In 1977, Industries Minister George Fernandes asked Coca-Cola to follow India’s foreign ownership rules and reportedly sought its secret formula. The company refused and left India, followed by IBM. Parle’s Thums Up filled the gap in the market. When Coca-Cola returned in 1993, it eventually bought the Indian brand that had prospered in its absence.
A Scottish plant hunter named Robert Fortune had, in 1848, slipped 20,000 tea plants from China with the know-how to cultivate them, and brought them for the East India Company, laying the foundation of a massive tea business for the colonisers.
The Patents Act, 1970 enabled Indian chemists to reverse engineer medicines and build the pharmaceutical industry. Since the 1990s, India has become a custodian of other people’s knowledge. More than 2,100 global capability centres now operate here. Has the law kept pace?
The Nvidia-Jensen Huang episode offers a contemporary warning. Allegations of a possible foreign intelligence connection raised a question: were the company’s secrets safe? A server need not be hacked if someone with access can be compromised. Companies must identify their secrets, know who can reach them and establish what counts as theft. The Official Secrets Act, 1923, deals with government secrets and political spying, not economic espionage. Indian companies must assemble remedies from contracts, breach of confidence, cyber law and other provisions. The patchwork makes cases uncertain and favours those able to afford sophisticated lawyers.
A trade secret is business information valuable because it is not generally known and its owner takes reasonable steps to keep it confidential. It may be a formula, manufacturing process, customer list, software code or AI model weights. A patent requires disclosure for time-limited exclusivity, a trade secret remains protected while it stays secret. The law should punish theft, bribery and breach of confidence, not honest discovery or reverse engineering. It should be a fence, not a monopoly. Article 39 of the WTO’s TRIPS Agreement requires protection for undisclosed information.
This proposal is not new. A draft National Innovation Act appeared in 2008, cooperation with the United States followed in 2016, the Law Commission was asked to study the issue in 2017, a parliamentary committee recommended a separate law in 2021, and the Commission delivered a report and draft bill in March 2024. But no bill has been placed in Parliament so far. Four developments make the case urgent. Investor confidence in 2,117 global capability centres must be bolstered with a solid legal framework. Returning start-ups such as PhonePe and Razorpay should come home to stronger safeguards. AI models and sensitive client data, and commitments in the UK-India and EU-India arrangements must all be taken into account.
The law must protect people as well as information. Valuable know-how lives in employees, vendors and executives. A modern statute should define secrets and misappropriation, protect whistleblowers and honest journalism, preserve workers’ freedom to use their general skills, and provide swift injunctions and damages. Closed hearings and edited judgments should prevent secrets from being exposed in court. Duties should be proportionate to business size. Emergency licensing must be narrowly defined, time-limited and reviewable, with Parliament examining the law after five years. State-backed theft should have a separate, carefully controlled economic-espionage law.
The government itself needs to be made accountable by the same legal framework. It receives confidential information through tenders, tax records, drug approvals and regulatory filings; it must protect what firms entrust to it and never pass secrets to favoured companies. Espionage prosecutions need senior sanction and judicial oversight, so accusations cannot become tools of harassment. The article also addresses concerns about drug access, worker mobility and state overreach.
The story returns to 1977, but the roles have changed. India once asked for a company’s formula; today the world entrusts India with chip designs, drug processes, software and AI models. That trust rests on contracts, courts and goodwill, but not yet on a clear statutory lock. Self-reliance is not only about making things at home. It is also about keeping what we know, and protecting what others trust us to keep.
Read the full article here on Chapter 1 Magazine.


