court regarding the application of the law of adultery on the armed forces. A three-judge Bench of the Supreme Court headed by Justice Rohinton Nariman considered the application filed by Ministry of Defense on Wednesday.

In a 2018 judgment (Joseph Shine v Union of India) the Supreme Court had decriminalised adultery under section 497 of the Indian Penal Code. Issuing notice on the Centre’s application, the Supreme Court said that since the 2018 judgment was passed by a Constitution Bench, it would be appropriate that a Constitution Bench considered the application.

Explaining why the clarification was sought, Attorney General KK Venugopal said that the 2018 judgment did not take into consideration the Armed Forces Act which penalises an ‘unbecoming act’. Under the act, a personnel can be court martialed on the ground of ‘unbecoming act’ for committing adultery with a colleague’s wife.

Deliberating on the ambit of the words ‘unbecoming conduct’ in the Armed Forces Act Justice Nariman noted that ‘unbecoming conduct’ would include things which do not strictly amount to adultery. “The Armed Forces Act is on a different footing because the expression used is ‘unbecoming conduct’. Something which is not strictly adultery because the section (497, IPC) has been struck down will strictly be ‘unbecoming conduct’. The person would be liable under that”, Justice Nariman observed.

Decriminalising adultery might cause instability: Centre

In its application, the Centre has contended that decriminalising adultery might cause instability as military personnel are separated from their families for long durations. “In view of the judgment, there will always be concern in the minds of the army personnel who are operating far away from their families under challenging conditions far away from their families about the families indulging in untoward activity”, the application read.

Sections 45 and 63 of the Army Act, sections 45 and 65 of the Air Force Act and sections 54 (2) and 74 of the Navy Act deal with unbecoming Act. However, the Army Act and the Rules thereunder do not specifically deal with ‘adultery’. The Defense Service Regulation refers to ‘plural marriage’ but does not mention adultery. In the Military Manual drafted by the British prior to the commencement of the Constitution and the enactment of the Army Act there was a reference to ‘stealing the affection of a brother officer’s wife’ in the Armed Forces.

Court not apprised of peculiar working conditions of defense personnel in Joseph Shine case: Centre

The application filed by the Centre said that the judgment passed by the Apex Court in Joseph Shine case did not consider the peculiar working conditions of defense personnel. It was further submitted in the application that in view of the judgment in Joseph Shine case, if a personnel is charged with adultery under the provisions of unbecoming act or for the violation of good order and military discipline then an argument may be raised that the army are bypassing the law and are trying to do indirectly what cannot be done directly.

Advocate on Record Sachin Sharma raised raised two important questions of law in the application:

  1. Whether the persons subject to the Army Act by virtue of Article 33 of the Constitution of India being a distinct class should continue to be subject to section 497 of the IPC by making an exception in regard to application of section 497 IPC vis-à-vis persons subject to Army Act?
  2. Whether promiscuous or adulterous acts by persons subject to Army Act should be allowed to be governed by the relevant provisions of Army Act, Navy Act and Air Force Act being special legislations irrespective of Joseph Shine judgment by treating as an abrogation of Fundamental Rights in terms of Article 33 of the Constitution?

The Joseph Shine judgment

A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court that included Justice Nariman had unanimously decriminalised adultery under 497 of the IPC as violative of Article 14, 15(1) and 21 of the Constitution. The provision relating to adultery is a civil offence now forming a ground for divorce. The court held that the provision was an archaic and paternalistic law infringing upon a woman’s autonomy and dignity.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Searched termsadultery armed forces
OpIndia Staffhttps://www.opindia.com
Staff reporter at OpIndia

 

Related Articles

Trending now

Nirbhaya protests, blaming the govt and other excuses: Here’s how liberals came out to defend the Red Fort siege and the accompanying violence

Left-leaning liberals went on an overdrive to defend the desecration of Red Fort by the tractor rally protesters.

Rajdeep Sardesai lies twice, says ‘farmer’ was killed because the police shot him in the head: Here is the truth

In this way, those who had shared the fake news once would live under the false impression that it was indeed a case of police firing.

Hindus must ask now if their religious flag atop Lal Quila would be an acceptable sight

A lasting visual from this Republic Day, would be one of the Sikh flag unfurled atop the Red Fort, by violent Khalistanis

After violence was unleashed on streets of Delhi on Republic Day, ‘farmer’ body thanks ‘farmers’ for ‘unprecedented participation’

Samyukta Kisan Morcha further claimed that despite their efforts, 'some organisations and individuals' violated route and indulged in condemnable acts.

‘Flag of Khalistan is waving on Red Fort,’ ‘Historic Moment’: All Pakistan Muslim League celebrates “Black Day” for India

The All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) is celebrating the hoisting of the 'Khalistan Flag' at Red Fort on Republic Day.

During Delhi Riots, NDTV cropped stones from rooftop of mosques, now it paints violent mobs in tractor rally as humanitarian

NDTV tried to downplay the chaos by claiming that protesters made way for an ambulance that was stuck in Tractor Rally

Recently Popular

Protesting mob enters Red Fort, unfurl the Sikh flag, Terrorist outfit SFJ had demanded Khalistani flag to be hoisted: Details

The protestors have hoisted the flag on Red Fort that appears to be the Sikh Flag. Some believe it is the Khalistan Flag.

Professor who translated Rahul Gandhi’s “don’t need army if farmers are strong” speech in Erode faints after the speech: Reports

Muhammed Imran, who translated Rahul Gandhi's speech at Erode, collapsed after interpreting the speech from English to Tamil

‘Flag of Khalistan is waving on Red Fort,’ ‘Historic Moment’: All Pakistan Muslim League celebrates “Black Day” for India

The All Pakistan Muslim League (APML) is celebrating the hoisting of the 'Khalistan Flag' at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Here is how Congress and trolls tried to paint a Khalistani accused of spearheading the Red Fort siege as a ‘sanghi’

Deep Sidhu is accused of being responsible for the hoisting of the Sikh flag at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Is it actor Prosenjit Chatterjee in the portrait of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose inaugurated by President Kovind? A fact check

It was claimed that it was actor Prosenjit Chatterjee in the portrait of Netaji Subhash Chandra Bose inaugurated by President Kovind.

Protesting ‘farmer’ spends Rs 35 lakh to modify his tractor for Republic Day rally

The modified tractor is fitted with huge wheels. It is said to withstand heavy rain and water cannon charge.
- Advertisement -

 

Nirbhaya protests, blaming the govt and other excuses: Here’s how liberals came out to defend the Red Fort siege and the accompanying violence

Left-leaning liberals went on an overdrive to defend the desecration of Red Fort by the tractor rally protesters.

Hundreds of children, artists for Republic Day were stuck at Red Fort crying, terrified by the mob: Reports

Around 200 artists of Republic Day parade were stranded since 12:00 PM near Red Fort. They were rescued by Delhi Police.

Here is how the Uttarakhand Youth Congress celebrated the Red Fort siege, incited violence by spreading fake news about protester death

The Uttarakhand Youth Congress shared a photograph from the Red Fort earlier today after the protesting mob breached its premises.

Here is how Congress and trolls tried to paint a Khalistani accused of spearheading the Red Fort siege as a ‘sanghi’

Deep Sidhu is accused of being responsible for the hoisting of the Sikh flag at Red Fort on Republic Day.

Rajdeep Sardesai lies twice, says ‘farmer’ was killed because the police shot him in the head: Here is the truth

In this way, those who had shared the fake news once would live under the false impression that it was indeed a case of police firing.

Tractor rally: Violence by the mob in Delhi leaves 83 policemen injured, attempt made to mow down Additional DCP with tractor

The tractor rally by farmers and Khalistanis in Delhi where they unleashed violence has left 18 policemen injured

Watch: Protestors throw away Tricolour, place Sikh flag on top of flag pole at Red Fort

Disturbing visuals emerge from the tractor rally on Republic Day.

Rahul Gandhi and CPIM use Republic Day insurrection to further their political agenda, demand repeal of farm laws

Sitaram Yechury and Rahul Gandhi are attempting to use the Republic Day violence to further the political agenda of their party.

Tractor rally on R-Day: Not just swords, violent protestors have come loaded with liquor too

Earlier, some violent protestors were seen attacking Delhi Police personnel with swords and trying to run them over with tractors.

Hindus must ask now if their religious flag atop Lal Quila would be an acceptable sight

A lasting visual from this Republic Day, would be one of the Sikh flag unfurled atop the Red Fort, by violent Khalistanis

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
496,912FollowersFollow
23,000SubscribersSubscribe