Home Editor's picks Here are 4 lies being spread about 10% reservation to the economically backward section of society

Here are 4 lies being spread about 10% reservation to the economically backward section of society

The subject of reservations is a sensitive subject and any lie that gets furthered in its name can create unrest in the country. Hence, it becomes imperative to not only fact-check but ensures that these fallacious claims don't gather wind.

The Narendra Modi government, in a historic move, introduced the 124th constitutional amendment that paved the way for 10% reservation to economically backward people. Thought due to political considerations, several parties had to support the Bill, including Congress, several lies and misrepresentations started being furthered by these political parties and their supporters.

The subject of reservations is a sensitive subject and any lie that gets furthered in its name can create unrest in the country. Hence, it becomes imperative to not only fact-check but ensures that these fallacious claims don’t gather wind.

Lie 1: The 10% reservation will accrue only to upper castes or Savarnas

The mainstream media can be largely held responsible for spreading this lie. While before this Bill was tabled, most people were speculating whether the reservation would be limited to upper castes or would encompass the general category as a while, several media persons continued to spread this lie even after the Bill was tabled in the parliament.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

Nistula Hebbar, senior journalist with The Hindu, said the reservations were for ‘uppar castes’ even thought she had tweeted a copy of the original bill moved in Parliament.

Other journalists and media houses too spread this lie liberally.

However, the truth is that in the Bill itself, the words ‘Upper caste’ finds no place at all. This 10% reservation is aimed at economically backward sections regardless of caste, creed and religion. Perhaos the journalists are peddling this fake news because now that it has been passed, the demands for caste based reservation and that of Muslim reservation would not find any traction or legal sanction. Any other category except the SC, ST, OBC etc would need to avail of the 10% quota if they meet the financial backwardness criteria.

Lie 2: Modi government is planning to eventually phase out reservation for SC, ST and OBCs

Several politicians including Arvind Kejriwal, Congress’ Jignesh Mevani and others spread the lie that ‘they had spoken to several people from RSS’ who had said that this 10% reservation for the poor is just a starting point. The BJP’s next step would be to phase out reservation for OBC, SC and ST. This lie was busted by us. 

The BJP government has reiterated several times that they do not intend to tamper with the existing 49.5% reservation already granted to socially weaker sections of the society.

Lie 3: The 10% reservation Bill breached the 50% reservation limit

We covered this aspect comprehensively too. The 10% reservation bill has been introduced by a Constitutional amendment that introduces Article 15 (6) and Article 16 (6). The 50% reservation limit pertains only to caste based reservation and this 10% reservation pertains the economically backward people which has never come up for discussion to begin with. Hence, the 50% reservation limit, that pertains only to caste based reservation according to the Indra Sawhney judgement, won’t get breached with this introduction of 10% reservation.

If at all the Bill is appealed in Supreme Court, the Court will have to evaluate the need for this 10% reservation independent of the 50% reservation limit set for socially backward classes.

Lie 4: ‘Individuals’ who earn less then Rs. 8 Lac per annum will be able to avail of this reservation

This is patently untrue. The Rs. 8 Lac per annum limit pertains to an entire family and not an individual. This limit is also in tune with the existing ‘creamy layer’ norms applicable to the 50% reservation for backward classes.

The ‘creamy layer’ criteria was defined as annual family income from all sources. n 1971, it was Rs. 1,00,000. Im 1993, it was increased to Rs. 2,50,000. It was revised against in 2004 to Rs. 4,50,000, Rs. 6,00,000 in 2013 and Rs. 8,00,000 in 2017.

The 10% reservation introduced by the Modi government adheres to the creamy layer criteria and hence, the metric is that of a family and not of an individual.

One must realise that for a family that earns Rs. 8 Lakh per annum, after standard deductions, the tax liability is miniscule. And hence, the argument that if a family pays that amount in tax they cannot be considered poor is incorrect.

One must also realise that inflation and cost of living has to be taken into account. How the Governemnt plans to impliment the scheme is another matter which has not yet been spelt out in clear terms, but these glaring lies which are politically motivated in order to create discord in the society must be called out.

Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans:
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Election 2019 Live Updates

Track all the updates on one page as the results and trends trickle in

IIT graduate and an IAS officer explains in detail why EVMs can’t be ‘hacked’ or ‘tampered’ with

Bhavesh Mishra, IAS 2015 batch, B.Tech IIT Delhi, on Quora gave a detailed explanation regarding why EVMs cannot be 'hacked' or 'tampered' with.

Barkha Dutt expresses deep anguish over the fact that the mainstream media can no longer influence elections

Barkha said it doesn't make her happy that mainstream media cannot influence the voters to vote in a particular way anymore.

‘Journalist sitting in a political party’s lap is calling others godi media’, Aaj Tak’s Rohit Sardana hits out at NDTV’s Ravish Kumar

Aaj Tak journalist Rohit Sardana said that earlier journalists used to decide ministry allocations.
Shehla Rashid remembers 2014, says she had wanted Kejriwal as PM

Shehla Rashid loses it early on counting day, says “Felt like a Muslim when ‘mass murderer’ won in 2014”

As early trends show an NDA victory, Shehla Rashid calls him a mass murderer, says she had wanted Arvind Kejriwal as PM in 2014 and she had felt like a 'Muslim'.

Live updates: According to EC, BJP leading in 299 seats on their own, clocks victory in 2, taking their tally possibly to 301

Latest results, trends, updates, and news about 2019 Lok Sabha election counting. Find out who will form the next government.
Shehla Rashid calls upon United Nations to resolve the EVM allegations

‘Why don’t we invoke the UN?’ Shehla Rashid takes EVM row to a new level as exit polls predict Modi’s victory

Shehla Rashid bemoaned about the lack of clarity and purpose among the opposition parties while levelling serious allegations of EVM fraud and rigging

Hindustan Times journalist links Hindu festival to Nathuram Godse, gets slammed

Ayudh Puja, also known as Astra Puja in some parts of India, was linked to Mahatma Gandhi's assassin.
NYT peddles Modi 2.0 as victory of India's most divisive leader

Dear New York Times, India has chosen Modi 2.0, deal with it

When India gives a thumping, unprecedented, overwhelming victory to a man who has made every single Indian feel proud of their nation and heritage, the NYT's heartburn is expected. 
Sba Naqvi spreads already debunked fake news on 'Missing EVMs'

India has 90 crore eligible voters, ‘journalists’ and opposition claim votes of 400 crore voters are ‘missing’

Following the rejection of the claims by ECI and the clarification over the issue, Frontline magazine had accepted that their report is false and a rejoinder will be published. TV9 Bharatvarsh had removed the report from their website and YouTube channel.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories

Latest articles

Connect with us

164,457FansLike
141,784FollowersFollow
64,321SubscribersSubscribe
Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans: