Sunday, March 7, 2021
Home News Reports Sexual Assault Vs harassment: Bombay HC Judge who gave 'skin-to-skin contact' judgement refuses to...

Sexual Assault Vs harassment: Bombay HC Judge who gave ‘skin-to-skin contact’ judgement refuses to charge accused under POCSO

The victim’s mother had alleged that the accused had held her daughter's hands with his pant zip opened. She had also testified that her daughter informed her that the accused removed his penis from the pant and asked her to come to the bed for sleeping.

In yet another controversial ruling, the Nagpur bench of the Bombay High Court on Wednesday held that ‘the act of holding a girl’s hands and opening the zip of pants will not come under the definition of sexual assault’ under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act 2012.

According to the reports, a single judge bench of Justice Pushpa Ganediwala ruled that the sexual assault instead comes under the ambit of ‘sexual harassment’ under Section 354-A (1) (i) of the Indian Penal Code.

Hearing a criminal appeal against the conviction and sentence awarded to a 50-year-old man for molesting a five-year-old girl, Justice Ganediwala observed that the case comes under the gambit of ‘sexual harassment’ and not ‘sexual assault’.

“The offense of sexual harassment under Section 354A (1) (i), which deals with physical contact and advances involving unwelcome and explicit sexual overtures, is attracted in the case,” the bench said.

Reportedly, the police had registered a case based on the complaint lodged by the victim’s mother, who had alleged that the accused had held her daughter’s hands with his pant zip opened. She had also testified that her daughter informed her that the accused removed his penis from the pant and asked her to come to the bed for sleeping.

The accused was sentenced to five years of imprisonment and Rs 25,000 fine for the charges of ‘aggravated sexual assault’ under section 10 of POCSO Act by a sessions court. He had then appealed in the HC against the lower court verdict.

Act does not fall under the POCSO act, says Bombay HC

Justice Ganediwala, hearing the case, observed that the definition of “sexual assault” under Section 7 of the POCSO says, “Sexual assault – Whoever, with sexual intent touches the vagina, penis, anus or breast of the child or makes the child touch the vagina, penis, anus or breast of such person or any other person, or does any other Act with sexual intent which involves physical contact without penetration is said to commit sexual assault”.

Further, the Court observed that according to the definition of ‘sexual assault’, a ‘physical contact with sexual intent without penetration’ is an essential part of the offence.

Since no actual touching of the private parts of the body happened in the case, the court wondered if the act will come under the ambit of the third part of the definition: “any other Act with sexual intent which involves physical contact without penetration”, as per the report by Live Law.

Groping a minor’s breast without ‘skin contact’ not sexual assault: Bombay High Court

Just a few days back, the Nagpur Bench led by Justice Pushpa Ganediwala had ruled that groping without skin-to-skin contact is not sexual assault. The Nagpur Bench of the Court had said that the act involving a minor would not amount to sexual assault if the accused did not remove the top of the minor or slide his hands under her garment.

In her order Justice Pushpa Ganediwala had ruled, “Evidently, it is not the case of the prosecution that the appellant removed her top and pressed her breast. The punishment provided for offence of ‘sexual assault’ is imprisonment of either description for a term which shall not be less than three years but which may extend to five years, and shall also be liable to fine. Considering the stringent nature of punishment provided for the offence, in the opinion of this Court, stricter proof and serious allegations are required.”

“The act of pressing the breast of a child aged 12 years, in the absence of any specific detail as to whether the top was removed or whether he inserted his hand inside her top and pressed her breast, would not fall under the definition of ‘sexual assault’,” Justice Ganediwala observed, before acquitting the accused who was found guilty of assault under Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act (POCSO).

Following the Bombay HC order to acquit the accused, the Supreme Court stayed the controversial Bombay High Court verdict on Wednesday. A Bench led by Chief Justice of India Sharad A Bobde took cognisance instantaneously after Attorney General K.K. Venugopal made a special mention in court, saying the High Court decision would set a ‘very dangerous precedent’ and cripple the intention of POCSO to punish sexual offenders.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

OpIndia Staff
Staff reporter at OpIndia

Related Articles

Trending now

40 year old Mohammed Intezar trying to marry minor Hindu girl, insist Hindu orgs, Delhi Police denies: Details

Hindu activists have alleged that a minor Hindu girl was converted and being married off to a 40-year-old Mohammed Intezar Hussain.

‘Biggest crime is I am Muslim’: TMC MLA breaks down into tears after being denied ticket, calls party the ‘B Team’ of BJP

Sitting Trinamool Congress MLA from Nalhati, Moinuddin Shams, has announced in tears that he has quit the party.

This time it’s personal: Suvendu Adhikari vs Mamata Banerjee in Nandigram is officially on, the most high profile contest this election season

The BJP has announced that Suvendu Adhikari will be the party candidate versus Mamata Banerjee from Nandigram.

Violence in Bengal, election rigging, misgiving of Congress, Abbas Siddiqui, COVID-19 and China: CPI (M) leader Rabin Deb talks to OpIndia

Rabin Deb, one of the tallest leaders in West Bengal of the CPI (M) talks to OpIndia ahead of the 2021 elections, TMC and BJP

Antilia bomb scare: Mansukh Hiren had written to Maharashtra CM and others alleging harassment by police and journalists. Read details

Two days before Mansukh Hiren had gone missing, he had sent a letter to Maharashtra CM, HM, and the police alleging mental harassment

NCPCR to take action against Christian NGO Persecution Relief for tarnishing the reputation of India

NCPCR said that Persecution Relief published a false report about the abuse of Child protection law in India and shared it in 150 countries

Recently Popular

Kiren Rijiju gives befitting reply to ‘befitting reply queen’ Taapsee Pannu’s boyfriend, who wanted the law to bend to his whims

Matthias Boe, boyfriend of actress Taapsee Pannu, had appealed to Kiren Rijiju to 'do something' to help the actress.

After IT raids, Taapsee Pannu suffers a meltdown and admits that she was questioned about cash receipts of Rs 5 crores

Taapsee Pannu attempted to take a sly at Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman for simply clarifying the facts about the raids

‘Does money in Bollywood come from Ganga?’: Shiv Sena mouthpiece claims Taapsee Pannu, Anurag Kashyap targeted for supporting ‘farmer protests’

The Saamana editorial asked why only Taapsee Pannu and Anurag Kashyap were targeted and not other Bollywood celebrities.

Indian Govt should ask badminton coach and Taapsee Pannu’s boyfriend Mathias Boe to quietly do his job or quit

Mathias Boe had tweeted tagging Minister Kiren Rijiju, asking him to do 'something' about the IT raids on his girlfriend Taapsee Pannu

Antilia bomb scare: Police recover handkerchiefs tied to Mansukh Hiren’s mouth, his wife says he met Mumbai Police officer hours before death

Vimla, the wife of one Mansukh Hiren has said that her husband had left the house saying he was going to meet crime branch officer Tawde

All you need to know about Elon Musk’s Starlink, which has begun pre-booking in India

Currently, Elon Musk's SpaceX, of which Starlink is a venture, has already sent 1000 such satellites to the Earth's orbit. In the future, the company plans to expand the number to a network of 12,000 satellites.
- Advertisement -


Connect with us