Tuesday, April 20, 2021
Home Opinions Climate Change and India: Urban elites should focus their energy on pressuring developed nations...

Climate Change and India: Urban elites should focus their energy on pressuring developed nations to meet emission targets

For Indians, particularly, for the urban elite, to embark on a Climate Change argument without addressing its intricacies is a dangerous game that can threaten India’s development and access of her citizens to good and necessary infrastructure.

A recent opposition to the felling of trees in a wooded area near Mumbai, called as the Aarey Colony, threw up some interesting debates and discussions amongst the citizens of India on Climate Change. Apart from the emotional aspect of cutting down trees to make way for a shed of a public transport project, which was important to note was the Climate Change argument.

Keeping aside the political reasons of this particular project, since the state of Maharashtra is going to the polls on 21 October, it is important for Indian citizens to understand the Climate Change politics and dynamics, before it is used an argument to protest against a much needed and important public infrastructure project, particularly an efficient public transport system like a Metro.

While I personally continue to question a lot of Climate Change models, the fact remains that we are causing grave damage to the natural resources around us. Our air and water is dirtier and just these should be reasons enough to act towards environmental conservation. Local action is needed much more than embroiling ourselves into a larger, global and possibly uncontrolled phenomenon of Climate Change.

Read: Greta Thunberg, Climate Change and Indian Dilemma

Having said this, it is also important to understand India’s role in the Climate Change debate and dynamics. Because, without this understanding, citizens will continue to target the wrong things, while large emitters will get away by polluting.

The following data by USEPA gives us economic sectors that are the largest contributors of GHG (greenhouse gases) in the world today.

Electricity & Heat Generation – 25% of all the GHGs are caused due to our need to generate electricity and produce heat (for cold nations). So our everyday lives and our demand to have electricity for all our daily routine is what contributes to the emission of GHGs into the atmosphere.

Industry – 21% of all GHGs are produced because you and I want things for our daily lives – right from our phones to our clothes. This includes everything – all metals mined for our daily things like pens and utensils.

Agriculture, Forestry and Other Landuses – 24% of all GHGs are caused due to a variety of our activities with which we grow our food and poultry etc. So our demand for food primarily gives rise to these emissions. Forests, themselves, also emit GHGs as trees can sequester carbon only during a very short period of their life. Approximately, 20% of this 24% can be considered as its sequestration potential through biomass, soils and dead organic matter.

Read: Aarey: Environmentalism should be a practical concern, not a religion

Transportation – 14% of all GHG emissions are due to our need for mobility, either by cars, rail, aeroplanes or buses. 10% of these emissions are due to private vehicles.

Buildings – 6% of all GHGs are emitted due to our need for a shelter. Our buildings and their services are responsible for these emissions.

Other – 10% of all GHGs are emitted by the Energy sector that is not directly counted during energy generation but is allied emissions.

Ways in which one can reduce contribution of GHGs

From this data, it is seen that there are multiple ways in which we can reduce our contribution of GHGs. Putting the entire onus of GHGs on construction activity and particularly on essential infrastructure building is futile. In fact, with reference to the recent protests at Aarey against the Metro, it is important to note that within the Transport GHGs (14%), 10% are due to private vehicles. Hence, any projects and initiatives undertaken to reduce this 10% have to be a welcome step towards mitigating Climate Change. This is completely missed in the argument when protestors protested against an efficient public transportation system which will give the citizens a more environmentally friendly alternative to their cars.

The Climate Change dialogue amongst nations has recognized that Developing countries like India still need to put in basic infrastructure to bring its citizens out of poverty. The World leaders know that India’s current quest for complete electrification cannot be held as an action against Climate Change. In this quest of rural electrification by the Modi government, collateral conversion of land-use has been done, but the larger benefit to the people is recognized in the climate change debates across the world. Similar is the case with Indian cities and other sectors in India as well.

The vagaries of the weather are often cited as coming of a Climate Change apocalypse. Yes, we should certainly worry about these weather variations, but also accept the fact that our local level actions may not directly impact these phenomena when the developed countries are still putting out much more GHGs into the atmosphere than India. So linking a small scale forest conversion to avoiding Climate Change is not just futile, it is counterproductive to the entire debate when India is trying to put in efficient systems in place.

Read: Why the Indian Right should take the lead on climate change and snatch the issue from the Left

For India, particularly, for the urban elite, to embark on a Climate Change argument without addressing its intricacies is a dangerous game that can threaten India’s development and access of her citizens to good and necessary infrastructure. While, we as a nation accept and acknowledge that environmental conservation is important, to be held ransom to the argument of Climate Change is just plain unfair, particularly to people still living in poverty. It is only with good infrastructure, mobility and access to resources can we expect our economy to perform so that poor are lifted out of their misery. The focus of activism against Climate Change should be governments of developed countries who despite numerous conferences and treaties, have not managed to reduced their emissions to acceptable targets. It is said, and rightly so, that the urban elite of India is often more connected to the global dynamics than with their rural counterparts. They should use their connections and passion for demanding action against Climate Change to put pressure on developed nations to achieve their emission targets

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Anagha Paranjape-Purohithttp://mazepune.com/
Architect-Planner. Pune & Arizona State Univ Graduate. Sustainability consultant. Public Policy. Green Buildings. Teacher. Writer. Tedx.

Related Articles

Trending now

AAP supported farmer protests hampering war against Covid-19, oxygen supplier writes to GOI saying tankers delayed due to roadblocks by protestors

Inox Air Products said that they are facing delays in Delhi while transporting oxygen due to road blockades by the farmer protestors

After getting vaccinated himself, Rakesh Tikait says the Modi government will be responsible if farmers get COVID-19

Rakesh Tikait had recently said that 'farmers' protests is not Shaheen Bagh than can be stopped in the name of coronavirus

How China’s ‘Re-education through labour’ policy put minorities in labour camps even before the Uyghur crisis: About the Masanjia camps

The letter went into detail about the conditions at China's Masanjia Labor Camp, including the gruelling hours, verbal abuse and physical abuse

From sitting on upturned dustbins to photo ops at crematorium grounds, Barkha Dutt gets questioned for her ‘vulture journalism’

While the situation on ground is indeed grim, people on social media have been calling out the dramatics by journalists who could have perhaps focused on the news instead of their brand building.

Maharashtra FDA minister embarrasses his own govt and alliance leaders, says his ministry had approved Remdesivir procurement by BJP

Maharashtra FDA Minister and NCP leader Dr. Rajendra Shingne confirms that he was aware about BJP procuring Remdesivir for state govt

Journalism: The new performance art

With the COVID-19 pandemic, journalists have screamed "Beware of the Ides of March" to anyone who would listen - Barkha Dutt for example.

Recently Popular

Understanding the hate factory: How Rohan Joshi and his hateful post against Hindus gives us an insight into the ‘liberal’ mind

Comedian Rohan Joshi tells Bhakts, "I have nothing but contempt for them and nit a shred of empathy" as he mocks Coronavirus deaths

Maharashtra Remdesivir ruckus: Saket Gokhale brazens his lies by filing complaint against Fadnavis, BJP returns favour. Details

A complaint has been filed against Saket Gokhale by a BJP member in which the complainant has accused the Congress supporter of lying and waging a war against the state in the midst of a pandemic

Filmmaker Hansal Mehta challenges for free flight tickets to Pakistan but goes into hiding after Twitter user provides it. Read what happened

Hansal Mehta's flight to Pakistan via Dubai is scheduled for 20th April, 2021. We shall keep you posted if Mehta goes to Pakistan or will he register his name in long list of paper tigers.

Delhi couple abuses cops over masks in viral video, husband blames wife after arrest

Police have booked and arrested a Delhi couple after the duo misbehaved with the personnel over masks. The video went viral.

250 ventilators sent by central govt lied unutilized in the state of Punjab amid the second wave of coronavirus

250 ventilators sent by the central government to Punjab for use in government hospitals were lying unused till late March.

When ‘comedians’ double up as doctors and believe ‘Bhakts’ deserve the misery as Chinese coronavirus rages

You will never see them questioning how many mosques have opened up their gates as medical facilities. Because, everyone likes to keep their heads.
- Advertisement -

 

Connect with us

254,077FansLike
530,786FollowersFollow
24,200SubscribersSubscribe