Home News Reports Economic Advisory Council slams Arvind Subramanian, says his criticism of GDP estimation methodology 'lacks rigor'

Economic Advisory Council slams Arvind Subramanian, says his criticism of GDP estimation methodology ‘lacks rigor’

The primary contributors to the report are Bibek Debroy, Rathin Roy, Surjit Bhalla, Charan Singh and Arvind Virmani.

The Economic Advisory Council to the Prime Minister (EAC-PM) has released a detailed analysis of India’s new GDP estimation methodology. In it, the Council has defended the technique dubbing it to be at par with global standards. It also offers a point-by-point rebuttal to former Chief Economic Adviser Dr. Arvind Subramanian’s critique of the technique where he had asserted that GDP numbers had been overestimated.

The report says, “India’s GDP estimation methodology stands at par with its global standing as a major and responsible economy. It is of the quality and precision expected from a transparent and well managed economy. The new methodology introduced in 2015 is a testament to India’s intent to adopt the most modern global standards to accurately report its economic data. And India’s direction and pace towards the goal of accurate National Income Accounting is worthy of praise.”

The primary contributors of the report “reject the author’s (Subramanian’s) methodology, arguments and conclusions” in the paper titled ‘India’s GDP Mis-estimation: Likelihood, Magnitudes, Mechanisms, and Implications’. They say that the paper does not specifically critique coverage or methodology and “lacks rigor in terms of specific data sources and description; alternative hypothesis; rationale of equation specifications, use of dummies, and robustness-check diagnostics of estimated equations; and choice of countries in the sample and a specific list”. Therefore, “it would not stand the scrutiny of academic or policy research standards”. It also remarks that the paper is not peer-reviewed.

- Ad - - article resumes -

The EAC analysis says that the former CEA has cherry-picked 17 indicators from a private agency, which is not a primary source of information.

The report notes that “the weakness of Dr. Subramanian’s attempt to suggest that the growth numbers are over-estimated confirms that the estimation process is robust to spurious criticism.” And stresses further, “The fact of the matter is that India’s GDP methodology is consistent with internationally accepted standards and is in a continuous process of improvement.” The statement also notes that Dr. Arvind Subramanian’s paper is not peer-reviewed.

However, the paper does admit that “GDP calculation has always been an imperfect art” and “Irrespective of the methodology, there are always some areas that require extrapolation, estimation and sometimes even guestimates based on past trends”. The primary contributors to the report are Bibek Debroy, Rathin Roy, Surjit Bhalla, Charan Singh and Arvind Virmani.

Reacting to Subramanian’s comments that India’s GDP has been overestimated by the previous governments, the government of India had issued a clarification last week as well.

The full report of the Economic Advisory Council can be accessed here [PDF].

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.

Big Story

Sanjay Leela Bhansali set to produce an hour-long movie based on the life of PM Modi and is titled Mann Bairagi.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

‘Professional Congress’ member posts promotional tweets for 500 rupees, blames ‘social media manager’ after having defended tweet

Flipkart Big Billion Sale is here and well, 'Congress supporters' would like to earn a few quick bucks.

‘Kashmir free from shackles of Pakistan sponsored terrorism’: Pakistani org representing Pashtuns refuses to support Imran Khan’s Kashmir protest, backs India

Pashtun Tahaffuz Movement (PTM), the principal body representing Pashtuns in Pakistan, has rejected Prime Minister Imran Khan’s recent call to all people in which he urged them to come out and support Pakistan’s narrative on Kashmir. 

Prashant Kishor’s team starts reaching out to media and influencers with ‘paid content’ offers ahead of West Bengal assembly elections

Darjeeling Chronicle has exposed how Prashant Kishor led IPAC is reaching out to 'influencers' and digital portals to carry out paid campaigning for TMC and Mamata Banerjee ahead of 2021 West Bengal state elections

Suvarna news anchor wants scientist arrested for his sarcastic Tweet about ‘Mysore Pak’, claims his act was ‘seditious’

The anchor of Suvarna news, Jayaprakash Shetty has now asked for the arrest of scientist Ranganathan for claiming Mysore Pak belonged to Tamil Nadu in a sarcastic Tweet

Congress’ AIPC member blames Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi for an incident of violence in Pakistan

All India Professionals' Congress member Andria D'Souza wants to hold PM Modi accountable for an incident in Pakistan

While talking about Muslims in Jammu, Karan Thapar diminishes massacre of Hindus and Sikhs in Jammu and the KP exodus

Karan Thapar in his article "We cannot be selective about the past in Jammu & Kashmir" in Hindustan Times dated 15th Sept 2019, gives a call to morality, intellectual honesty and being conscious to multiple peoples and their identities.
Stopped for traffic rules violation, Delhi girl threatens suicide

Watch: Stopped by traffic cops, Delhi girl threatens with suicide, helmet attack and then her mother

The girl was reportedly stopped for the broken license plate on her two-wheeler. When the traffic police demanded to see the scooter's documents, she stated that she had no papers.
Image Source: twitter

Malala Yousafzai spreads fake news, claims girl from Kashmir missed her exams on August 12 which was an Eid holiday

According to Malala, one of the three girls from Kashmir missed her exams on August 12. However, August 12 is a notified holiday declared across the country by Government of India on the occasion of Bakr Id or Eid ul-Adha.

Kannada media spreads fake news, accuses Nirmala Sitaraman of ‘giving’ Mysorepak to Tamil Nadu

No one had expected that a huge controversy would erupt over the issue of Mysore Pak, which originated in Mysuru during the rule of Wodeyar dynasty.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post