Wednesday, April 21, 2021
Home Media How TJS George defamed Rajiv Malhotra, misrepresented Vivekananda and maligned Ambedkar, all in one...

How TJS George defamed Rajiv Malhotra, misrepresented Vivekananda and maligned Ambedkar, all in one stroke

While Swami Vivekananda called converts out of Hinduism as “perverts” and Bhimji called them “denationalised”, Rajiv Malhotra did not even repeat any of these.

Recently, writer Thayil Jacob Sony George better known as TJS George (TJSG), writing for the New Indian Express (NIE), equated Rajiv Malhotra to the poison-spewing self-hating sepoy of the West, Christian-convert evangelist Lazarus Mohan. These assertions are not only disingenuous but can be construed as criminally defamatory.

While Rajiv Malhotra has proven several times that he can scientifically and logically, in an evidence-based manner, substantiate his position with data and arguments, the Christian-convert evangelist Lazarus Mohan relies entirely on religious arguments that draw from the bible or illogical superstition that has no basis in science.

Thus, from the beginning of the article, it is clear that TJSG is pen-pushing an agenda rather than trying to express an honest opinion or engage in a mutually respectful debate. This author has already explained why Rajiv Malhotra is morally and ethically justifiable with regards to the specific tweet that TJSG is quoting, particularly out-of-context.

To support his arguments TJSG quotes phrases from Swami Vivekananda’s speeches and works. For example, he quotes a phrase (not even a whole sentence) from Swami Vivekananda and wrote ‘A saint who said “we accept all religions as true” is being appropriated by a party that suppresses minorities for political gains.’

DID VIVEKANANDA AND AMBEDKAR SEE CHRISTIANITY AND ISLAM AS ‘TRUE’?

Swamiji has been most scathing about Abrahamic religions. For example, Swami Vivekananda is recorded to have stated, “When the Mohammedans first came, we are said — I think on the authority of Ferishta, the oldest Mohammedan historian — to have been six hundred millions of Hindus. Now we are about two hundred million. And then every man going out of the Hindu pale is not only a man less but an enemy the more.” It is not only the use of the word “enemy” that is most striking but the converts were described as “Hindu perverts” (“Hindu perverts to Islam and Christianity are perverts by the sword, or the descendants of these.” ~ Vol 5 Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda)

The same sentiment is seen in Bharat Ratna Ambedkar’s words a few decades down the lane. He stated during the middle of his life that “Conversion to Islam or Christianity will denationalise the depressed classes,” and reiterated the same opinion just before dying, “Buddhism is part and parcel of Bhartiya Culture. I have taken care that conversion will not harm the traditions, the culture and history of this land. I confess I have many quarrels with caste Hindus over some points but, I take my vow that I shall lay down my life in defence of our land”.

While Swami Vivekananda called converts out of Hinduism as “perverts” and Bhimji called them “denationalised”, Rajiv Malhotra did not even repeat any of these. He tweeted that Hindus should donate to Hindu or truly secular charities that will not indulge in proselytisation. Is it not comparably insignificant compared to what Swamiji or Bhimji have said?

Will TJS George claim that Swamiji and Bhimji were “peddlers of religious hatred”? Appears so.

Now let us see another example of what Swamiji said in Chicago 115-years ago (on the 15th of September 1893) about the narrow-mindedness of the faiths that which TJGS is cunningly defending.

Swamiji described a frog that lived in a well on its own and which had assumed that the well is the whole world. When a sea-living frog got washed away on to the shores and jumped into the well, the well-trapped frog asked where did the sea-living frog come from. When the sea-living frog said it came from the sea, the well-trapped frog asked for the size of the sea in comparison to its tiny well. The sea-living frog laughed and explained the size of the sea was immeasurable, especially when compared to the tiny well. The well-trapped frog got furious with disbelief and unable to bear the truth threw the sea-living frog out of the well. The author need not explain (to the people with conscientious brains) which religions Swamiji must have had in mind, especially given his statements about the “Hindu perverts” to the “denationalising” religions.

CAN TJSG USE VIVEKANANDA TO SUPPORT HIS ANTI-GAU-RAKSHA RHETORIC?

Regarding cow’s meat, Swami Vivekananda insisted that not eating beef is the “one point of unity among all Hindus” across the entire subcontinent. Yet TJSG does not refrain from critically abusing the supporters of Gau Rakshas in the same article while appropriating and misquoting Swami Vivekananda to make his point appear valid. Is it surprising that TJS George, named after the mythical patron saint of England is playing this part so well?

Thus, quoting Swami Vivekananda out-of-context and calling the stance taken by the current ruling dispensation as against the visions and words of the Swamiji is a gross misrepresentation and possibly defamatory.

THE FAVOURITE WHIPPING BOY OF THE SECULARS – THE RSS AGAIN

TJGS not only misrepresents Swami Vivekananda he goes against the grain and words of Bhimji as well in the process, calling the organisation (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh, RSS) praised by Bhimji in 1939 as an exemplar of a caste-free association as “suppressing minorities” and as one which is calling for a “sectarian war”. TJGS was alluding to RSS without naming it explicitly as again he quoted a phrase, not a whole sentence, from RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat’s recent speech in the US: ‘But Chicago heard this time a different voice that called for a sectarian war lest “the lone lion is destroyed by wild dogs”.’ Simply atrocious.

TJGS is able to do this because he is confident that none will call his bluff. The NIE newspaper publishes it because it sees no liability peddling such vile lies. This is an age-old technique of the missionaries and the Left cabal.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Murali KV
The author, a medic and a graduate of the University of Cambridge, is currently a consultant and has over half-a-dozen peer-reviewed scientific publications, ranging from clinical research to population genetics.

Related Articles

Trending now

Breathing oxygen? Thank a tree hugger in Aarey forest

As media reports started going oxygen, oxygen, oxygen in the last few days, the 'liberals' recalled their primary school science lessons.

No masks, abuses and ruckus: How a Shiv Sena corporator abuses power to threaten doctors on duty

The doctors of Bhagwati Hospital have threatened to resign after being humiliated by the Shiv Sena corporator.

Uttar Pradesh: SC inquiry commission gives clean chit to UP Police in Vikas Dubey encounter case

Supreme Court's inquiry commission found no evidence of wrongdoing against Uttar Pradesh Police in Vikas Dubey encounter case

India Inc step in after PM Modi addresses the nation on Covid crisis, here is how TATA, Reliance and others are pitching in

SAIL has informed that it has provided over 33,000 tons of medical oxygen from its steel plants so far.

Gujarat: Mob pelts stones, attacks police for asking them to not offer namaz in huge crowd

To control the violent mob, police had to resort to using tear gas. However, even then the mob was out of control. Eventually they had to call in additional forces.

The curious case of vaccines in Chhattisgarh: Why aren’t we talking about this?

Further, in February itself Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel had said that his state government will make the vaccines free for all.

Recently Popular

AAP supported farmer protests hampering war against Covid-19, oxygen supplier writes to GOI saying tankers delayed due to roadblocks by protestors

Inox Air Products said that they are facing delays in Delhi while transporting oxygen due to road blockades by the farmer protestors

Journalism: The new performance art

With the COVID-19 pandemic, journalists have screamed "Beware of the Ides of March" to anyone who would listen - Barkha Dutt for example.

IIT Kanpur Professor predicts COVID-19 to peak in May, dismisses claims of Kumbh and poll rallies being responsible for spread

The IIT Kanpur professor said that since the election rallies and the Kumbh are held in open spaces, there are few chances of it spreading the COVID virus

Understanding the hate factory: How Rohan Joshi and his hateful post against Hindus gives us an insight into the ‘liberal’ mind

Comedian Rohan Joshi tells Bhakts, "I have nothing but contempt for them and nit a shred of empathy" as he mocks Coronavirus deaths

From sitting on upturned dustbins to photo ops at crematorium grounds, Barkha Dutt gets questioned for her ‘vulture journalism’

While the situation on ground is indeed grim, people on social media have been calling out the dramatics by journalists who could have perhaps focused on the news instead of their brand building.

Why did 9 anti-Modi parties demand from Election Commission that rallies must be held?

Let us get into the dirt and start pointing fingers, if that is what everyone wants. How did the second wave come to be?
- Advertisement -

 

Connect with us

254,077FansLike
530,980FollowersFollow
24,200SubscribersSubscribe