Home Opinions Will tax on withdrawing cash fix tax evasion or black money?

Will tax on withdrawing cash fix tax evasion or black money?

It is no secret that the Modi government is undertaking various steps to move India towards a cashless or less-cash economy. The government believes that cashless transactions can help in curbing generation of black money as every such transaction will be documented. Government further believes that this will hurt fake currency mafia as well as push people towards better tax compliance.

While there is no doubt that cashless transactions will indeed help achieve those objectives, the move that pushes people towards cashless transactions need to be analysed for their effectiveness and feasibility. Demonetisation was one such step that was widely debated.

Now the next move – reportedly suggested by a panel to the government – is to introduce tax on cash withdrawals above 50000 rupees, so that people prefer cashless transactions. The panel is headed by Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu, who believes that the government could accept the suggestion and incorporate it into the Union Budget that will be presented on 1st February this year.

- Advertisement - - article resumes -

But will this withdrawal tax really help achieve the objectives of curbing black money and parallel economy? Let’s try to understand the issue:

The Cash Chain

Here is a representative cash chain. Cash is withdrawn from the system and from then it travels through various mediums till it reaches the bank again.

The cash chain
How typically cash withdrawals are used by a common man

Overall, the cash chain has 3 types of transactions:

  1. Type I – Where cash is withdrawn and used for an unaccounted transaction
  2. Type II – Cash to Cash unaccounted transactions
  3. Type III – Cash transactions which are disclosed

Of the 3, Type I and II can be termed as ‘Black’ transactions as they are not accounted for and among these two, only Type I will be taxed. Additionally, Type I is only the trigger which sets into motion the downstream transactions.

Type II which form bulk of the transactions in the cash chain will not be affected at all. Imagine this flow as a race track where you place a small speed breaker at the start of the track. Once you cross the initial hurdle you are free to step on the accelerator.

One argument here is that II and III are dependent on I and if Type I is reduced it will have a downstream impact on the other types as well. To test this argument, let’s dive a bit deeper and look at the Type I in detail.

The Buyer’s Burden

Since the proposed concept is to tax the buyer, it is the buyer who has to make the decision as to which mode of payment he prefers. So let us look at transactions from a buyer perspective:

  1. Low Hanging fruit: These are the transactions where the buyer can easily shift to other modes of payment. This is the low hanging fruit where alternatives are readily available and suit the buyer. So buyer will be tempted to go for non-cash means of purchase. For example, buying groceries from organized retail or merchants who accept cards, buy from e-commerce sites etc.
  2. Hard to Crack: These are the cases where even if the buyer wants to pay by card, seller offers no such alternative. Such transactions will not be affected by withdrawal tax. For example, Auto driver does not accept card, doctor does not accept card, a small-scale manufacturer wants to buy raw material but seller wants cash, contractor employs daily wage labour who does not have a bank account, BMC official asks for bribe to sign on papers etc.
  3. Where Cash withdrawal is cheaper than the alternative: It is highly unlikely that the withdrawal tax will be very high (say 10-20%). Most probably it will be in the sub 3% bracket. 3% is also a deterrent but not in cases where the alternative is even more expensive. For example, Paying bribe to the traffic cop rather than getting a challan, sellers passing on the transaction charges to the buyer if payment is by card, buyer wants to save taxes while registering property etc. Plus the tax slabs are higher than withdrawal tax and the seller can always offer a nominal discount if payment is by cash to save taxes. Transactions of such nature will also not be affected by withdrawal tax.
  4. Cash is King: The fourth type are the ones where buyer himself wants to hide the transaction. Here he has no alternative but to pay by cash. These will also not be affected by the proposed tax. For example, Buying drugs!

As we drill down deeper we can observe the gamut of transactions which the buyer will reconsider due to transaction tax are very low. Only Type I type of transactions will fall under this tax and even these will only be partially impacted. Cash will slowly seep through and build up reserves in the Type II transaction market.

Additionally, withdrawal tax is making cash dearer. And what do we do when something becomes dearer? We hold it close. Velocity of cash will reduce and people will also be reluctant to give cash back to the banks. As time passes and ample cash is available in the market, power of withdrawal tax will reduce severely.

In short – you cannot fix a long pipe having numerous leakages by placing a thin filter at the mouth of the pipe. Water will slowly seep in, build up and start leaking again.

Help Us Reach Every Indian, Please Share This Post
We need your support to survive in the media industry. Please consider paying us for the content we produce:

To know more about these payments, please click here.


Advertisement

Big Story

80 doctors at the RG Kar Medical College and Hospital in Kolkata have resigned demanding an apology from the Chief Minister for her remarks.

2019 World Cup Is Here!

Catch the latest on Cricket World Cup as it unfolds, special coverage by Opindia

Read OpIndia.com's response to the defamation notice served by Swati Chaturvedi

That you have lost readership and your peers doubt you, is not our problem: Read our response to Swati Chaturvedi’s defamation notice

Recently, OpIndia.com got a legal notice from abusive media troll Swati Chaturvedi. At the onset, we would like to reiterate that such intimidatory tactics won't work with OpIndia.
NDTV's takes journalism to new heights by asking Rahul Gandhi how did he like his samosa

Rahul Gandhi got conned by his own men: Report says ‘Big Data’ head Praveen Chakravarty billed Congress 24 crores and is now absconding

A day prior to election results, Rahul Gandhi had reportedly even contacted UPA allies and offered to accommodate them in the cabinet.

Even as 700 doctors resign, TMC leader Abu Taher Khan Chaudhury accused of threatening doctors with rape and murder

There are videos circulating on social media which purportedly show the Trinamool MP from Murshidabad, Abu Taher Khan threatening the doctors at the institution. The politician, however, has denied all allegations.

Rahul Gandhi finally arrives in Parliament, but stays true to form and goofs up while taking oath as MP

A Lok Sabha official stopped Rahul Gandhi and told him that he has to sign the register after taking oath

Pakistani Twitter erupts in self-deprecating humour as their cricket team stares at imminent defeat

India registered its 7th consecutive win against Pakistan in Cricket World Cup tournaments.

Pakistani pop singer wanted a Dutch MP killed for blasphemy, this is where she learnt bigotry from

The irony of all this is that Tablighi Jamaat promotes segregation and believes that women should stay at home
Order to demolish and remove cross

Village officer issues order to demolish and remove crosses planted by Church on encroached land near Sabarimala

Crosses have been planted on the sacred lands of Panchalimedu, believed to be a place inhabited by Pandavas during the 12 years of exile.

Here is what you missed when the India-Pakistan match was on

News you may have missed due to the India-Pakistan match yesterday
India won by 89 runs in their WC match against Pakistan

India refuses to be mediocre and docile, if that is ‘cold hearted’ for this Guardian writer, so be it

Some people, who have clearly run out of issues to find faults, have come up with a brilliant demonstration of what Hindi Twitter knows as 'Naraaz Fufa'.
PM Modi has not tweeted about the India Pakistan cricket match

Twitter diplomacy: Imran Khan made a thread on India-Pak world cup match but zero tweets by PM Modi

Cricket has always been part of ‘track 2 diplomacy’ so off-field events can’t be ignored.
Subscribe to Day's Top Stories
- Advertisment -

Latest articles

Connect with us

170,510FansLike
149,452FollowersFollow
69,762SubscribersSubscribe
Help Us Reach Every Indian, Please Share This Post