Home Crime Bishop Franco case: Catholic Church escapes scrutiny, again

Bishop Franco case: Catholic Church escapes scrutiny, again

In the end, it took 87 full days. Nearly three months. From the nun filing a rape complaint in Kerala to the powerful Bishop Franco Mulakkal being arrested from Punjab. It took more than 70 days of delay from the Kerala Police, sustained protests by Catholic nuns on the streets and indefinite fasts for the Bishop Franco story to rise to ‘national importance.’

And with a few days of outrage, the story quickly faded away. One celebrated TV anchor, who did her first and possibly only show on the Bishop Franco case after ignoring it for over 70 days, began her coverage by launching into a tirade against … “people on Twitter.” She seemed more angry with them than with Bishop Franco.

This was a characteristic feature of the coverage of the rape case against Bishop Franco by several media outlets. There was no sustained questioning of the murky role of the Catholic Church, the blatantly partisan attitude of the Communist government of Kerala and the way in which the victim had her character assassinated by powerful members of the political and Christian establishment.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

In fact, several media outlets chose to refer to the Bishop simply as Franco Mulakkal, implicitly exonerating the Catholic Church as an institution from all responsibility in the matter.

Which is a surprising choice, considering the sheer magnitude and global scale of the allegations of systemic sexual exploitation within the Church.

Only last month, a grand jury in the United States uncovered over 1000 cases of child abuse by members of the Church. It is alleged that as many as 300 Catholic priests could be involved. All this. In just *one* little state of Pennsylvania.

So deep is the rot and so systemic the sexual abuse that the Church is estimated to have paid nearly $4 billion to settle cases worldwide. These are just the cases that came to light. One wonders how much bigger the number of actual victims could be in places such as India, where a lot of the abused women and children could be from the weakest sections of society.

And yet, in what could only be described as a public relations miracle, the Catholic Church manages to evade scrutiny. Especially in India.

Like I said, several media outlets did not even use the word ‘Bishop’ for Franco Mulakkal.

Never has an institution been accused of sex crimes by so many people on such a scale across the world and come out so unscathed.

Historically, the Catholic Church has been just as lucky. The role of the Church in propping up Nazism has generally been overlooked in popular memory of the Second World War. Specifically, the Catholic Church threw all its weight behind Fascist Benito Mussolini in return for money and control of Vatican City, but history never blamed the Church for it. The only other people who got just as lucky were the Communists, who started World War 2 when they invaded Poland jointly with Hitler. The two biggest collaborators of the Nazis: the Communist Party and the Catholic Church have both been largely forgiven by history.

But at least that was a long time ago. The shocking thing is that the Church still scores over all of us, handing out diktats like a supranational government, bossing overall but accountable to none.

In India, the Church operates with impunity, with its officers openly meddling in our domestic political affairs through public appeals and even letters written on their institutional letterhead. No government, whether of the Congress or the BJP, calls them on it. Any officer of a foreign government, whether we have good relations with them or not, would face massive diplomatic blowback if they tried such a thing. But the Vatican, which is as much a sovereign foreign state as America or Pakistan, gets away with meddling in our affairs all the time.

Yes, the Vatican maintains an Embassy in India, just as much as any other foreign country does. As Head of a sovereign state, the Pope enjoys the same privileges, including diplomatic immunity, as the President of the United States or the Queen of England. That’s why Joseph Ratzinger, the previous Pope, still lives on the sovereign territory of Vatican City: courts and police in no other country of the world can press charges against him for helping cover up for cases of child abuse.

In the case of Bishop Franco Mulakkal, the man who was in the dock was a member of a minority religious institution. The state government responsible for investigating and prosecuting the crime was the CPI(M) government in Kerala. The state where Bishop Franco was residing was Punjab, one of the handful of states ruled by Congress.

In other words, Bishop Franco Mulakkal was wearing three levels of magic armour. It took a legendary 87 days for the Indian legal system to pierce that armour and arrest the Bishop. While I cannot comment on how the case will pan out in court, the one thing that’s certain is that the elites of Indian media, academia and intelligentsia will remain in the dock. The Catholic Church gets off scot-free, like always.

Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans:
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Election 2019 Final Tally

Check the final seat tally and other post election coverage

Advertisement

Smriti Irani’s aide in Amethi shot dead, his son says some Congress workers were not happy with BJP’s ‘Vijay Yatra’

Smriti Irani had defeated Rahul Gandhi on his home turf of Amethi in Uttar Pradesh by a margin of 55,120 votes

Left has failed, but the ‘Right’ does not understand Modi as well

With the left looking irrelevant, the right needs to get its act together.

Meerut: Communal tension after a video showing Muslim men beating up shopkeepers goes viral

A viral video where Muslim men are beating up a shopkeeper has triggered communal tensions in Meerut

Rajdeep Sardesai thinks Narendra Modi should thank Masood Azhar, among others, for BJP’s victory

As a long term Congress loyalist media person, Rajdeep Sardesai is yet to come to terms that Modi won a second term with thumping majority
NYT peddles Modi 2.0 as victory of India's most divisive leader

Dear New York Times, India has chosen Modi 2.0, deal with it

When India gives a thumping, unprecedented, overwhelming victory to a man who has made every single Indian feel proud of their nation and heritage, the NYT's heartburn is expected. 

Journalist wants to ‘crowdfund’ a parallel parliament so that Atishi Marlena can become an MP

The 'neutral media' meltdown seems to have reached its peak after AAP's Atishi Marlena came in third in East Delhi Lok Sabha seat

A tribute to OpIndia’s fallen star

On 13th May 2019, Devandhu Rajput succumbed to cancer.

Rahul Gandhi upset that senior Congress leaders didn’t shout ‘Chowkidar Chor Hai’ enough, lashes out on them for party’s defeat

Amusingly, though Rahul Gandhi had indeed offered to resign, the CWC, that is chaired by himself, had unanimously rejected the resignation and asked him to reconstruct the party
Rana Ayyub uses the 2015 murder of Akhlaq to peddle fear and victimhood for Muslims, ignores Hindus killed for their religion

PM Modi, I am a Charvaka Indian liberal, and this is my wish list

An atheist Indian liberal writes to PM Modi on what he wishes for in the next five years
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

165,224FansLike
143,811FollowersFollow
65,653SubscribersSubscribe
Share This Post With Your Friends & Fans: