Ownership of CMIE and their alleged proximity to P Chidambaram raises questions on the credibility of its Job Survey

Here is the crux of the matter that is not widely known: CMIE, that brings out periodic Job Survey, is wholly owned by Mr Ajay Shah (and his family), the same person who also happens to be one of the main accused in a mega scam commonly known as ‘NSE Co-location’ scam.

The last couple of weeks has witnessed a growing focus on the number of jobs that have been created by the current government. A major reason behind this has been the lack of availability of an official source of employment statistic but the government has tried to change this as it has undertaken the Periodic Labour Force Survey. The results of this survey for the last year will be released soon by the government, however, as we wait for the official statistic on jobs, CMIE has come up with its own pessimistic estimates of “jobs” in India.

In several cases, analysts are not as pessimistic, with reason. For example, an analysis today says that in 4 years, 18 million jobs have been created in the transport and professional sector alone.

Here is the crux of the matter that is not widely known: CMIE, that brings out periodic Job Survey, is wholly owned by Mr Ajay Shah (and his family), the same person who also happens to be one of the main accused in a mega scam commonly known as ‘NSE Co-location’ scam.

- Advertisement - - Article resumes -

Mr Shah has been accused of accessing data from NSE on a preferential basis in connivance with the authorities and sharing this data with certain stockbrokers for use in High-Frequency Trading. The scam is being investigated by SEBI, CBI as well as by Income Tax authorities.

The current MD of CMIE is Mr Mahesh Vyas, who happens to be the brother-in-law of Mr Ajay Shah. The timing of the commencement of this Job Survey raises suspicion on the motivation as well as the credibility of the data. The co-location scam came to public light in late 2015, and the first Job Survey was out in April 2016.

There are several eminent economists who are consistently questioning the veracity of the data, as well as methodology adopted by CMIE. It is pertinent to note that as the co-location scam keeps progressing further (FIR has been filed by CBI against Mr Shah in June 2018), the CMIE reports are getting shriller with bleaker unemployment picture, quite in contrast to several other data points and anecdotal pieces of evidence. Could it be a strange coincidence?

Another interesting aspect to note about this “Survey” is that, ever since its first release where the number of those employed was pegged at 410 million, the trend line of jobs has been steadily declining, despite a ‘V’ shaped recovery in the GDP growth rates during this period.

One fails to understand how can an economy grow at 7% per annum while steadily losing jobs quarter after quarter, as claimed by CMIE? As evident from the growth figures, there was indeed a temporary slowdown in the GDP growth rate, however, the economy recovered immediately, and the growth rate accelerated. Surprisingly, the jobs as measured by CMIE does not provide such a rebound for the employment situation and that seems highly unlikely.

If the labour employed is going down then how can there be an increase in the growth rates? This points at deep inconsistencies within the CMIE data base and it categorically indicates that this data is unreliable. The question that does exist is that whether such inconsistencies are because of genuine errors or are they a case of a deliberate attempt to cause confusion and paint a pessimistic picture of India’s job creation? Given the ownership of CMIE, it appears that it is not a case of a genuine mistake.

A comparative chart of CMIE Job Survey and GDP growth rates are given below.

Source: CMIE website, Trading Economics

A damning story on Ajay Shah in the Hindu Business Line talks of another angle: Ajay Shah routed many of his clients through his wife’s sister, Ms. Sunita Thomas’ IT firm – Infotech Financial. Ms. Thomas is also the wife of Mr. Suprabhat Lala, who was chief of the trading division of NSE, at the time of this scam. Interesting to note that even in this story (as well as in several other stories across various media outlets, links for which are given at the end), Mr. Ajay Shah’s ownership of CMIE is never ever mentioned.

Screenshot from the latest audited Balance Sheet of CMIE showing the shareholding pattern:

Screenshot from the latest audited Balance Sheet of CMIE showing the shareholding pattern

Even the website of CMIE lists Ajay Shah (Director) and Mahesh Vyas (Managing Director).

CMIE list of directors

Several of the news articles (as well as Wikipedia entry on NSE Co-location scam at the time of writing this article) mentions that Mr. Ajay Shah is a very close confidante of Mr P. Chidambaram. Given this information, and the ownership pattern of CMIE, any ‘Job Survey’ from CMIE should be taken with a pinch (or a tonne) of salt, as one would take it from a Congress IT cell.

Related links :

bloombergquint.com

sundayguardianlive.com

moneylife.in


Share This Post and Support:
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Most read articles recently

Dear Gujarat Samachar editor, how do you live with yourself?

Gujarati daily's insensitive headline over Pulwama attack has got readers upset

Pakistan funded Islamic terrorist blows up 300 kgs of IED, actor brings ‘Hindu right wing’ argument to shield Pakistan

Jaaved Jaaferi refuses to hold Pakistan accountable for the attack, instead equates Hindus with Jaish Terrorists.

Delhi’s education minister deletes tweet after being educated about electricity supply to Pakistan by Adani

Sisodia, without apologising or issuing a clarification, chose to quietly delete the tweet after being called out

NDTV suspends Deputy News Editor for celebrating Pulwama terror attack, may take further action

NDTV Deputy News Editor Nidhi Sethi suspended by the channel for her Facebook comment celebrating the Pulwama attack
Congress mouthpiece National Herald whitewashes Pulwama terrorist Adil Ahmed Dar

More stories about terrorist and his family than martyrs – what does it tell about the media?

The English language Indian media has focused more on ‘human stories’ about the terrorist than about the Pulwama martyrs.

JNU ‘student’ who was accused of stealing funds in Kathua case found spreading rumours about Kashmiri girls trapped in Uttarakhand

CRPF also issued a notice that certain 'miscreants' on social media are spreading rumours and hate on social media

Pulwama attack: Foreseeing strong and fast reaction from India, Pakistan relocates its terrorists nearer to Pak army camps

As per the report, Pakistan has not even vacated the winter posts along the LoC which it usually does.

Pulwama attack: Justice doesn’t give a tiny rat’s furry posterior about the sensibility of elites who go where the money takes them

Pulwama attack victims' mortal remains weren't even cold yet. The candles lit by the nation has not even been blown out by a sorrowful sigh of the nation, that the vultures started circling the remains
Rahul Gandhi

BJP government got soldiers killed for electoral gains: Gujarat Congress leader’s controversial remark

Congress leaders and supporters have been trying to float the theory that the Pulwama attack was an inside job

Congress supporting abusive troll claims Pulwama was an inside job by India

Sanjukta Basu is a very vocal Modi-hater and a bigot masquerading as a liberal feminist.

Latest articles

Connect with us

137,023FansLike
109,853FollowersFollow
22,959SubscribersSubscribe

Don't miss these