Wednesday, December 2, 2020
Home Opinions When Mahatma Gandhi mediated a debate over whether Vedic Hindus ate beef

When Mahatma Gandhi mediated a debate over whether Vedic Hindus ate beef

Right from its ban in Maharashtra, Haryana to the Dadri lynching, Beef has become the hot topic in India. The beef over Beef has made Sahitya Akademi recipients return their prestigious awards, with everyone citing the rising intolerance in India under BJP government.

While news channels were actively fanning communal tensions by bringing in the religious angle to the Dadri incident, it also projected this lynching as ‘the first of its kind ever in India’. This ‘first of its kind’ projection stimulated me to do a search of similar events that could have happened before this. Initial search in Google news with custom date ranges did not bring many search results and the search could only take me as far as 2000. Also, I tried with only English keywords and not Hindi, so I could have missed out any such events in regional newspapers.

Then, I turned over to Google Books, to find out whether ‘murders related to cow slaughter’ had ever happened in India. Via that search, I got a chance to read some excerpts from a book called ‘Beast and Man of India’ written by a J.L.Kipling (father of Rudyard Kipling). A chapter was devoted to cow & bull and how it finds its high place in agrarian India. But, in the search results, something else caught my eye – a screenshot of page 331 (Volume 9) of an old magazine called ‘Young India’ edited by none other than the famous Gandhiji. Unable to browse through the excerpt there, as Google had not taken snippets of the book, I tried to find an alternate online source for reading Young India. Thankfully, some really good guys at Gandhi Heritage Portal had kept 14 volumes of Young India magazine in their website. After browsing through every edition of Volume 9, I zeroed in on that particular page, which was a part of Young India published on September 29, 1927.

Nearly, 88 years before, Gandhiji had been a kind-of-mediator for a discussion over ‘whether the Vedic Hindus really ate beef or not’. Gandhiji starts the particular column titled ‘Cow sacrifice in Vedas’, by mentioning how C. V. Vaidya had earlier written in a previous edition of the same magazine(Volume 9, June 2 1927, Page 179), about the methods to protect cow. In that article, while Vaidya was listing the different steps needed for cow protection, it was mentioned that ‘cow was slaughtered during the Vedic period’. This had caught the attention of S.D.Satwalekar, who had written a rebuttal of Vadiya’s claims in a letter to Gandhiji.

1

Satwalekar in his letter, uses three verses from Charaka Samhita, to highlight how a Prishadra tried to slaughter cow and people who ate beef suffered from dysentery. He argues that it had happened, but it was not a ‘respectable’ practice.

2-3

Satwalekar then continues to mention about punishment in Vedas for cow slaughter and argues that how can such practise be prevalent when it was sure to be awarded with death. He then explains how Cow was an untouched animal in Vedic period, by explaining the etymology of its three Vedic names, ‘Adhanya’ (one which is not slaughtered), ‘Ahi’ (one which may not be killed) and ‘Aditi’ (one which may not be hacked to pieces).

4

Then, he mentions a single-line mantra and another four-line mantra to corroborate his claim that cows were not slaughtered in Vedic period. He concludes his reply by stating that ‘wise and thoughtful’ never killed cow and therefore, it cannot be regarded as an approved practice.

5

Satwalekar reply is followed by Vaidya’s reply, where he briefly states that cow slaughter would had been considered sinful, yet it was done for sacrificial purposes and Aryans in their hoary days had eaten beef, which Aryans of later periods had considered a heinous sin. After Vaidya’s reply, Satwalekar again comes back with six points to support his earlier claim. Below are those six points.

6-7

What do I incur from this exchange of letter? There is a possibility that people ate beef in Vedic age, as claimed by Vaidya. There is also a possibility that people neither touched beef not slaughtered cow, even for sacrifices. If someone who is an expert in Sanskrit and had read through all the Vedas, can bring some more verses that support or oppose the claims here, to the table, then it can enrich our debate with more facts and proofs. Until then, let me consider that I am just sharing it here, because I chanced upon this article in “Gandhiji’s magazine”and found it interesting that the same topic had been discussed nearly a century ago.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Manithan
Irritating. Irreligious. Opportunist. Group of Atoms. Hypocrite. Selfish.

Related Articles

Trending now

Yogi Adityanath to visit Maharashtra to attract investments to UP, Uddhav Thackeray says will not let anyone forcibly take away businesses

Yogi Adityanath will meet several industrialists and celebrities during his visit to Maharashtra to encourage them to invest in UP

After brutally suppressing protests by indigenous tribes in Canada, PM Justin Trudeau pontificates over farmers’ protests in India

Even though Canadian PM Justin Trudeau expressed his "concern" over the farmers' protest in India, Canada had last year moved WTO against India for high MSP rates

Farmer protest: From celebrity protestors hijacking the ‘protest’ to AAP and Congress fighting for credit, the circus is here

The farmers protests in Delhi have turned into a Shaheen Bagh redux with the same usual suspects coming together.

PFI is using ’72 hoors in Jannat’ concept to lure Muslim men into Jihadi activities, running terrorist schools: Sufi Islamic Board

PFI and SDPI are under scanner after the anti-Hindu Delhi Riots and Bengaluru riots earlier this year.

Maharashtra: Farmers in four districts record Rs 10 crore out-of-mandi trade with the help of new farm laws

FPCs in four districts in Maharashtra have made about Rs 10 crores from trade outside mandis after the laws were passed

Instead of answering allegations, Shehla Rashid decides to run away from a live show, calls her father ‘greedy’

Shehla Rashid, JNU student leader, has been accused by her biological father Abdul Rashid Shora, of taking Rs 3 crore from terror funding accused Zahoor Vatali and Rashid Engineer.

Recently Popular

Indian man proposes to his Australian girlfriend during Ind vs Aus cricket match, here is what happened next

While India's performance has been below par, netizens found happiness in the unusual proposal that became the highlight of the match.

Yogi snubs Trudeau, deputes bureaucrats to welcome the Canadian PM

The Canadian PM seems to be getting differential treatment

Indian Idol contestant reveals how she faced opposition from conservative Muslim society as singing is ‘not allowed’

The Indian Idol contestant revealed how women in her society are looked down upon if they try to excel in any field.

Shiv Sena to organise Azaan recitation competition, party leader calls it as important as ‘Maha Aarti’

Shiv Sena is to bear the cost of the event and will also reward the contest winners.

Instead of answering allegations, Shehla Rashid decides to run away from a live show, calls her father ‘greedy’

Shehla Rashid, JNU student leader, has been accused by her biological father Abdul Rashid Shora, of taking Rs 3 crore from terror funding accused Zahoor Vatali and Rashid Engineer.

ED reveals that Mumbai Police have not examined raw data from BARC, something that should have been the starting point of investigation

It is pertinent to note that in the complaint by Hansa Research, based on which the initial FIR was filed named only India Today and a few other local channels as the main accused in the alleged TRP scam.

London: South Hall’s Havelock Road, named after British general who fought Sikhs, renamed as Guru Nanak Road

The name change of a part of Havelock road in London's Southall district will come into effect early in 2021

Yogi Adityanath to visit Maharashtra to attract investments to UP, Uddhav Thackeray says will not let anyone forcibly take away businesses

Yogi Adityanath will meet several industrialists and celebrities during his visit to Maharashtra to encourage them to invest in UP

Blocked roads, shut shops, water scarcity: Delhiites suffer due to farmer protests while the state govt welcomes the protesters

Several roads connecting Delhi with nearby states have been blocked by police due to farmer protests, increasing traffic on other ones

As Justin Trudeau interferes in India’s internal politics, ‘liberals’ invoke ‘Howdy, Trump’ event to again spread lies on PM Modi

Leftist liberals started hoping on one leg after some social media users slammed Justin Trudeau for interfering in India internal matters

Indian security forces entered 200 meters inside Pakistan to unearth starting point of the tunnel used by JeM terrorists

On November 22, a 150-meter tunnel used by terrorists was detected by security forces in Samba sector of Jammu and Kashmir

‘Sanitary Panels clearly implies that SC is biased towards BJP’: Attorney General slams comic artist for assault on courts, allows contempt proceedings

Webcomic Sanitary Panels founder Rachita Taneja is known for her controversial, hateful and often Hinduphobic Tweets

Meerut: Communal tension after members of Muslim community create ruckus over Facebook post ‘insulting’ Prophet Muhammad

Police force from several police stations was reportedly called in to control the situation in Meerut.

Uttar Pradesh: Case under new Love Jihad law filed against two men for trying to convert a married Hindu woman to Islam

Case filed against Nadeem and Salman for trying to convert their Hindu co-worker Akshay's wife to Islam by regularly visiting her

After brutally suppressing protests by indigenous tribes in Canada, PM Justin Trudeau pontificates over farmers’ protests in India

Even though Canadian PM Justin Trudeau expressed his "concern" over the farmers' protest in India, Canada had last year moved WTO against India for high MSP rates

After creating trouble during Delhi Riots and Hathras, Bhim Army chief reaches the farmer protests site, now hijacked by Khalistanis

The so-called farmer protests have already been marred by the presence of Khalistani elements.

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
491,875FollowersFollow
20,300SubscribersSubscribe