Friday, October 30, 2020
Home Government and Policy The environment and the economy: India stands at crossroads

The environment and the economy: India stands at crossroads

Environmental activism has caught on because people love its emotional argument.

Why is it that we find NGOs in India constantly fighting the government asking it to choose between development projects and the environment?

Wearing environmentalism on the sleeve is a new urban pastime. People, usually, those who have returned to India, after a stint in the US, are found to be more and more spending their free time in fighting for the cause of the environment. Most of the time, this environmentalism is not only misplaced, but it is also downright wrong and myopic. It is just wrong and unfair when we make our government choose between building infrastructure and environmental conservation.

Development cycle

Typically, every nation, state and city undergo a cycle of development. As economic opportunities open up, people shift to a higher consumption lifestyle. Higher consumption leads to higher demand for goods and services, including roads, water, sanitation, health and so on. As this demand rises, governments have to step up and provide these services to the aspiring middle-class population.

The aspirations vary but are typically found to be wanting good schools, colleges, hospitals, better road connectivity, regular electricity and water supply etc. In order to cater to this new population and also service the earlier ones efficiently, governments have to augment existing infrastructure. Good and efficient infrastructure further fuels economic opportunities and the cycle thus continues. This, in itself, is a self-feeding mechanism that nations have used to bring out a multitude of people out of poverty. This same process is seen in emerging economies like China and South Korea in the past 2-3 decades. They have done a concerted superfast phase of infrastructure development which has increased their per capita income, reduced poverty and brought development.

Indian scenario

In India, the pace of adding this infrastructure is dismally low and delayed. The delays are due to many causes, including democratic processes, that tend to slow down decision making. However, one of the most disturbing causes of this delay is environmental activism. The already existing urban middle and higher income groups are driving this environmental movement from a very misplaced ideological perspective.

This elite urban middle and upper-middle class has been at the forefront of the cycle of development, having made their economic fortunes in the early part of the country’s economic development. Most of this urban elite live in areas that were forests about 50 years ago, have built factories in areas that were considered pristine and they have already enjoyed the aspirational needs such as good education, good healthcare services etc. Now, under the garb of environmentalism, this urban elite class, in a systematic manner, is keeping the rest of India’s aspiring population away from making their fortunes and enjoying a lifestyle that is by any standards basic and decent, today. In the name of environmental conservation, this elite class is, probably, unintentionally, ensuring that many people are excluded from the development cycle.

Environmental activism

Environmental activism has caught on because people love its emotional argument. But, often, people fail to link their actions and decisions to environmental degradation. Hence, when infrastructure threatens to cut hundreds of trees, people protest against the infrastructure – the most visible villain. However, most of the times, people don’t realise that they are directly degrading the environment by choices and lifestyles that they lead every day. The number of kilometres of use of car is more damaging to the environment than saving a tree from getting cut. Treated water consumption for cleaning of cars and not treating our wastewater is more harmful to the environment over a long period of time than the short term impacts on the environment due to the construction of powerplant for energy.

Environmental conservation is a multifaceted goal. Generally, environmental experts who work in this sector will agree that it is not just difficult, but often impossible to have any human activity that does not directly or indirectly impact the environment. Environmental conservation, often, looks at balancing the impacts with the benefits to society. In no case, can an environmental expert expect to have no impact on the environment.

When infrastructure is provided and is adequate, it offers environmental services to reach more number of people. Without it, more people will remain outside the access to basic services like water supply, sanitation, education, healthcare and mobility. Even in cities that are relatively well developed, the addition of roads, public utility lines etc. adds value to the citizens’ lives. When more infrastructure is added to cities, more people have the potential to access a city’s economic opportunity and thereby economic well being of a nation improves. And conversely, every time a citizen stops or delays a public infrastructure, there is a considerable loss to the economy as a whole.

The tough choice

The pace of infrastructure addition will change according to a particular nation’s stage of development. For a developing country, the pace has to be fast and cost-efficient. It is with this background that we can now appreciate Minister Nitin Gadkari’s comment in the Parliament, where he puts forth an important question for us as a country – “Environment or Economy?”

It is also important to know that all nations in their respective development stages have chosen ‘Economy’. As they moved forward from this stage that ‘Environment’ gained priority. Considering that India may not have the privilege of considering ‘environment’ later, India is doing tremendous efforts in environmental compensation. Afforestation lists high in the government’s priority today. Investments in renewable energy, electric vehicles, low carbon technologies, green buildings are all compensatory efforts of the government towards environmental conservation. However, when it comes to infrastructure development, these are often not linked, while ecological impacts are highlighted to show the potential of degradation.

‘No Action’ scenario

‘No Action’ is often considered as one of the most impacting human action. Delays in building infrastructure leads to a ‘no action’ scenario and often ends up causing more harm to the environment. Take the example of a road. A new road promises to cut down travel distance, increase speed of travel and provide access to more people. All these aspects directly benefit economic well being. A road will cause environmental impact such as cutting down of trees, cutting of land etc. But these will be over a short term and can be mitigated through a well operationalized Environmental Management Plan. The benefits to the environment, in the long term, are lower fuel consumption per capita, less air pollution and higher access to services. These are often unaccounted for, while the cutting of trees, as an impact gets highlighted amongst people and the media. Delay in road capacity augmentation leads to the existing road being congested, causing tremendous air pollution, loss of human productivity and lesser economic opportunities.

We have to stop saying no to infrastructure projects in India. We admire the early efforts of developed countries in setting up their infrastructure. We admire the way their cities function. We admire the state of the transport facilities that they offer. Yet, In India, we question the need for infrastructure. We have to change our approach towards building infrastructure. Infrastructure should be built when it is not needed. Infrastructure, necessarily, should be aimed at the future needs of our population.

India needs to develop its infrastructure for a focused period of 20 years to be able to fill the gap that has been caused since Independence. Governments need to invest and people need to support this infrastructure-building spree in the country, till the last person gets access to a basic, decent life. While doing this, we have to be conscious of environmental impacts, have processes to mitigate them, invest in environmental compensation efforts and rejuvenation as well. But the more delay we cause in this basic infrastructure building stage, more and more environmental degradation will be caused. And in the long run, it will cause irreparable damage to India’s economic opportunities potential. The question of ‘Environment or Economy’ will loom even larger if the Economy takes a backseat during this crucial period for India.

About the author: Anagha is an Architect and Environmental Planner, with a practice in Pune. She designs Green Buildings and consults projects on Environmental Assessments, Environmental Planning & Management. Anagha writes a blog www.mazepune.com which regularly highlights urban environmental issues.

  Support Us  

Whether NDTV or 'The Wire', they never have to worry about funds. In name of saving democracy, they get money from various sources. We need your support to fight them. Please contribute whatever you can afford

Anagha Paranjape-Purohithttp://mazepune.com/
Architect-Planner. Pune & Arizona State Univ Graduate. Sustainability consultant. Public Policy. Green Buildings. Teacher. Writer. Tedx.

Related Articles

Trending now

Here’s why Jammu and Kashmir does not need a law to protect their land but many other states do

In a landmark decision, the Government of India has now decided that any Indian can purchase land in the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.

French Churches mourn victims of Islamic terror attack while their Indian counterparts had opposed providing relief to victims of Islamic persecution

The Churches in France tolled their bells to commemorate and honour the victims of the terrorist attack in Nice.

The Hindu spreads fake news about China occupying new regions in Pangong Tso just a month after making money by publishing Chinese propaganda

The Hindu had quoted an ex-BJP MP to claim that Chinese forces have occupied finger 2 and 3 on north bank of Pangong Tso lake

Munger SP Lipi Singh’s claims shattered, CISF report says Police first opened fire against Hindus, 13 bullets fired

Munger SP Lipi Singh had earlier defended the police violence on Durga Procession attendees in Munger and claimed that Hindus had fired, not the police

AMU students, who wanted to dig ‘Hindutva ki kabar’, now protest against French President for standing up to Jihad after ‘blasphemy’ beheadings

After chanting against Hindus the students in AMU have now started a protest French President Emmanuel Macron for his remarks against Islamic terrorism

Congress MLA organises protest of thousands of Muslims against French President and his ‘Islamophobia’ after his citizens were beheaded for ‘blasphemy’

Congress MLA Arif Masood organised and led a protest supporting terrorism in the name of Islam that led to the beheading of Samuel Paty and others in France.

Recently Popular

‘Modi, Modi’ slogans inside Pakistan National Assembly: Here is what happened

The name of PM Modi echoed on Monday as members of Pakistan's opposition members chanted 'Modi, Modi' slogans inside Pakistan National assembly

Chinese state-run channel shows the portrait of Prophet Muhammad, netizens ask if Muslim nations will boycott China

Arslan Hidayat, an Uyghur Rights Activist, took to Twitter shared a video of a Chinese TV series on Twitter in which it was depicted that an Arab ambassador visiting China during the rule of Tang dynasty gifts a portrait of the Prophet Muhammad to the Chinese emperor.

As Pakistan minister admits role in Pulwama attack, Rajdeep Sardesai rushes to his rescue, allows him to ‘clarify’, attack India instead, NDTV follows suit

India Today and NDTV come together to rescue Pakistan minister Fawad Chaudhry after he admitted Terroristan's role in Pulwama attack

‘His legs were shivering, head was sweating fearing attack by India’: Pakistani opposition leader reveals why Imran Khan govt had released Abhinandan Varthaman

PML(N) leader Ayaz Sadiq said that Pakistani Foreign Minister had feared that India would attack Pakistan if Abhinandan is not returned

Watch: Pro-India accounts disrupt Pakistan’s anti-India online meeting on Zoom, play pro-Hindu and Indian nationalistic songs

Indic social media users caused embarrassment to Pakistani authorities and diplomats after they raided their online event on zoom

Here are ‘liberals’ who hailed Imran Khan’s benevolence for releasing Abhinandan, while he was shaking in his boots, thinking of Modi going to war

The usual suspects declared Imran Khan 'won' despite the fact that it was Indian Armed Forces that destroyed terror camps in Pakistan.
- Advertisement -

Shadow group of Lashkar-e-Taiba claims responsibility of killing three BJYM workers in Jammu and Kashmir

Three BJYM workers - Fida Hussain, Umer Hajam and Umer Rashid Beigh were shot dead by terrorists in Kulgam in Jammu &Kashmir on Thursday

Here’s why Jammu and Kashmir does not need a law to protect their land but many other states do

In a landmark decision, the Government of India has now decided that any Indian can purchase land in the Union Territory of Jammu and Kashmir.

Bhopal Congress MLA Arif Masood talks of crushing French President’s face, Darul Uloom demands Indian government to condemn France

Congress MLA Arif Masood said that if it had been in his capacity, he would have crushed the face of France President Emmanuel Macron

Kerala: Bineesh Kodiyeri, son of senior CPM leader Kodiyeri Balakrishnan, arrested for money laundering and links with drug smuggler Mohammed Anoop

Kerala CPM leader's son Bineesh Kodiyeri was arrested after ED had unearthed his links to one of the main accused in Sandalwood drug case

Assam becomes the first state to introduce ‘Transgender’ as a gender option in state civil service exam application form

Accepting demand of transgender community, Assam Public service Commission introduces transgender as gender option in exam forms

French Churches mourn victims of Islamic terror attack while their Indian counterparts had opposed providing relief to victims of Islamic persecution

The Churches in France tolled their bells to commemorate and honour the victims of the terrorist attack in Nice.

Alleged Mastermind of Delhi Riots where mobs killed amidst Allahu Akbar chants, condemns France beheadings saying ‘murder and Allahu Akbar’ do not go together

Apoorvanand wants the world to overlook the religious angles to these barbaric acts so that it suits its political narrative in the country

Russia: Teenager shot dead after he shouts ‘Allahu Akbar’ and stabs police officer

On Friday, a 16-year-old terrorist was shot dead by police in the Muslim-dominated region of Tatarstan in Russia.

Subramanian Swamy condemns the ‘knifing and beheading as retaliation’ in France, however, his condemnation comes with a big ‘but’: Read details

Subramanian Swamy on Friday condemned the beheading of innocent French citizens a day earlier by an Islamic terrorist.

The Hindu spreads fake news about China occupying new regions in Pangong Tso just a month after making money by publishing Chinese propaganda

The Hindu had quoted an ex-BJP MP to claim that Chinese forces have occupied finger 2 and 3 on north bank of Pangong Tso lake

Connect with us

245,563FansLike
471,459FollowersFollow
19,500SubscribersSubscribe