Home Fact-Check The Indian Express HSBC #SwissLeaks list, More sensationalism less substance?

The Indian Express HSBC #SwissLeaks list, More sensationalism less substance?

After generating a lot of hype on Social Media, about their “big break”, The Indian Express published a series of reports on HSBC’s clients, the details of their accounts in Switzerland and the balance in the accounts as of 2006-07. The list was sourced from French journalists who in turn got it from their sources in the French Government. The list was also given to a consortium of over 140 journalists from 45 countries. The date of publishing of this list i.e. 9th February, was decided by all the members of the consortium, well in advance. This should put to rest conspiracy theories that the list is out only after Delhi Elections.

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.jsThe Indian Express published only the Indian names, and also provided a list of top 100 account holders, calling it the “#SwissLeaks List”. On the page of the list itself there is no mention of black money or illegitimate accounts, but many on social media construed it to be a “Black Money list”

The Indian Express clarified this in a separate post, where it said that it is “Unlikely” that all these accounts have black money and haven’t been disclosed to the Indian tax Authorities. It further said that the list “may include legitimate account-holders who had taken permission and have declared the accounts, as well as holders of undeclared accounts who currently have to pay taxes and penalty, even face prosecution

- Ad - - article resumes -

And there lies the problem. Does any media agency have the right to publish names of legitimate account holders with legitimate “white” money, under a #SwissLeaks list, and thereby fuelling theories in the minds of a lay reader that such accounts are of “black money”? This question should go to all agencies around the world, not only Indian Express. Saikat Datta, a journalist himself raised this issue:

Again, the question arises, is Media competent to judge whether an account is related to tax fraud or not? We would have liked Indian Express to clearly mention on each page that this list may or may not have “black money” account holders, instead of a small disclaimer in another page. To their credit, they did ask for comments from some of the account holders, and while some have denied having HSBC accounts, some have taken a nuanced stand that they don’t have “illegitimate accounts”.

Some people on the list like Naresh Goyal, founder chairman of Jet Airways, and former Navy Chief Admiral Nanda, have made it clear that they have been NRIs for a long time and have always declared such accounts to the Indian Income tax department. Whether such people have been unfairly targeted or not, will be revealed only after the Government conducts its enquiry. Hence, there needs to be a clear distinction between legitimate accounts, illegitimate accounts (could be benaami accounts), accounts with “white” money and accounts with “black money”. 

While the actual list contains many of the usual suspects like the Ambani family, many were surprised by the absence of anybody from the Gandhi family. Some even went on to say they wont believe any list which doesn’t have Gandhis’ names in it. 

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.jsA more plausible explanation was given by @ParmarChandrika , a twitter user:

It is also possible that much of the money was long shifted to other financial centres such as Dubai and Singapore and tax havens such as St Kitts and Cayman Islands.  

The real news though will break soon, when the Government will reveal names of 60 people against whom prosecution has been initiated in the Black Money case. These are the cases where the Government has actually established that tax evasion has occurred, in contrast to the Indian Express list, which just summarily gives names of all people holding HSBC accounts in Switzerland. 

Consequently, what the Indian Express #SwissLeaks list will achieve is this:

1. Reveal names and details of legal account holders with legal money, thereby invading their privacy

2. Clubbing such legal names with people who have “black” money in such accounts, thereby defaming such legal account holders

3. Giving fodder to conspiracy theorists: When the Government, after investigation, will reveal the names against whom cases of Tax fraud have been established, there will be a section of people who will compare the Government’s list with the Indian Express list and start claiming that the people against whom the Government hasn’t acted have paid off the Government and that the Government is “XYZ agent”.

//platform.twitter.com/widgets.js

Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Big Story

Strange rumours are coming out of Kashmir. Shah Faesal, supposedly, is Doval's stooge.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

To Advertise on Opindia.com Click here

Pakistan takes a cue from Congress yet again, asks ‘what happened to Rafale investigation’

In case Chaudhry missed out, the first Rafale jet is expected to be delivered next month.

NDTV’s Interim CEO Suparna Singh resigns with immediate effect

NDTV interim CEO Suparna Singh, whose appointment as CEO was not approved by I&B ministry, has stepped down
Hartosh Singh Bal resorts to factually incorrect details to target Amit Shah

Fact-Check: Unlike Chidambaram who tried to escape from law, Amit Shah resolutely faced trial and was acquitted

Hartosh Singh Bal equated P Chidambaram's disgraceful escape with Amit Shah's tenacity to face the law

Former Pakistan army chief says Pakistan will use Kartarpur corridor to revive Khalistani terrorism in India

Gen Mirza Aslam Beg has said Pakistan army and the government should create trouble for India through Khalistan movement
Imran Khan has defended terrorists on Twitter

Imran ‘Taliban’ Khan goes on a bizarre defense of terrorists who may have infiltrated India disguised as Hindus

If harbouring, nourishing and sending terrorists to India was not enough, Pakistan has now shed all pretence and has been officially using terrorism as its state policy.
Rajiv Gandhi's tenure saw justice, freedom and institutions compromised at every level

No Sonia Gandhi, your husband did not stand for democracy or liberty

Rajiv Gandhi had infamously justified the Sikh massacre by saying, "When a big tree falls, the earth shakes."

Here is how these 7 opinion pieces in 4 days reveal newspaper The Hindu’s legendary level of meltdown and arrogance

Let’s take a look at the opinion pieces published by The Hindu in their print edition, in this week

Read about the P Chidambaram link in the new FIR filed against NDTV by the CBI

It appears that the INX Media case, the new FIR against NDTV and arrest of P Chidambaram are all interconnected.

McDonald’s India admits to discriminating against non-Muslims, buys only Halal meat for its restaurants

Halal is the Islamic method of slaughter which cannot be carried out by non-Muslims.
Pakistan may face a blacklisting by FATF's regional affiliate APG

Pakistan blacklisted: FATF’s regional affiliate APG blacklists Pakistan for failure to curb terror funding

In the APG, there are around 40 parameters of which Pakistan has failed in over 35. There are 11 effectiveness parameters and Pakistan has failed in 10.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
[newsletter_form type="minimal"]
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

181,311FansLike
172,793FollowersFollow
91,006SubscribersSubscribe
Help Opindia Reach Every Indian. Share This Post