Saturday, October 24, 2020
Home Editor's picks As India aspires to develop, the World strengthens its Climate Change narrative

As India aspires to develop, the World strengthens its Climate Change narrative

Greta’s outburst yesterday, once again, brought back memories of those early readings in greater force, as it did for so many people around the world and thus the world (of intellectuals on social media) exploded into primarily two parts - the Climate Change believers and the Climate Change skeptics. 

Since Greta Thunberg’s speech at the UN yesterday, the world (of social media) has exploded. The 30-year-old debate on Climate Change has resurfaced and how! Around the turn of this century, a film ‘Inconvenient Truth’ by Al Gore took the world by storm. I still remember an enduring image from the film, when Al Gore, an extremely prolific speaker, actually climbs the ladder on the stage to show how the temperatures have risen over the past few centuries. It had had a huge impact on me. The doomsday seemed to be near and we, as a human race, seemed to be walking right into its trap. 

This was around the same time that I had recently completed my Masters in Environmental Planning in the US and thus professionally accepted that I would be a part of the scene that will help create solutions, come up with innovation and planning and management techniques to curb the threat of Climate Change.

Thankfully, in due course of professional and academic pursuits, I worked with experts and mentors who guided me, no, coaxed me to look at the Science of Climate Change and also the dynamics of its politics in greater detail. So the impact of the ‘Inconvenient Truth’ wore off quickly to arrive at a conclusion that the narrative that’s being built around Climate Change needs greater scrutiny than what it is getting. This started as a mere thought at the time but reinforced itself as the world bypassed doomsday predictions of Climate Change easily. There had to be something more if the science is not supporting the narrative. This is exactly what professionals should do, right? They wait for conclusive tests and trials before pronouncing a malady. But, the world was not in a position to listen. The frenzy around Climate Change just grew and grew until it became the ultimate truth. Every child, since kindergarten started to parrot the words. And we, professionals, were sometimes left floundering. For want of conclusive science, I particularly could not diagnose nor prescribe the narrative of Climate Change, but laypersons around me swore by it. 

Even the early readings about the North versus South divide on a Climate Change give an insight into the politics around this issue. And of particular interest to me was the unfairness of it all to India and other developing countries. In fact, Greta’s outburst yesterday, once again, brought back memories of those early readings in greater force, as it did for so many people around the world and thus the world (of intellectuals on social media) exploded into primarily two parts – the Climate Change believers and the Climate Change skeptics. 

In a nutshell, the entire Climate Change narrative can be summed up to say that we, as a world, have reached a level of CO2 emissions where we cannot/should not add more. While this is the premise of the narrative, skeptics will argue that this is so far unproven scientifically. So developed countries started sending out messages through international conferences and educational programs that ‘developing’ countries should not add to this pool of global CO2 by wanting to develop like they themselves did in the 19th and 20th centuries.

The argument most commonly was and even today is, “Don’t make the same mistakes”, of course, never ever accepting that they made a mistake. So as not seem too unfair, given that China and India are two powerful nations, the narrative revolved vaguely around a concept of Carbon Credits, a monetisation of pollution. But that failed to take off as well because science and economics did not support it adequately. There are many allegations about vested interests and means for accessing Green Funds by Climate Change influencers etc, but I will not delve into those since these are unproven as well. 

In the meanwhile, in a typical Chinese fashion, China refused anything and everything the world had to say on Climate Change and developed at a pace that’s unprecedented in the history of the world. Within a single generation, the country brought poverty under control by giving her citizens adequate infrastructure to run the economy for its billion-plus people. Done. No one dared ask questions.

Now as India reared her head ever so slightly under PM Modi’s leadership since 2014, showing signs of development, the Climate Change narrative gained momentum. The developed world, once again, seemed to ask, “why are you developing?”. We need to keep our CO2 emissions low, you know. And then the same parroting of platitudes – we are not anti-development, but what about sustainability? I keep asking this question – can anyone in this world show how any nation can develop her infrastructure without increasing her carbon footprint? It’s inevitable and the only recourse is to optimise!

A teenager’s monologue and emotional appeal yesterday brought into my mind a typical teenager in my country. And this is not a teenager in an Indian city in an upper-middle-class household. A typical teenager in India is still in a small town somewhere, just larger than a village, who is struggling to reach school for want of a better road or suffers an iron deficiency for want of modern healthcare. A typical teenager in India is the one who aspires to be educated and find a good job in a city, even travel abroad, if lucky, and improve her parents’ lives. My first thought was, will and should an emotional appeal from an entitled European teenager, with a carbon footprint around 9 (German average) be allowed to set a development narrative for a teenager whose carbon footprint is 1 (Indian average)? 

Earlier, I was confident that science will catch up with the unfairness of global politics and we, as a humanity, will correct our course. But since this has not happened so far, I am further worried about the damage this Climate Change discourse will do to India. And the worst part is, the world from outside India never tells us what to do. It does it through the medium of foreign-educated intellectuals (like me) and thus successfully thwarts development from within. 

Having said this, as a professional in the field of Environment, there is no denying the fact that we are polluting and degrading our natural resources. Whether this leads to Climate Change or not may be up for debate, but the fact remains that we are rapidly dirtying our air, our water and depleting precious natural resources. And hence the focus of my professional journey has been to find local solutions – innovations, planning and management techniques to reduce pollution of our activities, to optimise the use of natural resources. Constantly, find ways to optimise rather than say NO. Instead of looking at every activity in the shadow of the Climate Change narrative, we have chosen to provide solutions so that India can continue her quest of offering liveability, access to basic services such as electrification, water supply, housing, healthcare, mobility etc, but we do so in a responsible manner. 

And hence, I have often circumvented discussions on Climate Change, at the peril of losing credibility, just as a doctor would look at unproven science, even if there is a strong narrative around it amongst the patients. We have tried to look at this objectively, much to the chagrin of Climate Change enthusiasts. This issue is similar to the quandary we feel when the scientific community makes its constant flip around eating an egg. First, an egg was great then it was bad for cholesterol and once again now it’s apparently good for the heart. Just like all this while, we continued to eat it in moderation, so should we continue India’s quest for a liveable country that offers basic services to all her population.

We should be mindful of local pollution that will threaten peoples’ well being but also allow for a broader judgment of overall economic and social well being, through mitigation, management and remediation solutions. We should accept the fact that India’s addition of infrastructure to meet the requirements of her people will add to CO2 emissions. We should just try to ensure that these are optimum, offsets made through compensatory actions. Any narrative, emotional or otherwise, and especially, an unproven one, is set to hinder India’s quest for economic growth, should not come in India’s way.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Anagha Paranjape-Purohithttp://mazepune.com/
Architect-Planner. Pune & Arizona State Univ Graduate. Sustainability consultant. Public Policy. Green Buildings. Teacher. Writer. Tedx.

Related Articles

Trending now

Pakistan fumes over reports of Saudi denying permission for ‘Kashmir Black Day’ program after it voted against it at FATF

After certain media reports suggested that Saudi Arabia had voted against Pakistan at the FATF plenary keeping it in grey list, the Arab nation has now reportedly denied Pakistan permission to hold 'Kashmir Black Day' on 27th October.

Faisal Khan says he wants to come out of brother Aamir Khan’s shadow who had earlier called him ‘mentally ill’

Faisal Khan said he will have to break out of his superstar brother's shadow and make his own decisions so that people recognise him as an individual

Exclusive: Conversation that shows how Mumbai Police is trying to coerce witness into naming Republic TV in TRP scam

While Hansa Research report and the FIR filed named India Today in TRP scam, in less than 24 hours, Mumbai Police had seemingly made up its mind that Republic TV was the culprit

Param Bir Singh now wants details of every purchase and expense made by Republic TV, even microphones, toilet papers, makeup and stationery

"This an overt attempt to harass a news organisation, infringe on its operations and bring back the Emergency-era way of functioning," Republic TV stated.

Bihar’s ‘lantern’ era has ended, those who made the state ‘Bimaru’ can not come back to power: PM Modi in Sasaram

PM Narendra Modi addressed his first election rally at Biada Maidan in Sasaram days before Bihar polls.

Legendary cricketer Kapil Dev suffers heart attack, admitted to Delhi hospital

Kapil Dev undergoes angioplasty surgery in Delhi after suffering a heart attack

Recently Popular

Exclusive: Conversation that shows how Mumbai Police is trying to coerce witness into naming Republic TV in TRP scam

While Hansa Research report and the FIR filed named India Today in TRP scam, in less than 24 hours, Mumbai Police had seemingly made up its mind that Republic TV was the culprit

‘He supplies drugs and girls’: Estranged wife of Mahesh Bhatt’s nephew Luviena Lodh alleges harassment by nephew-uncle duo

Luviena Lodh said that Mahesh Bhatt is the don of the industry, and he controls everything that goes on in the film industry

France: Charlie Hebdo cartoons projected on government building to express solidarity with deceased teacher who was beheaded by Islamic terrorist

Days after the barbaric beheading of teacher Samuel Paty on the streets of Paris by a terrorist for showing the cartoons of Prophet Mohammad to his students, support continues to pour in for the deceased teacher.

‘Jism ki garmi’: How Hindi film industry disregarded consent and normalised rape and molestation over the years

The Hindi film industry has, knowingly or unknowingly, convinced a generation of people that rape is normal when done in light of 'greater good'.

Lucknow: Jama Mazar caretaker ‘Kale Baba’ caught running sex racket, video goes viral

The caretaker has allegedly confessed to police that he was sexually exploiting women and engaging them in illicit activities in the name of curing infertility and other ailments.

Complaints filed against Eros Now and Arré for vulgar social media posts related to Navratri

Both Eros Now and Arre had published social media posts linking Navratri festival with sex and vulgarity
- Advertisement -

Pakistan fumes over reports of Saudi denying permission for ‘Kashmir Black Day’ program after it voted against it at FATF

After certain media reports suggested that Saudi Arabia had voted against Pakistan at the FATF plenary keeping it in grey list, the Arab nation has now reportedly denied Pakistan permission to hold 'Kashmir Black Day' on 27th October.

ED summons Punjab CM Captain Amarinder Singh’s son Raninder Singh in FEMA violation case

Amarinder Singh’s son Raninder Singh summoned by ED in relation to a trust named Jacaranda Trust & subsidiaries in British Virgin Islands

Delhi: Already married twice, e-rickshaw driver Dilbar Qureshi poses as Rahul to trap 13-year-old Hindu girl, calls the second wife his sister to deceive...

Dildar Qureshi elopes with minor Hindu girl in Delhi after introducing himself as Rahul, police launches a manhunt

OpIndia exclusive report vindicated: Bombay HC directs India Today to deposit Rs 5 lakh fine imposed by BARC for viewership data malpractice

OpIndia was the first to expose the matter regarding the show-cause notice being sent to India Today by BARC in April this year

‘He supplies drugs and girls’: Estranged wife of Mahesh Bhatt’s nephew Luviena Lodh alleges harassment by nephew-uncle duo

Luviena Lodh said that Mahesh Bhatt is the don of the industry, and he controls everything that goes on in the film industry

Mumbai Police registers FIR against the entire editorial team of Republic TV alleging incitement of disaffection among Mumbai police and defamation

FIR filed against the entire editorial team of the Republic TV for allegedly citing Hansa Research's report on the TRP scam case

Dalit woman gang-raped in Jalore in Rajasthan, victim files case after the accused circulate a video of the act

The victim had reportedly taken her goats for grazing when she was gang-raped by three persons in Jalore in Rajasthan 4 months ago

Tamil Nadu: Chidambaram MP Thol Thirumavalavan says Sanatana Dharma treats women as ‘sex workers’

"Women are basically created as prostitutes by God. All women are prostitutes as per Hindu Dharma, Manu Dharma. All women are prostitutes. This is what the Sanatana Dharma says", said the MP.

139 villages in Gujarat set an example in preventing Coronavirus before the world with not a single positive case recorded so far

The people in these villages have been strictly following the Coronavirus guidelines by wearing masks and following social distancing.

Kashmir: Two terrorists, Abid and Mehraj, surrender before the Indian army after the intervention of parents

When the presence of terrorists was confirmed, security forces called their parents to convince them to surrender

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
467,330FollowersFollow
19,100SubscribersSubscribe