HomeEditor's picks'Judge serving the master': Advocate moves Delhi HC to seek criminal contempt proceedings against...

‘Judge serving the master’: Advocate moves Delhi HC to seek criminal contempt proceedings against CJP legal head Ratna Singh 

A practising advocate Kausik Chatterjee has moved the Delhi High Court seeking initiation of criminal contempt proceedings against her over social media posts accusing a Saket Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM) Abhinav Pandey of "serving the master". 

Legal trouble for Cockroach Janta Party legal head Ratna Singh mounts as a practising advocate, Kausik Chatterjee, has moved the Delhi High Court seeking initiation of criminal contempt proceedings against her over social media posts accusing a Saket Chief Judicial Magistrate (CJM), Abhinav Pandey, of “serving the master”. 

The petition dated 16th November 2026 was filed after Delhi Government’s Additional Standing Counsel Amol Sinha granted consent for initiating criminal contempt proceedings against Ratna Singh. 

Sinha noted that there was an unquestionable distinction between questioning a judicial ruling’s correctness and attributing extraneous influence or inappropriate motives to the judge who passed that ruling. 

He further noted that the expressions “serving the master” and “following order from master” went beyond the merits of the order or how the proceedings were conducted.  

Rather, Ratna Singh’s remarks “prima facie” suggested that the judicial officer in question was acting under the influence of an external authority instead of exercising judicial discretion independently as per law. 

What does Advocate Kausik Chatterjee’s plea against CJP’s Ratna Singh over derogatory remarks on CJM Abhinav Pandey contend? 

In his petition filed through Advocates Samridhi Solanki and Megha Aggarwal of K Chatterjee Legal Consultants LLP, the petitioner invoked Article 215 of the Indian Constitution, read with Sections 2(c), 10 and 15 of the Contempt of  Courts Act, 1971, and the Contempt of Courts (Delhi High Court) Rules, 2025. 

The petitioner stated that he “does not question the right of the Respondent to criticise a judicial order or to express dissatisfaction with the manner in which judicial proceedings were conducted.” 

In addition, the petitioner, Kausik Chatterjee, stated that his plea “is not founded upon the Respondent’s criticism of the order or her statement concerning interruptions during the hearing.” 

The petitioner stated that his objection is strictly limited to the allegation that the judicial officer was “following” or “serving” a “master.” 

The petitioner argues that these statements by the CJP leader Ratna Singh against CJM Abhinav Pandey “suggest that the learned Judicial Officer was acting under the influence or directions of an unidentified external authority, rather than exercising his judicial functions independently and in accordance with law.” 

Advocate Chatterjee contends that such allegations, when made publicly without the backing of any evidence, can lower the Court’s authority and undermine public trust in judicial administration. 

“[Such allegations] when publicly made without any disclosed factual foundation, is capable of lowering the authority of the Court and undermining public confidence in the administration of justice,” the petition states. 

The petitioner had first written to the Standing Counsel (Criminal), GNCTD on 14th October, and submitted a supplementary representation on 28th October. 
 

What were the derogatory remarks Ratna Singh posted on X against CJM Abhinav Pandey? 

After hearing in Ratna Singh’s petition seeking registration of an FIR against police officials for allegedly ‘wrongfully’ confining her and preventing her from joining the CJP protest at Jantar Mantar on 10th October 2026, she had published X posts launching personal attacks on CJM Abhinav Pandey. 

In one of the posts, Ratna Singh quoted a Bar and Bench post and accused CJM Abhinav Pandey of “serving” the “master”. 

“Judge serving the master. Went for break/meeting 4 times during entire hearing. Order without any application of law. Welcome to new India, where Sarkar can put 30 police personnel confining you & then say we won coz armless people couldn’t come to the protest site. Irony is that people with criminal history are roaming around in Delhi & police personnel are busy detaining peaceful protesters,” she wrote. 

Source: X

Minutes before this, Ratna Singh had published an X post accusing the Delhi Police and the “Judge” of “following order from master.” 

“I am still detained. Since 9AM. There are 30 police official for one woman. Itne khaali hai yeh log. So many women are still detained. Men too. @DelhiPolice is following order from master. Judge is following order from master. There is no democracy in this country. Losers,” Singh wrote. 

Source: X

 
Ratna Singh apologised before court for making derogatory remarks against SEM courts

Ratna Singh has a penchant for casting aspersions on the integrity of the judiciary when court rulings concerning her and CJP leaders do not go in her favour. 

She gave several statements to the media while Ashutosh Ranka and Saurav Das were in judicial custody.  

On 19th October 2026, when the SEM Court extended the custody of the two CJP leaders by two days after rejecting their sureties, Singh called for the abolition of the SEM Court, accusing it of being compromised. 

“I think SEM (Special Executive Magistrate) courts should be abolished because the system is compromised. They have rejected the sureties,” Singh said, speaking to the media.

“The authorities show no regard for personal liberty or an individual’s past record; they simply seek an excuse, and we have just witnessed the kind of excuse they have offered today. I feel that while this entire system is designed to crush us, it will not succeed. The youth of this country is watching,” she alleged. 

Ratna Singh termed SEM Court proceedings a “mockery” 

In another statement issued on 19th October, the CJP leader Ratna Singh termed the proceedings before the SEM Court a “mockery”.

Criticising the extension of judicial custody of Ranka and Das, Singh claimed that the SEM Court gave the extension for a “vague reason”. She described the extension order as “mental torture” and an attempt to “stifle voices”. 

“A mockery was going on in the Court. For the last 6 days, we have been saying that one or the other reason is being nitpicked — surety verification has not been done, that an FIR has been lodged against the surety,” Singh said. 

“There was no reason to keep them in further judicial custody. They have been sent to judicial custody for a very vague reason…We will challenge this. This is mental torture and an attempt to stifle voices…We can see everything; the entire world can see everything. They cannot silence everyone,” she added. 

In an earlier statement, Ratna Singh had alleged that the SEM Court was acting in connivance with the government as part of an alleged conspiracy to keep the CJP leaders in detention. 

However, after the Delhi Police flagged Ratna Singh’s derogatory remarks against the SEM Court, she had to apologise before an SEM Court in Delhi. 

Responding to the Police’s submission, Ratna Singh’s counsel assured the SEM Court that such conduct will not be repeated by her in the future. 

Detention of CJP ‘cockroaches’ Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka 

It must be recalled that CJP leaders Ashutosh Ranka and Saurav Das were detained on 13th October 2026, two days after they were released from detention on the undertaking not to engage in any peace-breaching activity.  

The CJP leaders were arrested after they violated their undertaking and trespassed Jantar Mantar, after the place was de-notified as a designated protest site. 

On 14th October 2026, they were sent to five days’ judicial custody, which was prolonged by two days on 19th October 2026, after their sureties were rejected. They were released on October 21, 2026, after Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Ritu Raj, who presided over the SEM Court proceedings, ordered their release. On the same day, the Delhi Police transferred two registered cases against Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka to its Crime Branch. 

Earlier, Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka were detained alongside CJP founder Abhijeet Dipke, ahead of their unauthorised agitation in the national capital on October 10, 2026.  

They were detained under Sections 126 and 170 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).  

All three of them were subsequently released after submitting ₹50,000 as surety and signing a peace bond, promising to maintain peace and good behaviour for a year. 

However, two days after signing the peace bond, Das and Ranka violated it, resulting in their second detention. 

Join OpIndia's official WhatsApp channel

  Support Us  

For likes of 'The Wire' who consider 'nationalism' a bad word, there is never paucity of funds. They have a well-oiled international ecosystem that keeps their business running. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Shraddha Pandey
Shraddha Pandey
Senior Sub-Editor at OpIndia. Email: [email protected]

Related Articles

Trending now

Political party of Italian leader Giacomo Filibeck, who raised the ‘Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhor’ slogan at the Bharat Summit, amplifies Rahul Gandhi’s ‘SIR used to favour BJP’...

If democracy was actually strangled by the Modi government, as Rahul Gandhi suggested while speaking about the denial of visa permits to some of the foreign attendees, even his newly imported Italian cheerleader, Giacomo Filibeck, would not have made it to India. 

Dear Rahul Gandhi, nobody needed that information about your mama sitting on papa’s lap

In a country that hasn’t yet learned to accept the strange sleeping habits of Mahatma Gandhi, the strange eating habits of the other Gandhis were bound to trigger a widespread discussion.
- Advertisement -