Sunday, August 9, 2020
Home Law Why Sabarimala temple issue should not be clubbed with women entry to mosques

Why Sabarimala temple issue should not be clubbed with women entry to mosques

At first sight, these might appear like similar issues, all related to the common theme of dignity and rights of women. They are not.

Today, a five judge bench of the Supreme Court decided to refer a bundle of cases to a larger seven judge bench: the Sabarimala Temple case, petitions relating to entry of women into mosques as well as the matter of female genital mutilation within the Dawoodi Bohra community.

At first sight, these might appear like similar issues, all related to the common theme of dignity and rights of women. They are not.

Read: SC refers the Sabarimala matter to a larger bench by 3:2 majority, pegged with issues like women entry into Mosques and FGM

One of the things that has been missing from the public discourse surrounding Sabarimala Temple has been moral clarity. So here is my humble effort to explain things, carved into a simple Q & A format.

- Advertisement -

Isn’t it wrong that Sabarimala Temple denies entry to women (of certain ages)? 

That is not for us to decide. That is for the management of the temple to decide in consultation of devotees of Ayyappa.

But still, isn’t it always discriminatory to admit people of one sex and not another? 

Let’s make this simpler. Suppose that Sabarimala were not a temple but a school exclusively for boys. Or for that matter, a school exclusively for girls. Would you still call it discrimination? Would you still ask the state to intervene and make sure that the Sabarimala school admits students of all sexes?

Read: Sabarimala is NOT about ‘impurity’ being associated with menstruation, stop repeating that lie

Shouldn’t the state act to end discrimination in public spaces?

The Indian Constitution does allow for an ‘activist state’ : where the state intervenes to ensure social justice and dignity for all.

However, a temple is not a public space in the same way as a public park or even a privately owned shopping mall. This is intuitively clear to all. For example, beef is legal in Kerala. If you think of a temple as a public space similar to a park, then should it be legal to eat beef inside the temple? What if someone wanted to enter the temple wearing a shirt carrying abusive slogans against the gods? Can they be denied entry for that?

I believe most people would agree that the temple should be allowed to ban beef eating within its premises.

Read: Sabarimala: Consent of the Governed vs Divine Right

The truth is that the status of Hindu temples in India is based on a tricky compromise between religion and state. The state takes over the temple and in return agrees to respect religious sentiments in the running of temple affairs.

So the state should never intervene just because a temple says they have a tradition? What if they try to deny entry to Dalits?

The question is under what circumstances should the state intervene. When there is a systemic social injustice that denies dignity to a group of people, the state should intervene and set it right.

Denying temple entry to Dalits has a long and painful history in our country. If a temple tried to deny entry to someone based on caste, the state should intervene and act against them immediately.

The Sabarimala case is exactly the opposite. It is *one* temple with one specific tradition grounded in ancient faith.

How is the Sabarimala case different from women seeking entry to mosques?

Because women are uniformly denied entry to mosques. This is a systemic injustice that is happening everywhere. State intervention is needed to correct this.

Read: No Mr Owaisi, the oppressive practice of Triple Talaq and the traditions of Sabarimala cannot be equated. Here is why

In the case of Sabarimala, this is one temple making a choice based on a specific tradition. There is no history of Hindu women being denied entry to temples as a general rule.

If Sabarimala is allowed to uphold its tradition, why not triple talaq? 

Again, triple talaq is a systemic injustice that humiliates women, which could affect almost any Muslim woman anywhere.

Sabarimala is one temple in one corner of Kerala.

The reality is that, once you strip away the rhetoric and agendas, the Sabarimala Temple issue is quite simple. The matter has been unnecessarily caught up in the rhetoric of gender justice. At the heart of all this is just one temple in one place with a specific tradition. The existence of this temple and this tradition causes no systemic harm or humiliation to anyone. If you do not like the tradition, you don’t have to be in their face with your business. You can always go to the hundreds of thousands of other Hindu temples all around the country. No harm done.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Abhishek Banerjeehttps://dynastycrooks.wordpress.com/
Abhishek Banerjee is a math lover who may or may not be an Associate Professor at IISc Bangalore. He is the author of Operation Johar - A Love Story, a novel on the pain of left wing terror in Jharkhand, available on Amazon here.  

Related Articles

Trending now

Was Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Singh thrashed by Dalit Morcha of AAP, asks BJP leader Kapil Mishra

Kapil Mishra made the comment at a time when Sanjay Singh from the AAP has been leading a spirited effort to brand the BJP 'anti-Dalit'.

Rajasthan: 11 Pakistani Hindu refugees including five children die in Jodhpur

Pakistani Hindu refugees who had come from Sindh province were found dead in Jodhpur, Rajasthan.

Kakori Train Robbery: On this day in 1925 one of the most landmark events of Indian independence movement took place

The Kakori Train Robbery also known as the Kakori conspiracy was an armed robbery which took place on August 9, 1925, on a train in central Uttar Pradesh and the subsequent court trial instituted by the government of British India against more than 20 Indian revolutionaries accused of involvement, directly or otherwise, in the crime.

Maharashtra: Mount Carmel school teacher Sunita Joseph suspended for hurting religious sentiments of Hindus

Catholic school teacher in Maharashtra suspended for sharing a Hindophobic message on the school's class 6 WhatsApp group

Amit Shah’s COVID19 test not yet conducted, say MHA officials

BJP MP Manoj Tiwari on Sunday took to Twitter to announce that Home Minister has tested negative for coronavirus.

Sushant Singh Rajput’s brother-in-law gives a befitting reply to toxic journalism of Shekhar Gupta’s portal

Sushant Singh Rajput's brother-in-law Vishal Kirti on Sunday slammed Shekhar Gupta and his portal for toxic journalism.

Recently Popular

Who really is Binod? Read how one Youtube comment triggered a bizarre meme fest

The name 'Binod', which has now become the talk of the town and trending on Twitter, originated from a YouTube channel 'Slayy Point'

Sushant Singh Rajput’s former manager Disha Salian’s post-mortem report says she was found nude after her death: Reports

According to the post-mortem report of Disha Salian, her body was found nude, which was not revealed by the police so far

Pakistan: Maulvi rapes child reading Quran in mosque in Sindh province, caught on CCTV

Muslim Cleric in Sindh province in Pakistan on the run after video of hem raping a child inside a mosque emerges, case registered

Pakistan borrows $1 Billion from its all-weather ally China to repay $1 Billion Saudi Arabia loan to avoid default on international debt obligations

China tightens its grip over Pakistan, gives $1 billion loan to repay Saudi Arabia's $1 billion loan, grants 90% of $6.8 billion railway project

‘These numbers are bewildering’: Watch how Rajdeep Sardesai refuses to believe India Today survey’s approval rating of PM Modi

Rajdeep Sardesai was rather shocked and bewildered as his own channel's survey seems to give PM Modi's handling of the economy an approval rating of 72%

‘Be a good wife’: 14-year-old Christian girl Maria Shahbaz, abducted and converted to Islam, to be returned to her abductor, rules Lahore HC

The Lahore High Court has ruled in favour of a Muslim perpetrator who abducted, forcibly converted and married an underage Christian girl.

After Pakistan threatens to split Saudi Arabia led OIC for not discussing Kashmir, Saudi govt decides not to renew oil supply pact with Pakistan

Saudi Arabia defers oil supply contact with Pakistan after Imran Khan Govt Threatens to Split OIC over Kashmir

Delhi Health Minister Satyendra Jain blames outsiders for rising cases of Coronavirus in the National Capital

However, since the number of Coronavirus cases is again on the rise in Delhi, Satyendra Jain chose to shift the blame on the outsiders instead of taking up the responsibility.

Rapper Badshah confesses to having paid Rs 75 lakh for fake views and likes of his videos: Report

Rapper Badshah had paid Rs 75 lakh for additional views on one of his music videos, in a bid to break a viewership record in first 24 hours

Was Rajya Sabha MP Sanjay Singh thrashed by Dalit Morcha of AAP, asks BJP leader Kapil Mishra

Kapil Mishra made the comment at a time when Sanjay Singh from the AAP has been leading a spirited effort to brand the BJP 'anti-Dalit'.

Kakori Train Robbery: On this day in 1925 one of the most landmark events of Indian independence movement took place

The Kakori Train Robbery also known as the Kakori conspiracy was an armed robbery which took place on August 9, 1925, on a train in central Uttar Pradesh and the subsequent court trial instituted by the government of British India against more than 20 Indian revolutionaries accused of involvement, directly or otherwise, in the crime.

Uttar Pradesh: Video of intoxicated man hanging son upside down and brutally beating him goes viral, case registered by Agra police

According to Superintendent of Police Ravi Kumar, the accused seen in the video was miffed with his eldest son

“Delete the video or there will be negative consequences,” Chinese embassy threatens India based strategic affairs portal over a critical video on Xi Jinping

Chinese authorities were irked with the portrayal of Xi Jinping in a 'negative light' by Indian portal 'Strat News Global run by Nitin A Gokhale

Maharashtra: Mount Carmel school teacher Sunita Joseph suspended for hurting religious sentiments of Hindus

Catholic school teacher in Maharashtra suspended for sharing a Hindophobic message on the school's class 6 WhatsApp group

Sushant Singh Rajput’s brother-in-law gives a befitting reply to toxic journalism of Shekhar Gupta’s portal

Sushant Singh Rajput's brother-in-law Vishal Kirti on Sunday slammed Shekhar Gupta and his portal for toxic journalism.

Atmanirbhar Bharat gets a push as Defence Minister Rajnath Singh announces import embargo on 101 weapon systems

The Defence Minister said that the decision to impose embargo 101 items will give a big boost to India’s self-reliant initiatives in the defence sector.

Connect with us

239,250FansLike
424,987FollowersFollow
294,000SubscribersSubscribe