Thursday, October 22, 2020
Home News Reports "First Day First Show": Did Odd-Even work? and how Media played its part

“First Day First Show”: Did Odd-Even work? and how Media played its part

Call it a novel idea, call it “Tughlaq-esque”, Delhi’s Odd-Even plan caught the eye of many in India and most on social media. One of the reasons for this could be our Delhi based media’s infatuation with the Delhi state Government which often leads it to conflate stories which are important to Delhi, with stories which matter for India as a whole. Add to that Arvind Kejriwal’s penchant for making a media spectacle out of anything he does (based on advice from his Guru Rajdeep Sardesai) and you have a sure shot prime-time debate topic.

So did this Odd-Even experiment work based on Day 1 results? Is it even fair to judge something based on the results of the 1st day? Lets get to the 2nd question later. First see how our media reported it:

As many on Twitter pointed out, “First Day, First Show” was the preferred phrase for what could have been synchronized tweeting by some of our top journalists, just as the experiment began.

ba rahul raj

The reports became fuzzier as the day went by, with some journalists like Vishnu Som from NDTV determined to prove Odd-Even worked against all “odds”. This even while his own channel NDTV was simultaneously running a story which said Air quality had shown no marked change and was still poor. Amusingly, Som’s claims and NDTV’s reports, both claimed to be based on the same SAFAR report. A report in India-Today cited multiple studies and data sources showing that Odd-Even plan may not have worked on Day 1.

Times of India too was running a similar story saying air quality had not really improved. But, come morning, Times of India’s data had changed drastically and splashed across its print edition was this news that claimed Odd-Even worked. To back this claim, Times of India chose to compare pollution levels on 31st December 2015 with 1st January 2016:

The basic fallacy among all the reports above, whether positive or negative was their premature jumping to conclusions, based on data of only 1 day. Even this day is a very bad sample to be taken to judge the efficacy of the plan. Consider this: 1st January is a holiday for a large number of establishments by virtue of being the 1st day of the year. It marked the start of a long weekend owing to which it is natural to expect a large number of city dwellers to head out of the city. Can an outlier of a day be used to judge an experiment? This is something which is taught at the most basic level of statistical sampling. Even worse, can just 1 day be taken into account to make any sort of claim?

The next big brain-fade is comparing the data of 1st January, with the data on 31st December, like Times of India did. It is unbelievably stupid to compare a holiday with a day which sees traffic snarls. But then logic and common sense have never been the forte of Times of India.

A larger point here is, is it even fair to expect any change in 1 day? Air pollution is not something which can be wished away in a day. It takes sustained efforts over a long period to show credible results. And Delhi is not an insulated pocket which is not affected by surrounding areas. While areas in the NCR region like Noida continue with their usual pollution levels, is it fair to expect Delhi to remain completely unaffected? In the world of quick-fixes and desire for even quicker results such nuances and realities are all but lost.

Coming to the actual Odd-Even plan as it stands, can any finding from this 15 day period be credible? Schools have been asked to shut down, thus artificially reducing traffic which would have been there on any normal day. The results of an experiment are credible only when all other things are kept constant (ceteris paribus) and only the change, here the plan of odd-even cars, is implemented.

Add to this the number of exemptions given, the plan loses most of its teeth. A report suggests after all exemptions are taken car of, the odd-even plan would affect only 6% of of cars. For all the brouhaha if a meagre 6% is what the best case scenario is, then the plan needs serious rethinking. Besides the sheer number, even the type of exemptions are questionable. Take for example the exemption given to two-wheelers. Multiple studies show motorcycles pollute way more, from 10 to 16 times worse than cars. And we have elected legislators of AAP itself “setting an example” by riding motorcycles to work:

At this stage the questions are many. Can day 1 data be used to claim a victory or defeat? With inbuilt aberrations in test conditions, will even 15-day data be helpful? Data aside, are the technicalities in the plan defeating the very purpose of the plan?

Some people have also begun branding anyone opposed to the Odd-Even plan as Anti-Delhiite or Pro-Pollution. A comparison is made to the Swacch Bharat Abhiyaan run by the Central Government and how the opposers of that move were  branded anti-Nationals. Here, a fundamental flaw in comparison arises since the 2 are frankly completely different.

Swacch Bharat is an aim, a mission, a target. The means to achieve this target are measures like photo-ops by celebrities, nominations of influencers to take up the task, awareness about cleanliness, Swacch Bharat Cess, focus on building toilets, launch of Air Quality Index etc. Similarly, in Delhi, Clean Air is the mission and Odd-Even plan is just a means of achieving this plan. In case of Swacch Bharat, we saw numerous people trashing the measures such as photo-ops etc. Similarly, this time many people are voicing concerns over the Odd-Even plan because they feel it is not practical. Surely everybody wants a cleaner India and cleaner air, the disagreement is only on the methods.

q

Having said all of the above, the AAP Government deserves kudos for deciding to actually do something, and backing it fully. Sure, this action was prompted by a rap from the Supreme Court but the Government did act. The common refrain of “at least he is doing something” holds good here because we really haven’t seen any Government in India take up the cause of air pollution with such aggression, however foolhardy one might consider the actual methods.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Gauravhttp://bwoyblunder.co.in/
co-founder, OpIndia.com

Related Articles

Trending now

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

CM Yogi distributes relief amount of Rs 113.21 crore among the flood-affected farmers in Uttar Pradesh

CM Yogi distributed the relief amount to the flood-affected farmers in 19 districts of the state by online transaction.

‘Mughal Prince Tucy’ lashes out on AIMIM’s Asaduddin Owaisi, calls him ‘Bewakoof, and Gadha’

Prince Tucy said that when the people of Hyderabad are dealing with horrific floods, MP Asaduddin Owaisi is busy doing poll campaign in Bihar.

Is Modi govt giving Coronavirus vaccines for ‘free’ only to Bihar? No, that’s not how it works

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Thursday while releasing the BJP manifesto in Bihar for upcoming elections said that the BJP promises free coronavirus vaccines in Bihar, whenever the vaccine is made available.

Recently Popular

UK: 37-year-old paedophile named Rehan Baig jailed for raping chickens to death while his wife filmed it

Rhan Baig's wife had also joined him in the videos and at one point he alternated between having sex with his wife and the chickens.

Eros Now apologises for publishing vulgar Hinduphobic content on Navratri

After netizens outraged over vulgar posts on Navratri, Eros Now issued an apology.

France: Charlie Hebdo cartoons projected on government building to express solidarity with deceased teacher who was beheaded by Islamic terrorist

Days after the barbaric beheading of teacher Samuel Paty on the streets of Paris by a terrorist for showing the cartoons of Prophet Mohammad to his students, support continues to pour in for the deceased teacher.

Remember Sheena Bora case? Param Bir Singh was the IG of Konkan range, the site where her body was dumped

Param Bir Singh knew that Sheena Bora was missing. He had asked Rahul Mukerjea to file a 'missing persons' report. Sheena, however, was never reported as 'missing'.

‘Comedian’ Agrima Joshua, who calls herself ‘feminist’, passes offensive sexual comments against woman due to political differences

Agrima Joshua had earlier found herself in a controversy after insulting the Shivaji Maharaj memorial during a performance.

Paris: Two Muslim women stabbed under Eiffel Tower by white women shouting “dirty Arabs”

Two Muslim women were stabbed repeatedly under the Eiffel Tower on Sunday night by two white women who called them "dirty Arabs".
- Advertisement -

Complaints filed against Eros Now and Arré for vulgar social media posts related to Navratri

Both Eros Now and Arre had published social media posts linking Navratri festival with sex and vulgarity

Chhattisgarh police file FIR against video journalist who had reported on farmer protests based on an allegedly edited video

Video journalist Manish Soni had reported about the plight of farmers whose paddy crops were ruined due to anti-encroachment drive

Reducing Navratri to ‘mating dance’, comparing Holi with terrorism— how the Indian media has turned Hinduphobic

After Eros Now posted series of vulgar messages associated with Navratri, far-left site Arre posted a Hinduphobic tweet on Durga puja

Remembering Lalu’s Jungle Raj in Bihar: When an IAS officer’s wife was raped for two years by an RJD leader

During Lalu's Jungle Raj in Bihar, IAS Officer BB Vishwas's wife Chamba Biswas was raped for 2 years by RJD leader Mrityunjay Yadav

“Your outrage against Hinduphobic content on OTT platforms may actually be fuelling more such content”- Here is what an industry insider says

OTT platforms are not hit if a movie or a series if boycotted for Hinduphobic content as people have already paid for subscription

Mumbai Police threatens Republic TV executive editor with imprisonment for refusing to reveal source of Hansa report in TRP scam

Republic TV Executive Editor warned by Mumabi Police that he will be booked under IPC sections 174 and 179 if does not give source of Hansa report

No, India Today, Katrina Kaif in yellow saree for Navratri is not offensive to Hindus, this is where you got it wrong

India Today tries to be holier than thou while trying to paint Hindus as trolls over Eros Now's vulgar Navratri posts

UP: Police find conversion of over 200 people to Buddhism fake, people were asked to sign conversion papers disguised as govt scheme

After reports of 236 Valmiki community members converting to Buddhisim, police find no evidence of conversion in Karehra village

Lucknow: Jama Mazar caretaker ‘Kale Baba’ caught running sex racket, video goes viral

The caretaker has allegedly confessed to police that he was sexually exploiting women and engaging them in illicit activities in the name of curing infertility and other ailments.

Meghalaya: Khasi student body puts up racist posters saying “All Meghalaya Bengalis are Bangladeshis”

The banners put up by Khasi Students Union read, ''All Meghalaya Bengalis are Bangladeshis'' and "Khasiland for Khasis; Foreigners Go Away".

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
466,035FollowersFollow
18,800SubscribersSubscribe